To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Edited by
Baidik Bhattacharya, Centre for the Study of Developing Societies, India,Prathama Banerjee, Centre for the Study of Developing Societies, India
This chapter concerns itself primarily with the idea of India as it emerges in both global imagination as well as the imagination of prominent Indian intellectuals and academics through their engagement with religion in the late nineteenth to the first half of the twentieth century. The growth of the discipline of comparative religion, the establishment of the modern school and university system in India, the rise of anti-colonial nationalism, and related to all of these, the pressing question of the status and role of India, as a nation and a civilization, on a global platform form the context of this exploratory piece. I take as granted the principle that modern disciplines and their disciplinary frameworks and horizons—as we understand them— in their methodological and epistemic formulations evolve in a systematic fashion by the late nineteenth century, thereby making this period a critical one to examine. Given the central role played by Hinduism as a religious and cultural system in recent years in buttressing India's civilizational claims on a global scale, this chapter tries to unravel the interconnections and fissures between the academic study of religion, the pedagogy of religion, and the intellectual and cultural burden borne by religion in the making and remaking of the idea of India over the twentieth century.
In her landmark contribution to the study of nationalism, Manu Goswami pointedly notes that ‘[c]entral to the project of nationalism is making the nation appear natural’ (Goswami 2004: 1). By ‘natural’, she means a timeless, ahistorical, and yet deeply territorial understanding of the nation—a task that she notes was executed admirably by the nationalist elite of colonial India. Goswami's primary site of inquiry in producing this ‘natural’ nation is the nation's political economy.
Whether cluster mergers enhance ram pressure stripping (RPS) and accelerate the subsequent evolution of member galaxies remains an open question. In this paper, we address this question by investigating galaxy populations in the nearby merging cluster Abell 3667 (z ≃ 0.0553) using spatially resolved data from the Hector Galaxy Survey. We define an RPS sample by combining Hector-selected galaxies with ionised gas disturbances (e.g. asymmetric tails or truncated disks) and supplementary, optically identified jellyfish galaxies lacking Hector data. The majority of the RPS sample (∼${71}_{-10}^{+7}$%; 20/28) lies within R200, where the impact of the merger is greater. Most asymmetric galaxies (∼$73_{-14}^{+8}$%; 11/15), especially those with extreme RPS signatures, are concentrated towards the inner cluster regions (R ≲ 0.6 R200), distributed along the merger axis between two shock-tracing radio relics. These central asymmetric galaxies present two separate spatial and kinematic concentrations: a population located at the North-West (NW) subcluster and downstream of its radio relic, a region of high-velocity intracluster medium (ICM) bulk motion, with blueshifted line-of-sight velocities, and a primarily redshifted population close to the main cluster (MC), which also shows evidence of a turbulent ICM. Despite their projected spatial association with the MC core and the NW substructure, the velocities of both samples indicate they are not bound to these merging substructures. Tail orientations provide additional insight into their orbital histories: NW tails point away from the cluster centre and are frequently aligned with the merger axis, suggestive of merger-driven stripping, while MC tails show neither pattern clearly. The tails are also broadly westward-pointing, with the MC tails closely tracing due west and the NW tails shifted towards the northwest, pointing to two distinct filamentary accretion events for the NW and MC populations. Taken together, our results indicate enhanced RPS activity in the heart of A3667, primarily driven by infalling galaxies accreted along nearby filaments and interacting with the merger-driven turbulent environment.
Access to depression care can be improved by overcoming a combination of supply-side barriers and demand-side factors.
Aims
To describe the systematic development of a community-based intervention to improve uptake of, and adherence to, a psychosocial treatment for depression delivered by trained primary healthcare staff in Goa, India.
Method
This mixed-methods study included five steps: Step 1, Synthesis of existing evidence by conducting relevant systematic reviews and a review of public health programmes in India; Step 2, In-depth interviews with community stakeholders (n = 35); Step 3, Consultation workshops with community stakeholders (n = 19) and primary healthcare staff (n = 34); Step 4, Triangulation of findings from the preceding steps; and Step 5, Content development for the intervention (e-course for training and the community intervention toolkit for delivery).
