Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The full spectrum of ethical issues in dementia care: systematic qualitative review

  • Daniel Strech (a1), Marcel Mertz (a2), Hannes Knuüppel (a3), Gerald Neitzke (a4) and Martina Schmidhuber (a4)...
Abstract
Background

Integrating ethical issues in dementia-specific training material, clinical guidelines and national strategy plans requires an unbiased awareness of all the relevant ethical issues.

Aims

To determine systematically and transparently the full spectrum of ethical issues in clinical dementia care.

Method

We conducted a systematic review in Medline (restricted to English and German literature published between 2000 and 2011) and Google books (with no restrictions). We applied qualitative text analysis and normative analysis to categorise the spectrum of ethical issues in clinical dementia care.

Results

The literature review retrieved 92 references that together mentioned a spectrum of 56 ethicalissues in clinical dementia care. The spectrum was structured into seven major categories thatconsist of first- and second-order categories for ethical issues.

Conclusions

The systematically derived spectrum of ethical issues in clinical dementia care presented in this paper can be used as training material for healthcare professionals, students and the public for raising awareness and understanding of the complexity of ethical issues in dementia care. It can also be used to identify ethical issues that should be addressed in dementia-specific training programmes, national strategy plans and clinical practice guidelines. Further research should evaluate whether this new genre of systematic reviews can be applied to the identification of ethical issues in other cognitive and somatic diseases. Also, the practical challenges in addressing ethical issues in training material, guidelines and policies need to be evaluated.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      The full spectrum of ethical issues in dementia care: systematic qualitative review
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      The full spectrum of ethical issues in dementia care: systematic qualitative review
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      The full spectrum of ethical issues in dementia care: systematic qualitative review
      Available formats
      ×
Copyright
Corresponding author
Daniel Strech, Hannover Medical School, Institute for History, Ethics and Philosophy in Medicine, CELLS - Centre for Ethics and Law in the Life Sciences, Carl-Neuberg Straβe 1, 30625 Hanover, Germany. Email: strech.daniel@mh-hannover.de
Footnotes
Hide All

