Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

A methodology for design and appraisal of surgical robotic systems

  • Michael D. O'Toole (a1), Kaddour Bouazza-Marouf (a1), David Kerr (a1), Mahendra Gooroochurn (a1) and Michael Vloeberghs (a1)
  • DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0263574709990658
  • Published online: 07 December 2009
Abstract
SUMMARY

Surgical robotics is a growing discipline, continuously expanding with an influx of new ideas and research. However, it is important that the development of new devices take account of past mistakes and successes. A structured approach is necessary, as with proliferation of such research, there is a danger that these lessons will be obscured, resulting in the repetition of mistakes and wasted effort and energy. There are several research paths for surgical robotics, each with different risks and opportunities and different methodologies to reach a profitable outcome. The main emphasis of this paper is on a methodology for ‘applied research’ in surgical robotics. The methodology sets out a hierarchy of criteria consisting of three tiers, with the most important being the bottom tier and the least being the top tier. It is argued that a robotic system must adhere to these criteria in order to achieve acceptability. Recent commercial systems are reviewed against these criteria, and are found to conform up to at least the bottom and intermediate tiers, the most important first two tiers, and thus gain some acceptability. However, the lack of conformity to the criteria in the top tier, and the inability to conclusively prove increased clinical benefit, is shown to be hampering their potential in gaining wide establishment.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Corresponding author. E-mail: M.D.OToole@lboro.ac.uk
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

1. Y. S. Kwoh , J. Hou , E. A. Jonckheere and S. Hayati , “A robot with improved absolute positioning accuracy for CT guided stereotactic brain surgery,” IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng. 35 (2), 153160 (1988).

2. R. H. Taylor and D. Stoianovici , “Medical robotics in computer-integrated surgery,” IEEE Trans. Robotics Automat. 19 (5), 765781 (2003).

3. P. Dario , B. Hannaford and A. Menciassi , “Smart surgical tools and augmenting devices,” IEEE Trans. Robotics Automat. 19 (5), 782792 (2003).

4. B. Davies , “A review of robotics in surgery,” Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part H: J. Eng. Med. 214 (H1), 129140 (2000).

5. P. P. Pott , H. P. Scharf and M. L. Schwarz , “Today's state of the art in surgical robotics,” Comput. Aided Surg. 10 (2), 101132 (2005).

6. N. A. Patronik , M. A. Zenati and C. N. Riviere , “Preliminary evaluation of a mobile robotic device for navigation and intervention on the beating heart,” Comput. Aided Surg. 10 (4), 225232 (2005).

7. Y. W. Lu and C. J. Kim , “Microhand for biological applications,” Appl. Phys. Lett. 89 (16), (2006).

9. G. Kosa , M. Shoham and M. Zaaroor , “Propulsion of a swimming micro medical robot,” Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation, Alberta, Canada (2005).

10. K. B. Yesin , K. Vollmers and B. J. Nelson , “Modeling and control of untethered biomicrorobots in a fluidic environment using electromagnetic fields,” Int. J. Robotics Res. 25 (5/6), 527536 (2006).

14. M. Menon , A. Shrivastava and A. Tewari , “Laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: Conventional and robotic,” Urology 66 (5 Suppl.), 101104 (2005).

15. M. Menon , A. Shrivastava , S. Kaul , K. K. Badani , M. Fumo , M. Bhandari and J. O. Peabody , “Vattikuti Institute prostatectomy: Contemporary technique and analysis of results,” Eur. Urol. 51 (3), 648657; discussion 657–648 (2007).

16. D. G. Murphy , M. Kerger , H. Crowe , J. S. Peters and A. J. Costello , “Operative details and oncological and functional outcome of robotic-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: 400 cases with a minimum of 12 months follow-up,” Eur. Urol. 55 (6), 13581367 (2009).

17. T. Hananouchi , N. Sugano , T. Nishii , N. Nakamura , H. Miki , A. Kakimoto , M. Yamamura and H. Yoshikawa , “Effect of robotic milling on periprosthetic bone remodeling,” J. Orthop. Res. 25 (8), 10621069 (2007).

