Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T04:26:54.469Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Action for Cities: the Thatcher government and inner-city policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 May 2019

Otto Saumarez Smith
Otto Saumarez Smith*
Affiliation:
History of Art Department, Milburn House, University of Warwick, Coventry, CV4 7HS, UK
*
*Corresponding author. Email: Otto.saumarez-smith@warwick.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article surveys the Thatcher administration's approach to inner-city policy. It uses recently opened archives to reignite the debate over how far these years marked a radical break with past practices towards market-oriented approaches. The first part explains why inner cities became such a central issue for the Conservative party, running through all areas of domestic policy and taking up a vast amount of legislative time. The second part details some of the transatlantic neo-liberal ideas that blamed inner-city ills on government intervention, which were increasingly influential amongst senior Conservatives. The third section shows how little free market ideology actually succeeded in directing government policy, which more often than not saw an expansion of the role of the state. Antagonism with local authorities is revealed to have been a much more important and influential factor. These themes are expanded in the fourth section, which charts the Action for Cities policy drive of Thatcher's final term.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 47 , Special Issue 2: The de-industrializing city in the UK and Germany: conceptual approaches and empirical findings in comparative perspective , May 2020 , pp. 274 - 291
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 ‘Dulwich vulgarity’, Spectator, 10 Aug. 1985, 5.

2 Wright, P., Journey through Ruins (London, 1991), 32Google Scholar.

3 Samuel, R., Theatres of Memory: Past and Present in Contemporary Culture (London, 1994)Google Scholar.

4 Keiller, P., View from the Train: Cities and Other Landscapes (London, 2013)Google Scholar.

5 For an overview of recent scholarship, see Saunders, R., ‘The many lives of Margaret Thatcher’, English Historical Review, 82 (2017), 638–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Bale, T. (ed.), Margaret Thatcher (London, 2015)Google Scholar.

7 www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/thatcherism-conference-planned-liverpool-its-13961587, accessed 15 Jan. 2018.

8 See Thornley, A., Urban Planning under Thatcherism: The Challenge of the Market (London, 1991)Google Scholar, for a summary of the debate.

9 Lawless, P., ‘British inner urban policy post 1979’, Policy and Politics, 14 (1988), 152–74Google Scholar; Deakin, N. and Edwards, J., The Enterprise Culture and the Inner City (London, 1993)Google Scholar, Parkinson, M., ‘The Thatcher government's inner urban policy, 1979–1989, a review’, Town Planning Review, 60 (1989), 421–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar; MacGregor, S. and Pimlott, B. (eds.), Tackling the Inner Cities: The 1980s Reviewed: Prospects for the 1990s (Oxford, 1990)Google Scholar; Butcher, H. et al. , Local Government and Thatcherism (London, 1990)Google Scholar; Thornley, Urban Planning under Thatcherism; Shaw, K., Action for Cities: A Critical Review of Urban Policy since 1979 (Newcastle, 1989)Google Scholar; Robson, B., Those Inner Cities: Reconciling the Economic and Social Aims of Urban Policy (Oxford, 1988)Google Scholar.

10 Bourne, J., ‘“May we bring harmony”? Thatcher's legacy on “race”’, Race and Class, 55 (2013), 87–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Feldman, D., ‘Why the English like turbans: a history of multiculturalism in one country’, in Feldman, D. and Lawrence, J. (eds.), Structures and Transformations in Modern Britain: Essays for Gareth Stedman Jones (Cambridge, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Gilmour, I., Dancing with Dogma (London, 1992), 104–41Google Scholar.

12 Farrall, S. and Hay, C., ‘Not so tough on crime? Why weren't the Thatcher governments more radical in reforming the criminal justice system?’, British Journal of Criminology, 50 (2010), 550–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 E. Sorensen, ‘Report on the inner cities’, 1987, The National Archives (TNA), PREM 19/2463.

14 ‘Report of the home secretary's policy group on law and order, the inner cities and drugs – December 1986’, Conservative Party Archive (CPA), Conservative Research Department (CRD) 4/9/56. See Sim, D., ‘Urban deprivation: not just the inner city’, Area, 16 (1984), 299–306Google Scholar.