Declaration of interest

None.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
1 Post, SG Whitehouse, PJ. Fairhill guidelines on ethics of the care of people with Alzheimer's disease: a clinical summary. Center for Biomedical Ethics, Case Western Reserve University and the Alzheimer's Association. J Am Geriatr Soc 1995; 43: 1423–9.
2 Nuffield Council on Bioethics. Dementia: Ethical Issues. Nuffield Council on Bioethics, 2009.
3 Oppenheimer, C. Ethics in old age psychiatry. In Psychiatric Ethics (eds Bloch, S Green, S): 409–33. Oxford University Press 2009.
4 Rabins, PV Black, BS. Ethical issues in geriatric psychiatry. Int Rev Psychiatry 2010; 22: 267–73.
5 Rai, GS Eccles, J. Ethical issues in dementia. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 125–37. Radcliffe 2009.
6 Bernat, JL. Ethical issues in the care of patients with dementia. In Handbook of Clinical Neurology (eds Duyckaerts, C Litvan, I): 115–30. Elsevier 2008.
7 Baldwin, C Hughes, J Hope, T Jacoby, R Ziebland, S Ethics and dementia: mapping the literature by bibliometric analysis. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2003; 18: 4154.
8 Hughes, JC Hope, T Savulescu, J Ziebland, S Carers, ethics and dementia: a survey and review of the literature. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2002; 17: 3540.
9 Beauchamp, TL Childress, JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford University Press, 2008.
10 ABIM Foundation, ACP–ASIM Foundation, European Federation of Internal Medicine. Medical professionalism in the new millennium: a physicians' charter. Lancet 2002; 359: 520–2.
11 American Psychiatric Association. The Principles of Medical Ethics: With Annotations Especially Applicable to Psychiatry. APA, 2010.
12 Walaszek, A. Clinical ethics issues in geriatric psychiatry. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2009; 32: 343–59.
13 Strauss, A Corbin, JM. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. Sage Publications, 1998.
14 Hughes, JC Baldwin, C. Ethical Issues in Dementia Care: Making Difficult Decisions. Jessica Kingsley, 2006.
15 Sofaer, N Strech, D. Reasons why post-trial access to trial drugs should, or need not be ensured to research participants: a systematic review. Public Health Ethics 2011; 4: 160–84.
16 Strech, D Persad, G Marckmann, G Danis, M Are physicians willing to ration health care? Conflicting findings in a systematic review of survey research. Health Policy 2009; 90: 113–24.
17 Hughes, JC Baldwin, C. Ethics and the old age psychiatry. In Oxford Textbook of Old Age Psychiatry (eds Jacoby, R Oppenheimer, C Dening, T): 709–29. Oxford University Press 2008.
18 Wetzstein, V. Diagnose Alzheimer: Grundlagen einer Ethik der Demenz [Diagnosing Alzheimer's Disease: Fundamentals of Dementia Ethics]. Campus Verlag, 2005.
19 Moher, D Liberati, A Tetzlaff, J Altman, DG Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med 2009; 151: 264–9, W64.
20 Strech, D Sofaer, N. How to write a systematic review of reasons. J Med Ethics 2012; 38: 121–6.
21 Sofaer, N Strech, D. The need for systematic reviews of reasons. Bioethics 2012; 26: 315–28.
22 Strech, D Synofzik, M Marckmann, G Systematic reviews of empirical bioethics. Conceptual challenges and practical recommendations. J Med Ethics 2008; 34: 472–7.
23 McCullough, LB Coverdale, JH Chervenak, FA Constructing a systematic review for argument-based clinical ethics literature: the example of concealed medications. J Med Philos 2007; 32: 6576.
24 Eriksson, S Hoglund, AT Helgesson, G Do ethical guidelines give guidance? A critical examination of eight ethics regulations. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 2008; 17: 1529.
25 Schmidt, R. Geschlechtsspezifische unterschiede der Alzheimer demenz [Gender-specific differences of Alzheimer's disease]. Neuropsychiatr 2008; 22: 115.
26 Murray, LM Boyd, S. Protecting personhood and achieving quality of life for older adults with dementia in the U.S. health care system. J Aging Health 2009; 21: 350–73.
27 Graham, JE Ritchie, K. Mild cognitive impairment: ethical considerations for nosological flexibility in human kinds. Philos Psychiatr Psychol 2006; 13: 3143.
28 Diehl, J Fröstl, H Kurz, A Alzheimer-krankheit. Symptomatik, diagnose und therapie [Alzheimer's disease. Symptoms, diagnosis and therapy]. Z Med Ethik 2005; 51: 312.
