Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c4f8m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T20:29:47.474Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Order beyond the state: explaining Somaliland's avoidance of maritime piracy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 March 2018

Justin V. Hastings  and
Sarah G. Phillips
Justin V. Hastings*
Affiliation:
Department of Government and International Relations, Merewether (H04), University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
Sarah G. Phillips*
Affiliation:
Centre for International Security Studies, Merewether (H04), University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
*
Email: justin.hastings@sydney.edu.au
Email: sarah.phillips@sydney.edu.au
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

How do some places with weak institutional capacity avoid being caught in the cycles of violence and criminality so often associated with African institutions in the ‘failed states’ literature? This paper exploits in-country variation in piracy incidence across different regions of Somalia to investigate how some territories with low state capacity can nonetheless deter piracy and provide relative order. We find that the usual explanation – state ‘failure’ in Somalia, compared with a reasonably functional government in Somaliland – does not withstand scrutiny. Somaliland's lack of piracy was not due to ‘strong’ state institutions, but can be attributed to the strength of a discourse that emphasises Somaliland's ‘inherent’ capacity for order against the disorder supposedly endemic to the rest of Somalia. The exploration of the discursive underpinnings of Somaliland's supposed ‘piratelessness’ has implications for understanding the relationship between state institutions, political order and violence, particularly where the state does not exercise a monopoly on force.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Modern African Studies , Volume 56 , Issue 1 , March 2018 , pp. 5 - 30
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Thanks to Maxamed Axmed Ali and Sean Whipple for research support. This paper was previously presented at a panel at the 2016 International Studies Association annual meeting in Atlanta, where Omar McDoom and other participants provided helpful comments. The research for this paper was funded by the Australian Research Council through grants DP130103966 and DE130101468.

