Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-t5pn6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T03:43:27.679Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Crafting and Promoting International Crimes: A Controversy among Professionals of Core-Crimes and Anti-Corruption

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 February 2017

MIKKEL JARLE CHRISTENSEN
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The emergence of new international criminal courts in the 1990s intensified an existing professional contest to define international crimes. This ongoing competition concerned which crimes should be termed international and consequently become the subject of international institution-building and prosecution. The article draws upon Pierre Bourdieu's analytical tool of the ‘field’ in order to investigate how legal professionals located in different fields of practice have crafted and promoted specific crimes as international, in successive phases. The focus of the analysis is on two stages of this development. The first is the protracted emergence of a field of ‘core crimes’ centred on a specific set of crimes: genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes. The second is an emergent contestation of this focus on ‘core crimes’ embedded in the careers of legal professionals engaged in the field of anti-corruption. By adapting the impactful narratives developed around core crimes, this second phase of contestation becomes a new frontline in the wider endeavour to define the role of criminal law in a larger international space of governance and politics.

Keywords

anti-corruptioninternational crimeinternational criminal courtsinternational criminal lawsociology of law
Type
INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURTS AND TRIBUNALS
Information
Leiden Journal of International Law , Volume 30 , Issue 2 , June 2017 , pp. 501 - 521
Copyright
Copyright © Foundation of the Leiden Journal of International Law 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 P. Bourdieu, Raisons pratiques: sur la théorie de l'action (1994) 152–3.

2 Naim, M., ‘The Corruption Eruption’, (1997) 2 (4) Trends in Organized Crime 60, at 60CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Sampson, S., ‘The Anti-Corruption Industry: From Movement to Institution’, (2010) 11 (2) Global Crime 261, at 263CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 L. de Sousa, P. Larmour and B. Hindess, Governments, NGOs and Anti-Corruption: The New Integrity Warriors (2009); See Sampson, supra note 3, at 261.

5 C. Rose, International Anti-Corruption Norms. Their Creation and Influence on Domestic Legal Systems (2015).

6 M. Nuijten and G. Anders, Corruption and the Secret of Law: A Legal Anthropological Perspective (2007); P. Lascoumes, Une démocratie corruptible: arrangements, favoritisme et conflits d'intérêts (2011) 100; and P. Lascoumes and C. Nagels, Sociologie des élites délinquantes - De la criminalité en col blanc à la corruption politique (2014).

7 Lascoumes, P., ‘Change and Resistance in the Fight Against Corruption in France’, (2001) 19 (1) French politics, culture, and society 49 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 P. Hazan, Justice in a Time of War: The True Story Behind the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (2004); S. Roach, Governance, order, and the International Criminal Court, between realpolitik and a cosmopolitan court (2009); and D. Bosco, Rough Justice: The International Criminal Court in a World of Power Politics (2014).

9 V. Peskin, International Justice in Rwanda and the Balkans: Virtual Trials and the Struggle for State Cooperation (2008) xxi.

10 J. Hagan, Justice in the Balkans: Prosecuting War Crimes in the Hague Tribunal (2003); Hagan, J. and Levi, R., ‘Social Skill, the Milosevic Indictment, and the Rebirth of International Criminal Justice’, (2004) 1 (4) European Journal of Criminology 445 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Hagan, J., Levi, R., and Ferrales, G., ‘Swaying the Hand of Justice: The Internal and External Dynamics of Regime Change at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia’, (2006) 31 (3) Law & Social Inquiry 585 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Christensen, M.J., ‘The Emerging Sociology of International Criminal Courts: Between Global Restructurings and Scientific Innovations’, (2015) 63 (6) Current Sociology 825 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Hagan, J. and Levi, R., ‘Crimes of War and the Force of Law’, (2005) 83 Social Forces 1499 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Dixon, P. and Tenove, C., ‘International Criminal Justice as a Transnational Field: Rules, Authority and Victims’, (2013) 7 International Journal of Transitional Justice 393 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Meierhenrich, J., ‘Foreword to Special Edition: The Practices of the International Criminal Court’, (2013) 76 Law and Contemporary Problems i-xGoogle Scholar; and Meierhenrich, J., ‘The Practice of International Law: A Theoretical Analysis’, (2013) 76 Law and Contemporary Problems 1 Google Scholar.