15 Campkin, B., Remaking London: Decline and Regeneration in Urban Culture (London, 2013), 99CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 Smith, O. Saumarez, ‘The inner city crisis and the end of urban modernism in 1970s Britain’, Twentieth Century British History, 27 (2016), 578–98Google Scholar.

17 CPA, CRD 4/8/14.

18 M. Kohler to T. Hutt, 28 Jul. 1981, CPA, CRD/D/8/24.

19 Archbishop of Canterbury's Commission on Urban Priority Areas, Faith in the City: A Call for Action by Church and Nation (London, 1985)Google Scholar.

20 ‘Tackling the inner cities’, New Society, 11 Mar. 1988, 3.

21 ‘Draft on speech on inner city issues to Greater London Area Conservative political centre 6 July 1987’, TNA, PREM 19/2462.

22 Lawless, P., ‘Urban policy in the Thatcher decade: English inner-city policy, 1979–90’, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 9 (1991), 15–30, at 19CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 Smith, O. Saumarez, ‘Central government and town centre redevelopment in Britain, 1959–1966’, Historical Journal, 58 (2015)Google Scholar.

24 Harrison, B., ‘Joseph, Keith Sinjohn, Baron Joseph (1918–1994)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (Oxford, 2004)Google Scholar.

25 Scruton, R., ‘The architecture of Stalinism’, Cambridge Review, 97 (26 Nov. 1976), 36–41Google Scholar; Hutber, P., The Decline and Fall of the Middle Class and How It Can Fight Back (London, 1977)Google Scholar. Thatcher herself had been lent a copy of David Watkin's Morality and Architecture although she found it tough going; Moore, C., Margaret Thatcher: The Authorised Biography, vol. I: Not for Turning (London, 2013)Google Scholar.

26 Joseph, K., A Bibliography of Freedom (London, 1980), 20Google Scholar.

27 Jacobs, J., The Death and Life of Great American Cities (New York, 1961)Google Scholar; Jacobs, J., The Economy of Cities (New York, 1969)Google Scholar; Joseph, A Bibliography of Freedom, 20.

28 Anderson, M., The Federal Bulldozer (New York, 1964)Google Scholar. See Conn, S., Americans against the City (Oxford, 2014), 157–63Google Scholar, for a discussion of Anderson's influence on the New Right into the 1980s.

29 Banfield, E., The Unheavenly City Revisited (Boston, MA, 1974)Google Scholar.

30 Klemek, C., The Transatlantic Collapse of Urban Renewal: Postwar Urbanism from New York to Berlin (Chicago, 2011)Google Scholar.

31 Banfield, The Unheavenly City Revisited.

32 Jones, D. Stedman, Masters of the Universe (Princeton, 2012)Google Scholar.

33 A fascinating first-hand account of Banfield and his place in neo-liberal intellectual networks can be found in Letwin, O., Hearts and Minds (London, 2017)Google Scholar.

34 For example Clarke, K., A Free Market and the Inner Cities (London, 1987)Google Scholar; Mount, F., Property and Poverty: An Agenda for the Mid-80s (London, 1984)Google Scholar; Steen, A., New Life for Old Cities (London, 1981)Google Scholar.

35 For example A. Sherman, ‘Counting the cost of New Towns’, Daily Telegraph, 10 Aug. 1973, 14.

36 See also ‘What went wrong with the inner cities’, Economist, 10 Apr. 1982, 37; Saumarez Smith, ‘The inner city crisis’.

37 CPA, CAB 164/1548, Policy Unit on ‘It took a riot’, 3 Sep. 1981.

38 Clarke, A Free Market and the Inner Cities.

39 Vile to Pattison, 7 Oct. 1979, TNA, PREM 19/577.

40 Lord Trenchard to Michael Heseltine, 3 Sep. 1979, TNA, T380/865.

41 G. Howe to Heseltine, 7 Sep. 1979, TNA, T380/865.

42 M. Heseltine, ‘Statement on inner city policy’, 6 Sep. 1979, TNA, T380/865.

43 ‘Urban cities brief’, 11 Dec. 1985, CPA, CRD/B/11/4.