References

REFERENCES

Anderson, M. 2012. ‘Somaliland says new laws show intent to fight piracy’, Reuters, 22 February.Google Scholar
Bahadur, J. 2011. The Pirates of Somalia: inside their hidden world. New York, NY: Vintage.Google Scholar
Blyth, M. 2010. ‘On setting and upsetting agendas: Blyth on Gofas and Hay, Tonder and Seabrooke’, in Gofas, A. & Hay, C., eds. The Role of Ideas in Political Analysis: a portrait of contemporary debates. London: Routledge, 167–86.Google Scholar
Boege, V., Brown, A., Clements, K. & Nolan, A.. 2009. ‘Building peace and political community in hybrid political orders’, International Peacekeeping 16, 5: 599–615.Google Scholar
Braithwaite, A. 2010. ‘Resisting infection: how state capacity conditions conflict contagion’, Journal of Peace Research 47, 3: 311–19.Google Scholar
Bryden, M. 2003. ‘The ‘Banana Test’: is Somaliland ready for recognition?’, Annales d'Ethiopie 19: 341–64.Google Scholar
Bueger, C. 2013. ‘Practice, pirates and coast guards: the grand narrative of Somali piracy’, Third World Quarterly 34, 10: 1811–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carstensen, M. 2011. ‘Ideas are not as stable as political scientists want them to be: using discourse theory in ideational analysis’, Political Studies 59, 3: 596–615.Google Scholar
Chalk, P. 1998. ‘Low intensity conflict in Southeast Asia: piracy, drug trafficking, and political terrorism’, Conflict Issues 305/306.Google Scholar
Chalk, P. 2008. The Maritime Dimension of International Security: Terrorism, Piracy, and Challenges for the United States. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.Google Scholar
Clunan, A. & Trinkunas, H., eds. 2010. Ungoverned Spaces: alternatives to state authority in an era of softened sovereignty. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Coggins, B. 2011. ‘Nothing fails like success: anarchy, piracy and state-building in Somalia’. Hanover, NH: Dartmouth College.Google Scholar
Coggins, B. 2016. ‘Failing and the Seven Seas? Somali piracy in global perspective’, Journal of Global Security Studies 1, 4: 251–69.Google Scholar
Collier, P. 2008. The Bottom Billion: why the poorest countries are failing and what can be done about it. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Collier, P. 2009. ‘The political economy of state failure’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy 25, 2: 219–40.Google Scholar
Crocker, C. 2003. ‘Engaging failing states’, Foreign Affairs 82, 5: 32–45.Google Scholar
Daxecker, U. & Prins, B.. 2013. ‘Insurgents of the sea: institutional and economic opportunities for maritime piracy’, Journal of Conflict Resolution 57, 6: 940–65.Google Scholar
Daxecker, U. & Prins, B.. 2015 a. ‘The new Barbary Wars: forecasting maritime piracy’, Foreign Policy Analysis 11, 1: 23–44.Google Scholar
Daxecker, U. & Prins, B.. 2015 b. ‘Searching for sanctuary: government power and the location of maritime piracy’, International Interactions 41, 4: 699–717.Google Scholar
DeRouen, K., Ferguson, M., Norton, S., Park, Y., Lea, J. & Streat-Bartlett, A.. 2010. ‘Civil war peace agreement implementation and state capacity’, Journal of Peace Research 47, 3: 333–46.Google Scholar
Dua, J. 2011. ‘Piracy and the narrative of recognition: the view from Somaliland’. New York, NY: Social Science Research Council. Available at: http://www.ssrc.org/pages/Piracy-and-the-Narrative-of-Recognition-The-View-from-Somaliland/.Google Scholar
Dua, J. 2013. ‘A sea of trade and a sea of fish: piracy and protection in the Western Indian Ocean’, Journal of Eastern African Studies 7, 3: 353–70.Google Scholar
Dua, J. & Menkhaus, K.. 2012. ‘The context of contemporary piracy the case of Somalia’, Journal of International Criminal Justice 10, 4: 749–66.Google Scholar
Epstein, C. 2008. The Power of Words in International Relations: birth of an anti-whaling discourse. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Fearon, J. 1999. ‘Weak states, rough terrain, and large-scale ethnic violence’, for American Political Science Association Annual Meeting 1999, Atlanta, GA.Google Scholar
Fearon, J. & Laitin, D.. 2003. ‘Ethnicity, insurgency, and civil war’, American Political Science Review 97, 1: 75–90.Google Scholar
FSNAU (Food Security and Nutrition Analysis Unit – Somalia) (2013). ‘Family ties: remittances and livelihoods support in Puntland and Somaliland study report’, http://www.fsnau.org/in-focus/family-ties-remittances-and-livelihoods-support-puntland-and-somaliland-study-report.Google Scholar
Ghani, A. & Lockhart, C.. 2008. Fixing Failed States. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Gleditsch, K. & Ruggeri, A.. 2010. ‘Political opportunity structures, democracy, and civil war’, Journal of Peace Research 47, 3: 299–310.Google Scholar
Hagmann, T. & Höhne, M.. 2009. ‘Failures of the state failure debate: evidence from the Somali territories’, Journal of International Development 21, 42–57.Google Scholar
Hansen, L. 2006. Security as Practice: discourse analysis and the Bosnian war. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hansen, S. 2009. Piracy in the Greater Gulf of Aden: myths, misconceptions and remedies. Oslo: Norwegian Institute for Urban and Regional Research.Google Scholar
Hansen, S. 2011. ‘The myths of piracy in the Horn of Africa’, for the International Studies Association Meeting 2011, Montreal, QC.Google Scholar
Harmony Project. 2007. Al-Qaida's (Mis)Adventures in the Horn of Africa. West Point, NY: Combating Terrorism Center, United States Military Academy.Google Scholar
Harper, M. 2012. Getting Somalia Wrong? Faith and war in a shattered state. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Hastings, J. 2009. ‘Geographies of state failure and sophistication in maritime piracy hijackings’, Political Geography 28, 4: 213–23.Google Scholar
Hastings, J. & Phillips, S.. 2015. ‘Maritime piracy business networks and institutions in the Horn of Africa and the Gulf of Guinea’, African Affairs 114, 457: 555–76.Google Scholar
Hill, J. 2005. ‘Beyond the other? A postcolonial critique of the failed state thesis’, African Identities 3, 2: 139–54.Google Scholar
Höhne, M. 2009. ‘Mimesis and mimicry in dynamics of state and identity formation in Northern Somalia’, Africa: Journal of the International African Institute 79, 2: 252–81.Google Scholar
Höhne, M. 2011. ‘Not born as a de facto state: Somaliland's complicated state formation’, in Sharamo, R. & Mesfin, B., ed. Regional Security in the post-Cold War Horn of Africa. Institute for Security Studies, Monograph 178, 309–46.Google Scholar
