Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-jr42d Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T15:29:47.447Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Meditation techniques v. relaxation therapies when treating anxiety: a meta-analytic review

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 July 2019

Jesus Montero-Marin Open the ORCID record for Jesus Montero-Marin [Opens in a new window] ,
Javier Garcia-Campayo Open the ORCID record for Javier Garcia-Campayo [Opens in a new window] ,
Mari Cruz Pérez-Yus Open the ORCID record for Mari Cruz Pérez-Yus [Opens in a new window] ,
Edurne Zabaleta-del-Olmo Open the ORCID record for Edurne Zabaleta-del-Olmo [Opens in a new window]  and
Pim Cuijpers Open the ORCID record for Pim Cuijpers [Opens in a new window]
Jesus Montero-Marin*
Affiliation:
Primary Care Prevention and Health Promotion Research Network (RedIAPP), Zaragoza, Spain
Javier Garcia-Campayo
Affiliation:
Primary Care Prevention and Health Promotion Research Network (RedIAPP), Zaragoza, Spain Miguel Servet University Hospital, University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain Aragon Institute of Health Research, Zaragoza, Spain
Mari Cruz Pérez-Yus
Affiliation:
Primary Care Prevention and Health Promotion Research Network (RedIAPP), Zaragoza, Spain Aragon Institute of Health Research, Zaragoza, Spain Department of Psychology and Sociology, University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain
Edurne Zabaleta-del-Olmo
Affiliation:
Fundació Institut Universitari per a la recerca a l'Atenció Primària de Salut Jordi Gol i Gurina (IDIAPJGol), Barcelona, Spain
Pim Cuijpers
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
*
Author for correspondence: Jesus Montero-Marin, E-mail: jmonteromarin@hotmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

To what extent meditation techniques (which incorporate practices to regulate attention, construct individual values, or deconstruct self-related assumptions), are more or less effective than relaxation therapy in the treatment of anxiety, is not clear. The aim of this study was to examine the effectiveness of meditation compared to relaxation in reducing anxiety. A systematic review from PubMed, Embase, PsycInfo and the Cochrane Central was conducted. A meta-analysis of 14 RCTs (n = 862 participants suffering from anxiety disorders or high trait anxiety) was performed. Effect sizes (ESs) were determined by Hedges’ g. Heterogeneity, risk of publication bias, quality of studies/interventions, and researcher allegiance, were evaluated. Meditation techniques incorporated attentional elements, and five of them also added constructive practices. No studies were found using deconstructive exercises. The overall ES was g = −0.23 [95% confidence interval (CI) −0.40 to −0.07], favouring meditation (number needed to treat = 7.74). Heterogeneity was low (I2 = 2; 95% CI 0 to 56). There was no evidence of publication bias, but few studies and interventions were of high quality, and allegiance might be moderating results. Meditation seems to be a bit more effective than relaxation in the treatment of anxiety, and it might also remain more effective at 12-month follow-up. However, more research using the full spectrum of meditation practices to treat different anxiety disorders, including independent studies to avoid researcher allegiance, is needed if we are to have a precise idea of the potential of these techniques compared to relaxation therapy.