44 ‘Regional policy under the axe’, Economist, 19 Feb. 1983, 21.

45 MacGregor and Pimlott (eds.), Tackling the Inner Cities, 9.

46 Department of the Environment, The Urban Programme Fact Sheets 1985/6 (London, 1985)Google Scholar.

47 E. Sorensen, ‘Inner cities report’, TNA, PREM 19/2463.

48 Letter from Robert Young to Margaret Thatcher, 12 Oct. 1984, TNA, PREM 19/1615.

49 Morison, H., Regeneration of Local Economies (Oxford, 1987), 84Google Scholar.

50 Sir G. Howe, ‘Liberating free enterprise: a new experiment’, speech to the Bow Group, 26 Jun. 1978, Margaret Thatcher Foundation Archive, 2/1/1/39, www.margaretthatcher.org/document/111842, accessed 29 Apr. 2019.

51 Brooke, S., ‘Living in “new times”: historicizing 1980s Britain’, History Compass, 12 (2014), 20–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

52 Wetherell, S., ‘Freedom planned: enterprise zones and urban non-planning in post-war Britain’, Twentieth Century British History, 27 (2016), 266–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Not all enterprise zones would be in inner-city areas or areas of dereliction; see, for example, Wellingborough.

54 Butler, S.M., ‘Enterprise zones: pioneering in the inner city’, in Sternlieb, G. (ed.), New Tools for Economic Development: The Enterprise Zone, Development Bank, and RFC (New Brunswick, 1981)Google Scholar.

55 Keating, M., Midwinter, A. and Taylor, P., ‘Enterprise zones: implementing the unworkable’, Political Quarterly, 55 (1984), 78–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar; see also Massey, D., ‘Enterprise zones: a political issue’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 6 (1982), 429–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Butcher et al., Local Government and Thatcherism; McDonald, I. and Howick, C., ‘Monitoring the enterprise zones’, Built Environment, 7 (1981), 31–7Google Scholar.

56 Morison, Regeneration of Local Economies, 85–6.

57 Marriott, O., The Property Boom (Abingdon, 1989)Google Scholar.

58 Hall, P., Cities of Tomorrow (Oxford, 1989), 357Google Scholar; see also Hall, P., ‘The British enterprise zones’, in Green, R.E. (ed.), Enterprise Zones: New Directions in Economic Development (Newbury Park, 1991)Google Scholar.

59 PA Cambridge Economic Consultants, An Evaluation of the Enterprise Zone Experiment (London, 1987)Google Scholar; and Tym, R. et al. , Monitoring Enterprise Zones: Year Three Report (London, 1984)Google Scholar.

60 See Brownhill, S. and O'Hara, G., ‘From planning to opportunism? Re-examining the creation of the London Docklands Development Corporation’, Planning Perspectives, 30 (2015), 537–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

61 ‘Urban enterprise corporations’, CPA, CRD 4/9/48.

62 Gold, J., ‘A SPUR to action: the Society for the Promotion of Urban Renewal, “anti-scatter” and the crisis of reconstruction’, Planning Perspectives, 27 (2012), 199–223CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Howe, ‘Liberating free enterprise’, 15. I have not been able to locate the original Crossbow article, but that such ideas were countenanced by the Bow Group can be seen from their publication, Knight, T. et al. , Let Our Cities Live (London, 1960)Google Scholar.

64 Suggested for example in Thirteenth Report from the Expenditure Committee, New Towns, House of Commons Paper 616 (London, 1975)Google Scholar.

65 Heseltine, M., Where There's a Will (London, 1987), 134Google Scholar.

66 Policy for the Inner Cities (London, 1977), 8Google Scholar.

67 Butcher et al., Local Government and Thatcherism, 107.

68 Quoted in Hall, P., Cities in Civilisation (London, 1998), 913Google Scholar.

69 P. Stredder, ‘Inner city policy: lessons from the American experience’, 18 Sep. 1987, TNA, PREM 19/2462.

70 ‘Inner cities policy group report, 1983’, CPA, CRD 4/9/54.