14 M. Goodale, The Practice of Human Rights: Tracking Law Between the Global and the Local (2007); K.M. Clarke, Fictions of Justice: the International Criminal Court and the Challenges of Legal Pluralism in sub-Saharan Africa (2009), xxv; A. Hinton, Transitional Justice, Global Mechanisms and Local Realities after Genocide and Mass Violence (2010); Anders, G., ‘Contesting Expertise: Anthropologists at the Special Court for Sierra Leone’, (2014) 20 Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 426 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Eltringham, N., ‘“When We Walk Out, What Was it all About?”: Views on New Beginnings from within the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda’, (2014) 45 Development and Change 543 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Campbell, K., ‘Reassembling International Justice: The Making of “the Social” in International Criminal Law and Transitional Justice’, (2014) 8 International Journal of Transitional Justice 53 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16 P. Bourdieu, Sur l’État: Cours au Collège de France 1989–1992 (2012).

17 Bourdieu, supra note 1, at 116–31.

18 P. Bourdieu, ‘La force du droit’, (1986) 64(1) Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales 3.

19 Y. Dezalay and B.G. Garth, The Internationalization of Palace Wars: Lawyers, Economists, and the Contest to Transform Latin American States (2002), 9–11.

20 Bourdieu, supra note 1, at 45–6.

21 M. Lewis, The Birth of the New Justice: The Internationalization of Crime and Punishment, 1919–1950 (2014), at 122–49.

22 M. Travers, Le Droit Pénal International et sa Mise en Oeuvre, en Temps de Paix et en Temps de Guerre (1920); H.D. de Vabres, Introduction à l’Étude du Droit pénal International;Essai d'Historie et de Critique sur la Compétence Criminelle dans les Rapports avec l’Étranger (1922); V. Pella, La Criminalité Collective des États et le Droit Pénal de l'Avenir (1926); and E.S. Rappaport, The Problem of the Inter-State Criminal Law, Transactions from the Grotius Society (1932), 41–64.

23 Commission on the Responsibilities of the Authors of the War and on Enforcement of Penalties, ‘Report Presented to the Preliminary Peace Conference’, (1920) 14(1/2) American Journal of International Law 95, at 95–8.

24 League of Nations, Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Terrorism, CE 1937, available at www.wdl.org/en/item/11579/#q=Convention+on+the+Prevention+and+Punishment+of+Terrorism&qla=en (accessed 6 April 2016).

25 1945 Charter of the International Military Tribunal, The Charter and Judgment of the Nürnberg Tribunal - History and Analysis: Memorandum Submitted by the Secretary-General (Appendix II), UN Doc. A/CN.4/5 (1949).

26 Control Council Law No. 10, Punishment of Persons Guilty of War Crimes, Crimes Against Peace and Against Humanity, 20 December 1945.

27 1946 International Military Tribunal for the Far East Charter, IMTFE (1946).

28 Documents of the Second Session, YILC 1950, Vol. II, paras. 95–127.

29 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, 78 UNTS 277.

30 See Art. 6 of the Charter of the International Military Tribunal, supra note 25; Art. 2(1) of Control Council Law No. 10, supra note 26; Art. 5 of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East Charter, supra note 27; and the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, UN Doc. A/RES/3/260 (1948).

31 Lewis, supra note 21.

32 This was the case for Ricardo Alfaro (Panama) serving in the ICJ from 1959–64 and Sir Hersch Lauterpacht (UK) who served in the ICJ from 1955–60. Other examples include Roberto Cordoba (Mexico), the ICJ judge from 1955–64; Feodor I. Kozhevnikov (USSR), the ICJ judge from 1953–61 – with Sergei Krylov moving the other way from the ICJ to the ILC; Benegal Narsing Rau (India), the ICJ judge from 1952–53; Sir Gerald Fitzmaurice (UK), the ICJ judge from 1960–73; and Jean Spiropoulus (Greece), the ICJ judge from 1958–67.

33 UN Doc. A/RES/260 B (III) A-C, (1948).

34 R.J. Alfaro, Report on Question of International Criminal Jurisdiction, UN Doc. A/CN.4/15 (1950).

35 Summary Records of the Second Session, YILC 1950, Vol. I, at 1–2.

36 Ibid., at 157.

37 Documents of the Second Session, YILC 1950, Vol. II, at 379.

38 Sandström, E., ‘FN's Lagkommission Och Folkerättskodifikationen’, (1963) 33 Nordic Journal of International Law 1 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, note 33, at 21.