29 Helmchen, H Lauter, H. Dürfen Ärzte mit Demenzkranken Forschen? Forschungsbedraf und Einwiliigungsproblematik bei Demenz [Should Physicians Conduct Research with Dementia Patients? Research Needs and Consent Challenges in Dementia]. Thieme, 1995.
30 Füsgen, I Demenz. Praktischer Umgang mit der Hirnleistungsstörung [Dementia: A Practice Guide for the Brain Disorder]. MMV Medizin Verlag, 1995.
31 Steeman, E de Casterlé, BD Godderis, J Grypdonck, M Living with early-stage dementia: a review of qualitative studies. J Adv Nurs 2006; 54: 722–38.
32 Kruse, A. Lebensqualität demenzkranker menschen [Quality of life in people with dementia]. Z Med Ethik 2005; 51: 4157.
33 Carpenter, B Dave, J. Disclosing a dementia diagnosis: a review of opinion and practice, and a proposed research agenda. Gerontologist 2004; 44: 149–58.
34 Synofzik, M. Effective, indicated–and yet without benefit? The goals of dementia drug treatment and the well-being of the patient [in German]. Z Gerontol Geriatr 2006; 39: 301–7.
35 Briggs, S Vernon, M. Informed consent. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 1929. Radcliffe 2009.
36 Schwaber, MJ Carmeli, Y. Antibiotic therapy in the demented elderly population: redefining the ethical dilemma. Arch Intern Med 2008; 168: 349–50.
37 Oliver, D Gee, P. Communication, barriers to it and information sharing. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 4961. Radcliffe 2009.
38 Post, SG. Respectare: moral respect for the lives of the deeply forgetful. In Dementia: Mind, Meaning and the Person (eds Hughes, JC Louw, S Sabat, SR): 223–34. Oxford University Press 2006.
39 Penrod, J Yu, F Kolanowski, A Fick, DM Loeb, SJ Hupcey, JE Reframing person-centered nursing care for persons with dementia. Res Theory Nurs Pract 2007; 21: 5772.
40 Mahon, MM Sorrell, JM. Palliative care for people with Alzheimer's diesease. Nurs Philos 2008; 9: 110–20.
41 Hughes, JC Sabat, SR. The advance directive conjuring trick and the person with dementia. In Empirical Ethics in Psychiatry (eds Widdershoven, G McMillan, J Hope, T): 123–40. Oxford University Press 2008.
42 Bouman, W. Sexuality in later life. In Oxford Textbook of Old Age Psychiatry (eds Jacoby, R Oppenheimer, C Dening, T Thomas, A): 689707. Oxford University Press 2008.
43 Bavidge, M. Aging and human nature. In Dementia: Mind, Meaning, and the Person (ed. Hughes, JC): 4153. Oxford University Press 2006.
44 Rabins, PV. Can suicide be a rational and ethical act in persons with early or pre-dementia? Am J Bioeth 2007; 7: 47–9.
45 Bowling, A. Quality of life in healthcare decisions. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 149–56. Radcliffe 2009.
46 Gove, E Sparr, S Dos Santos Bernardo, AM Cosgrave, MP Jansen, S Martensson, B et al Recommendations on end-of-life care for people with dementia. J Nutr Health Aging 2010; 14: 136–9.
47 Jones, WJ McCullough, LB Richman, BW Advanced age, dementia, and an abdominal aneurysm: intervene? J Vasc Surg 2003; 37: 1132–3.
48 Baumrucker, SJ Davis, MP Paganini, E Morris, GM Stolick, M Sheldon, JE Case study: dementia, quality of life, and appropriate treatment. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2005; 22: 385–91.
49 Menne, HL Whitlatch, CJ. Decision-making involvement of individuals with dementia. Gerontologist 2007; 47: 810–9.
50 Weissenberger-Leduc, M. Palliativpflege bei Demenz [Palliative Care in Dementia]. Springer, 2009.
51 Boyle, G. Social policy for people with dementia in England: promoting human rights. Health Soc Care Community 2010; 18: 511–9.
52 Dworkin, R. Autonomy and the demented self. In An Anthology of Psychiatric Ethics (eds Green, S Bloch, S): 293–6. Oxford University Press 2006.
53 Defanti, CA Tiezzi, A Gasparini, M Congedo, M Tiraboschi, P Tarquini, D et al Ethical questions in the treatment of subjects with dementia. Part I. Respecting autonomy: awareness, competence and behavioural disorders. Neurol Sci 2007; 28: 216–31.
54 Luttrell, S. Mental capacity and best interests. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 71–9. Radcliffe 2009.
55 Holm, S. Autonomy, authenticity, or best interest: everyday decision-making and persons with dementia. Med Health Care Philos 2001; 4: 153–9.
56 Jaworka, A. Respecting the marking of agency. Philos Public Aff 1999; 28: 105–38.
