Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-xtgtn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T14:20:50.746Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Determining Consumer Perceptions of and Willingness to Pay for Appalachian Grass-Fed Beef: An Experimental Economics Approach

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 September 2016

Jason R. Evans ,
Gerard E. D'Souza ,
Alan Collins ,
Brown Cheryl  and
Mark Sperow
Jason R. Evans
Affiliation:
Agricultural Business Management in the College of Agriculture & Technology at the State University of New York at Cobleskill in Cobleskill, New York
Gerard E. D'Souza
Affiliation:
Division of Resource Management at West Virginia University in Morgantown, West Virginia
Alan Collins
Affiliation:
Division of Resource Management at West Virginia University in Morgantown, West Virginia
Brown Cheryl
Affiliation:
Division of Resource Management at West Virginia University in Morgantown, West Virginia
Mark Sperow
Affiliation:
Division of Resource Management at West Virginia University in Morgantown, West Virginia
Get access

Abstract

The focus of the current study was on the market potential for grass-fed beef in the Appalachian region, given that these products embody observed, experiential, nutritional, and process attributes that may appeal to a large consumer base. An in-store variant of the Becker-DeGroot-Marschack experimental auction mechanism was employed in the region to determine consumer preferences and willingness to pay. A majority of respondents preferred the grass-fed product over conventional grain-fed samples and were willing to pay a price premium to obtain it. Preferences for grass-fed were rooted largely in the associated superior nutritional content and core observed attributes.

Keywords

AppalachiaBecker-DeGroot-Marschackbeefexperimental auctiongrass-fed
Type
Contributed Papers
Information
Agricultural and Resource Economics Review , Volume 40 , Issue 2 , August 2011 , pp. 233 - 250
Copyright
Copyright © 2011 Northeastern Agricultural and Resource Economics Association 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Balistreri, E., McClelland, G., Poe, G., and Schulze, W. 2001. “Can Hypothetical Questions Reveal True Values? A Laboratory Comparison of Dichotomous Choice and Open-Ended Contingent Values with Auction Values.” Environmental and Resource Economics 18(3): 275–292.Google Scholar
Becker, G., DeGroot, M., and Marschak, J. 1964. “Measuring Utility by a Single-Response Sequential Method.” Behavioral Science 9(3): 226–232.Google Scholar
Berthiaume, R., Mandell, I., Faucitano, L., and Lafreniere, C. 2006. “Comparison of Alternative Beef Production Systems Based on Forage Finishing or Grain-Forage Diets with or without Growth Promotants.” Journal of Animal Science 84(8): 2168–2177.Google Scholar
Bidner, T., Schupp, A., Montgomery, R., and Carpenter, J. Jr. 1981. “Acceptability of Beef Finished on all Forage, Forage Plus Grain, or High Energy Diets.” Journal of Animal Science 53(5): 1181–1187.Google Scholar
Bird, R., and Bodkin, R. 1965. “The National Service Life Insurance Dividend of 1950 and Consumption: A Further Test of the ‘Strict’ Permanent Income Hypothesis.” Journal of Political Economy 73(5): 499–515.Google Scholar
Bodkin, R. 1959. “Windfall Income and Consumption.” American Economic Review 49(4): 602–614.Google Scholar
Bowling, R., Riggs, J., Smith, G., Carpenter, Z., Reddish, R., and Butler, O. 1977. “Production, Carcass and Palatability Characteristics of Steers Produced by Different Management Systems.” Journal of Animal Science 46(2): 333–340.Google Scholar
Branson, R., Cross, H., Savell, J., Smith, G., and Edwards, R. 1986. “Marketing Implications from the National Consumer Beef Study.” Western Journal of Agricultural Economics 11(1): 82–91.Google Scholar
Buhr, B., Hayes, D., Shogren, J., and Kliebenstein, J. 1993. “Valuing Ambiguity: The Case of Genetically Engineered Growth Enhancers.” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 18(2): 175–184.Google Scholar
Byrne, P., Toensmeyer, U., German, C., and Muller, H.R. 1991. “Analysis of Consumer Attitudes toward Organic Produce and Purchase Likelihood.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 22(2): 46–62.Google Scholar