Keywords

Anxiety disordersmeditation techniquesmeta-analysisrelaxation therapy
Type
Review Article
Information
Psychological Medicine , Volume 49 , Issue 13 , October 2019 , pp. 2118 - 2133
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Agee, JD, Danoff-Burg, S and Grant, CA (2009) Comparing brief stress management courses in a community sample: mindfulness skills and progressive muscle relaxation. Explore the Journal of Science and Healing 5, 104–109.Google Scholar
Alonso, J and Lepine, JP (2007) Overview of key data from the European study of the epidemiology of mental disorders (ESEMeD). Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 68, 3–9.Google Scholar
Amihai, I and Kozhevnikov, M (2014) Arousal v. relaxation: a comparison of the neurophysiological and cognitive correlates of Vajrayana and Theravada meditative practices. PLoS One 9, e102990.Google Scholar
Begg, CB and Mazumdar, M (1994) Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Journal of the International Biometric Society 50, 1088–1101.Google Scholar
Benson, H (1975) The Relaxation Response. New York: HyperCollins.Google Scholar
Bernstein, DA and Borkovec, TD (1973) Progressive Relaxation Training: A Manual for the Helping Professions. IL: Research Press.Google Scholar
Bohlmeijer, E, Prenger, R, Taal, E and Cuijpers, P (2010) The effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction therapy on mental health of adults with a chronic medical disease: a meta-analysis. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 68, 539–544.Google Scholar
Bolognesi, F, Baldwin, DS and Ruini, C (2014) Psychological interventions in the treatment of generalized anxiety disorder: a structured review. Journal of Psychopathology 20, 111–126.Google Scholar
Borenstein, M, Hedges, LV, Higgins, JPT and Rothstein, HR (2009) Introduction to Meta-Analysis. UK: Wiley.Google Scholar
Borenstein, M, Higgins, JPT, Hedges, LV and Rothsteind, HR (2017) Basics of meta-analysis: I2 is not an absolute measure of heterogeneity. Research Synthesis Methods 8, 5–18.Google Scholar
Butow, PN, Turner, J, Gilchrist, J, Sharpe, L, Smith, AB, Fardell, JE, Tesson, S, O'Connell, R, Girgis, A, Gebski, VJ, Asher, R, Mihalopoulos, C, Bell, ML, Zola, KG, Beith, J and Thewes, B (2017) Randomized trial of ConquerFear: a novel, theoretically based psychosocial intervention for fear of cancer recurrence. Journal of Clinical Oncology 35, 4066–4077.Google Scholar
Chambless, DL and Hollon, SD (1998) Defining empirically supported therapies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 66, 7–18.Google Scholar
Chen, YF, Huang, XY, Chien, CH and Cheng, JF (2017) The effectiveness of diaphragmatic breathing relaxation training for reducing anxiety. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care 53, 329–336.Google Scholar
Chiang, LC, Ma, WF, Huang, JL, Tseng, LF and Hsueh, KC (2009) Effect of relaxation-breathing training on anxiety and asthma signs/symptoms of children with moderate-to-severe asthma: a randomized controlled trial. International Journal of Nursing Studies 46, 1061–1070.Google Scholar
Cludius, B, Hottenrott, B, Alsleben, H, Peter, U, Schröder, J and Moritz, S (2015) Mindfulness for OCD? No evidence for a direct effect of a self-help treatment approach. Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders 6, 59–65.Google Scholar
Cohen, J (1988) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.Google Scholar
Colgan, DD, Wahbeh, H, Pleet, M, Besler, K and Christopher, M (2017) A qualitative study of mindfulness among veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder: practices differentially affect symptoms, aspects of well-being, and potential mechanisms of action. Journal of Evidence-Based Complementary & Alternative Medicine 22, 482–493.Google Scholar
Conrad, A and Roth, WT (2007) Muscle relaxation therapy for anxiety disorders: it works but how? Journal of anxiety disorders 21, 243–264.Google Scholar
Crome, E, Grove, R, Baillie, AJ, Sunderland, M, Teesson, M and Slade, T (2015) DSM-IV and DSM-5 social anxiety disorder in the Australian community. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 49, 227–235.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, Driessen, E, Hollon, SD, van Oppen, P, Barth, J and Andersson, G (2012) The efficacy of non-directive supportive therapy for adult depression: a meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review 32, 280–291.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P, Gentili, C, Baños, RM, García-Campayo, J, Botella, C and Cristea, IA (2016) Relative effects of cognitive and behavioural therapies on generalized anxiety disorder, social anxiety disorder and panic disorder: a meta-analysis. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 43, 79–89.Google Scholar
Cushing, RE and Braun, KL (2018) Mind–body therapy for military veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder: a systematic review. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 24, 106–114.Google Scholar
