Skip to main content

US–Tyres: Upholding a WTO Accession Contract – Imposing Pain for Little Gain


In 2009, the United States imposed additional tariffs for a three-year period on imports of automotive tires from China under a special-safeguard provision included in China's Protocol of Accession to the WTO. China challenged the measure in the WTO. The case marked the first WTO dispute in which a challenged safeguard was upheld by the Appellate Body; the first in which an accession protocol was used successfully as a defense; and the first that China lost as a complaining party. It also was noteworthy in that the safeguard was sought by a labor union, not the domestic industry. This paper reviews the WTO Appellate Body's findings and discusses a number of the legal and policy implications regarding China's Accession Protocol, the Safeguards Agreement, and WTO accession law, as well as economic aspects of the case.

Corresponding author
Hide All
Andersen Scott and Lau Christian (2002), ‘Hedging Hopes with Fears in China's Accession to the World Trade Organization: The Transitional Special-Product Safeguard for Chinese Exports’, The Journal of World Intellectual Property, 5(3): 405476.
Bank of America/Merrill Lynch (2010), ‘Global Tire Quarterly Review’, July.
Bown Chad P. (2011), ‘Taking Stock of Antidumping, Safeguards and Countervailing Duties, 1990–2009’, The World Economy, 34(12): 19551998.
Bradsher Keith (2009), ‘China Moves to Retaliate against US Tire Tariff’, The New York Times, 13 September.
Bussey John (2012), ‘Get-Tough Policy on Chinese Tires Falls Flat’, The Wall Street Journal, 20 January, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
Charnovitz Steve (2006), ‘The (Neglected) Employment Dimension of the World Trade Organization’, in Leary Virginia A. and Warner Daniel (eds.), Social Issues, Globalisation and International Institutions: Labour Rights and the EU, ILO, OECD and WTO, Leiden, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, pp. 125155.
Charnovitz Steve (2008), ‘Mapping the Law of WTO Accession’, in Janow Merit E., Donaldson Victoria, and Yanovich Alan (eds.), The WTO: Governance, Dispute Settlement and Developing Countries, Huntington, NY: Juris Publishing, pp. 855920.
Eisenstein Adam (2010–2011), ‘Free Trade, Tires, and Tariffs: Why Imposing Import Duties Against Chinese Goods is the Wrong Course of Action for the United States’, The Federal Circuit Bar Journal, 20(2): 305335.
Grimmett Jeanne J. (2011), ‘Chinese Tire Imports: Section 421 Safeguards and the World Trade Organization (WTO)’, CRS Report R40844, July.
Grossman Gene M. and Sykes Alan O. (2007), ‘United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures on Imports of Certain Steel Products’, World Trade Review, 6(1): 89122.
Hohmann George (2012), ‘Cheap Chinese Tires Become Election Issue’, Charleston Daily Mail (West Virginia), 29 October.
Horn Henrik and Mavroidis Petros C. (2003), ‘US – Lamb United States – Safeguard Measures on Imports of Fresh, Chilled or Frozen Lamb Meat from New Zealand and Australia: What Should Be Required of a Safeguard Investigation?World Trade Review, 2(3): 395430.
Hufbauer Gary Clyde and Lowry Sean (2012), ‘US Tire Tariffs: Saving Few Jobs at High Cost’, Policy Brief 12–9 (April), Petersen Institute for International Economics, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
Ikenson Daniel (2009), ‘Burning Rubber: Proposed Duties on Chinese Tires Whiff of Senseless Protectionism’, Free Trade Bulletin 39, Center for Trade Policy Studies, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
Ji Wenhua and Huang Cui (2011), ‘China's Experience in Dealing with WTO Dispute Settlement: A Chinese Perspective’, Journal of World Trade, 45(1): 137.
Lee Joonhyung (2011), ‘Who Benefited from the US Tariffs on the Chinese tires?’, MPRA Paper No. 29705, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
Lee Yong-Shik (2002), ‘The Specific Safeguard Mechanism in the Protocol on China's Accession to the WTO: A Serious Step Backward from the Achievement of the Uruguay Round’, The Journal of World Intellectual Property, 5(2): 219231.
Obama Barack H. (2012), ‘Remarks by the President in State of the Union Address’, White House, 24 January.
Prusa Thomas J. (2009), ‘Estimated Economic Effects of the Proposed Import Tariff on Passenger Vehicle and Light Truck Tires from China’, American Coalition for Free Trade in Tires, July.
Rajan Raghuram G., Volpin Paolo, and Zingales Luigi (1997), ‘The Eclipse of the US Tire Industry’, Working Paper No. 97–13, US Census Bureau, Center for Economic Studies.
Spadi Fabio (2002), ‘Discriminatory Safeguards in the Light of the Admission of the People's Republic of China to the World Trade Organization’, Journal of International Economic Law, 5(2): 421443.
Sykes Alan O. (2003), ‘The Safeguards Mess: A Critique of WTO Jurisprudence’, World Trade Review, 2(3): 261295.
Sykes Alan O. (2004), ‘The Persistent Puzzle of Safeguards: Lessons from the Steel Dispute’, John M. Olin Law and Economics Working Paper No. 212 (2nd Series), The University of Chicago Law School, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
Tire Industry Association (2009), ‘Tire Industry Association Expresses Disappointment With President's Decision Concerning Chinese Tire Tariff’, Press release, 14 September, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
US International Trade Commission (USITC) (2009), Certain Passenger Vehicle and Light Truck Tires from China, Washington DC: USITC (July), available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
United Steelworkers (USW) (2012), ‘Saving Jobs by Fighting Unfair Trade’, available at (last visited 2 November 2012).
Will George (2009), ‘With China Tire Tariffs, Obama Bows to Labor’, The Seattle Times, 24 September.
World Trade Organisation (WTO) (2001), ‘Accession of the People's Republic of China’, WT/L/432, 23 November.
World Trade Organisation (WTO) (2010), United States – Measures Affecting Imports of Certain Passenger Vehicle and Light Truck Tyres from China, Panel Report, WT/DS399/R.
World Trade Organisation (WTO) (2011a), United States – Measures Affecting Imports of Certain Passenger Vehicle and Light Truck Tyres from China, Appellate Body Report, WT/DS399/AB/R.
World Trade Organisation (WTO) (2011b), ‘Minutes of Meeting Held on 5 October 2011’, Dispute Settlement Body, WT/DSB/M/304.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

World Trade Review
  • ISSN: 1474-7456
  • EISSN: 1475-3138
  • URL: /core/journals/world-trade-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 4
Total number of PDF views: 32 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 382 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 15th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.