Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-xtgtn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T04:45:37.842Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Republicanism on the borders: Jewish activism and the refugee crisis in Strasbourg and Nice

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 October 2015

MEREDITH L. SCOTT-WEAVER
MEREDITH L. SCOTT-WEAVER*
Affiliation:
Department of History and Political Science, York College of Pennsylvania, 441 Country Club Road, York, PA 17403–3651, USA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

This case-study of Jewish activism in Strasbourg and Nice, interwar urban locales situated along the frontiers with National Socialist Germany and fascist Italy, respectively, examines critical facets of Jewish advocacy during the refugee crisis of the 1930s. It focuses on how urban spaces engendered dense thickets of community activism unlike that which took place in Paris. Whereas friction and ineffectiveness characterized aid efforts in Paris, these cities offer alternative views on the nature of the refugee crisis in France and the ways that Jews overcame obstacles to help asylum-seekers. It advances much-needed discourse on the complexity of French Jewish experiences during the interwar years and highlights the city as both location and a conduit for diverse activist strategies. Although circumstances varied in Strasbourg and Nice, Jews in these two borderland cities followed similar patterns of engaging urban civil society to build flexible networks that addressed the plight of refugees from multiple angles.

Type
Special section: Beyond the Pletzl: Jewish urban histories in interwar France
Information
Urban History , Volume 43 , Issue 4 , November 2016 , pp. 599 - 617
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Caron, V., Uneasy Asylum: France and the Jewish Refugee Crisis, 1933–1942 (Stanford, 1999), 2 Google Scholar.

2 Delpech, F., ‘La persécution Nazi et l’attitude de Vichy’, Historiens et geographes: revue de l’Association des Professeurs d’Histoire et de Géographie de l’Enseignement Public, 273 (May–Jun. 1979)Google Scholar. Also found online at http://aphgcaen.free.fr/cercle/delpech2.htm. Accessed Aug. 2015.

3 Carrol, A., ‘In the border's shadow: reimagining urban spaces in Strasbourg’, Journal of Contemporary History, 48 (2013), 668 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 This article examines Jews whose families had resided in France for generations or who had naturalized by 1919.

5 Foundational works on this period include Weinberg, D., A Community on Trial: The Jews of Paris in the 1930s (Chicago, 1977)Google Scholar, Hyman, P., From Dreyfus to Vichy: The Remaking of French Jewry, 1906–1939 (New York, 1979)Google Scholar; idem, The Jews of Modern France (Berkeley, 1998); Marrus, M., ‘Vichy before Vichy: anti-Semitic currents in France during the 1930s’, Wiener Library Bulletin, 33 (1980), 13–19 Google Scholar.

6 Pflieger, G. and Rozenblat, C., ‘Introduction. Urban networks and network theory: the city as the connector of multiple networks’, Urban Studies, 47 (2010), 2723–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bandelj, N. and Purg, D., ‘Networks as resources, organizational logic, and change mechanism: the case of private business schools in post-socialism’, Sociological Forum, 21 (2006), 587–622 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Malinovich, N., French and Jewish: Culture and the Politics of Identity in Early Twentieth-Century France (Portland, 2008), 8–9 and 116–200Google Scholar.

7 Harvey, D., Rebel Cities: From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution (Brooklyn, 2012)Google Scholar. Harvey examines cities as sites of mobilization.

8 Mumford, L., The City in History (New York, 1961), 569 Google Scholar.

9 Harris, R., Dreyfus: Politics, Emotion, and the Scandal of the Century (New York, 2011)Google Scholar. On p. 70, for example, one prominent Jewish figure felt that he was ‘treading a tightrope’ when taking a public stance on Dreyfus.

10 Birnbaum, P., The Jews of the Republic: A Political History of State Jews in France from Gambetta to Vichy, trans. J.M. Todd (Stanford, 1996)Google Scholar; Marrus, ‘Vichy before Vichy’; Benbassa, E., The Jews of France: A History from Antiquity to the Present, trans. M.B.D. DeBevoise (Princeton, 1999), 163 Google Scholar; Weinberg, A Community on Trial. Vicki Caron's work, however, argues that the path from the Third Republic to Vichy was not linear; it comprised different, often clashing, stages between liberal and more hard-line policies. Caron, Uneasy Asylum; Caron, V., ‘Unwilling refuge: France and the dilemma of illegal immigration, 1933–1939’, in Caestecker, F. and Moore, B. (eds.), Refugees from Nazi Germany and Liberal European States (New York, 2010), 57–81Google Scholar.

