It was never intended that the company to be constituted should consist of one substantial person and six mere dummies.
The robust affirmation of separate corporate personality by the House of Lords in Salomon is in sharp contrast to the fragile legal personality possessed by Mrs Salomon in 1897. In corporate law discourse Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd is portrayed as the first case about the “one person company”. The case has given rise to considerable debate about the recognition of corporate personality where the corporation is the alter ego of a human person. In fact the portrayal of A. Salomon & Co Ltd as the alter ego of Aron Salomon is misleading because the company was a family company. The subscribers to the memorandum, described by Lopes LJ in the above quote as “six mere dummies” were Aron Salomon's wife and five children who were active participants in the company.