18. P. Kornprat , G. Werkgartner , H. Cerwenka , H. Bacher , A. El-Shabrawi , P. Rehak and H. J. Mischinger , “Prospective study comparing standard and robotically assisted laparoscopic cholecystectomy,” Langenbecks Arch. Surg. 391 (3), 14352443 (2006).

19. J. C. Wu , H. S. Wu , M. S. Lin , D. A. Chou and M. H. Huang , “Comparison of robot-assisted laparoscopic adrenalectomy with traditional laparoscopic adrenalectomy – 1 year follow-up,” Surg. Endosc. 22 (2), 463466 (2008).

20. F. Rodriguez , S. Harris , M. Jakopec , A. Barrett , P. Gomes , J. Henckel , J. Cobb and B. Davies , “Robotic clinical trials of uni-condylar arthroplasty,” Int. J. Med. Robot 1 (4), 2028 (2005).

22. T. R. K. Varma and P. Eldridge , “Use of the NeuroMate stereotactic robot in a frameless mode for functional neurosurgery,” Int. J. Med. Robotics Comput. Assisted Surg. 2 (2), 107113 (2006).

24. A. A. Wagner , I. M. Varkarakis , R. E. Link , W. Sullivan and L. M. Su , “Comparison of surgical performance during laparoscopic radical prostatectomy of two robotic camera holders, EndoAssist and AESOP: Apilot study,” Urology 68 (1), 7074 (2006).

25. M. Alessandrini , A. De Padova , B. Napolitano , A. Camillo and E. Bruno , “The AESOP robot system for video-assisted rigid endoscopic laryngosurgery,” Eur. Arch. Otorhinolaryngol. 265 (9), 11211123 (2008).

26. N. Calcerrada Diaz-Santos , J. A. Blasco Amaro , G. A. Cardiel and E. Andradas Aragones , “The safety and efficacy of robotic image-guided radiosurgery system treatment for intra- and extracranial lesions: A systematic review of the literature,” Radiother. Oncol. 89 (3), 245253 (2008).

27. D. W. Andrews , G. Bednarz , J. J. Evans and B. Downes , “A review of 3 current radiosurgery systems,” Surg. Neurol. 66 (6), 559564 (2006).

28. F. Colombo , L. Casentini , C. Cavedon , P. Scalchi , S. Cora and P. Francescon , “Cyberknife radiosurgery for benign meningiomas: Short-term results in 199 patients,” Neurosurgery 64 (2 Suppl.), A713 (2009).

29. R. Berryhill Jr., J. Jhaveri , R. Yadav , R. Leung , S. Rao , A. El-Hakim and A. Tewari , “Robotic prostatectomy: A review of outcomes compared with laparoscopic and open approaches,” Urology 72 (1), 1523 (2008).

30. V. Ficarra , S. Cavalleri , G. Novara , M. Aragona and W. Artibani , “Evidence from robot-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: A systematic review,” Eur. Urol. 51 (1), 4555; discussion 56 (2007).

31. S. Aiono , J. M. Gilbert , B. Soin , P. A. Finlay and A. Gordan , “Controlled trial of the introduction of a robotic camera assistant (EndoAssist) for laparoscopic cholecystectomy,” Surg. Endosc. 16 (9), 12671270 (2002).

32. J. M. Gilbert , “The EndoAssist robotic camera holder as an aid to the introduction of laparoscopic colorectal surgery,” Ann. Roy. College Surgeons Engl. 91 (5), 389393 (2009).

33. K. Tanoue , T. Yasunaga , E. Kobayashi , S. Miyamoto , I. Sakuma , T. Dohi , K. Konishi , S. Yamaguchi , N. Kinjo , K. Takenaka , Y. Maehara and M. Hashizume , “Laparoscopic cholecystectomy using a newly developed laparoscope manipulator for 10 patients with cholelithiasis,” Surg. Endosc. 20 (5), 753756 (2006).

34. I. Yoshino , T. Yasunaga , M. Hashizume and Y. Maehara , “A novel endoscope manipulator, Naviot, enables solo-surgery to be performed during video-assisted thoracic surgery,” Interact. Cardiovasc. Thoracic Surg. 4 (5), 404405 (2005).

