Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-gtxcr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T05:00:18.274Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘But then they started all this killing’:1 attitudes to the I.R.A. in the Irish Republic since 1969

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 February 2015

Brian Hanley
Brian Hanley*
Affiliation:
School of History and Archives, University College Dublin
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This article examines one of the most intense divisions between Irish nationalists during the Northern Ireland conflict. The Provisional I.R.A. claimed to be waging a similar war to that of the I.R.A. of the revolutionary era (1916–1921); an assertion disputed by many. The argument was significant because all the major political forces in the Irish Republic honoured the memory of what they called the ‘old’ I.R.A. (defined in a popular school history book as ‘the men who fought for Irish freedom between 1916 and 1923’). They argued that in contrast to the Provisionals, the ‘old’ I.R.A. possessed a democratic mandate and avoided causing civilian casualties. Echoes of these disputes resurfaced during Sinn Féin's bid for the Irish presidency during 2011. Commemorating Denis Barry, an anti-treaty I.R.A. prisoner who died on hunger strike in 1923, Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin claimed that in contrast to men like Barry ‘those who waged war in Northern Ireland during the more recent Troubles were an impediment to Irish unity and directly responsible for causing distress and grief to many families. Yet they still seek to hijack history and the achievements of the noble people who fought for Ireland in our War of Independence … to justify their terrorist campaign.’

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 38 , Issue 151 , May 2013 , pp. 439 - 456
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 Tierney, Mark and MacCurtain, Margaret, The birth of modern Ireland (Dublin, 1969), p. 188.Google Scholar The authors stressed that these men ‘were not to be confused’ with later organisations using the I.R.A. title.

3 Irish Times, 21 Nov. 2011.

4 See Hayes, Bernadette C. and McAllister, Ian, ‘Public support for political violence and paramilitarism in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland’ in Terrorism and Political Violence, 17 (2005), pp 599–617.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

5 Irish Times, 29 Nov. 1972.

6 Irish Times, 20 Jan. 1973.

7 Patterson, Henry, ‘“Deeply anti-British”? The Irish state and cross-border security cooperation, 1970–1974’ p. 2, Google Scholar

8 Irish Times, 20 May 1972.

9 Irish Times, 27 Aug. 1984.

10 Gallagher, Michael and Marsh, Michael, Days of blue loyalty: the politics of membership of Fine Gael (Dublin, 2002), pp 164–5Google Scholar, 186–7. See also remarks by John, Deasy T.D. in Irish Independent, 8 Nov. 2002.Google Scholar

11 Puirséil, Niamh, The Irish Labour Party 1922–73 (Dublin, 2007), pp 288–99.Google Scholar

12 Gallagher, Michael, The Irish Labour Party in transition, 1957–82 (Manchester, 1982), p. 142.Google Scholar

13 Hot Press, 8 Sept. 1993.

14 Irish Times, 1 Jan. 1980.

15 O’Brien, Conor Cruise, Herod: reflections on political violence (London, 1978), pp 11, 137.Google Scholar

16 Fortnight, no. 216 (18–31 Mar., 1985).

17 Irish Times, 20 Feb. 1980.

18 See interview with Tones, Wolfe, Hot Press, 14 Aug. 1986.Google Scholar

19 ‘The Whole Hog’, Hot Press, 16 Aug. 1990.

20 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 20 Jan. 1980.

21 An Phoblacht, 20 Dec. 1974.

22 J.J. Arthur to Jack Lynch, 28 Nov. 1972, (N.A.I., DT2003/16/590).

23 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 9 Feb. 1984

24 Féin, Sinn Publicity Department, The good old I.RA.: Tan war operations (Dublin, 1985).Google Scholar

25 Ibid., p. 1.

26 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 7 Nov. 1985.