Höhne, M. 2015. Between Somaliland and Puntland: marginalization, militarization and conflicting political visions. London: Rift Valley Institute.Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch. 2009. Hostages to Peace: threats to human rights and democracy in Somaliland. New York, NY: Human Rights Watch.Google Scholar
International Crisis Group (ICG). 2009. Somalia: the trouble with Puntland. Brussels: ICG.Google Scholar
Ismail, E. 2006. ‘The case for unitary government’, for Conference on Ethnicity and Federalism in Africa, Lagos, 20–23 February. Available at <http://www.sirag.org.uk/case_unitary_government_edna_somaliland.htm>>Google Scholar
Jablonski, R. & Oliver, S.. 2013. ‘The political economy of plunder: economic opportunity and modern piracy’, Journal of Conflict Resolution 57, 4: 682–708.Google Scholar
Kabamba, P. 2010. ‘“Heart of Darkness”: current images of the DRC and their theoretical underpinning’, Anthropological Theory 10, 3: 265–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Menkhaus, K. 2006/7. ‘Governance without government in Somalia: spoilers, state building, and the politics of coping’, International Security 31, 3: 74–106.Google Scholar
Migdal, J. & Schlichte, K.. 2005. ‘Rethinking the state’, in Schlichte, K., ed. The Dynamics of States: the formation and crises of state domination. Oxford: Routledge, 1–40.Google Scholar
Milliken, J. 1999. ‘The study of discourse in international relations: a critique of research and methods’, European Journal of International Relations 5, 2: 225–54.Google Scholar
Murphy, M. 2007. Contemporary Piracy and Maritime Terrorism. London: International Institute of Strategic Studies.Google Scholar
Murphy, M. 2008. Small Boats, Weak States, Dirty Money: piracy and maritime terrorism in the modern world. London: Hurst & Company.Google Scholar
Murphy, M. 2010. Somalia: the new Barbary? New York, NY: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Murphy, M. 2013. ‘Petro-piracy: oil and troubled waters’, Orbis 57, 3: 424–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nuruzzaman, M. 2009. ‘Revisiting the category of fragile and failed states in international relations’, International Studies 46, 3: 271–94.Google Scholar
Observatory of Conflict and Violence Prevention. 2015. Safety and Security Baseline Report: Burao. Hargeisa: OCVP.Google Scholar
Oliver, S., Jablonski, R. & Hastings, J.. 2017. ‘The Tortuga disease: the perverse effects of illicit foreign capital’, International Studies Quarterly 61, 2: 312–27.Google Scholar
Percy, S. & Shortland, A.. 2013. ‘The business of piracy in Somalia’, Journal of Strategic Studies 36, 4: 541–78.Google Scholar
Phillips, S. 2013. ‘Political settlements and state formation: the case of Somaliland, ‘The Developmental Leadership Program, Research Paper 23, December 2013.Google Scholar
Phillips, S. 2016. ’ When less was more: external assistance and the political settlement in Somaliland’, International Affairs 92, 3: 630–45.Google Scholar
Phillips, S.G. & Hunt, J.S.. 2017. ‘“Without Sultan Qaboos, we would be Yemen”: the renaissance narrative and the political settlement in Oman’, Journal of International Development 29, 5: 645–60.Google Scholar
Piazza, J. 2008. ‘Incubators of terror: do failed and failing states promote transnational terrorism?’, International Studies Quarterly 52, 3: 469–88.Google Scholar
Rabasa, A. & Chalk, P.. 2001. Colombian Labyrinth: the synergy of drugs and insurgency and its implications for regional stability. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.Google Scholar
Rabasa, A., Boraz, S., Chalk, P., Cragin, K., Karasik, T., Moroney, J., O'Brien, K. & Peters, J.. 2007. Ungoverned Territories: understanding and reducing terrorism risks. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.Google Scholar
Raeymaekers, T., Menkhaus, K. & Vlassenroot, K.. 2008. ‘State and non-state regulation in African protracted crises: governance without government?’, Afrika Focus 21, 2: 7–21.Google Scholar
Renders, M. & Terlinden, U.. 2010. ‘Negotiating statehood in a hybrid political order: the case of Somaliland’, Development and Change 41, 4: 723–46.Google Scholar
Rotberg, R. 2002. ‘The new nature of nation-state failure’, The Washington Quarterly 25, 3: 85–96.Google Scholar
Rotberg, R., ed. 2003. State Failure and State Weakness in a Time of Terror. Cambridge, MA: World Peace Foundation.Google Scholar
Schmidt, V. 2008. ‘Discursive institutionalism: the explanatory power of ideas and discourse’, Annual Review of Political Science, 11: 303–26.Google Scholar
Schmidt, V. 2011. ‘Speaking of change: why discourse is key to the dynamics of policy transformation’, Critical Policy Studies 5, 2: 106–26.Google Scholar
Takeyh, R. & Gvosdev, N.. 2002. ‘Do terrorist networks need a home?’, Washington Quarterly 25, 3: 97–108.Google Scholar
The Economist . 2008. ‘Piracy and much worse’. 2 October. http://www.economist.com/node/12341825.Google Scholar
The Economist . 2015. ‘The Economist explains why Somaliland is not a recognised state’, 1 November. http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2015/11/economist-explains.Google Scholar
Torfing, J. 2005. ‘Discourse theory: achievements, arguments, and challenges’, in Howarth, D. & Torfing, J., eds. Discourse Theory in European Politics: identity, policy and governance. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA). 2014. ‘Population estimation survey for the 18 Pre-War regions of Somalia’. Nairobi: Somalia Country Office, United Nations Population Fund.Google Scholar
United Nations Security Council. 2008. ‘Report of the Monitoring Group on Somalia pursuant to Security Council Resolution 1811 (2008)’. New York, NY: United Nations Security Council.Google Scholar
United Nations Security Council. 2010. ‘Report of the Monitoring Group on Somalia and Eritrea pursuant to Security Council resolution 1916 (2010) (S/2011/433)’. New York, NY: United Nations Security Council.Google Scholar
United Nations Security Council. 2011. ‘Report of the Monitoring Group on Somalia and Eritrea pursuant to Security Council Resolution 1916 (2010)’. New York, NY: United National Security Council.Google Scholar
Walter, B. 2015. ‘Why bad governance leads to repeat civil war’, Journal of Conflict Resolution 59, 7: 1242–72.Google Scholar
World Bank Group. 2011. The World Development Report 2011: Conflict, Security, and Development. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
World Bank Group. 2013. The Pirates of Somalia: ending the threat, rebuilding a nation. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar