VARIVM ET MVTABILE SEMPER FEMINA: DIVINE WARNINGS AND HASTY DEPARTURES IN ODYSSEY 15 AND AENEID 4

Abstract In his second appearance to Aeneas in Aeneid 4 Mercury drives the hero to flee Carthage with a false allegation that Dido is planning an attack, capping his warning with an infamous sententia about the mutability of female emotion. Building on a previous suggestion that Mercury's first speech to Aeneas is modelled on Athena's admonishment of Telemachus at the opening of Odyssey 15, this article proposes that Mercury's second speech as well is modelled on Athena's warning, in which the goddess uses misdirection about Penelope's intentions and a misogynistic gnōmē about the changeability of women's affections to spur Telemachus’ departure from Sparta. After setting out how Virgil divides his imitation of Athena's speech verbally and thematically between Mercury's two speeches, the discussion turns to why both Athena and Mercury adopt these deceptive tactics. The speeches are shown to be culminations of the poets’ similar approaches to creating doubt and foreboding around the queens’ famed capacities for using δόλος. Common features in the ensuing hasty departures of Telemachus and Aeneas further confirm Virgil's use of Odyssey 15 in devising Aeneas’ escape from Carthage.

Critics have long regarded these lines as cruel and unjust to Dido. Henry in his Aeneidea is indignant: 'Dido in particular was unchangeably and devotedly attached to Aeneas, whom, if she did not pursue with fire and sword, it was not that his inconstancy did not so deserve, but that her magnanimity disdained, and her still-subsisting passion forbade.' 1 Austin agrees: 'But Mercury is lying … and Virgil makes it clear that his Dido was the sport of the gods.In spite of her wild moods she had no plots against him to do him personal injury.' 2 Why does Mercury lie about Dido's intentions, bolstering his claims with an infamous concluding line of misogyny?
Perhaps we can find a clue in Homer.Harrison points out that Mercury's second appearance to Aeneas recalls Hermes' second appearance to Priam in Iliad 24 (677-92), where the god warns Priam not to wait by Achilles' hut until morning, lest Agamemnon and the other Greeks take him for ransom. 3But Mercury's misogynistic sententia is not paralleled in Hermes' speech to Priam.It is characteristic of Virgil, however, to draw simultaneously upon multiple Homeric models in composing his scenes. 4I propose that Mercury's misleading and misogynistic warning about Dido is modelled on Athena's address to Telemachus at the opening of Odyssey 15, a similar pre-dawn admonishing of a hero that likewise employs falsehood and misogyny to spur a hasty departure.I have argued previously that Mercury's first appearance to Aeneas draws upon this same speech of Athena. 5Building upon this suggestion, I will show how Virgil has verbally and thematically split Athena's warning between Mercury's two speeches.The discussion will then turn to why Athena and Mercury adopt these tactics.We will see that both speeches are culminations of the poets' similar approaches to creating doubt and foreboding around the queens' famed capacities for using δόλος.Finally, comparison of the subsequent hasty departures of Telemachus and Aeneas will confirm Virgil's use of Odyssey 15 in devising Aeneas' escape from Carthage.
Echoing Telemachus' name, Athena repeats the syllable τηλ in her first line, Τηλέμαχ᾿, οὐκέτι καλὰ δόμων ἄπο τῆλ᾿ ἀλάλησαι, indicating that the 'far-fighting' Telemachus is 'far' from where he needs to be, a wordplay charmingly rendered by W.H.D. Rouse as 'Don't dally in this valley, Telemachus I tell 'ee'. 7Drawing upon an etymology of terra current in Virgil's day (Varro, Ling.5.22), Mercury repeats the syllable ter, likewise spelling out the dislocation of Aeneas, who tarries on land when he should be on his way to Italy.Noting the phonetic resemblance between τηλ and ter and the similar construction and motives of the wordplays, I proposed that Mercury's jingle imitates Athena's.8I add here that the puns of both deities involve editorial substitution.Athena's opening four lines repeat what Nestor says to Telemachus at 3.313-16, but Nestor's καὶ σύ, φίλος, μὴ δηθά in the first half of line 313 becomes Τηλέμαχ' οὐκέτι κάλα, insuring the jingle with τῆλ᾿.Mercury substitutes Libycis teris otia terris for Jupiter's inimica in gente moratur (4.235) in the second half of the first line he renders from Jupiter's message. 9oth Athena and Mercury warn against the loss of patrimony if the heroes do not depart.Telemachus is neglecting his κτήματα, a word Athena uses twice (15.11, 15.13).Mercury likewise reproaches Aeneas for forgetting his kingdom and his fortunes (4.267 regni rerumque oblite tuarum), reminding him that regnum Italiae Romanaque tellus (4.275) are owed to Ascanius. 10Like Telemachus, Aeneas lacks his father's guidance.I compared the situation at the opening of Terence's Andria, where Simo reports to his freedman Sosia that he has been scrutinizing the behaviour of his son Pamphilus now that he is grown and no longer supervised. 11Despite initial signs of moderation (Ter.An. 51-4, 88-102), Pamphilus starts a love affair that threatens Simo's plans for him to marry (119-36, 144-9).I was unaware that A.-M. Guillemin had anticipated my suggestion, observing that, when Anchises and Aeneas are reunited in Aeneid 6, Anchises' allusion to Aeneas' affair with Dido, quam metui ne quid Libyae tibi regna nocerent!(6.694), echoes Sosia's relief that Pamphilus is in no danger from the recently deceased courtesan Chrysis (Ter.An. 106): ei metui a Chryside. 12As Saylor argues, moreover, Fama's charge that Aeneas and Dido are indulging in luxus while neglecting their kingdoms (4.193-4; see also 4.221) mirrors the dual harm the prodigal amator does to his fama and res in comedy and satire, a topos Lucretius uses in a passage on the dangers of love affairs that Virgil likely has in mind in his depiction of Aeneas and Dido (Lucr.4.1123-4): labitur interea res et Babylonica fiunt, | languent officia atque aegrotat fama uacillans. 13Thus Mercury in effect has come to scold Aeneas for squandering his patrimony-the future of his people-on a mistress. 14hereas Penelope's suitors plunder the absent Telemachus' inheritance, Aeneas, the ambiguous quasi-suitor and quasi-husband to Dido, is himself squandering his own fortunes by tarrying with the queen.The alleged luxus of Dido and Aeneas points to another likely attraction for Virgil of the spendthrift-son motif, recalling Octavian's propaganda war against Antony's liaison with Cleopatra, a probable reminiscence of which can be found in Propertius' portrayal of Cleopatra as a grasping meretrix regina (3.11.39) who demanded from Antony the Roman empire as the price of an illegitimate marriage (3.11.29-32). 15 women.Such use of a single Homeric model for more than one scene has several parallels in the Aeneid. 16In each of Mercury's warnings, moreover, Virgil has imitated one of Athena's memorable rhetorical devices.The first speech features the paronomasia teris otia terris warning of dislocation.The second contains the misogynistic sententia instilling doubt and panic, preceded in the line before by an echo of the wordplay from the first speech (4.568 si te his attigerit terris Aurora morantem).With these effects Mercury's warnings escalate.His first speech rings with the moral danger to Aeneas, the second with the mortal one.
How Athena and Mercury manifest and how they depart from the heroes' vision enhance the startling effect in both cases.It is unusual that Athena appears undisguised to Telemachus. 17Kirchhof and Wilamowitz attributed this oddity to an inferior Bearbeiter. 18In a similar scene in Odyssey 20, by contrast, Athena appears to the sleepless Odysseus in the guise of a woman (20.31): δέμας δ' ἤϊκτο γυναικί. 19hatever the reason why the poet omits to disguise Athena at the opening of Odyssey 15, Virgil seems to have found the lack of disguise appropriate for the crisis of Aeneid 4, putting Mercury before Aeneas the first time undisguised and in daylight.When Aeneas reports this vision to Dido (4.356-9), she responds with scornful disbelief (4.376-80).Mercury is undisguised in the dream-epiphany as well (4.558 omnia Mercurio similis), though Aeneas disclaims certainty about the god's identity in his exhortation to his crew (4.574-9). 20Underscoring the urgency, both Mercury and Athena depart abruptly within a single line (Aen.4.570 sic fatus, nocti se immiscuit atrae; Od. 15.43 ἡ μὲν ἄρ' ὣς εἰποῦσ' ἀπέβη πρὸς μακρὸν Ὄλυμπον).Knauer records only one other Homeric parallel, the departure of Agamemnon's dream at Il. 2.35. 21

