We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 June 2020
This paper draws on material from the dissertation books of the University of Edinburgh's student societies and surviving lecture notes from the university's professors to shed new light on the debates on human variation, heredity and the origin of races between 1790 and 1835. That Edinburgh was the most important centre of medical education in the English-speaking world in this period makes this a particularly significant context. By around 1800 the fixed natural order of the eighteenth century was giving way to a more fluid conception of species and varieties. The dissolution of the ‘Great Chain of Being’ made interpretations of races as adaptive responses to local climates plausible. The evidence presented shows that human variation, inheritance and adaptation were being widely discussed in Edinburgh in the student circles around Charles Darwin when he was a medical student in Edinburgh in the 1820s. It is therefore no surprise to find these same themes recurring in similar form in the evolutionary speculations in his notebooks on the transmutation of species written in the late 1830s during the gestation of his theory of evolution.
I would like to thank John Henry, Sarah Frank, Aileen Fyfe, Clare Button and Catherine Laing for taking the time to read and comment on a draft version of this paper. Thanks are also due to the BJHS's two reviewers for their extremely helpful and constructive comments and suggestions for improvements. Any remaining faults are, of course, my responsibility alone.
1 Desmond, Adrian and Moore, James, Darwin's Sacred Cause: Race, Slavery and the Quest for Human Origins, London: Penguin, 2009, p. xviGoogle Scholar, original emphasis.
2 Desmond and Moore, op. cit. (1), p. 27.
3 Hudson, Nicholas, to, ‘From “nation” “race”: the origin of racial classification in eighteenth-century thought’, Eighteenth-Century Studies (1996) 29, 247–264CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
4 Hoquet, Thierry, ‘Biologization of race and racialization of the human’, in Bancel, Nicolas, David, Thomas and Thomas, Dominic (eds.), The Invention of Race: Scientific and Popular Representations, New York: Routledge, 2014, pp. 17–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 17.
5 Harrison, Mark, Climates and Constitutions: Health, Race, Environment and British Imperialism in India 1600–1850, New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1999, pp. 11–18Google Scholar.
6 Malik, Kenan, The Meaning of Race: Race, History and Culture in Western Society, Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1996, pp. 7–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Rupke, Nicolaas, ‘Scientific racism and Huxley's rule’, in Rupke, Nicolaas and Lauer, Gerhard (eds.), Johann Friedrich Blumenbach: Race and Natural History, 1750–1850, London: Routledge, 2019, pp. 233–247Google Scholar, 235.
8 Stepan, Nancy, The Idea of Race in Science: Great Britain, 1800–1960, London: Macmillan, 1982, p. xvCrossRefGoogle Scholar.
9 Sebastiani, Silvia, The Scottish Enlightenment: Race, Gender, and the Limits of Progress, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10 The last of these, the author of the ‘Inaugural disputation on the varieties of man’, should not be confused with his namesake, John Hunter the famous London surgeon who was born in 1728.
11 Brantlinger, Patrick, Dark Vanishings: Discourse on the Extinction of Primitive Races, 1800–1930, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2003, p. 13Google Scholar.
12 See, for example, Secord, James A., ‘Edinburgh Lamarckians: Robert Jameson and Robert E. Grant’, Journal of the History of Biology (1991) 24, pp. 1–18Google Scholar; Desmond, Adrian, The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine and Reform in Radical London, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1989Google Scholar; Hodge, Jonathan, ‘On Darwin's science and its contexts’, Endeavour (2014) 38, pp. 169–178CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; and Corsi, Pietro, Lamarck, ‘Jean-Baptiste, “from myth to History”’, in Gissis, Snait B. and Jablonka, Eva (eds.), Transformations of Lamarckism: From Subtle Fluids to Molecular Biology, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2011, pp. 9–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 Stepan, op. cit. (8), p. xiii.
14 Ludmilla Jordanova, ‘Earth science and environmental medicine: the synthesis of the late Enlightenment’, in Ludmilla Jordanova and Roy Porter (eds.), Images of the Earth: Essays in the History of Environmental Science, Chalfont St Giles: British Society for the History of Science, 1997, pp. 119–146, 130.