Dahl, CJ, Lutz, A and Davidson, RJ (2015) Reconstructing and deconstructing the self: cognitive mechanisms in meditation practice. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 19, 515–523.Google Scholar
Davis, L and Kurzban, S (2012) Mindfulness-based treatment for people with severe mental illness: a literature review. American Journal of Psychiatric Rehabilitation 15, 202–232.Google Scholar
Deepak, KK (2019) Meditation induces physical relaxation and enhances cognition: a perplexing paradox. Progress in Brain Research 144, 85–99.Google Scholar
Delgado, LC, Guerra, P, Perakakis, P, Vera, MN, Reyes del Paso, G and Vila, J (2010) Treating chronic worry: psychological and physiological effects of a training programme based on mindfulness. Behaviour Research and Therapy 48, 873–882.Google Scholar
Delmonte, MM (1985) Meditation and anxiety reduction: a literature review. Clinical Psychology Review 5, 91–102.Google Scholar
Duval, S and Tweedie, R (2000) Trim and fill: a simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Journal of the International Biometric Society 56, 455–463.Google Scholar
Egger, M, Davey Smith, G, Schneider, M and Minder, C (1997) Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal 315, 629–634.Google Scholar
Eifert, GH and Heffner, M (2003) The effects of acceptance versus control contexts on avoidance of panic-related symptoms. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 34, 293–312.Google Scholar
Eppley, KR, Abrams, AI and Shear, J (1989) Differential effects of relaxation techniques on trait anxiety: a meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Psychology 45, 957–974.Google Scholar
Esch, T, Fricchione, GL and Stefano, GB (2003) The therapeutic use of the relaxation response in stress-related diseases. Medical Science Monitor 9, RA23–RA34.Google Scholar
Eustis, EH, Hayes-Skelton, SA, Roemer, L and Orsillo, SM (2016) Reductions in experiential avoidance as a mediator of change in symptom outcome and quality of life in acceptance-based behavior therapy and applied relaxation for generalized anxiety disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy 87, 188–195.Google Scholar
Feldman, G, Greeson, J and Senville, J (2010) Differential effects of mindful breathing, progressive muscle relaxation, and loving-kindness meditation on decentering and negative reactions to repetitive thoughts. Behaviour Research & Therapy 48, 1002–1011.Google Scholar
Frances, AJ and Nardo, JM (2013) ICD-11 should not repeat the mistakes made by DSM-5. The British Journal of Psychiatry 203, 1–2.Google Scholar
Gao, L, Curtiss, J, Liu, X and Hofmann, SG (2018) Differential treatment mechanisms in mindfulness meditation and progressive muscle relaxation. Mindfulness 9, 1268–1279.Google Scholar
Glanville, J, Lefebvre, C and Wright, K (2008) The InterTASC Information Specialists’ Sub-Group. York (UK) [updated 2019 May 7]. Available at https://sites.google.com/a/york.ac.uk/issg-search-filters-resource/home.Google Scholar
Goldberg, SB, Tucker, RP, Greene, PA, Davidson, RJ, Wampold, BE, Kearney, DJ and Simpson, TL (2018) Mindfulness-based interventions for psychiatric disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review 59, 52–60.Google Scholar
Goyal, M, Singh, S, Sibinga, EMS, Gould, NF, Rowland-Seymour, A, Sharma, R, Berger, Z, Sleicher, D, Maron, DD, Shihab, HM, Ranasinghe, PD, Linn, S, Saha, S, Bass, EB and Haythornthwaite, JA (2014) Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine 174, 357–368.Google Scholar
Graser, J and Stangier, U (2018) Compassion and loving-kindness meditation: an overview and prospects for the application in clinical samples. Harvard Review of Psychiatry 26, 201–215.Google Scholar
Gu, J, Strauss, C, Bond, R and Cavanagh, K (2015) How do mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and mindfulness-based stress reduction improve mental health and wellbeing? A systematic review and meta-analysis of mediation studies. Clinical Psychology Review 37, 1–12.Google Scholar
Hayes-Skelton, SA, Roemer, L and Orsillo, SM (2013) A randomized clinical trial comparing an acceptance-based behavior therapy to applied relaxation for generalized anxiety disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 81, 761–773.Google Scholar
Hedges, LV (1981) Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 6, 107–128.Google Scholar
Heimberg, RG, Hofmann, SG, Liebowitz, MR, Schneier, FR, Smits, JA, Stein, MB, Hinton, DE and Craske, MG (2014) Social anxiety disorder in DSM-5. Depression and Anxiety 31, 472–479.Google Scholar
Higgins, JPT and Green, S (2011) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. (Updated March 2011). Oxford, UK: The Cochrane Collaboration.Google Scholar
Higgins, JPT, Altman, DG and Sterne, JAC (2011) Assessing risk of bias in included studies. In Higgins, JPT and Green, S (eds), Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. (Updated March 2011). Oxford, UK: The Cochrane Collaboration, pp. 173–225.Google Scholar
Higgins, JP, Thompson, SG, Deeks, JJ and Altman, DG (2003) Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. British Medical Journal 327, 557–560.Google Scholar
