Skip to main content

Where should bipolar disorder appear in the meta-structure?: Paper 7 of 7 of the thematic section: ‘A proposal for a meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11’

  • D. P. Goldberg (a1), G. Andrews (a2) and M. J. Hobbs (a2)

The extant major psychiatric classifications, DSM-IV and ICD-10, are purportedly atheoretical and largely descriptive. Although this achieves good reliability, the validity of a medical diagnosis is greatly enhanced by an understanding of both risk factors and clinical history. In an effort to group mental disorders on the basis of risk factors and clinical manifestations, five clusters have been proposed. The purpose of this paper is to consider the position of bipolar disorder (BPD), which could be either with the psychoses, or with emotional disorders, or in a separate cluster.


We reviewed the literature on BPD, unipolar depression (UPD) and schizophrenia in relation to 11 validating criteria proposed by the DSM-V Task Force Study Group, and then summarized similarities and differences between BPD and schizophrenia on the one hand, and UPD on the other.


There are differences, often substantial and never trivial, for 10 of the 11 validators between BPD and UPD. There are also important differences between BPD and schizophrenia.


BPD has previously been classified together with UPD, but this is the least justifiable place for it. If it is to be recruited to a ‘psychotic cluster’, there are several important respects in which it differs from schizophrenia, so the cluster would have a division within it. The alternative would be to allow it to be in an intermediate position in a cluster of its own.