15 Hoquet, op. cit. (4), p. 21.
16 The classic work on the subject is Lovejoy, Arthur O., The Great Chain of Being, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1964Google Scholar. See also Bynum, William F.'s important paper ‘The great chain of being after forty years: an appraisal’, History of Science (1975) 13, pp. 1–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 John Walker, lectures on natural history, taken down by David Pollock (1797), 10 vols., Edinburgh University Library, Gen.703-12D, vol. 3, f. 135.
18 John Walker, notes on Professor J. Walker's lectures on natural history (1791), Edinburgh University Library, Dc.10.33, f. 45.
19 John Walker, lectures on natural history (1790), 6 vols., Edinburgh University Library, Dc.2.25-28, vol. 4, f. 164.
20 Walker, op. cit. (19), vol. 4, f. 166.
21 Walker, op. cit. (17), vol. 9, ff. 135–136.
22 Smellie, William, The Philosophy of Nature, 2 vols., Edinburgh: Heirs of Charles Elliot, 1790, vol. 1, p. 306Google Scholar.
23 George Leclerc, Comte de Buffon, Histoire naturelle, generale et particuliere, avec la descriptions du Cabinet du roy, Paris: Imprimerie Royale, 1755, vol. 5, p. 194.
24 Alexander Monro Secundus, Professor Monro's lectures (1786), Edinburgh University Library, Dc.10.13, f. 19.
25 Buffon, op. cit. (23), vol. 1, p. 38.
26 Joseph Reade, ‘What are principally the Causes of Variety in the Human Species (Read 24 October 1800)’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1800), 43, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, pp. 99–114, p. 110.
27 Plinian Natural History Society, minutes of the Plinian Society, 1826–1841, 2 vols., Centre for Research Collections, Edinburgh University Library, Dc.2.53, vol. 1, p. 81. Browne went on to be a pioneering superintendent of Montrose Lunatic Asylum; see Scull, Andrew, The Asylum as Utopia: W.A.F. Browne and the Mid-Nineteenth Century Consolidation of Psychiatry, London: Routledge, 1991Google Scholar.
28 Gray, James, History of the Royal Medical Society, 1737–1937, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1952, p. 73Google Scholar.
29 Nicholas C. Pitta, ‘What is the influence of climate on the human species? And what are the varieties of men which result from it?’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1811–1812), 66, pp. 283–307, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh); and Pitta, ‘What is the influence of the climate on the human species and what are the varieties of man that result from it?’, Royal Physical Society dissertations (c.1812), 31, pp. 190–210, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys.
30 Pitta, Nicholas C., Influence of Climate on the Human Species; and on the Varieties of Men Resulting from It, London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme and Brown, 1812Google Scholar.
31 John Taylor, ‘Are all men originally descended from the same stock?’, Royal Physical Society dissertations (1804–1806), 24, pp. 464–71, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys, p. 471.
32 See Kidd, Colin, The Forging of Races: Race and Scripture in the Protestant Atlantic World, 1600–2000, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Livingstone, David N., Adam's Ancestors: Race, Religion and the Politics of Human Origins, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008Google Scholar.
33 William Webb, ‘Are the diversities among mankind the effect of physical & moral causes?’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1794–1795), 32, pp. 134–167, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, p. 167.
34 E. Holme, ‘To the operation of what causes are we to ascribe the variety of complexion in the human species?’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1792–1794), 29, pp. 366–381, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, p. 368, underlining original.
35 Hudson, op. cit. (3), p. 253.
36 Buffon, op. cit. (23), vol. 3 (1749), p. 530.
37 Buffon, op. cit. (23), vol. 3 (1749), p. 483.
38 Smith, Samuel Stanhope, An Essay on the Causes of the Variety of Complexion and Figure in the Human Species, Edinburgh: C. Elliot, 1788, p. 72Google Scholar.