Results
Overall, 20 strategies to enhance help-seeking and 5 strategies to improve adherence were identified to constitute the intervention. The community-based intervention is organised into four domains (Learn, Inform, Engage and Follow-up), with self-care integrated throughout the intervention. This intervention is designed to be delivered by a community volunteer who is motivated to cater to the communities’ needs. The community volunteer is trained to deliver the intervention via a blended approach, an e-course and in-person one-on-one learning support by a coach, who later acts as a facilitator during the intervention delivery phase.
Conclusions
The systematic method enabled the development of a comprehensive intervention with contextually appropriate delivery strategies. The effectiveness of the intervention is presently being tested as part of a Hybrid Type II Implementation-Effectiveness randomised controlled trial. If found effective, the intervention has the potential to be a low-cost and sustainable opportunity to improve demand and adherence to depression treatment while also providing essential social, emotional and logistical support during the recovery process.
This article employs normative democratic theory to examine a counterintuitive suggestion raised repeatedly by empirical scholars of clientelism: namely, that practices of particularistic exchange might sometimes serve democratic ends. Certainly, most particularistic practices are widely agreed to undermine democracy, on both intrinsic and instrumental grounds. Yet some observers resist blanket condemnation—and in particular, many highlight the redeeming democratic virtues of certain practices that seem to facilitate collective organization among disempowered groups. Drawing on “realist” approaches to democratic theory, we vindicate this basic insight while clarifying its scope conditions. Countervailing power is a crucial democratic priority, and programmatic methods of promoting it sometimes face serious obstacles: as when clientelist practices are deeply entrenched, or incumbents capture the tools of programmatic competition. Under such conditions, we conclude, democracy-seeking leaders may justifiably employ particularistic practices to promote countervailing power—but only if they respect five constraints tethering them strictly to that goal.
This study aimed to evaluate the performance of large language models in post-operative adjuvant treatment decision-making for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma compared with multidisciplinary team recommendations.
Methods
In this retrospective observational study, 30 surgically treated head and neck squamous cell carcinoma cases discussed at an institutional multidisciplinary team (January–June 2025) were independently assessed by ChatGPT 5.0, DeepSeek and Perplexity artificial intelligence using standardised pathological summaries. Each model generated a single adjuvant treatment recommendation with rationale. Multidisciplinary team decisions served as the reference standard. The primary endpoint was concordance; secondary endpoints included safety, reasoning quality, guideline adherence and treatment-intensity deviation.
Results
ChatGPT achieved the highest concordance with multidisciplinary team recommendations (87 per cent; κ = 0.71), the lowest TID (0.13), optimal safety (100 per cent) and the highest reasoning quality scores.
Conclusions
Large language models closely approximated multidisciplinary team recommendations in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. ChatGPT 5.0 demonstrated the most reliable, safe and guideline-concordant performance, supporting its potential role as an adjunct clinical decision-support tool.
Most studies on modern state formation assume that enhanced state capacity and institutionalization increase clarity and predictability. We argue that this view fails to consider ambiguity politics—a form of governance in which formal and informal institutions are inconsistent, unclear, or ill-defined, thereby creating space for multiple interpretations, practices, and procedures. Combining inductive insights from research in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan and deductive engagement with different strands of literature, we developed a typology that distinguishes mechanisms of ambiguity politics according to the level at which the ambiguation takes place (elite/administrative) and the intentionality of it (strategic/accidental). Although ambiguity politics is particularly visible in conflict and postconflict settings, we show that it is not inevitably a temporary stage toward greater order and predictability but rather a persistent feature of governance in various contexts.
A key book about rights, separation of powers and the State, which assesses a decade and a half of transformative constitutionalism in Kenya through the lens of landmark constitutional judgments, discussing their international import and suggesting new pathways towards democratic constitutionalism.
