Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-42gr6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T11:25:36.230Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Problems in Kalahari Historical Ethnography and the Tolerance of Error

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 May 2014

Richard B. Lee  and
Mathias Guenther
Richard B. Lee
Affiliation:
University of Toronto
Mathias Guenther
Affiliation:
Wilfrid Laurier University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The !Kung San or Bushmen of Namibia and Botswana are one of the most thoroughly documented hunting and gathering societies in the annals of African anthropology. In recent years two radically different views of the !Kung San have emerged in the anthropological literature. One sees the !Kung as hunters and gatherers living under changed circumstances and maintaining an old but adaptable way of life: the characteristic features associated with the hunter-gatherer subsistence or foraging mode of production.

The other sees these same !Kung as products of a very different history, a history of long association with Bantu-speaking overlords, followed by intense involvement with merchant capital. In this view it was the !Kungs' experience of domination and incorporation, not the dynamics of autonomous foraging that shaped their economy and social life. Their well-documented egalitarian politics and gender relations are thus a product not of their own history, but of their history of shared poverty. The San are classless today precisely because they are the underclass in a more inclusive class structure (Wilmsen 1983:17).

Which view more accurately reflects the historical realities and experience of the !Kung? A body of opinion within contemporary anthropology holds that this “revisionist” view provides a much-needed corrective to the anthropological tendency to treat African societies ahistorically. Others have denied this charge and have countered that the history of Kalahari peoples showed great variation; while some may have formed an underclass at an early date, others persisted as relatively independent (but not isolated) hunter-gatherers into the modem period.

Type
Research Article
Information
History in Africa , Volume 20 , 1993 , pp. 185 - 235
Copyright
Copyright © African Studies Association 1993