57 Welie, S. Patient incompetence in the practice of old age psychiatry: the significance of empirical research for the law. In Empirical Ethics in Psychiatry (ed. Widdershoven, G): 231–47. Oxford University Press 2008.
58 Chernoff, R. Tube feeding patients with dementia. Nutr Clin Pract 2006; 21: 142–6.
59 Cornett, PF Hall, JR. Issues in disclosing a diagnosis of dementia. Arch Clin Neuropsychol 2008; 23: 251–6.
60 Vollmann, J. Advance directives in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Ethical and clinical considerations. Med Health Care Philos 2001; 4: 161–7.
61 Hartmann, J Förstl, H Kurz, A Suizid bei beginnender Demenz [Suicide in early-stage dementia]. Z Med Ethik 2009; 55: 343–50.
62 Schermer, M. Nothing but the truth? On truth and deception in dementia care. Bioethics 2007; 21: 1322.
63 Hofmann, S. Demenz und Autonomie: Zur Realtionalität des Autonomiebegriffs in der Pflege bei Menschen mit Demenz [Dementia and Autonomy: The Challenge of the Concept of Autonomy in the Care of People with Dementia]. VDM, 2010.
64 Dworkin, R. Life's Dominion: An Argument about Abortion, Euthanasia, and Individual Freedom. Knopf, 1993.
65 Dresser, R. Dworkin on Dementia. In An Anthology of Psychiatric Ethics (eds Green, S Bloch, S): 297301. Oxford University Press 2006.
66 Maio, G. Verfügen über das Unverfügbare? Die Patientenverfügung als unvollkommene Antwort auf die ethische Herausforderung des Sterbens [Controlling the uncontrollable? The advance directive as the imperfect answer to the ethical challenge of dying]. Jahrb Wiss Ethik 2010; 15: 211–20.
67 Harvey, M. Advance directives and the severely demented. J Med Philos 2006; 31: 4764.
68 Rozzini, R Trabucchi, M. Antibiotic therapy in elderly persons affected by severe dementia. Arch Intern Med 2008; 168: 2497–8.
69 Geppert, CM Andrews, MR Druyan, ME Ethical issues in artificial nutrition and hydration: a review. JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr 2010; 34: 7988.
70 Gastmans, C Denier, Y. What if patients with dementia use decision aids to make an advance euthanasia request? Am J Bioeth 2010; 10: 25–6.
71 Gedge, EB. Collective moral imagination: making decisions for persons with dementia. J Med Philos 2004; 29: 435–50.
72 Goldsteen, M. Empirical ethics in action in practices of dementia care. In Empirical Ethics in Psychiatry (eds Widdershoven, G McMillan, J Hope, T): 95106. Oxford University Press 2008.
73 Barnes, M Brannelly, T. Achieving care and social justice for people with dementia. Nurs Ethics 2008; 15: 384–95.
74 Kaldjian, LC Shinkunas, LA Bern-Klug, M Schultz SK. Dementia, goals of care, and personhood: a study of surrogate decision makers' beliefs and values. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2010; 27: 387–97.
75 Kwok, T Twinn, S Yan, E The attitudes of Chinese family caregivers of older people with dementia towards life sustaining treatments. J Adv Nurs 2007; 58: 256–62.
76 Baldwin, C. Family carers, ethics and dementia: an empirical study. In Empirical Ethics in Psychiatry (eds Widdershoven, G McMillan, J Hope, T): 107–21. Oxford University Press 2008.
77 Bolmsjo, IA Edberg, AK Sandman, L Everyday ethical problems in dementia care: a teleological model. Nurs Ethics 2006; 13: 340–59.
78 Synofzik, M. Tube-feeding in advanced dementia. An evidence-based ethical analysis [in German]. Nervenarzt 2007; 78: 418–28.
79 Nagao, N Aulisio, MP Nukaga, Y Fujita, M Kosugi, S Youngner, S et al Clinical ethics consultation: examining how American and Japanese experts analyze an Alzheimer's case. BMC Med Ethics 2008; 9: 2.
80 Schermer, M. In search of ‘good life’ for demented elderly. Med Health Care Philos 2003; 6: 3544.
81 Kastner, U Löbach, R Handbuch Demenz [The Dementia Handbook]. Urban & Fischer, 2007.
82 Lawrence, V Murray, J Samsi, K Banerjee, S Attitudes and support needs of Black Caribbean, south Asian and White British carers of people with dementia in the UK. Br J Psychiatry 2008; 193: 240–6.
83 Gatterer, G Croy, A. Leben mit Demenz: Praxisbezogener Ratgeber für Pflege und Betreuung [Living with Dementia: Practice Guide for Care and Support]. Springer, 2004.
84 Jakobsen, R Sorlie, V. Dignity of older people in a nursing home: narratives of care providers. Nurs Ethics 2010; 17: 289300.
85 Cohen-Mansfield, J Bester, A. Flexibility as a management principle in dementia care: the Adards example. Gerontologist 2006; 46: 540–4.