Corresponding author
*Address for correspondence: Professor Sir David Goldberg, Institute of Psychiatry, de Crespigny Park, London SE5 8AF, UK. (Email:
Hide All
Agid O, Shapira B, Zislin J, Ritsner M, Hanin B, Murad H, Troudart T, Bloch M, Heresco-Levy U, Lerer B (1999). Environment and vulnerability to major psychiatric illness: a case control study of early parental loss in major depression, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. Molecular Psychiatry 4, 163172.
Akiskal HS, Kilzieh N, Maser JD, Clayton PJ, Schettler PJ, Traci Shea M, Endicott J, Scheftner W, Hirschfeld RMA, Keller MB (2006). The distinct temperament profiles of bipolar I, bipolar II and unipolar patients. Journal of Affective Disorders 92, 1933.
Alnaes R, Torgersen S (1993). Mood disorders: developmental and precipitating events. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 38, 217224.
Andreasen NC, Rice J, Endicott J (1987). Familial rates of affective disorder. A report from the National Institute of Mental Health Collaborative Study. Archives of General Psychiatry 44, 461469.
Andrews G, Goldberg DP, Krueger RF, Carpenter WT Jr., Hyman SE, Sachdev P, Pine DS (2009 a). Exploring the feasibility of a meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11: could it improve utility and validity? Psychological Medicine. doi:10.1017/S0033291709990250.
Andrews G, Pine DS, Hobbs MJ, Anderson TM, Sunderland M (2009 b). Neurodevelopmental disorders: Cluster 2 of the proposed meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11. Psychological Medicine. doi:10.1017/S0033291709990274.
Angst J, Gamma A (in press). Validators of generalised anxiety disorder and major depression. In Diagnostic Issues in Depression and Generalized Anxiety Disorder: Refining the Research Agenda for DSM-V (ed. Goldberg D. P., Kendler K. S., Sirovatka P. and Regier D. A.), American Psychiatric Association: Arlington, VA.
Baxter LR Jr., Phelps ME, Mazziotta JC, Schwarz JM, Gerner RH, Selin CE, Sumida RM (1985). Cerebral metabolic rate for glucose in mood disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry 42, 441447.
Bertelsen A, Harvald B, Hague M (1977). A Danish twin study of manic depressive disorders. British Journal of Psychiatry 130, 330351.
Blacker D, Tsuang MT (1993). Unipolar relatives in bipolar pedigrees: are they bipolar? Psychiatric Genetics 3, 516.
Borkowska A, Rybakowski JK (2001). Neuropsychological frontal lobe tests indicate that bipolar depressed patients are more impaired than unipolar. Bipolar Disorders 3, 8894.
Brockington IF, Leff J (1979). Schizoaffective psychosis: definitions and incidence. Psychological Medicine 9, 9199.
Bunney WE, Bunney BG (2000). Molecular clock genes in man and lower animals: possible implications for circadian abnormalities in depression. Neurophyschopharmacology 22, 335345.
Cannon DM, Ichise M, Rollis D, Klaver JM, Gandhi SK, Charney DS, Manji HK, Drevets WC (2007). Elevated serotonin transporter binding in major depressive disorder assessed using positron emission tomography and [11C]DASB: comparison with bipolar disorder. Biological Psychiatry 62, 870877.
Cannon TD, Rosso IM, Hollister JM, Bearden CE, Sanchez LE, Hadley T (2000). A prospective cohort study of genetic and perinatal influences in the etiology of schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin 26, 351366.
Cardno AG, Rijsdijk F, Sham PC, Murray RM, McGuffin P (2002). A twin study of genetic relationships between psychotic symptoms. American Journal of Psychiatry 159, 539545.
Carpenter WT Jr., Bustillo JR, Thaker GK, van Os J, Krueger RF, Green MJ (2009). Psychoses: Cluster 3 of the proposed meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11. Psychological Medicine. doi:10.1017/S0033291709990286.
Chun BJ, Dunner DL (2004). A review of antidepressant-induced hypomania in major depression: suggestions for DSM-V. Bipolar Disorders 6, 3242.
Clayton PJ, Ernst C, Angst J (1994). Premorbid personality traits of men who develop unipolar or bipolar disorders. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience 243, 340346.
Coryell W, Andreasen NC, Endicott J, Keller M (1987). The significance of past mania or hypomania in the course and outcome of major depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 144, 309315.
Craddock N (1995). Genetic linkage and association studies of bipolar disorder. Ph.D. thesis, University of Wales, UK.
Crow TJ (2007). How and why genetic linkage has not solved the problem of psychosis: review and hypothesis. American Journal of Psychiatry 164, 1321.
Cuellar AK, Johnson SL, Winters R (2005). Distinctions between bipolar and unipolar depression. Clinical Psychology Review 25, 307339.
Forty L, Smith D, Jones I, Caesar S, Cooper C, Fraser C, Gordon-Smith K, Hyde S, Farmer A, McGuffin P, Craddock N (2008). Clinical differences between bipolar and unipolar depression. British Journal of Psychiatry 192, 388389.
Furukawa TA, Konno W, Morinobu S, Harai H, Kitamura T, Takahashi K (2000). Course and outcome of depressive episodes: comparison between bipolar, unipolar and subthreshold depression. Psychiatry Research 96, 211220.
Furukawa TA, Ogura A, Hirai T, Fujihara S, Kitamura T, Takahashi K (1999). Early parental separation experiences among patients with bipolar disorder and major depression: a case–control study. Journal of Affective Disorders 52, 8591.
Geddes JR, Verdoux H, Takei N, Lawrie SM, Bovet P, Eagles JM, Heun R, McCreadie RG, McNeil TF, O'Callaghan E, Stober G, Willinger U, Murray RM (1999). Schizophrenia and complications of pregnancy and labor: an individual patient data meta-analysis. Schizophrenia Bulletin 25, 413423.