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Andersson, C.J. 1856. Lake Ngami. London: Hurst and Blackett.Google Scholar
Andersson, C.J. 1861. The Okavango River: A Narrative of Travel, Exploration, and Adventure. New York: Harper and Brothers.Google Scholar
Andersson, C.J. 1875. Notes and Travels in South Africa. Ed. Lloyd, L.London: Hurst and Blackett.Google Scholar
Baines, T. 1864. Exploration in South-West Africa. London: Longmans.Google Scholar
Barnard, A. 1979. Kalahari Bushman Settlement Patterns. In Burnham, P. & Ellen, R. F., eds., Social and Ecological Systems. London: Academic Press, 131–44.Google Scholar
Barnard, A. 1992a. Hunters and Herders of Southern Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Barnard, A. 1992b. The Kalahari Debate: a Bibliographical Survey. Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Bleek, D. 1928. The Naron. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Brooks, A. 1991. Patterns in the Prehistory of the Dobe Area. Paper presented at Harvard Symposium opening Peabody Museum exhibit “The Bushman;” December 13, 1991.Google Scholar
Carstens, P. 1992. Review of Wilmsen 1989. Anthropologica, 34, forthcoming.Google Scholar
Chapman, J. 1971. [1868] Traveb in the Interior of South Africa, 1849-1863, 2 vols. Cape Town: A.A. Balkema.Google Scholar
Cliffe, L. 1982. Class Formation as an “Articulation” Process: East African Cases. In Alavi, H. and Shanin, T., eds., Introduction to the Sociology of Developing Countries. New York: Monthly Review Press.Google Scholar
Crone, G.R. 1962. Maps and Their Makers. 2d ed. New York: Hutchinson's University Library.Google Scholar
Davies, J. H. n.d. Descriptive List of the Andersson Papers. Windhoek: State Archives.Google Scholar
De Klerk, W. 1988. [1977] The Thirstland. Manzini/Durban: Bok Books.Google Scholar
De Kock, W.J. 1948. Robert Lewis of Damaraland. Africana Notes and News, 6(1):14–15.Google Scholar
Dickens, Patrick n.d. Why Anthropologists Need Linguists: The Case of the !Kung. Windhoek: Nyae Nyae Development Foundation of Namibia, Ms.Google Scholar
Dictionary of South African Biography 1967–1987. Entries for C. J. Andersson I,14), G. D. duPlessis, A. Ericksson (II,220), F. Green (II,273), J. C. Greyling, C. H. Hahn (I, 341), W.W. Jordan (III, 453), S. Passarge (V.568), G. D. Prinsloo, H. Schinz (II,629), C. Thomas, H. Van Zyl (IV.720), C. Von Francois (I,853).Google Scholar
Draper, P. 1975. !Kung Women: Contrasts in Sexual Egalitarianism in Foraging and sedentary Contexts. In Reiter, R. P., ed., Toward an Anthropology of Women. New York: Monthly Review Press, 77–109.Google Scholar
Ebert, J. n.d. The Later-Stone Age of the Dobe area. Paper Presented at The Kalahari Debate Symposium at the American Anthropological Association Annual Meetings, Chicago, November 1989.Google Scholar
Esterhuyse, J. H. 1968. South West Africa, 1888-1894: The Establishment of German Authority in South West Africa. Struik: Cape Town.Google Scholar
Fisch, M. 1985. Ursprung und Bedeutung des Namens Okavango. Journal of the South-West Africa Science Society 40:7–28.Google Scholar
Galton, F. 1971. [1853] Narrative of an Explorer in Tropical South Africa. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
Gordon, R. 1984. The !Kung in the Kalahari Exchange: An Ethnohistorical Perspective. In Schrire, C., ed., Past and Present in Hunter-Gatherer Studies. 195–224.Google Scholar
Gordon, R. 1990. Kicking up a Kalahari Storm. Southern African Review of Books, February/May 1990:18–19.Google Scholar
Gough, K. 1971. Nuer Kinship: A Re-examination. In Beidelman, T., ed., The Translation of Culture. London: Tavistock, 79–102.Google Scholar
Guenther, M. 1986. The Nharo Bushmen of Botswana. Hamburg: Helmut Buske Verlag. (Quellen zur Khoisan-Forschung, 3)Google Scholar
Guenther, M. 1990. Comment on Wilmsen and Denbow 1990. Current Anthropology, 31:509–10.Google Scholar
Hahn, C. H. 1985. Carl Hugo Hahn Tagebücher 1837-1860 Diaries. Part IV 1856-1860. Ed. Lau, B.Windhoek: State Archives, (fircheia, 4).Google Scholar
Harpending, H. 1991. Review of Wilmsen 1989. Anthropos, 86:313–15.Google Scholar
Headland, T. 1990. Review of Wilmsen 1989. The Sciences, 30/5:45–50.Google Scholar
Katz, R. 1982. Boiling Energy: Community Healing among the !Kung. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Leacock, E. 1981. Myths of Male Dominance. New York: Monthly Review Press.Google Scholar
Leacock, E. and Lurie, N., eds., 1971. North American Indians in Historical Perspective. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Lee, R. 1965. Subsistence Ecology of !Kung Bushmen. PhD., University of California—Berkeley.Google Scholar
Lee, R. 1979. The !Kung San: Men, Women, and Work in a Foraging Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Lee, R. 1990. Comment on Wilmsen and Denbow 1990. Current Anthropology, 31:510–12.Google Scholar
Lee, R. n.d. Solitude or Servitude?: !Kung Perceptions of the Colonial Encounter. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Anthropology Association, University of Western Ontario, May 1991.Google Scholar
Lee, R. in preparation. Solitude or Servitude: !Kung Images of the Colonial Encounter. Ms., University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Lee, R. and Biesele, M. in preparation. Dependency or Self-reliance: The Later History of the Ju/'hoansi. Ms. University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Lee, R. and De Vore, I., eds., 1976. Kalahari Hunter-Gatherers: Studies of the !Kung San and their Neighbors. Cambridge Mass., Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Lee, R. and De Vore, I., eds. and Guenther, M. 1991. Oxen or Onions? The Search for Trade (and Truth) in the Kalahari. Current Anthropology 32:592–601.Google Scholar
Livingstone, D. 1857. Missionary Travels and Researches in South Africa. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