39 International Criminal Jurisdiction, UN Doc. A/RES/489 (V), 12 December 1950.

40 International Criminal Jurisdiction, UN Doc. A/RES/898 (IX) 14 December 1954. For an overview, see Schabas, W., ‘International Criminal Courts’, in Romano, C., Alter, K.J., and Shany, Y. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of International Adjudication (2014), 205 Google Scholar.

41 M.C. Bassiouni and V.P. Nanda, A Treatise on International Criminal Law (1973); and T.A. Eser, Principles and Procedures for a New Transnational Criminal Law (1992).

42 Bassiouni, M. and Vetere, E., ‘Towards Understanding Organized Crime and its Transnational Manifestations’, in Bassiouni, M.C. (ed.) International Criminal Law (1998), 883 Google Scholar.

43 K.J. Alter, The New Terrain of International Law: Courts, Politics, Rights (2014), xxvi, 142–60.

44 J. Hagan, Justice in the Balkans, supra note 10; and Christensen, M.J., ‘From Symbolic Surge to Closing Courts: The Transformation of International Criminal Justice and its Professional Practices’, (2015) 34 International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 609 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 Interview with UN civil servant, 12 November 2014.

46 M. Glasius, The International Criminal Court: A Global Civil Society Achievement (2006), at 9–11.

47 UN Doc. A/RES/44/39 (1989).

48 M. Gorbachev, Realities and Guarantees for a Secure World (1987), 10. The proposal was repeated in Gorbachev's speech at the UN General Assembly Meeting on 7 December 1988.

49 Interview with academic C, 24 November 2014.

50 Hazan, supra note 8, at 37.

51 UNSC Meeting Records, S/PV.3217, 25 May 1993, at 6.

52 Report of the International Law Commission on the work of its forty-fifth session (3 May – 23 July 1993), 1993 YILC, Vol. II (Part Two), at 110–11.

53 ILC Draft Statute for an International Criminal Court (with Commentaries), 1994 YILC, Vol. II (Part Two), at 38–41.

54 Ibid., para. 15, at 40.

55 Ibid., para. 20, at 41.

56 UN Doc. A/RES/50/46 (1995).

57 UN Diplomatic Conference of Plenipotentiaries on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, Report of the Preparatory Committee on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, UN Doc. A/CONF.183/2/Add.1 (1998), at 27.

58 UN Diplomatic Conference of Plenipotentiaries on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, Rome 15 June – 17 July 1998, UN Doc. A/CONF.183/13, Vol. II (1998), at 66 (Trinidad and Tobago), at 77 (Costa Rica), at 107 (Thailand), at 116 (Haiti), at 123 (Sri Lanka). See also Summary Records of the Meetings of the Committee of the Whole, at 171–9. Note also that there was a certain discord between CARICOM members, Jamaica remaining unconvinced but open to later inclusion of treaty crimes, ibid., at 284.

59 Ibid., Summary Records of the Meetings of the Committee of the Whole, at 172.

60 UN Diplomatic Conference of Plenipotentiaries on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, Rome 15 June – 17 July 1998, UN Doc. A/CONF.183/13 Vol. I (1998), at 71–2.

61 Washburn, J., ‘The Negotiation of the Rome Statute for the International Criminal Court and International Lawmaking in the 21st Century’, (1999) 11 (2) Pace International Law Review 361 Google Scholar.

62 Interview with academic B, 4 June 2015.

63 Interview with academic A, 3 May 2016.

64 Ibid.

65 N. Boister, An Introduction to Transnational Criminal Law (2012).

66 Drumbl, M.A., ‘Waging War Against the World: The Need to Move from War Crimes to Environmental Crimes’, (1998) 22 (1) Fordham International Law Journal 122 Google Scholar; Mégret, F., ‘The Problem of an International Criminal Law of the Environment’, (2011) 36 (2) Columbia Journal of Environmental Law 195 Google Scholar; and S. Freeland, Addressing the Intentional Destruction of the Environment during Warfare under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (2015).

67 Interview with professional A in international NGO, 10 December 2013; interview with professional in international NGO B, 12 December 2013; and interview with professional in international NGO C, 4 September 2014.

