Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Commentary on the Appellate Body Report in EC–Bananas III (Article 21.5): waiver-thin, or lock, stock, and metric ton?

  • SIMON A. B. SCHROPP (a1) and DAVID PALMETER (a2)
Abstract
Abstract

At first glance, the Appellate Body Report in Bananas III (Article 21.5; Second Recourse) does not seem to be a case for the Guinness Book. The AB upheld most of the Panel's findings, and the EC lost big. This was hardly surprising, given that the contested measure only marginally differed from the measure at issue in the first recourse to a compliance Panel. It is at second sight that this AB Report reveals its interesting facets. We highlight a few remarkable legal and economics aspects, some of a more systemic nature, some offering practical insights: For practitioners, the role of estoppel in WTO litigation, the legal effect of Panel suggestions, and the relevance of Uruguay Round Modalities Papers as interpretative tools may be of interest. Readers more concerned with systemic aspects of the WTO may take interest in the economics of tariff quotas, the inherently discriminatory nature of tariff-quota allocation in the WTO, and the relevance of compliance proceedings for the damage calculation under Article 22.6 of the DSU.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Email: sschropp@sidley.com
References
Hide All
Bergsten C. Fred, Kimberly Ann Elliott, Jeffrey J. Schott, and Takacs Wendy E. (1987), Auction Quotas and United States Trade Policy, Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics.
Bown Chad P. and McCulloch Rachel (2003), ‘Non-discrimination and the WTO Agreement on Safeguards’, World Trade Review, 2(3): 327348.
Bown Chad P. and Ruta Michele (2009), ‘The Economics of Permissible WTO Retaliation’, forthcoming in Bown Chad P. and Pauwelyn Joost (eds.), The Law, Economics and Politics of Retaliation in WTO Dispute Settlement, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
de Gorter Harry and Sheldon Ian (eds.) (2001), ‘Agriculture in the WTO: Issues in Reforming Tariff-Rate Import Quotas in the Agreement on Agriculture in the WTO’, Department of Applied Economics, International Agricultural Trade Research Consortium, University of Minnesota, St Paul, Minnesota.
Fearon James D. (1998), ‘Bargaining, Enforcement, and International Cooperation’, International Organization, 52(2): 269305.
Gantz David A. and Schropp Simon A. B. (2009), ‘Rice Age: Comments on the Panel Report in Turkey – Measures Affecting the Importation of Rice’, World Trade Review, 8(1): 145177, and in Henrik Horn and Petros C. Mavroidis (eds.), The American Law InstituteThe WTO Case Law of 2006–2007: Legal and Economic Analysis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Goetz Charles J. and Scott Robert E. (1981), ‘Principles of Relational Contracts’, Virginia Law Review, 67(2): 10891150.
Horn Henrik, Maggi Giovanni, and Staiger Robert W. (2009), ‘Trade Agreements as Endogenously Incomplete Contracts’, American Economic Review, forthcoming.
Hudec Robert E. (1997), ‘Tiger, Tiger in the House: A Critical Appraisal of the Case Against Discriminatory Trade Measures’, in Jackson John H. and Sykes Alan O. (eds.), Implementing the Uruguay Round, Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp. 167212.
Jackson John H. (1997), The World Trading System: Law and Policy of International Economic Relations, 2nd edn, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Jackson John H. and Grané Patricio (2001), ‘The Saga Continues: An Update on the Banana Dispute and Its Procedural Offspring’, Journal of International Economic Law, 4(3): 581595.
Lockhart Nicolas (2009), ‘A commentary to Thomas Sebastian's contribution entitled “The Law of Permissible WTO Retaliation”’, forthcoming in Bown Chad P. and Pauwelyn Joost (eds.), The Law, Economics and Politics of Retaliation in WTO Dispute Settlement, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Maggi Giovanni and Staiger Robert W. (2008), ‘On the Role and Design of Dispute Settlement Procedures in International Trade Agreements’, NBER Working Paper 14067.
Mahlstein Kornel and Schropp Simon A. B. (2007), ‘The Optimal Design of Trade Policy Flexibility in the WTO’, HEI Working Paper 27-2007 (available at www.hei.unige.ch).
Mavroidis Petros C. (2007), Trade in Goods, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Mavroidis Petros C. (2000), ‘Remedies in the WTO Legal System: Between a Rock and a Hard Place’, European Journal of International Law, 11(4): 763813.
Messerlin Patrick A. (2000), ‘Antidumping and Safeguards’, in Schott Jeffrey J., The WTO After Seattle, Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics, pp. 159183.
Palmeter David (2003), The WTO as a Legal System: Essays on International Trade Law and Policy, London: Cameron May.
Palmeter David and Mavroidis Petros C. (2004), Dispute Settlement in the World Trade Organization: Practice and Procedure, 2nd edn, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schropp Simon A. B. (2009a), Trade Policy Flexibility and Enforcement in the WTO: A Law and Economics Analysis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schropp Simon A. B. (2009b), ‘The Equivalence Standard Under Article 22.4 DSU: A “Tariffic” Misunderstanding?’, forthcoming in Bown Chad P. and Pauwelyn Joost (eds.), The Law, Economics and Politics of Retaliation in WTO Dispute Settlement, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Skully David W. (2001), ‘Economics of Tariff-Rate Quota Administration’, Technical Bulletin No. 1893, Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture.
Skully David W. (2000), ‘US Tariff-Rate Quotas: Historical Allocation and Non-discrimination’, Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 29(1): 8190.
Skully David W. (1999), ‘The Economics of TRQ Administration’, International Agricultural Trade Research Consortium, Working Paper #99-6.
Skully David W. (1998), ‘Auctioning the Tariff Quota for US Sugar Imports’, in Sugar and Sweetener: Situation and Outlook Report, US Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Market and Trade Economics Division, May (SSS-223): 1722.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

World Trade Review
  • ISSN: 1474-7456
  • EISSN: 1475-3138
  • URL: /core/journals/world-trade-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 15
Total number of PDF views: 76 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 534 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 15th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.