Gelder MG, Lopez-Ibor JJ, Andreasen NC (ed.) (2000). New Oxford Textbook of Psychiatry. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Goldberg DP, Krueger RF, Andrews G, Hobbs MJ (2009). Emotional disorders: Cluster 4 of the proposed meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11. Psychological Medicine. doi:10.1017/S0033291709990298.
Hettema JM (2008). What is the genetic relationship between anxiety and depression? American Journal of Medical Genetics. Part C, Seminars in Medical Genetics 148C, 140146.
Himmelhoch JM, Thase ME, Mallinger AG, Houck P (1991). Tranylcypromine versus imipramine in angeric bipolar depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 148, 910916.
Jacobi F, Wittchen H-U, Holting C, Hofler M, Pfister H, Muller N, Lieb R (2004). Prevalence, co-morbidity and correlates of mental disorders in the general population: results from the German Health Interview and Examination Survey (GHS). Psychological Medicine 34, 597611.
Jaffee SR, Moffitt TE, Capsi A, Fombonne E, Poulton R, Martin J (2002). Differences in early childhood risk factors for juvenile-onset and adult-onset depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 59, 215222.
Jones I, Kent L, Craddock N (2002). Genetics of affective disorders. In Psychiatric Genetics and Genomics (ed. McGuffin P., Owen M. and Gottesman I. I.), pp. 211246. Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK.
Kendler KS, Karkowski LM, Walsh D (1998). The structure of psychosis: latent class analysis of probands from the Roscommon family study. Archives of General Psychiatry 55, 492499.
Kendler KS, Neale MC, Kessler RC, Heath AC, Eaves LJ (1993). A longitudinal twin study of personality and major depression in women. Archives of General Psychiatry 50, 853862.
Kendler KS, Pedersen NL, Neale MC, Mathe AA (1995). A pilot twin study of affective illness including hospital- and population-ascertained subsamples: results of model fitting. Behavior Genetics 25, 217232.
Kendler KS, Prescott CA, Myers J, Neale MC (2003). The structure of genetic and environmental risk factors for common psychiatric and substance use disorders in men and women. Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 929937.
Kessler R, Chiu WT, Demler O, Walters EF (2005). Prevalence severity and co-morbidity of 12 month DSM-4 disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 62, 617627.
Konarski JZ, McIntyre RS, Kennedy SH, Rafi-Tari S, Soczynska JK, Ketter TA (2008). Volumetric neuroimaging investigations in mood disorders: bipolar disorder versus major depressive disorder. Bipolar Disorders 10, 137.
Krueger RF, South SC (2009). Externalizing disorders: Cluster 5 of the proposed meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11. Psychological Medicine. doi:10.1017/S0033291709990328.
Krüger S, Cooke RG, Hasey GM, Jorna T, Persad E (1995). Comorbidity of obsessive–compulsive disorder in bipolar disorder. Journal of Affective Disorders 34, 117120.
Krüger S, Seminowicz D, Goldapple K, Kennedy SH, Mayberg HS (2003). State and trait influences on mood regulation in bipolar disorder: blood flow differences with an acute mood challenge. Biological Psychiatry 54, 12741283.
Laursen TM, Munk-Olsen T, Nordentoft M, Mortensen PB (2007). A comparison of selected risk factors for unipolar depressive disorder, bipolar affective disorder, schizoaffective disorder, and schizophrenia from a Danish population-based cohort. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 68, 16731681.
Lawrence NS, Williams AM, Surguladze S, Giampietro V, Brammer MJ, Andrew C, Frangou S, Ecker C, Phillips ML (2004). Subcortical and ventral prefrontal cortical neural responses to facial expressions distinguish patients with bipolar disorder and major depression. Biological Psychiatry 55, 578587.
Lichtenstein P, Yip BH, Bjork C, Pawitan Y, Cannon TD, Sullivan PF, Hultman CM (2009). Common genetic determinants of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder in Swedish families: a population-based study. Lancet 373, 234239.
Liotti M, Mayberg HS, McGinnis S, Brannan SL, Jerabek P (2002). Unmasking disease-specific cerebral blood flow abnormalities: mood challenge in patients with remitted unipolar depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 159, 18301840.
Maier W, Lichterman D, Minges J, Hallmayer J, Heun R, Benkert O, Levinson DF (1993). Continuity and discontinuity of affective disorders and schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry 50, 871873.
Malhi GS, Green MJ, Fagiolini A, Peselow ED, Kumari V (2008). Schizoaffective disorder: diagnostic issues and future recommendations. Bipolar Disorders 10, 215230.
McDonald C (2008). Structural brain deviations in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder: to what extent are they genetically related? In The Maudsley Family Study of Psychosis (ed. McDonald C.), pp. 155196. Psychology Press: New York, NY.
McGuffin P, Katz R, Bebbington P (1987). Hazard, heredity and depression. A family study. Journal of Psychiatric Research 21, 365375.
McGuffin P, Rijsdijk F, Andrew M, Sham P, Katz R, Cardno A (2003). The heritability of bipolar disorder and its relationship to unipolar depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 499502.
Merikangas K, Herrell R, Swendsen J, Rössler W, Ajdacic-Gross V, Angst J (2008). Specificity of bipolar spectrum conditions in the comorbidity of mood and substance use disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry 65, 4752.