27 An Phoblacht, 10 Dec. 1972.

28 An Phoblacht, 31 Jan. 1975.

29 Magill, Feb. 1983.

30 Irish Times, 27 Aug. 1981.

31 McGarry, John and O’Leary, Brendan, Explaining Northern Ireland: broken images (London, 1995), p. 259.Google Scholar See Hanley, Brian and Millar, Scott, The lost revolution: the story of the Official IRA. and the Workers Party (Dublin, 2009), pp 108–30.Google Scholar

32 C/S Ó Cearbhaill, T.L., ‘Military considerations’ 23 Aug. 1971, (U.C.D.A., Patrick Hillery papers, P205/37).Google Scholar

33 Peck, John, ‘Republic of Ireland: annual review for 1971’, 10 Jan. 1972, (T.N.A., Foreign and Commonwealth Office, FCO 87/7).Google Scholar

34 ‘State of security — the Irish Republic’, 19 May 1972, (T.N.A., CAB 134/3574).

35 Kilkenny People, 4 Feb. 1972.

36 The Kerryman (North Cork edition), 5 Feb. 1972; Munster Express, 4 Feb. 1972; Longford Leader, 4. Feb. 1972; Drogheda Independent, 4. Feb 1972; Herald and Western Advertiser, 5 Feb. 1972.

37 Lyons, F.S.L. to FitzGerald, G., 17 Feb. 1972 (U.C.D.A., Garret FitzGerald papers P215/4).Google Scholar

38 An Phoblacht, Mar. 1972.

39 Irish Times, 2 Dec. 1972.

40 Sunday Independent, 12 Dec. 1971.

41 The report was commissioned after the escape of senior Provisional I.R.A. members from Mountjoy Prison in 1973. It was not published but sections of it were quoted in the Barron Commission report on the Dublin/Monaghan bombings.

42 Joint committee on justice, equality, defence and women’s rights, Report of Independent Commission of Inquiry into the Dublin and Monaghan bombings (Dublin, 2003), p. 34.Google Scholar

43 British diplomats had informed Dublin during 1972 of Soviet connections to the O.I.R.A.: Foreign and Commonwealth Office telegram no. 106, 26 Feb. 1972, (T.N.A., Prem 15/1046).

44 Hibernia, 9 June 1972.

45 Established in 1971 by former Fianna Fáil members who felt the party had abandoned republicanism under Jack Lynch.

46 Irish Times, 24 July 1972.

47 Irish Times, 29 July 1972.

48 Hibernia, 25 Aug. 1972.

49 Gallagher, Michael, (ed.) Irish elections, 1948–77: results and analysis (London, 2009) p. 272.Google Scholar

50 D. Hunt to J. Lynch, 28 Nov. 1972 (N.A.I., D.T. 2003/16/590).

51 Gallagher, , Irish elections, p. 311.Google Scholar Provisional Sinn Féin did not contest the 1973 general election.

52 Irish Times, 21 Feb. 1980.

53 Irish Times, 17 Oct. 1979.

54 Mitchell, Paul ‘The 1992 general election in the Republic of Ireland’ in Irish Political Studies, 8 (1993), p. 116.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55 Irish Times, 31 Aug. 1979.

56 An Phoblacht, 5 July 1974.

57 Editor of An Phoblacht/Republican News from 1979 and Sinn Féin director of publicity throughout the 1980s.

58 O’Malley, Padraig, The uncivil wars: Ireland today (Boston, 1997 edn), p. 276.Google Scholar

59 Adams, Gerry, The politics of Irish freedom (Dingle, 1986), p. 46.Google Scholar

60 Fortnight, no. 407 (Oct. 2002).

61 Irish Times, 20 Oct. 1979.

62 Gogan, Larry, Larry Gogan’s pop file (Dublin, 1979), pp 169–70.Google Scholar

63 An Phoblacht, 27 Sept. 1974.

64 Hibernia, 27 Sept. 1974.

65 Raven, John, Whelan, C.T., Pfretzschner, Paul A. and Borock, Donald M., Political culture in Ireland: the views of two generations (Dublin, 1976), p. 131.Google Scholar

66 Ibid., p. 129.

67 Ibid., pp 127, 187.

68 McGréil, Mícheál, Prejudice and tolerance in Ireland: based on a survey of intergroup attitudes of Dublin adults and other sources (Dublin, 1977), p. 415.Google Scholar