Conner, D., and Christy, R. 2002. “Consumer Preferences for Organic Standards: Guiding Demand-Expansion Strategies for Organic Food.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 33(1): 46–51.Google Scholar
Cross, H., and Dinius, D. 1978. “Carcass and Palatability Characteristics of Beef Steers Finished on Forage Diets.” Journal of Animal Science 47(6): 1265–1271.Google Scholar
Davis, D., and Holt, C. 1993. Experimental Economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Dhiman, T., Anand, G., Satter, L., and Pariza, M. 1999. “Conjugated Linoleic Acid Content of Milk from Cows Fed Different Diets.” Journal of Dairy Science 82(10): 2146–2156.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dickinson, D., and Bailey, D. 2002. “Meat Traceability: Are U.S. Consumers Willing to Pay for It?” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 27(2): 348–364.Google Scholar
Duckett, S., Wagner, D., Yates, L., Dolezal, H., and May, S.G. 1993. “Effects of Time on Feed on Beef Nutrient Composition.” Journal of Animal Science 71(8): 2079–2088.Google Scholar
Eales, J., and Unnevehr, L. 1988. “Demand for Beef and Chicken Products: Separability and Structural Change.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 70(3): 521–532.Google Scholar
Evans, J., Sperow, M., D'souza, G., and Rayburn, E.B. 2007. “Stochastic Simulation of Pasture-Raised Beef Production Systems and Implications for the Appalachian Cow-Calf Sector.” Journal of Sustainable Agriculture 30(4): 27–51.Google Scholar
Ferrell, C., Berry, E., Freetly, H., and Miller, D. 2006. “Influence of Genotype and Diet on Steer Performance, Manure Odor, and Carriage of Pathogenic and other Fecal Bacteria.” Journal of Animal Science 84(9): 2515–2522.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Feuz, D. 2009. “In the Cattle Markets: Feedlot Profitability.” Available at: http://www.lmic.info/memberspublic/intheCattleMarket/Archives/2009/cattlemarkets0113.pdf (accessed August 2009).Google Scholar
French, P., Stanton, C., Lawless, F., O'Riordan, E., Monahan, F., Caffrey, P., and Moloney, A. 2000a. “Fatty Acid Composition, including Conjugated Linoleic Acid, of Intramuscular Fat from Steers Offered Grazed Grass, Grass Silage, or Concentrate-Based Diets.” Journal of Animal Science 78(11): 2849–2855.Google Scholar
French, P., O'Riordan, E., Monahan, F., Caffrey, P., Vidal, M., and Mooney, M. 2000b. “Meat Quality of Steers Finished on Autumn Grass, Grass Silage, or Concentrate-Based Diets.” Meat Science 56(2): 173–180.Google Scholar
Friedman, M. 1957. A Theory of the Consumption Function. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Goss, J., Holcomb, R., and Ward, C. 2002. “Factors Influencing Consumer Decisions Related to Natural Beef in the Southern Plains.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 33(1): 73–84.Google Scholar
Grannis, J., Thilmany, D., and Sparling, E. 2001. “Shopping for Meat: Empirical Demand Estimation for Natural Beef across Store Choices.” Western Agricultural Economics Association Selected Paper; Logan, UT, July 20–24.Google Scholar
Hayes, D., Shogren, J., Shin, S., and Kliebenstein, J. 1995. “Valuing Food Safety in Experimental Auction Markets.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 77(1): 40–53.Google Scholar
Holmes, J. 1970. “A Direct Test of Friedman's Permanent Income Theory.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 65(331): 1159–1162.Google Scholar
Horrigan, L., Lawrence, R., and Walker, P. 2002. “How Sustainable Agriculture Can Address the Environmental and Human Health Harms of Industrial Agriculture.” Environmental Health Perspectives 110(5): 445–456.Google Scholar
Irwin, J., McClelland, G., Mckee, M., Schulze, W., and Norden, N. 1998. “Payoff Dominance vs. Cognitive Transparency in Decision Making.” Economic Inquiry 36: 272–285.Google Scholar
Kansas State University (KSU). 2009. “Focus on Feedlots.” Available at: http://www.asi.ksu.edu/DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=302 (accessed August 2009).Google Scholar
Kinnucan, H., Xiao, H., Hsia, C., and Jackson, J. 1997. “Effects of Health Information and Generic Advertising on U.S. Meat Demand.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 79(1): 13–23.Google Scholar
Klein, L., and Liviatan, N. 1957. “Significance of Income Variability on Savings Behavior.” Bulletin of the Oxford University Institute of Economics and Statistics 19(2): 151–160.Google Scholar
Lanari, M., Brewster, M., Yang, A., and Tume, R. 2002. “Pasture and Grain Finishing Affect the Color Stability of Beef.” Journal of Food Science 67(7): 2467–2474.Google Scholar
Lancaster, K. 1966. “A New Approach to Consumer Theory.” Journal of Political Economy 74(2): 132–157.Google Scholar
Laumas, P. 1969. “A Test of the Permanent Income Hypothesis.” Journal of Political Economy 77(5): 857–861.Google Scholar
Laumas, P., and Mohabbat, K. 1972. “The Permanent Income Hypothesis: Evidence from Time-Series Data.” The American Economic Review 62(4): 730–734.Google Scholar
Lee, T.H. 1975. “More on Windfall Income and Consumption.” Journal of Political Economy 83(2): 407–417.Google Scholar
Lorenzen, C., Hale, D., Griffin, D., Savell, J., Belk, K., Frederick, T., Miller, M., Montgomery, T., and Smith, G. 1993. “National Beef Quality Audit: Survey of Producer-Related Defects and Carcass Quality and Quantity Attributes.” Journal of Animal Science 71(6): 1495–1502.Google Scholar
Lusk, J., Daniel, M., Mark, D., and Lusk, C. 2002. “Alternative Calibration and Auction Institutions for Predicting Consumer Willingness to Pay for Nongenetically Modified Corn Chips.” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 26(1): 40–57.Google Scholar
Lusk, J., Feldkamp, T., and Schroeder, T. 2004. “Experimental Auction Procedure: Impact on Valuation of Quality Differentiated Goods.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 86(2): 389–405.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lusk, J., and Fox, J. 2000. “Consumer Valuation of Beef Rib Eye Steak Attributes.” American Agricultural Economics Association Selected Paper; Tampa, FL, July 30-August 2.Google Scholar
Lusk, J., Fox, J., Schroeder, T., Mintert, J., and Koohmaraie, M. 2001. “In-Store Valuation of Steak Tenderness.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 83(3): 539–550.Google Scholar
Mandell, I., Buchanan-Smith, J., and Campbell, C. 1998. “Effects of Forage vs. Grain Feeding on Carcass Characteristics, Fatty Acid Composition, and Beef Quality in Limousin-Cross Steers when Time on Feed is Controlled.” Journal of Animal Science 76(10): 2619–2630.Google Scholar
May, S., Dolezal, H., Gill, D., Ray, F., and Buchanan, D. 1992. “Effects of Days Fed, Carcass Grade Traits, and Subcutaneous Fat Removal on Postmortem Muscle Characteristics Beef Palatability.” Journal of Animal Science 70(2): 444–453.Google Scholar
Maynard, L., Burdine, K., and Meyer, A. 2003. “Market Potential for Locally Produced Meat Products.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 34(2): 26–37.Google Scholar
McCoy, J. 1979. Livestock and Meat Marketing, 2nd ed. Westport, Connecticut: The AVI Publishing Company, Inc. Google Scholar
Menkhaus, D., Borden, G., Whipple, G., Hoffman, E., and Field, R. 1992. “An Empirical Application of Laboratory Experimental Auctions in Marketing Research.” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 17(1): 44–55.Google Scholar
Menkhaus, D., Whipple, G., Field, R., and Moore, S. 1988. “The Impact of a Price Premium on Sales of Branded, Low Fat, Fresh Beef.” Agribusiness 4(6): 521–534.Google Scholar
Moon, W., and Ward, R. 1999. “Effects of Health Concerns and Consumer Characteristics on U.S. Meat Consumption.” American Agricultural Economics Association Selected Paper; Nashville, TN, August 8–11.Google Scholar
Neely, T., Lorenzen, C., Miller, R., Tatum, J., Wise, J., Taylor, J., Buyck, M., Reagan, J., and Savell, J. 1998. “Beef Customer Satisfaction: Role of Cut, USDA Quality Grade, and City on In-Home Consumer Ratings.” Journal of Animal Science 76(4): 1027–1032.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Noci, F., Monahan, F., French, P., and Moloney, A. 2005. “The Fatty Acid Composition of Muscle Fat and Subcutaneous Adipose Tissue of Pasture-Fed Beef Heifers: Influence of the Duration of Grazing.” Journal of Animal Science 83(5): 1167–1178.Google Scholar
Oberholtzer, L., Dimitri, C., and Greene, C. 2005. “Price Premiums Hold On as U.S. Organic Produce Market Expands.” USDA/ERS Research Document VGS-308-01; Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Patterson, P., Olofsson, H., Richards, T., and Sass, S. 1999. “An Empirical Analysis of State Agricultural Product Promotions: A Case Study of ‘Arizona Grown’.” Agribusiness 15(2): 179–196.Google Scholar