35. K. Yamada and S. Kato , “Robot-assisted thoracoscopic lung resection aimed at solo surgery for primary lung cancer,” Gen. Thoracic Cardiovasc. Surg. 56 (6), 292294 (2008).

36. M. S. Eljamel , “Robotic neurological surgery applications: Accuracy and consistency or pure fantasy?Stereotactic Funct. Neurosurg. 87 (2), 8893 (2009).

37. M. S. Eljamel , “Robotic application in epilepsy surgery,” Int. J. Med. Robot 2 (3), 233237 (2006).

38. S. Nishihara , N. Sugano , T. Nishii , H. Miki , N. Nakamura and H. Yoshikawa , “Comparison between hand rasping and robotic milling for stem implantation in cementless total hip arthroplasty,” J. Arthroplasty 21 (7), 957966 (2006).

39. A. P. Schulz , K. Seide , C. Queitsch , A. von Haugwitz , J. Meiners , B. Kienast , M. Tarabolsi , M. Kammal and C. Jurgens , “Results of total hip replacement using the Robodoc surgical assistant system: Clinical outcome and evaluation of complications for 97 procedures,” Int. J. Med. Robot 3 (4), 301306 (2007).

40. M. Shoham , I. H. Lieberman , E. C. Benzel , D. Togawa , E. Zehavi , B. Zilberstein , M. Roffman , A. Bruskin , A. Fridlander , L. Joskowicz , S. Brink-Danan and N. Knoller , “Robotic assisted spinal surgery – From concept to clinical practice,” Comput. Aided Surg. 12 (2), 105115 (2007).

41. I. Pechlivanis , G. Kiriyanthan , M. Engelhardt , M. Scholz , S. Lucke , A. Harders and K. Schmieder , “Percutaneous placement of pedicle screws in the lumbar spine using a bone mounted miniature robotic system: First experiences and accuracy of screw placement,” Spine 34 (4), 392398 (2009).

43. J. Heemskerk , R. Zandbergen , J. G. Maessen , J. W. Greve and N. D. Bouvy , “Advantages of advanced laparoscopic systems,” Surg. Endosc. 20 (5), 730733 (2006).

44. H. G. Sim , S. K. H. Yip and C. W. S. Cheng , “Equipment and technology in surgical robotics,” World J. Urol. 24 (2), 128135 (2006).

45. A. Rane , S. Kommu , B. Eddy , P. Rimington and C. Anderson , “Initial experience with the endoassist (R) camera holding robot in laparoscopic urological surgery,” Eur. Urol. Suppl. 6 (2), 186186 (2007).

46. P. A. Finlay and P. Morgan , “PathFinder image guided robot for neurosurgery,” Industr. Robot Int. J. 30 (1), 3034 (2003).

47. B. W. Fei , W. S. Ng , S. Chauhan and C. K. Kwoh , “The safety issues of medical robotics,” Reliability Eng. Syst.Safety 73 (2), 183192 (2001).

48. P. Varley , “Techniques for development of safety-related software for surgical robots,” IEEE Trans. Information Technol. Biomed. 3 (4), 261267 (1999).

50. W. Korb , M. Kornfeld , W. Birkfellner , R. Boesecke , M. Figl , M. Fuerst , J. Kettenbach , A. Vogler , S. Hassfeld and G. Kornreif , “Risk analysis and safety assessment in surgical robotics: A case study on a biopsy robot,” Minim. Invasive Ther. Allied Technol. 14 (1), 2331 (2005).

51. D. Kilic and E. A. Croft , “Safe planning for human–robot interaction,” J. Robotic Syst. 22 (7), 383396 (2005).

52. C. D. Scales Jr., P. J. Jones , E. L. Eisenstein , G. M. Preminger and D. M. Albala , “Local cost structures and the economics of robot assisted radical prostatectomy,” J. Urol. 174 (6), 23232329 (2005).

53. Y. Lotan , J. A. Cadeddu and M. T. Gettman , “The new economics of radical prostatectomy: Cost comparison of open, laparoscopic and robot assisted techniques,” J. Urol. 172 (4 Pt 1), 14311435 (2004).

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Robotica
  • ISSN: 0263-5747
  • EISSN: 1469-8668
  • URL: /core/journals/robotica
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×