Marshall, L. 1976. The !Kung of Nyae Nyae. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Mattenklodt, W. 1931. [1923] A Fugitive in South-West Africa 1908 to 1920. Trans. Williams, O.London: Thornton Butterworth Ltd.Google Scholar
McKiernan, G. 1954. The Narrative and Journal of Gerald McKiernan in South West Africa, 1874-1879. ed. Serton, P.Cape Town: Van Riebeeck Society.Google Scholar
Moritz, W. 1980. Entdeckungsreiseins Ovamboland 1857 Tagebuch von Carl Hugo Hahn. Aus alten Tagen in Südwest, 4.Google Scholar
Morton, F. n.d. Slave-Raiding and Slavery in the Western Transvaal After the Sand River Convention of 1852. Paper Presented at the 1991 Meeting of the Canadian Association of African Studies, York University, May 1991.Google Scholar
Palgrave, W. C. 1992. The Commissions of W. C. Palgrave Special Emissary to South West Africa 1876-1885. Ed. Stals, E. L. P.Cape Town: Van Riebeeck Society.Google Scholar
Passarge, S. 1904. Die Kalahari. Berlin: Dietrich Reimer.Google Scholar
Passarge, S. 1907. Die Buschmänner der Kalahari. Berlin: Dietrich Reimer.Google Scholar
Panoff, M. and Perrin, M. 1982. Taschenwörterbuch der Ethnologic Berlin: Dietrich Reimer.Google Scholar
Petermann, A. 1859. Reise der Herrn Hugo Hahn und Rath im südwestlichen Afrika. Dr. A. Petermanns Mittheilungen aus Justus Perthes' geographischer Anstalt. 7:299–302.Google Scholar
Petermann, A. 1867. Neueste deutsche Forschungen in Süd-Afrika: Von Karl Mauch, Hugo Hahn und Richard Brenner, 1866 und 1867. Dr. A. Petermanns Mittheilungen aus Justus Perthes' geographischer Anstalt 8:281–98.Google Scholar
Petermann, A. 1878. Herero-Land, Land und Leute. Dr. A. Petermanns Mittheilungen aus Justus Perthes' geographischer Anstalt 8:306–11.Google Scholar
Peters, M. 1972. Notes on the Place Names of Ngamiland. Botswana Notes and Records 4:219–33.Google Scholar
Peters, P. 1990. Review of Wilmsen 1989. Science, 248:905–07.Google Scholar
Postma, D. 1897. Eenige Schelsen voor eene Geschiedenis van de Trekboeren. Amsterdam, Höveker and Wormser.Google Scholar
Preller, G. 1941. Voortrekkers van Suidwes. Cape Town: Nasionale Pers Beperk.Google Scholar
Prinsloo, J. and Gauche, J. 1933. In die Woeste Weste: Die Lydengeskiedenis van die Dorslandtrekkers. Pretoria: J.H. de Bussy.Google Scholar
Raisz, E. 1962. Principles of Cartography. New York: McGraw Hill.Google Scholar
Schapera, I. 1930. The Khoi-San Peoples: Bushmen and Hottentots. London: George Routledge and Sons.Google Scholar
Schinz, H. 1891. Deutsch-Südwest Afrika: Forschungreisen durch die deutschen Schutzgebiete, Gross-Nama-und Hereroland, nach dem Kunene, dem Ngami-See und der Kalahari, 1884-1887. Oldenberg: Schulzescher Hof.Google Scholar
Shipton, P. 1991. Review of Wilmsen 1989. American Anthropologist 93:756.Google Scholar
Shostak, M. 1981. Nisa: The Life and Words of a !Kung Woman. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Silberbauer, G. 1991. Morbid Reflexivity and Overgeneralization in Masarwa Studies. Current Anthropology 32: 96–99.Google Scholar
Solway, J. and Lee, R. 1990. Foragers Genuine or Spurious? Situating the Kalahari San in History. Current Anthropology 31:109–46.Google Scholar
Szalay, M. 1979. Die ethnographische Südwestafrika-Sammlung Hans Schinz 1884-86. Special issue of Ethnologische Zeitschrift Zürich, 1.Google Scholar
Tabler, E. 1973. Pioneers of South West Africa and Ngamiland: 1738-1880. Cape Town: A.A. Balkema.Google Scholar
Tlou, T. 1985. A History of Ngamiland, 1750-1906. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Trigger, B. 1976. The Children of Aataentsic: A History of the Huron People to 1600. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press.Google Scholar
Vedder, H. 1938. South-West Africa in Early Times. London: Cass.Google Scholar
Wallis, J.P.R. 1936. Fortune My Foe: The Story of Charles John Andersson. London: Jonathan Cape.Google Scholar
Wellington, J. 1955. Southern Africa: A Geographical Study. Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand Press.Google Scholar
Wessely, E., ed., 1883. Thieme-Preusser: A New and Complete Critical Dictionary of the English and German Languages. 2d ed., Hamburg: Haendcke and Lemkuhl.Google Scholar
Williams, F. 1991. Precolonial Communities of Southwestern Africa. A History of Owambo Kingdoms, 1600-1920. Windhoek: State Archives (Archeia, 16).Google Scholar
Wilmsen, E. 1983. The Ecology of Illusion: Anthropological Foraging in the Kalahari. Reviews in Anthropology 10:9–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilmsen, E. 1982. Exchange, Interaction, and Settlement in North-western Botswana: Past and Present Perspectives. In Hitchcock, R. and Smith, M., eds., Settlement in Botswana. Marshalltown: Heinemann, 98–109.Google Scholar
Wilmsen, E. 1989. Land Filled with Flies: A Political Economy of the Kalahari. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Wilmsen, E. 1992. A Myth and Its Measure. Current Anthropology 33:611–14.Google Scholar
Wilmsen, E. and Denbow, J. 1990. Paradigmatic History of San-Speaking Peoples and Current Attempts at Revision. Current Anthropology 31:489–524.Google Scholar
Winquist, A. H. 1978. Scandinavians in South Africa. Cape Town: A.A. Balkema.Google Scholar
Worsley, P. 1952. The Kinship System of the Tallensi: A Re-evaluation. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 86:#7–77.Google Scholar
Yellen, J. 1977. Archaeological Approaches to the Present: Models for Reconstructing the Past. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Yellen, J. 1990. Comment on Wilmsen and Denbow 1990. Current Anthropology 31: 516–17.Google Scholar
Yellen, J. and Brooks, A. 1990. The Late Stone Age Archaeology in the /Xai/Xai Region: A Response to Wilmsen. Botswana Notes and Records, 22:17–19.Google Scholar