11 Lefebvre, H., Production of Space, trans. D. Nicholson-Smith (Oxford, 1991), 71 Google Scholar.

12 Kohn, M., Radical Space: Building the House of the People (Ithaca, 2003), 3 Google Scholar.

13 Harvey, Rebel Cities.

14 Kohn, Radical Space, 129.

15 For an excellent analysis of Jewish life in Alsace and Lorraine, see Caron, V., Between France and Germany: The Jews of Alsace-Lorraine, 1871–1918 (Stanford, 1988)Google Scholar. See also Hyman, P., The Jews of Modern France; and idem, The Emancipation of the Jews of Alsace (New Haven, 1991)Google Scholar.

16 Caron, France and Germany, 188.

17 Vice Président du Conseil from Préfet Viguié, 4 May 1939, Archives Départementales du Bas-Rhin (ADBR) 98AL 698.

18 R. Berg, ‘Quelques précisions sur le Judaïsme Alsacien’, Univers Israélite, 25 Apr. 1936, Archives of the Alliance Israélite Universelle (AIU), MS 650, dossier 41.

19 Sous-Secretaire d’État from Préfet du Bas-Rhin, no date, ADBR 286D 383; Thalmann, R., ‘L’immigration allemande et l’opinion publique en France de 1933 à 1936’, in La France et l’Allemagne, 1932–1936 (Paris, 1980), 162 Google Scholar.

20 Thalman, ‘L’immigration allemande’, 162–3.

21 Rapport: Réunion privée de la Communauté Allemande Nationale-Socialiste, 15 Sep. 1938, Archives Départementales des Alpes-Maritimes (ADAM) 4M 162.

22 Carrol, Border's Shadow, 671.

23 To M. le Haut Commissaire à Strasbourg from L. Armbruster (signature illegible), 3 Jan. 1919, ADBR 121AL 11; Haut Commissaire from M. Armbruster, 1 Dec. 1918. ADBR 121AL 11.

24 Hobsbawm, E., ‘From social history to the history of society’, Daedalus, Historical Studies Today, 100 (1971), 34 Google Scholar; see also Celik, Z. and Favro, D., ‘Methods of urban history’, Journal of Architectural Education, 41 (1988), 5 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Berman, Lisa discusses these concepts in ‘Jewish urban politics in the city and beyond’, Journal of American History, 99 (2012), 492–519 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Kohn, Radical Space, 66, 67–9, 83–6.

27 Caron, Uneasy Asylum, 14–16.

28 Sylvain Halff to Cromback, 5 Dec. 1938, AIU France IIL4.

29 To Préfet du Bas-Rhin from Isaïe Schwartz, 6 Mar. 1939, ADBR 460D 36.

30 ‘Le danger Allemand’, La Dépêche, 22 Oct. 1933, ADBR 286D 383.

31 Préfet du Bas-Rhin from Commissaire Divisionnaire, 18 Oct. 1933, ADBR 286D 383.

32 Préfet du Bas-Rhin from Commissaire Divisionnaire, 18 Oct. 1933, ADBR 286D 383.

33 Préfet du Bas-Rhin from the Président de la Chambre de Commerce de Strasbourg, 2 Feb. 1935, ADBR 460D 36; ‘Le régime des étrangers’, Journal d’Alsace et de Lorraine, 25 Jul. 1933, and ‘L’installation des refugiés allemands dans les départements recouvrés’, Le Matin, 16 Aug. 1933, ADBR 460D 36.

34 Président de l’Union Régionale des Sionistes de l’Est de France to Préfet du Bas-Rhin, 26 Mar. 1934, ADBR 460D 36; Préfet du Bas-Rhin to Président de l’Union Régionale des Sionistes de l’Est de la France, 25 Apr. 1934, ADBR 460D 36; to Secrétaire Général of AIU from Isaïe Schwartz, 10 Nov. 1938, AIU France IXD54.

35 Schor, R., ‘Nice de 1914 à 1939’, in Ruggiero, A. and Arnaud, A. (eds.), Nouvelle Histoire de Nice (Toulouse, 2006), 226 Google Scholar.

36 The Comité d’Aide, see Report 43: Comité d’Aide aux Victimes de Hitlérisme, 6 Jan. 1934, ADAM 4M 133.

37 Archives, Ligue des Droits de l’Homme f delta rés. 798/133, fédération des Alpes-Maritimes, dossier 2.

38 Commissaire Divisionnaire de Police Spéciale, 3 Nov. 1937, ADAM 4M 155.

39 Voigt, K., ‘Les naufragés: l’arrivée des refugiés allemands et autrichiens d’Italie (Septembre 1938 à Mai 1940)’, Cahiers d’études germaniques, 13 (1987), 163 Google Scholar; Zuccotti, S., The Italians and the Holocaust: Persecution, Rescue, and Survival (New York, 1987), 29–36 Google Scholar; Veziano, P., ‘L’expulsion des juifs étrangers d’Italie (1938–1940)’, Le Sourgentin, 168 (2005), 18–19 Google Scholar.