Peterson, R. 1972. “A Test of the Permanent Income Hypothesis of the Demand for Money Using Grouping as an Instrumental Variable.” Journal of Political Economy 80(2): 403–408.Google Scholar
Purchas, R., Knight, T., and Busboom, J. 2005. “The Effect of Production System and Age on Concentrations of Fatty Acids in Intramuscular Fat of the Longissimus and Triceps Brachii Muscles of Angus-Cross Heifers.” Meat Science 70(4): 597–603.Google Scholar
Realini, C., Duckett, S., Brito, G., Dalla Rizza, M., and De Mattos, D. 2004. “Effect of Pasture vs. Concentrate Feeding with or without Antioxidants on Carcass Characteristics, Fatty Acid Composition, and Quality of Uruguayan Beef.” Meat Science 66(3): 567–577.Google Scholar
Roosen, J., Hennessy, D., Fox, J., and Schreiber, A. 1998. “Consumers' Valuation of Insecticide Use Restrictions: An Application to Apples.” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 23(2): 367–384.Google Scholar
Rule, D., Broughton, K., Shellito, S., and Maiorano, G. 2002. “Comparison of Muscle Fatty Acid Profiles and Cholesterol Concentrations of Bison, Beef Cattle, Elk, and Chicken.” Journal of Animal Science 80(5): 1202–1211.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rutstrom, E. 1998. “Home-Grown Values and Incentive Compatible Auction Design.” International Journal of Game Theory 27: 427–441.Google Scholar
Schaake, S., Skelley, G., Halpin, E., Grimes, L., Brown, R., Cross, D., and Thompson, C. 1993. “Carcass and Meat Sensory Traits of Steers Finished on Fescue and Clover, Summer Forage, or for Different Periods in Drylot.” Journal of Animal Science 71(12): 3199–3205.Google Scholar
Schroeder, J., Cramer, D., Bowling, R., and Cook, C. 1980. “Palatability, Shelf Life, and Chemical Differences Between Forage and Grain-Finished Beef.” Journal of Animal Science 50(5): 852–859.Google Scholar
Scollan, N., Hocquette, J., Nuernberg, K., Dannenberger, D., Richardson, I., and Moloney, A. 2006. “Innovations in Beef Production Systems that Enhance the Nutritional and Health Value of Beef Lipids and the Relationship with Meat Quality.” Meat Science 74(1): 17–33.Google Scholar
Sithyphone, K., Yabe, M., Horita, H., Fumita, T., Shiotsuka, Y., Etoh, T., Ebara, F., Samadmanivong, O., Wegner, J., and Gotoh, T. 2011. “Comparison of Feeding Systems: Feed Cost, Palatability and Environmental Impact among Hay-Fattened Beef, Consistent Grass-Only-Fed Beef and Conventional Marbled Beef in Wagyu.” Animal Science Journal 82(2): 352–359.Google Scholar
Smith, G., Savell, J., Morgan, J., Lawrence, T. 2005. Final Report of the National Beef Quality Audit—2005: A New Benchmark for the U.S. Beef Industry. Available at: http://meat.tamu.edu/nbqa2005/nbqasummary.html (accessed August 2009).Google Scholar
Spiselman, A. 2006. “Is Grass-Fed Greener?” Meatingplace: In the Aisles section. September issue: 74–77.Google Scholar
Taubman, P. 1965. “Permanent and Transitory Income Effects.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 47(1): 38–43.Google Scholar
Umberger, W., Feuz, D., Calkins, C., and Killinger-Mann, K. 2002. “U.S. Consumer Preference and Willingness to Pay for Domestic Corn-Fed Beef versus International Grass-Fed Beef Measured through an Experimental Auction.” Agribusiness 18(4): 491–504.Google Scholar
Underhill, S., and Figueroa, E. 1996. “Consumer Preferences for Non-Conventionally Grown Produce.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 27(2): 56–66.Google Scholar
USDA/National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS). 2009. Selected data. Available at http://www.nass.usda.gov (accessed August 2009).Google Scholar
Vickrey, W. 1961. “Counterspeculation, Auctions, and Competitive Sealed Tenders.” The Journal of Finance 16(1): 8–37.Google Scholar
Wolf, M., and Thulin, A. 2000. “A Target Consumer Profile and Positioning for Promotion of a New Locally Branded Beef Product.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 31(1): 193–197.Google Scholar
Wooldridge, J. 2006. Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach, 3rd ed. Mason, Ohio: Thomson South-Western. Google Scholar
Ziehl, A., Thilmany, D., and Umberger, W. 2005. “A Cluster Analysis of Natural Beef Product Consumers by Shopping Behavior, Importance of Production Attributes, and Demographics.” Journal of Food Distribution Research 36(1): 209–217.Google Scholar