39 Hunter, John, ‘Inaugural disputation on the varieties of man’ (1775), in Anthropological Treatises of Johann Friedrich Blumenbach and the Inaugural Dissertation of John Hunter, M.D. on the Varieties of Man (tr. Bendshye, Thomas), London, 1865, p. 386Google Scholar.
40 This is what Mark Harrison has described as a ‘weak transmutationist argument’, with the inheritance of acquired characteristics leading to adaptive change within strict limits. See Harrison, op. cit. (5), p. 104.
41 For a useful discussion of the concept of degeneration in European discourses on race see Claude-Olivier Doron, ‘Races et dégénérescence: L’émergence des savoirs sur l'homme anormal’, PhD thesis, Histoire, philosophie et sociologie des sciences, Université Paris-Diderot – Paris VII, 2011 <TEL-00876157>, pp. 137–211.
42 Buffon, op. cit. (23), vol. 14 (1766), p. 311.
43 Blumenbach, Johann Friedrich, ‘On the natural variety of mankind’, 3rd edn (1795), in The Anthropological Treatises of Johann Friedrich Blumenbach and the Inaugural Dissertation of John Hunter, M.D. on the Varieties of Man (tr. Bendshye, Thomas), London: Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts & Green, 1865, p. 264Google Scholar.
44 Blumenbach, op. cit. (43), p. 188.
45 Thomas Junker, ‘Blumenbach's theory of human races and the natural unity of humankind’, in Rupke and Lauer, op. cit. (7), pp. 96–112, 104.
46 For a more detailed discussion of Camper's views see Meijer, Miriam Claude, Race and Aesthetics in the Anthropology of Petrus Camper (1722–1789), Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1999Google Scholar; and the twelve essays in van Berkel, Klaas and Ramakers, Bart (eds.), Petrus Camper in Context: Science, the Arts and Society in the Eighteenth-Century Dutch Republic, Hilversum: Verloren, 2015Google Scholar.
47 John Bradley, ‘Whence the varieties of the human species?’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1791–1792), 27, pp. 95–105, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, p. 98.
48 W.F. Neville, ‘What are the principle causes of the diversity of Colour in the human species?’, Royal Physical Society dissertations, no date, 29, pp. 118–29, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys, p. 471.
49 J.C. Prichard, ‘Of the varieties of the human race’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1807–1808), 58, pp. 87–133, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, p. 133.
50 Holme, op. cit. (34), p. 379.
51 John Fitzgerald, ‘To what causes are we to attribute the difference of colour in the human race?’, Royal Physical Society dissertations (1798–1800), 19, pp. 4–13, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys, p. 9.
52 Webb, op. cit. (33), p. 136.
53 [William] Scully, ‘Question on the causes of variety among mankind’, Royal Physical Society dissertations (1802–1804), 22, pp. 79–85, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys, p. 80.
54 Samuel Cramer, ‘What influence has climate on the human constitution?’, Royal Physical Society dissertations (1798–1800), 19, pp. 475–492, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys, p. 489.
55 Robert Jameson, notes on zoology lectures (notes taken by an anonymous student), 2 vols. (no date), Centre for Research Collection, Edinburgh University Library Dc.2.34, vol. 2, f.237.
56 Blumenbach's system of classification was also to strongly influence medical understandings of racial difference in the colonies; see, for example, Arnold, David, ‘Race, place and bodily difference in early nineteenth-century India’, Historical Research (2004) 77, pp. 254–273, 258CrossRefGoogle Scholar. The extent to which racial theory conditioned colonial attitudes is also explored in Kapila, Shruti, ‘Race matters: orientalism and religion, India and beyond, c.1770–1880’, Modern Asian Studies (2007) 41, pp. 471–513CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
57 Robert Jameson, notes on natural history lectures (1822–1823) (taken by George Gordon), Elgin Museum, L.1987.5.3 (28/5), f. 1.
58 Dugald Stewart, notes from a course of lectures on moral philosophy delivered by Dugald Stewart (taken by John Borthwick) (1806–1807), Centre for Research Collections, Edinburgh University Library, Gen.843, f. 367. For Camper's use of this example see Meijer, op. cit. (46), p. 82.