Merikangas KR, Akiskal HS, Angst J, Greenberg PE, Hirschfeld RMA, Petukhova M, Kessler RC (2007). Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of bipolar spectrum disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 64, 543552.
Mitchell PB, Goodwin GM, Johnson GF, Hirschfeld RMA (2008). Diagnostic guidelines for bipolar depression: a probabilistic approach. Bipolar Disorders 10, 144152.
Mitchell PB, Slade T, Andrews G (2004). Twelve-month prevalence and disability of DSM-IV bipolar disorder in an Australian general population survey. Psychological Medicine 34, 777785.
Mortensen PB, Pedersen CB, Melbye M, Mors O, Ewald H (2003). Individual and familial risk factors for bipolar affective disorders in Denmark. Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 12091215.
Murray RM, Sham P, Van Os J, Zanelli J, Cannon M, McDonald C (2004). A developmental model for similarities and dissimilarities between schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Schizophrenia Research 71, 405416.
Owen MJ, Craddock N, Jablensky A (2007). The genetic deconstruction of psychosis. Schizophrenia Bulletin 33, 905911.
Passino CS, Perugi G (2005). Eating disorders, obesity and bipolar spectrum. Italian Journal of Psychopathology 11, 326346.
Phillips ML, Drevets WC, Rauch SL, Lane R (2003). Neurobiology of emotion perception. II: Implications for major psychiatric disorders. Biological Psychiatry 54, 515528.
Phillips ML, Vieta E (2007). Identifying functional neuroimaging biomarkers of bipolar disorder: toward DSM-V. Schizophrenia Bulletin 33, 893904.
Rea MM, Miklowitz DJ, Tompson MC, Goldstein MJ, Hwang S, Mintz J (2003). Family-focused treatment versus individual treatment for bipolar disorder: results of a randomized clinical trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71, 482492.
Roschke J, Wagner P, Mann K, Fell J, Grozinger M, Frank C (1996). Single trial analysis of event related potentials: a comparison between schizophrenics and depressives. Biological Psychiatry 40, 844852.
Roy-Byrne P, Post RM, Uhde TW, Porcu T, Davis D (1985). The longitudinal course of recurrent affective illness: life chart data from research patients at the NIMH. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (Suppl.) 71, 134.
Sachdev P, Andrews G, Hobbs MJ, Sunderland M, Anderson TM (2009). Neurocognitive disorders: Cluster 1 of the proposed meta-structure for DSM-V and ICD-11. Psychological Medicine. doi:10.1017/S0033291709990262.
Sachs GS, Nierenberg AA, Calabrese JR, Marangell LB, Wisniewski LR, Gyulai L, Friedman ES, Bowden CL, Fossey MD, Ostacher MJ, Ketter TA, Patel J, Hauser P (2007). Effectiveness of adjunctive antidepressant treatment for bipolar depression. New England Journal of Medicine 356, 17111722.
Solomon DA, Leon AC, Coryell W, Mueller TI, Posternak MA (2003). Unipolar mania: a 20-year follow-up study. American Journal of Psychiatry 160, 20492050.
Soreca I, Frank E, Kupfer DJ (2009). The phenomenology of bipolar disorder: what drives the high rate of medical burden and determines long-term prognosis? Depression and Anxiety 26, 7382.
Strakowski SM, McElroy SL, Keck PW Jr., West SA (1994). The co-occurrence of mania with medical and other psychiatric disorders. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine 24, 305328.
Summers M, Papadopoulou K, Bruno S, Cipolotti L, Ron MA (2006). Bipolar I and bipolar II disorder: cognition and emotion processing. Psychological Medicine 36, 17991809.
Tackett JL, Quilty LC, Sellbom M, Rector M, Bagby NA (2008). Internalizing disorders and personality structure. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 117, 454459.
Taylor M (1992). Are schizophrenia and affective disorder related? A selective literature review. American Journal of Psychiatry 149, 2232.
Thase ME, Mallinger AG, McKnight D, Himmelhoch JM (1992). Treatment of imipramine-resistant recurrent depression. IV: A double-blind crossover study of trancypromine for anergic bipolar depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 149, 195198.
Van Os J, Jones P, Sham P, Bebbington P, Murray RM (1998). Risk factors for onset and persistence of psychosis. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 33, 596605.
Weissman MM, Bland RC, Canino GJ, Fravelli C, Greenwald S, Hwu H-G, Joyce PR, Karam EG, Lee C-K, Lellouch J, Lepine J-P, Newman SC, Rubio-Stipec M, Wells JE, Wickamaratne PJ, Wittchen H-U, Yeh E-K (1996). Cross-national epidemiology of major depression and bipolar disorder. Journal of the American Medical Association 276, 293299.
Wildes JE, Marcus MD, Fagiolini A (2008). Prevalence and correlates of eating disorder co-morbidity in patients with bipolar disorder. Psychiatry Research 161, 5158.
Winokur G, Coryell W, Keller M, Endicott J, Leon A (1995). A family study of manic-depressive (bipolar I) disease: is it a distinct illness separable from primary unipolar depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 52, 367373.
Wolfe J, Granholm E, Butters EN, Saunders E, Janowsky D (1987). Verbal memory deficits associated with major affective disorders: a comparison of unipolar and bipolar patients. Journal of Affective Disorders 13, 8392.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 8
Total number of PDF views: 61 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 240 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 25th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.