86 Reitinger, E Pleschberger, S Schumann, F Living and dying in community based housing for people with dementia. An exploratory qualitative study [in German]. Z Gerontol Geriatr 2010; 43: 285–90.
87 Yamamoto, M Aso, Y. Placing physical restraints on older people with dementia. Nurs Ethics 2009; 16: 192202.
88 Robinson, D O'Neill, D Ethics of driving assessment in dementia: care, competence and communication. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 101–9. Radcliffe 2009.
89 Rosen, AC Bokde, AL Pearl, A Yesavage, JA Ethical, and practical issues in applying functional imaging to the clinical management of Alzheimer's disease. Brain Cogn 2002; 50: 498519.
90 Kalis, A von Delden, J Schermer, M ‘The good life’ for demented persons living in nursing homes. Int Psychogeriatr 2004; 16: 429–39.
91 Villars, H Oustric, S Andrieu, S Baeyens, JP Bernabei, R Brodaty, H et al The primary care physician and alzheimer's disease: an international position paper. J Nutr Health Aging 2010; 14: 110–20.
92 Sabat, S. Subjectivity, the brain, life narratives and the ethical treatment of persons with Alzheimer's disease. Am J Bioeth 2009; 9: 23–5.
93 Morris, C. Personal construct psychology and person-centred care. In Care-Giving in Dementia: Research and Applications (Vol 3) (eds Jones, GMM Miesen, BL): 6794. Brunner-Routledge 2004.
94 Kalis, A van Delden, J Schermer, M Ideals regarding a good life for nursing home residents with dementia: views of professional caregivers. Nurs Ethics 2005; 12: 3042.
95 Hughes, J. Dementia and ethics: the view of informal carers. J R Soc Med 2002; 95: 242–6.
96 Richter, J Eisemann, MR. Attitudinal patterns determining decision making in the treatment of the elderly: a comparison of the physicians and the nurses in Germany and Sweden. Intensive Care Med 2000; 26: 1326–33.
97 Rapoport, MJ Herrmann, N Molnar, FJ Man-Son-Hing, M Marshall, SC Shulman, K et al Sharing the responsibility for assessing the risk of the driver with dementia. CMAJ 2007; 177: 599601.
98 Landau, R Auslander, GK Werner, S Shoval, N Heinek, J Families' and professional caregivers' views of using advanced technology to track people with dementia. Qual Health Res 2010; 20: 409–19.
99 Kang, HG. In situ monitoring of health in older adults: technologies and issues. J Am Geriatr Soc 2010; 58: 1579–86.
100 Landau, R Auslander, GK Werner, S Shoval, N Heinik, J Who should make the decision on the use of GPS for people with dementia? Aging Ment Health 2011; 15: 7884.
101 Hokanen, L. Point-counterpoint: is it ethical to give drugs covertly to people with dementia? No: covert medication is paternalistic. West J Med 2001; 174: 229.
102 Lamnari, A. Point-counterpoint: is it ethical to give drugs to people with dementia? Yes: it is ethical if it is in their best interests. West J Med 2001; 174: 228.
103 Sayers, GM Rai, G. The lawful use of restraints. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 139–47. Radcliffe 2009.
104 Weiner, C Tabak, N Bergman R. The use of physical restraints for patients suffering from dementia. Nurs Ethics 2003; 10: 512–25.
105 Briggs, S Vernon, M. Decisions on life-sustaining therapy: nutrition and fluid. In Medical Ethics and the Elderly (ed. Rai, G): 3146. Radcliffe 2009.
106 Venturo, L. Dignity, dining and dialogue: reviewing the literature on quality of life. Int J Older People Nurs 2010; 5: 228–34.
107 Werner, S. Über Essen und Trinken demenziell erkrankter Bewohner: “Marmeladenstullen und Pdding am Abend? …” [About food and drink of dementia residents: ‘Jam sandwiches and pudding in the evening?’]. Pflegezeitschrift 2010; 63: 7880.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The British Journal of Psychiatry
  • ISSN: 0007-1250
  • EISSN: 1472-1465
  • URL: /core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary materials

Strech et al. supplementary material
Supplementary Material

 PDF (477 KB)
477 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed

The full spectrum of ethical issues in dementia care: systematic qualitative review

  • Daniel Strech (a1), Marcel Mertz (a2), Hannes Knuüppel (a3), Gerald Neitzke (a4) and Martina Schmidhuber (a4)...
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.

×

Reply to: Submit a response


Your details


Conflicting interests

Do you have any conflicting interests? *