59 For an account of this period of Knox's life see Bates, A.W., The Anatomy of Robert Knox: Murder, Mad Science and Medical Regulation in Nineteenth-Century Edinburgh, Brighton: Sussex Academic Press, 2010, pp. 33–41Google Scholar.
60 Knox, Robert, ‘Inquiry into the origin and characteristic differences of the native races inhabiting the extra-tropical part of southern Africa’, Memoirs of the Wernerian Society (1824) 5, pp. 206–219Google Scholar.
61 Knox, op. cit. (60), p. 210.
62 Richards, Evelleen, ‘The “moral anatomy” of Robert Knox: the interplay between biological and social thought in Victorian scientific naturalism’, Journal of the History of Biology (1989) 22, pp. 373–436CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
63 John Bradley, ‘Whence the varieties of the human species?’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1791–1792), 27, pp. 95–105, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, p. 97.
64 Fitzgerald, op. cit. (51), p. 6.
65 Fitzgerald, op. cit. (51), p. 6.
66 John Taylor, ‘Are all men originally descended from the same stock?’, Royal Physical Society dissertations (1804–1806), 24, pp. 464–471, Edinburgh University Library, Da.67 Phys, p. 464.
67 Meijer, op. cit. (46), pp. 47–49.
68 Robert Jameson, student's notes of Jameson's lectures on natural history delivered in Edinburgh University, 1816–1817, Edinburgh University Library, Dc.10.32, f. 1.
69 Hunter, op. cit. (39), p. 362.
70 Smith, op. cit. (38), pp. 21–22.
71 James Hutton, unpublished treatise on agriculture, 2 vols., National Library of Scotland, MS.23165–6, vol. 2, f. vi.
72 Hutton, op. cit. (71), vol. 2, f. vii.
73 Prichard, James Cowles, Researches into the Physical History of Man, 2nd edn, 2 vols., London: John and Arthur Arch, 1826, vol. 2, pp. 574–5Google Scholar.
74 Prichard, op. cit. (73), vol. 2, p. 581–582.
75 Augstein, H.F., James Cowles Prichard's Anthropology: Remaking the Science of Man in Early Nineteenth Century Britain, Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1999, pp. 108–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
76 E.J. Scott, ‘What are the causes of the diversities of the human species?’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1833), 95, pp. 317–357, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, p. 357.
77 Scott, op. cit. (76), p. 357.
78 Henry H. Cheek, ‘On the varieties of the human race (Read 29 January 1830)’, dissertations of the Royal Medical Society (1829–1830), 91, pp. 286–307, Library of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, pp. 306–307.
79 Cheek, op. cit. (78), p. 306.
80 Cheek, op. cit. (78), p. 302, underlining original.
81 Ospovat, Dov, The Development of Darwin's Theory: Natural History, Natural Theology and Natural Selection 1838–1859, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981, pp. 70–73Google Scholar.
82 Sloan, Phillip R., ‘Darwin, vital matter, and the transformism of species’, Journal of the History of Biology (1986) 19, pp. 369–445, 372CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
83 Desmond and Moore, op. cit. (1), p. 112.
84 De Gregorio, Mario A. and Gill, N.W. (eds.), Charles Darwin's Marginalia, vol. 1, New York: Garland, 1990, p. 683Google Scholar.
85 Jenkins, Bill, ‘Henry H. Cheek and transformism: new light on Darwin's Edinburgh background’, Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science (2015) 69, pp. 155–171CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
86 Plinian Natural History Society, minutes of the Plinian Society, 2 vols., Edinburgh University Library, Dc.2.53, vol. 1.
87 Plinian Natural History Society, op. cit. (27), p. 57. Royal Medical Society, List of Members, the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, Edinburgh: Royal Medical Society, 1906, p. 44.
88 Darwin, Charles, ‘Recollections of the development of my mind and character’, in Darwin, Autobiographies, London: Penguin, 2002, pp. 6–28, 24Google Scholar.