Hilton, L, Maher, AR, Colaiaco, B, Apaydin, E, Sorbero, ME, Booth, M, Shanman, RM and Hempel, S (2017) Meditation for posttraumatic stress: systematic review and meta-analysis. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy 9, 453.Google Scholar
Ioannidis, JPA, Patsopoulos, NA and Evangelou, E (2007) Uncertainty in heterogeneity estimates in meta-analyses. British Medical Journal 335, 914–916.Google Scholar
Jacobson, E (1974) Progressive Relaxation: A Physiological and Clinical Investigation of Muscular States and Their Significance in Psychology and Medical Practice. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Jain, S, Shapiro, SL, Swanick, S, Roesch, SC, Mills, PJ, Bell, I and Schwartz, GE (2007) A randomized controlled trial of mindfulness meditation versus relaxation training: effects on distress, positive states of mind, rumination, and distraction. Annals of Behavioral Medicine 33, 11–21.Google Scholar
Kessler, RC, Petukhova, M, Sampson, NA, Zaslavsky, AM and Wittchen, HU (2012) Twelve-month and lifetime prevalence and lifetime morbid risk of anxiety and mood disorders in the United States. International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research 21, 169–184.Google Scholar
Kirkland, K and Hollandsworth, JG (1980) Effective test taking: skills-acquisition versus anxiety-reduction techniques. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology 48, 431–439.Google Scholar
Kirsch, I and Henry, D (1979) Self-desensitization and meditation in the reduction of public speaking anxiety. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 47, 536–541.Google Scholar
Klainin-Yobas, P, Oo, WN, Suzanne Yew, PY and Lau, Y (2015) Effects of relaxation interventions on depression and anxiety among older adults: a systematic review. Aging & Mental Health 19, 1043–1055.Google Scholar
Kraemer, HC and Kupfer, DJ (2006) Size of treatment effects and their importance to clinical research and practice. Biological Psychiatry 59, 990–996.Google Scholar
Krisanaprakornkit, T, Krisanaprakornkit, W, Piyavhatkul, N and Laopaiboon, M (2006) Meditation therapy for anxiety disorders. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 25, CD004998.Google Scholar
Laupacis, A, Sackett, DL and Roberts, RS (1988) An assessment of clinically useful measures of the consequences of treatment. The New England Journal of Medicine 318, 1728–1733.Google Scholar
Lee, JK and Orsillo, SM (2014) Investigating cognitive flexibility as a potential mechanism of mindfulness in generalized anxiety disorder. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 45, 208–216.Google Scholar
Lehrer, PM, Woolfolk, RL, Rooney, AJ, McCann, B and Carrington, P (1983) Progressive relaxation and meditation: a study of psychophysiological and therapeutic differences between two techniques. Behaviour research and therapy 21, 651–662.Google Scholar
Lutz, A, Slagter, HA, Dunne, JD and Davidson, RJ (2008) Attention regulation and monitoring in meditation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12, 163–169.Google Scholar
Lutz, A, Jha, AP, Dunne, JD and Saron, CD (2015) Investigating the phenomenological matrix of mindfulness-related practices from a neurocognitive perspective. American Psychologist 70, 632–658.Google Scholar
Manzoni, GM, Pagnini, F, Castelnuovo, G and Molinari, E (2008) Relaxation training for anxiety: a ten-years systematic review with meta-analysis. BMC psychiatry 8, 41.Google Scholar
McCallie, MS, Blum, CM and Hood, CJ (2006) Progressive muscle relaxation. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 13, 51–66.Google Scholar
Millstein, DJ, Orsillo, SM, Hayes-Skelton, SA and Roemer, L (2015) Interpersonal problems, mindfulness, and therapy outcome in an acceptance-based behavior therapy for generalized anxiety disorder. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 44, 491–501.Google Scholar
Moher, D, Liberati, A, Tetzlaff, J and Altman, DG (2010) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. International Journal of Surgery 8, 336–341.Google Scholar
Montero-Marin, J, Garcia-Campayo, J, López-Montoyo, A, Zabaleta-del-Olmo, E and Cuijpers, P (2018 a) Is cognitive-behavioural therapy more effective than relaxation therapy in the treatment of anxiety disorders? A meta-analysis. Psychological Medicine 48, 1427–1436.Google Scholar
Montero-Marin, J, Navarro-Gil, M, Puebla-Guedea, M, Luciano, JV, Van Gordon, W, Shoning, E and García-Campayo, J (2018 b) Efficacy of “attachment-based compassion therapy” in the treatment of fibromyalgia: a randomized controlled trial. Frontiers in Psychiatry 8, 307.Google Scholar
Moritz, S, Cludius, B, Hottenrott, B, Schneider, BC, Saathoff, K, Kuelz, AK and Gallinat, J (2015) Mindfulness and relaxation treatment reduce depressive symptoms in individuals with psychosis. European Psychiatry 30, 709–714.Google Scholar
Niles, BL, Mori, DL, Polizzi, C, Pless Kaiser, A, Weinstein, ES, Gershkovich, M and Wang, C (2018) A systematic review of randomized trials of mind body interventions for PTSD. Journal of Clinical Psychology 74, 1485–1508.Google Scholar