In 2010, after more than two decades of struggle, Kenya's new Constitution was born. Widely accepted to be "transformative" in nature, in the decade and a half since it was enacted, the Constitution has been at the centre of national discourse. And in that time, the country's courts have been confronted with crucial and high-stakes constitutional disputes, which are both distinctively Kenyan in nature, but also, are disputes that have long been common to constitutional democracies around the world: they include issues around constitutional change, federalism, imperial presidencies, the role of the legislature, election disputes, land rights, and horizontality, among others. Drawing comparisons with constitutional jurisdictions globally, which often rely upon precedent from each other's jurisdictions, this book examines transformative constitutionalism under the 2010 Constitution, and shows that while Kenyan courts have been informed by - and been in conversation with - global precedent, they have crafted unique and particular solutions.
The book excavates the engagement of Kenyan Courts with the 2010 Kenyan Constitution to highlight the unique and innovative contributions that Kenyan courts have made to global constitutional problems and to suggest pathways for the future. Showcasing the jurisprudence of the courts in action, this book discusses how and when the power to amend a constitution can be limited or constrained and how constitutional change can be insulated from political interference. It examines issues of parliamentarianism and devolution in the context of the national controversy around constituency development funds, and reveals how Kenya provides a model for understanding constitutional separation of powers. It looks at the process for challenging presidential elections, and details how the Supreme Court has aimed to set out clear legal and evidentiary standards for how a court ought to deal with a pure political dispute - something with which judiciaries around the world have struggled. It explores the evolution of socio-economic rights, including the right to housing, non-discrimination, and equality before the law, as well as the question of how transformative constitutionalism interrogates private power. Placing contemporary Kenyan constitutionalism at its heart, this work of comparative constitutional law asks what the ongoing, global constitutional conversation can learn from the Kenyan experience under its new order.
Silence was a mighty sound in its own right. If you paid attention, you could separate its warps and wefts.
It is a story as old as it is familiar. The tides of change compel the political elite to accept, whether grudgingly or enthusiastically, a constitution that places significant constraints upon their power. However, once the new settlement comes into force, they realise quickly that it is much more of an inconvenience than they had bargained for. The People – who were supposed to vanish after their ceremonial invocation in the Preamble – are invoking the constitution to make all sorts of claims against state power. The newly transformed courts are too often upholding these claims, and dealing serious setbacks to the government. The constitution is ‘taming Leviathan’.
Stung into action, the political class – in turn – devises various stratagems to tame the recalcitrant constitution, the contumelious courts, and the impudent People. The simplest method: use parliamentary super-majorities (easiest in countries dominated by a single party, often the party of the independence struggle) to change the constitution, and remove the provisions that are proving to be a thorn in the government's side. In small doses, this is often effective, and the political cost can be borne. Equally often though, the government's vaulting ambition overleaps itself, and it becomes clear that what is dressed up as constitutional change is actually constitutional evisceration.
With these words – which would soon go down in national folklore – the High Court of Kenya brought an ambitious project of constitutional overhaul to a juddering halt.
The origins of the words lay four years in the past. The 2017 General Election had seen a close and bitter contest between the incumbent President Uhuru Kenyatta and his challenger Raila Odinga. The process had been so rife with irregularities that the Supreme Court of Kenya had taken the unprecedented step of declaring the election invalid and ordering a rerun. But a few weeks before the rerun, Raila Odinga stated that none of the reforms recommended by the Supreme Court had been implemented, and that he was, therefore, boycotting the second election. Kenyatta's re-election became a formality.
In office, President Kenyatta gradually moved towards political reconciliation. The public articulation of this was a famous handshake between the two erstwhile contenders, on the steps of Harambee House. The constitutional articulation was a proposed set of seventy-four amendments, collectively known as the Building Bridges Initiative (BBI) Bill, which would be presented to the public as a package deal for constitutional reform. From altering the structure of the executive to increasing the number of constituencies, from creating a presidentially appointed judicial ombudsman to police reform, the BBI Bill contained a motley set of far-reaching changes to the Constitution.