68 Glasius, supra note 46.

69 Human Rights Watch and the Arms Project, Colombia's Killer Networks: The Military-Paramilitary Partnership and the United States (1996), at 69; Amnesty International, ‘Burundi: Struggle for Survival. Immediate Action Vital to Stop Killings’ (1995), available at www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6a9e1c.html (accessed 13 April 2016).

70 Preparatory Committee on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, List of Non-Governmental Organisations having expressed an interest in attending the Rome Conference, UN Doc. A/AC.249/1998/CRP.22.

71 Interview with academic D, 7 June 2013; and interview with academic E, 10 November 2014.

72 Rose, supra note 5, at 1.

73 Gutterman, E., ‘The Legitimacy of Transnational NGOs: Lessons from the Experience of Transparency International in Germany and France’, (2014) 40 (2) Review of International Studies 391 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

74 Interview with professional in international NGO D, 9 December 2013.

75 Interview with professional in international criminal court A, 28 October 2013; and interview with professional in international criminal court B, 10 June 2014.

76 C. Brummer, Soft Law and the Global Financial System, Rule Making in the 21st Century (2011); and Rose, supra note 5, at 13–58.

77 UN Doc. A/RES/58/4 (2003).

78 Art. 43(1) UNCAC: ‘Where appropriate and consistent with their domestic legal system, State Parties shall consider assisting each other in investigations of and proceedings in civil and administrative matters relating to corruption.’

79 Art. 36 UNCAC.

80 1999 Civil Law Convention on Corruption, CETS 174; and 1999 Criminal Law Convention on Corruption, CETS 173.

81 See Sousa, Larmour and Hindess, supra note 4, at 209–14.

82 Interview with anti-corruption professional A, 13 June 2014.

83 L. Gray et al., Few and Far: The Hard Facts on Stolen Asset Recovery (2014), 15–16.

84 B. Bertossa, et al., ‘Appel de Genève’ (1996).

85 ‘Spain's judge Baltasar Garzón convicted for wiretapping’, BBC News, available at www.bbc.com/news/world-16965790 (accessed 16 May 2016).

86 ‘Purposes and Objectives’, FIBGAR, available at en.fibgar.org/fundacion (accessed 23 January 2017).

87 Bantekas, I., ‘Corruption as an International Crime and Crime against Humanity: An Outline of Supplementary Criminal Justice Policies’, (2006) 4 Journal of International Criminal Justice 466 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Starr, S., ‘Extraordinary Crimes at Ordinary Times: International Justice Beyond Crisis Situations’, (2007) 101 Northwestern University Law Review 1257 Google Scholar; Rose, C., ‘Boersma M., Corruption: A Violation of Human Rights and a Crime under International Law?’, (2014) 61 (3) Netherlands International Law Review 455 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and E. Schmid, Taking Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Seriously in International Criminal Law (2015).

88 M.L. Wolf, ‘The Case for an International Anti-Corruption Court’, Governance Studies at Brookings (2014), available at www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/AntiCorruptionCourtWolfFinal.pdf (accessed 23 January 2017).

89 Interview with anti-corruption professional B, 10 February 2016.

90 Wouters, J. et al., ‘International Legal Framework against Corruption: Achievements and Challenges’, (2013) 14 (1) Melbourne Journal of International Law 205 Google Scholar.

91 Peterson, J., ‘Playing the Transparency Game: Consultation and Policy‐Making in the European Commission’, (1995) 73 (3) Public Administration 473 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

92 Interview with anti-corruption professional A, 29 November 2013.

93 Interview with anti-corruption professional D, 13 June 2014.

94 E. Joly, Justice Under Siege: One Woman's Battle against a European Oil Company (2006), 178.

95 Ligeti, K. and Simonato, M., ‘The European Public Prosecutor's Office: Towards a Truly European Prosecution Service?’, (2013) 4 New Journal of European Criminal Law 7 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

96 E. Joly et al., ‘Déclaration de Paris’ presented at La Sorbonne, 19 June 2003.

97 Interview with anti-corruption professional G, 3 June 2015.

98 Interview with anti-corruption professional E, 12 June 2014.

99 Interview with anti-corruption professional E, 12 June 2014; and interview with anti-corruption professional F, 13 May 2015.

100 Interview with anti-corruption professional A, 29 November 2013; and interview with anti-corruption professional B, 10 February 2016.

101 Abbott, A., ‘Linked Ecologies: States and Universities as Environments for Professions’, (2005) 23 Sociological Theory 245 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

102 Christensen, supra note 44, at 609.