71 T. Barron, ‘The scope for the private developer’, 1980, CPA, CRD 4/9/60.

72 ‘Inner city housing demand and land availability’, CPA, CRD 4/9/60. See also Home Office and Inner Cities Policy Group, ‘The inner cities’, 29 Sep. 1986, CRD 4/9/55.

73 N. Deva-Aditya, ‘Race and politics: the missed opportunities’, 1981, CPA, CRD 4/9/48. On the Conservatives’ attempts to appeal to ethnic minority voters on the issue of home ownership, see Francis, Matthew, ‘Mrs Thatcher's peacock blue sari: ethnic minorities and the Conservative party, c. 1974’, Contemporary British History, 31 (2017), 274–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

74 Robert Young to Margaret Thatcher, 28 Jun. 1984, TNA, PREM 19/1615.

75 Inner Cities Policy Group, ‘Handling “multicultural Britain” in the manifesto’, 1986, CPA, CRD 4/9/56.

76 ‘Report of the home secretary's policy group on law and order, the inner cities and drugs – December 1986’, CPA, CRD 4/9/56.

77 Ridley, N., My Style of Government: The Thatcher Years (London, 1991), 85Google Scholar.

78 Murie, A., ‘Housing and the environment’, in Kavanagh, D. and Seldon, A. (eds.), The Thatcher Effect: A Decade of Change (Oxford, 1989), 215Google Scholar.

79 Davies, A., ‘“Right to buy”: the development of a conservative housing policy, 1945–1980’, Contemporary British History, 27 (2013), 421–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Francis, M., ‘“A crusade to enfranchise the many”: Thatcherism and the “property owning democracy”’, Twentieth Century British History, 21 (2011), 275–97Google Scholar.

80 Walker, P., Trust the People: The Collected Essays and Speeches of Peter Walker (London, 1987), 55–91Google Scholar.

81 Donoghue, B., Downing Street Diaries: With Harold Wilson in No. 10 (London, 2006), 525Google Scholar.

82 Cmnd 6845, Policy for the Inner Cities, 26.

83 ‘Selling of the slums’, Shelter, Mar./Apr. 1984.

84 ‘Inner cities launch – presentation’, 6 Mar. 1988, TNA, PREM 19/2465.

85 ‘Taking over the inner cities’, New Society, 11 Mar. 1988, 3.

86 Meeting held at 10 Downing Street, 27 Jul. 1987.

87 H. Booth and N. Blackwell to PM attaching Sorenson's paper and Sir Robert Armstrong's proposals, 22 Sep. 1987, TNA, PREM 19/2462.

88 Thatcher, M., The Downing Street Years (London, 2012)Google Scholar.

89 TNA, PREM 19/2462.

90 A. Howarth, ‘Points on law and order and the inner cities, 8th Dec. 1986’, CPA, CRD 4/9/56.

91 ‘PMs notes for inner cities meeting, 30 Nov. 1987, by Norman Blackwell and Hartley Booth’, TNA, PREM 19/2463.

92 B. Ingham, ‘Inner cities launch – presentation’, 6 Mar. 1988, TNA, PREM 19/2463.

93 Letter from Norgrove to Thatcher, 23 Sep. 1987, TNA, PREM 19/2463.

94 ‘Thatcher blueprint for the inner cities’, New Society, Mar. 1988, 23–4.

95 Kenneth Clarke to Margaret Thatcher, 31 Mar. 1988, TNA PREM 19/2463.

96 D. Dewar, Hansard, 29 Mar. 1988.

97 Booth and Blackwell to Thatcher, 22 Sep. 1987, TNA, PREM 19/2462.

98 D. Lawson, ‘Newcastle brown study’, Spectator, 6 Aug. 1988, 14–16.

99 Clarke to Thatcher, 31 Mar. 1988, TNA PREM 19/2463.

100 TNA, PREM 19/2462.

101 Hilton, M., Moores, C. and Suttcliffe-Braithwaite, F., ‘New times revisited: Britain in the 1980s’, Contemporary British History, 31 (2017), 145–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.