In the poetry of many cultures, there is an enduring image: of a shore that recedes even as you move towards it. If transformative constitutionalism's metaphor of the bridge expresses confidence that the chasm between the past and the future will be bridged, then the language of poetry warns us about the ‘essential cruelty of hope’. Transformative constitutionalism may be a bridge, but a bridge to a horizon that is always receding.
The chapters in this book trace the journey of transformative constitutionalism under Kenya's 2010 Constitution, between the bridge and the horizon. These chapters – each dedicated to a constitutional dispute that was brought before the Kenyan courts between 2010 and 2025 – correspond to five axes of transformation.
The first axis is that of constraining the executive and empowering the People. This was at issue in the BBI Case, where an executive-driven attempt to make large-scale changes to the 2010 Constitution was rebuffed by the courts. The ball was set rolling by the High Court, which reached into history to hold that sweeping constitutional change could not be done without a correspondingly deep participation of the People. In doing so, the High Court offered to the world a new – and distinctively Kenyan – articulation of the famous basic structure doctrine. While the Supreme Court disagreed with the High Court on the applicability of the doctrine to the Kenyan context, its own interpretation of the Constitution affirmed – in substance – the document's commitment to public participation in constitutional change.
In the previous chapter, we examined the role of the People as an external counterbalance to Presidential power, and as a check upon the Imperial Presidency. Classical constitutional theory, on the other hand, has always focused on what Gargarella labels a system of internal checks and balances: that is, the different institutions of the State checking and constraining each other. This is the ‘separation of powers’: originally between the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary, and, in recent times, a more complex distribution of public power involving fourth branch institutions such as independent commissions, and other bodies.
The separation of powers has always been more ideal than reality. To start with, in parliamentary systems, there is no clean-cut separation between the legislature and the executive. The latter is drawn from the former and while, in theory, is meant to be answerable to it, in practice, often dominates it. Besides, the complexity of modern governance can no longer sustain (if it ever could) the bright-line division between law-making (the legislature), implementation (the executive), and adjudication (the judiciary). This complexity has, in turn, seen a mid-twentieth-century drift towards greater executive power, whether in parliamentary systems (beyond their inherent tendency of executive domination), or presidential ones. Courts have grappled with doctrines such as ‘excessive delegation’ (where the legislature passes vague laws, giving the executive so much discretion that the line between implementation and law-making dissolves), the executive abuse of temporary rule-by-decree powers, and so on.
Post-colonial constitutions are often born in riven and unequal societies, marked by histories of violence and dispossession. Transformative constitutions seek to address the burdens of those histories. But constitutions are not inked upon a tabula rasa. The new constitutional order is a palimpsest, carrying enduring traces of the social and economic institutions of the past. The success of the transformative project depends on how the constitutional order engages with those institutions.
For all the mutations that it experienced in different parts of the world, colonialism has always cleaved to a certain logic: the logic of material dispossession, often accomplished by imposing capitalist forms of legal property over indigenous systems of community tenure and landholding. Land-grabbing by invoking notions of ‘productivity’, turning people into tenants on their own land, introducing capitalist agriculture, and forcing precarity as a method of maintaining social control have all been defining features of modern coloni- alism. Furthermore, within the colonial context, patriarchy has invariably intensified dispossession and inequality along gendered lines, overseeing both the visible – and often invisible – subordination of women.
It is therefore scarcely surprising that demands for land justice constituted a core part of twentieth-century independence struggles. Once independence had been accomplished, landlessness and deeply skewed patterns of land ownership were some of the major problems that confronted the framers of post-colonial constitutions.
Liberal constitutions framed in the ‘first wave’ of decolonisation often chose to avoid directly addressing this issue: that is, they excluded the ‘social question’ from the purview of constitutionalism.