40 Kleinmann, J., ‘De 1934 à 1943, l’arrivée des juifs à Nice’, Le Sourgentin, 168 (2005), 20 Google Scholar; Report of Lieutenant Brodard, 28 Jul. 1939, ADAM 4M 1358.

41 Veziano, ‘L’expulsion des juif’, 18; Voigt, ‘Les naufragés’, 165–6.

42 Veziano, ‘L’expulsion des juif’, 18.

43 Voigt, ‘Les naufragés’, 167.

44 To Préfet du Bas-Rhin from Isaïe Schwartz, 20 Feb. 1939, ADBR 460D 36.

45 To Messieurs du Communauté Israélite de Strasbourg from Union des Sociétés OSE, 27 Jul. 1937, Archives Communauté Israélite du Bas-Rhin (CIBR) 233.

46 Procès-verbal, Consistoire du Bas-Rhin, 21 May 1937, CIBR 7.

47 To Préfet du Bas-Rhin from Isaïe Schwartz, 6 Mar. 1939, ADBR 460D 36; to Vice-Président du Conseil from Préfet du Bas-Rhin, 8 Feb. 1939, ADBR 460D 36.

48 Ibid .

49 To Chef de la 4eme Division from Préfet Roland-Marcel, 24 Nov. 1933, ADBR 460D 36; Home Israelite des Jeunes Filles in box dated 1933–39, ADBR 460D 36.

50 To Préfet du Bas-Rhin from Président du Conseil Ministre de l’Intérieur, 30 Jan. 1934, ADBR 460D 36; to Laure Weill from Roland-Marcel, 2 Mar. 1934, ADBR 460D 36.

51 In Dec. 1939, she founded the Œuvres d’Aide Sociale Israélite aux populations évacuées d’Alsace et de Lorraine; see Memorial de la Shoah, Archives Centre de Documentation Juive Contemporaine (CDJC) http://mms.pegasis.fr/jsp/core/MmsRedirector.jsp?id=1003994&type=RESISTANT (accessed Aug. 2015).

52 Ibid .

53 Although not specified, Dr Schwartz may have been with the Joint Distribution Committee.

54 ‘Ebrei strangieri – tentato espatrio clandestine in Francia’, 17 Mar. 1939 and reports dated 10 Aug., 6 Sep., and 7 Sep., 8 Sep. 1939, ADAM 1J 579.

55 Report No. 28, 5 Jan. 1939, ADAM 4M 1343; to Ministre Bonnet from Union Magna Charta, 5 Jan. 1939, ADAM 4M 1343.

56 Déclaration de Constitution d’une Association, Société de Haute Charité des Dames Israélites, 12 Jul. 1939, ADAM 4M 365.

57 Déclaration de Constitution d’une Association, 28 Feb. 1939, ADAM 4M 365; Comité d’Assistance aux Refugiés, 8 Oct. 1939, ADAM 4M 365.

58 Déclaration de Constitution d’une Association, 28 Feb. 1939, ADAM 4M 365; Comité d’Assistance aux Refugiés, 8 Oct. 1939, ADAM 4M 365; Statuts adoptés par l’Assemblée Générale, 28 Feb. 1939, ADAM 4M 365.

59 Ibid.

60 Ibid

61 ‘Nice: une éloquente manifestation d’union au Comité d’Assistance aux Refugiés’, 19 Jan. 1939, clipping in AIU, MS 650, dossier 60.

62 Report 7569, Directeur de Police d’État, 1 Jul. 1939, ADAM 4M 166.

63 Ibid .

64 To Robert Schumann from Marcel Lowenstein, 6 Apr. 1939, AIU, MS 650, dossier 28; Voigt, ‘Les naufragés’, 168.

65 Voigt, ‘Les naufragés’, 168.

66 Report 7569, 1 Jul. 1939, ADAM 4M 166.

67 Voigt, ‘Les naufragés’, 170.

68 Ibid ., 174.

69 To M. le Directeur du SNCF from J. Babani, 9 Dec. 1938, AIU, MS 650, dossier 28; to Robert Schumann from Marcel Lowenstein, Nice, 6 Apr. 1939, AIU, MS 650, dossier 28.

70 To Robert Schumann from Marcel Lowenstein, 6 Apr. 1939, AIU, MS 650, dossier 28.

71 Ibid .; Voigt, ‘Les naufragés’, 167–8.

72 Report 2107, Directeur de Police d’État, 7 Aug. 1939, ADAM 4M 170; Report 2063, Directeur de Police d’État, 4 Aug. 1939, ADAM 4M 170.

73 Ibid .

74 Bordes et al., Histoire de Nice, 410.

75 ‘Modifications des Statuts votés par l’Assemblée Générale’, 23 Feb. 1941, ADAM 4M 365.

76 Harvey, Rebel Cities, 4.