Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Concept of Disease and its Implications for Psychiatry

  • R. E. Kendell (a1)
Extract

It has often been suggested in recent years that there is no such thing as mental illness; that the conditions psychiatrists spend their time trying to treat ought not, properly speaking, to be regarded as illness at all, or even to be the concern of physicians. Szasz is the best-known exponent of this viewpoint, and the core of his argument is essentially this: that as prolonged search has never demonstrated any consistent physical abnormality in those regarded as mentally ill, and as their ‘illness' consists simply in behaving in ways that alarm or affront other people, or in believing things which other people do not believe, there is no justification for labelling them as ill, and to do so is to use the word illness in a purely metaphorical sense (Szasz, 1960). Schneider had previously been led by the same reasoning to the conclusion that neurotic illness and personality disorders were ‘abnormal varieties of sane mental life’ rather than disease, but he took care to exempt schizophrenia and cyclothymia by assuming that both would in time prove to possess an organic basis (Schneider, 1950). The argument Eysenck puts forward in the first edition of his textbook, though written from the quite different standpoint of academic psychology, is a similar one. After observing that ‘the term psychiatry does not denote any meaningful grouping of problems or subjects of study’ he went on to suggest that the traditional subject-matter of psychiatry should be divided into a small medical part ‘dealing with the effects of tumours, lesions, infections and other physical conditions' and a much larger behavioural part ‘dealing with disorders of behaviour acquired through the ordinary processes of learning’, thereby implying that most of what doctors regarded as mental illness was really learnt behaviour rather than disease, and therefore much better understood, and dealt with, by psychologists than by physicians (Eysenck, 1960). A third line of attack is provided by R. D. Laing, and a fourth is exemplified by the sociologist Scheff. Laing argues that schizophrenia, far from being a disease or a form of insanity, is really the only sane or rational way adolescents have of coping with the intolerable emotional pressures placed on them by society and their families (Laing, 1967). Scheff has developed the somewhat similar argument that what psychiatrists call mental illness is largely a response to the shock of being labelled and treated as insane and the expectations this produces; in other words that schizophrenia is created by the people and institutions that purport to treat it (Scheff, 1963).

Copyright
References
Hide All
Alström, C. H. (1942) Mortality in mental hospitals. Acta Psychiatrica et Neurologica Scandinavica, Suppl. 24.
Babigian, H. M. & Odoroff, G. L. (1969) The mortality experience of a population with psychiatric illness. American Journal of Psychiatry, 126, 470–80.
Cohen, H. (1943) The Nature, Method and Purpose of Diagnosis. Cambridge.
Dahlbero, G. (1933) Die Fruchtbarkeit der Geisteskranken, Zeitschrift für die gesamte Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 144, 427.
Engle, R. L. & Davis, B. J. (1963) Medical diagnosis: past, present and future. I. Present concepts of the meaning and limitations of medical diagnosis. Archives of Internal Medicine, 112, 512–19.
Essen-Möller, E. (1935) Untersuchungen über die Fruchtbarkeit gewisser Gruppen von Geisteskranken. Acta Psychiatrica et Neurologica Scandinavica, Suppl. 8.
Eysenck, H. j. (1960) Classification and the problem of diagnosis. In Handbook of Abnormal Psychology (ed. Eysenck). London.
Eysenck, H. j. (1971) Personality and sexual adjustment. British Journal of Psychiatry, 118, 593608.
Hopkinson, G. (1963) Celibacy and marital fertility in manic-depressive patients. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 39, 473–6.
Innes, G. & Millar, W. M. (1970) Mortality among psychiatric patients. Scottish Medical Journal, 15, 143–8.
Kräupl Taylor, F. (1971) A logical analysis of the medico-psychological concept of disease. Psychological Medicine, 1, 356–64.
Laing, R. D. (1967) The Politics of Experience. Penguin Books.
Larsson, T. & Sjögren, T. (1954) A methodological, psychiatric and statistical study of a large Swedish rural population. Acta Psychiatrica et Neurologica Scandinavica, Suppl. 89.
Lewis, A. (1958) Fertility and mental illness. Eugenics Review, 50, 91106.
Linder, R. (1965) Diagnosis: description or prescription? A case study in the psychology of diagnosis. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 20, 1081–92.
Macsorley, K. (1964) An investigation into the fertility rates of mentally ill patients. Annals of Human Genetics, 27, 247–56.
Malzberg, B. (1953) Rates of discharge and rates of mortality among first admissions to the New York civil state hospitals. Mental Hygiene, 37, 619–54.
Ødegaard, Ø. (1951) Mortality in Norwegian mental hospitals, 1926–41. Acta Genetica, 2, 141–73.
Oldham, P. D., Pickering, G., Fraser Roberts, J. A. & Sowry, G. S. G. (1960) The nature of essential hypertension. Lancet, i, 1085–93.
Rosenthal, D. (1970) Genetic Theory and Abnormal Behavior. New York.
Sainsbury, P. (1968) Suicide and depression. In Recent Developments in Affective Disorders (ed. Coppen and Walk). London.
Scadding, J. G. (1967) Diagnosis: the clinician and the computer. Lancet, ii, 877–82.
Scheff, T. J. (1963) The role of the mentally ill and the dynamics of mental disorder: a research framework. Sociometry, 26, 436–53.
Schneider, K. (1950) Systematic psychiatry. American Journal of Psychiatry, 107, 334–5.
Slater, E. (1945) Neurosis and sexuality. Journal of Neurology and Psychiatry, 8, 1214.
Stevens, B. G. (1969) Marriage and Fertility of Women Suffering from Schizophrenia or Affective Disorders (Maudsley Monograph No. 19.) London.
Szasz, T. S. (1960) The myth of mental illness. American Psychologist, 15, 113–8; or book of same title. London: Seeker and Warburg, 1961.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The British Journal of Psychiatry
  • ISSN: 0007-1250
  • EISSN: 1472-1465
  • URL: /core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 31 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 141 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 29th January 2018 - 21st June 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

The Concept of Disease and its Implications for Psychiatry

  • R. E. Kendell (a1)
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.

×

Reply to: Submit a response


Your details


Conflicting interests

Do you have any conflicting interests? *