69 Ibid., p. 387.

70 Davis, E.E. and Sinnott, Richard, Attitudes in the Republic of Ireland relevant to the Northern Ireland problem, i: descriptive analysis, Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute paper no. 97 (Sept. 1979), pp 98–9.Google Scholar

71 Ibid., p. 116.

72 Ibid., p. 98.

73 Davis, E.E. and Sinnott, Richard, ‘The controversy concerning attitudes in the Republic to the Northern Ireland problem’ in Studies, 69Google Scholar, nos. 275–6 (autumn/winter, 1980), pp 179–92. A counter report was undertaken and published a year later: Baker, T.J., Hannan, D., Rottman, D. and Walsh, B., ‘Critique of E.S.R.I. paper No. 97’, (June-Aug., 1980) (N.A.I., DT 2010/53/877).Google Scholar

74 Irish Times, 17 Oct. 1979.

75 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 20 Oct. 1979.

76 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 27 Oct. 1979.

77 Irish Times, 21 Feb 1980.

78 Hot Press, 19 May. 1993.

79 Hot Press, 14 Dec. 1989.

80 Hot Press, 21 March 1991.

81 Hot Press, 20 Sept. 1990.

82 For a wider discussion on section 31 see Corcoran, Mary P. and O’Brien, Mark, Political censorship and the democratic state: the Irish broadcasting ban (Dublin, 2004).Google Scholar

83 A phenomenon noted in An Phoblacht as early as 10 Aug. 1973.

84 See Gkotzaridis, Evi, Trials of Irish history: genesis and evolution of a reappraisal 1938–2000 (London, 2006)Google Scholar and Dorgan, Theo and Ní Dhonnchadha, Máirín (eds), Revising the Rising (Derry, 1991).Google Scholar While far from the only commentators engaged in such reassessments, Cruise O’Brien and Dudley Edwards were among the most prominent.

85 Irish Times, 25 Feb. 1980.

86 Irish Times, 18 Feb. 1980.

87 Magill, May 1979.

88 The Starry Plough, Apr. 1980.

89 Of the 125 fatalities during 1979, republicans were responsible for 104, loyalists for 18 and the British army for 2. McKittrick, David, Kelter, Seamus, Feeney, Brian and Thornton, Chris, Lost lives: the stories of the men, women and children who died as a result of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Edinburgh, 1999), pp 773–4.Google Scholar

90 Irish Times, 18 Feb. 1980.

91 Irish Times, 9 Nov. 1996.

92 In Dublin, 3 Sept. 1987.

93 Irish Times, 23 Aug. 1982.

94 Irish Times, 1 Apr.1986.

95 Son of C.S. Todd Andrews, I.R.A. activist during the War of Independence and Civil War.

96 Doherty had been elected to the Dáil shortly before his death.

97 Hot Press, 11 Sept. 1986.

98 Hot Press, 21 June 1985.

99 The Kerryman (North Cork edition), 5 Feb. 1972.

100 Sunday Independent, 7 Mar. 1976. Twenty-one people were killed by I.R.A. bombs in Birmingham during November 1974.

101 Undated note of telephone conversation with Barry, 1977 (U.C.D.A., Sighle Humphreys papers, P106/1566 (6)).

102 Sunday Independent, 7 Mar. 1976.

103 In Dublin, 3 Sept. 1987.

104 This was certainly my memory of discussions within my own family circle.

105 Magill, Apr.1981 and 7 — 13 June 1981.

106 Sighle Humphries to Thatcher, 23 May 1981, (U.C.D.A., Sighle Humphreys papers, P106/1570 (4)).

107 Magill, 31 May— 6 June 1981.

108 Morrison, , quoted in O’Malley, , Uncivil wars, p. 279.Google Scholar

109 Hot Press, 19 Aug. 1983.

110 Irish Times, 28 Nov. 1980.

111 Magill, 14 June 1981. In the 1982 general election seven Sinn Féin candidates won 16,894 votes: An Phoblacht/Republican News, 11 Feb. 1982.