Norton, GR, Rhodes, L, Hauch, J and Kaprowy, EA (1985) Characteristics of subjects experiencing relaxation and relaxation-induced anxiety. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 16, 211–216.Google Scholar
Olthuis, JV, Watt, MC, Bailey, K, Hayden, JA and Stewart, SH (2016) Therapist-supported internet cognitive behavioural therapy for anxiety disorders in adults. Cochrane Database of Systematic Review 3, CD011565.Google Scholar
Orme-Johnson, DW and Barnes, VA (2014) Effects of the transcendental meditation technique on trait anxiety: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 20, 330–341.Google Scholar
Ospina, MB, Bond, K, Karkhaneh, M, Buscemi, N, Dryden, DM, Barnes, V, Carlson, LE, Dusek, JA and Shannahoff-Khalsa, D (2008) Clinical trials of meditation practices in health care: characteristics and quality. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 14, 1199–1213.Google Scholar
Öst, LG (1987) Applied relaxation: description of a coping technique and review of controlled studies. Behaviour Research and Therapy 25, 397–409.Google Scholar
Parker, JC, Gilbert, GS and Thoreson, RW (1978) Reduction of autonomic arousal in alcoholics: a comparison of relaxation and meditation techniques. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 46, 879–886.Google Scholar
Remes, O, Brayne, C, van der Linde, R and Lafortune, L (2016) A systematic review of reviews on the prevalence of anxiety disorders in adult populations. Brain and Behavior 6, e00497.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, R (1979) The ‘file-drawer problem’ and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin 86, 638–641.Google Scholar
Russell, RK and Sipich, JF (1973) Cue-controlled relaxation in the treatment of test anxiety. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 4, 47–49.Google Scholar
Schultz, JH and Luthe, W (1969) Autogenic Therapy. Vol. I: Autogenic Methods. New York: Grune & Stratton.Google Scholar
Seaword, BL (2012) Managing Stress: Principles and Strategies for Health and Well-Being, 7th Edn. Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.Google Scholar
Semple, RJ (2010) Does mindfulness meditation enhance attention? A randomized controlled trial. Mindfulness 1, 121–130.Google Scholar
Simpson, HB, Neria, Y, Lewis-Fernández, R and Schneier, F (2010) Anxiety Disorders: Theory, Research, and Clinical Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Taylor, S, Thordarson, DS, Maxfield, L, Fedoroff, IC, Lovell, K and Ogrodniczuk, J (2003) Comparative efficacy, speed, and adverse effects of three PTSD treatments: exposure therapy, EMDR, and relaxation training. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71, 330–338.Google Scholar
Twohig, MP, Hayes, SC, Plumb, JC, Pruitt, LD, Collins, AB, Hazlett-Stevens, H and Woidneck, MR (2010) A randomized clinical trial of acceptance and commitment therapy versus progressive relaxation training for obsessive-compulsive disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 78, 705–716.Google Scholar
Uher, R, Payne, JL, Pavlova, B and Perlis, RH (2014) Major depressive disorder in DSM-5: implications for clinical practice and research of changes from DSM-IV. Depression and Anxiety 31, 459–471.Google Scholar
Valentine, JC, Pigott, TD and Rothstein, HR (2010) How many studies do you need? A primer on statistical power for meta-analysis. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 35, 215–247.Google Scholar
Wahbeh, H, Goodrich, E, Goy, E and Oken, BS (2016) Mechanistic pathways of mindfulness meditation in combat veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Clinical Psychology 72, 365–383.Google Scholar
Weinstein, M and Smith, JC (1992) Isometric squeeze relaxation (progressive relaxation) vs meditation: absorption and focusing as predictors of state effects. Perceptual and Motor Skills 75, 1263–1271.Google Scholar
Young, JD and Taylor, E (1998) Meditation as a voluntary hypometabolic state of biological estivation. News in Physiological Sciences 13, 149–153.Google Scholar
Zargar, F, Farid, AAA, Atef-Vahid, MK, Afshar, H and Omidi, A (2013) Comparing the effectiveness of acceptance-based behavior therapy and applied relaxation on acceptance of internal experiences, engagement in valued actions and quality of life in generalized anxiety disorder. Journal of Research in Medical Sciences: the Official Journal of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences 18, 118–122.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material

Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material 1

Download Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material(File)
File 28 KB
Supplementary material: File

Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material

Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material 2

Download Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material(File)
File 30.5 KB
Supplementary material: File

Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material

Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material 3

Download Montero-Marin et al. supplementary material(File)
File 26.6 KB