112 O’Connor, Linda in The Kerryman, 13 Nov. 1981.Google Scholar

113 Hot Press, 15 June 1984.

114 The Wolfe Tones, for example, were loath to admit to having I.R.A. sympathies: Hot Press, 29 Aug. 1986.

115 Hot Press, 24 Oct. 1985.

116 Tom Oliver was a Louth farmer accused by the I.R.A. of being an informer. Patsy Gillespie was killed after having been forced to drive a ‘proxy’ bomb into a British base.

117 An I.R.A. bomb killed eleven Protestant civilians at a Remembrance Day ceremony in November 1987.

118 Hot Press, 19 Sept. 1991.

119 In 1991 Sinn Féin gained just 1.7 per cent of the vote in the Republic’s local government elections: Fitzgerald, Rona, ‘The 1991 local government elections in the Republic of Ireland’ in Irish Political Studies, 7 (1992), pp 103–4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

120 O’Malley, Padraig, Biting at the grave: the Irish hunger strike and the politics of despair (Boston, 1990), p. 253.Google Scholar

121 See Dunne, Derek, Out of the Maze: the true story of the biggest jailbreak in Europe since the Second World War (Dublin, 1988).Google Scholar

122 In Dublin, 26 Nov. 1987.

123 MacGréil, Mícheál, Prejudice in Ireland revisited: based on a national survey of intergroup attitudes in the Republic of Ireland (Dublin, 1996), p. 239.Google Scholar

124 Ibid., p. 240.

125 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 9. Feb. 1984.

126 Irish Times, 20 Jan. 1973.

127 Féin, Sinn, The good old IR.A., p. 7;Google ScholarFoster, R.F., Modern Ireland 1600–1972 (London, 1989), p. 494.Google Scholar

128 Sunday Independent, 19 Sept. 1976.

129 Adams, , Politics, p. 47.Google ScholarPubMed

130 An Phoblacht, Sept 1971.

131 An Phoblacht, Mar. 1971.

132 An Phoblacht, 15 June 1973.

133 ‘Seán Ó Riain’, Provos: patriots or terrorists? (Dublin, 1974) p. 19.

134 Magill, March 1989.

135 Sunday Press, 30 Jan. 1972.

136 Hot Press, 14 June 1990.

137 McCann, Eamonn, Bloody Sunday in Derry: what really happened (Dingle, 1992), p. 4.Google Scholar

138 Irish Times, 1 Feb. 1974.

139 Hot Press, 1 Nov. 1990.

140 Irish People, 7 Apr. 1989.

141 Magill, Sept. 1979, Dec. 1980, Aug. 1982.

142 Magill, June 1982.

143 Hot Press, 31 May 1990.

144 Farrell, Michael, Struggle in the north (Belfast, 1972).Google Scholar

145 O’Connor, Fionnuala, In search of a state: Catholics in Northern Ireland (Belfast, 1993), pp 260–1.Google Scholar In January 1992 the Provisional I.R.A. killed eight Protestant men in a bomb attack at Teebane, County Tyrone: McKittrick, , Lost lives, pp 1268–71.Google Scholar

146 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 14 Nov. 1985.

147 Magill, July 1983.

148 Irish Times, 10 July 1972.

149 An Phoblacht, July 1971.

150 An Phoblacht, Apr. 1971.

151 Hot Press, 25 Aug. 1988, 14 Dec. 1989.

152 Irish Times, 12 Apr. 1993.

153 Irish Independent, 29 Sept. 2011.

154 Irish Times, 24 Sept. 2011.

155 Ibid.

156 Anthony McIntyre, thepensivequill.am blog (11 July 2011).

157 Bowyer Bell, J., The secret army: the IRA. (Dublin, 1989), p. 376.Google Scholar

158 O’Connor, , In search, p. 124.Google Scholar

159 Irish Times, 1 Apr.1993.

160 Sweeney, Eamonn, Down down deeper and down: Ireland in the 70s & 80s (Dublin, 2010), p. 182.Google Scholar

161 Irish Times, 14 July 1972.

162 Irish Independent, 29 Mar. 1991.