PENELOPE AND DIDO: ΚΛΕΟΣ AND FAMA, ΔΟΛΟΣ AND DOLVS
To understand why Athena and Mercury resort to misogyny, we begin with the remarkably similar reactions of learned readers to their speeches.As noted at the beginning, modern critics of the Aeneid have decried Mercury's characterization of Dido's intentions as a lie.His claim that Dido is contemplating deceptions and a terrible crime is true only in the sense that she has deceived Anna about the purpose of the pyre and is now bent on suicide.Her monologue just before Mercury appears to Aeneas is a self-condemnation, giving no indication that she plans to ambush the hero.Dido's panic when she sees Aeneas' fleet underway shows that she is caught unprepared for attacking him.She calls for fire and ships, but then she catches herself, asking: quid loquor?aut ubi sum? quae mentem insania mutat?-her last question indicating that she has not planned to attack Aeneas, and that she is not so mutabilis as to give in to sudden impulse (4.595).She then gives rein to dark fantasies of what she could have done with Aeneas from the start (4.596-606) and issues her terrible curse (4.607-29).One might see all this as confirmation of Mercury's forebodings. 22But Dido's defenders will reply that her violent thoughts are a response to Aeneas' departure, not a matter of premeditation as Mercury's warning implies.
Critics of the Odyssey have expressed similar misgivings about Athena's warning to Telemachus.Athena pulls from thin air the notion that Penelope is on the verge of marrying Eurymachus for his gifts and taking some of Telemachus' property. 23The Oxford commentary calls Athena's claim that Icarius and Penelope's brothers are pressuring her 'a white lie'. 24Repelled by the σμικρολογία imputed to Penelope, Aristophanes of Byzantium athetized Athena's warning that Penelope might take property (15.19). 25Concurring with Kirchhof that this scene is the work of a clumsy interpolator, Wilamowitz laments Athena's 'pointless lies' ('ihre zwecklosen Lügen'). 26he indignation of critics in both cases is understandable.Having no evidence, Athena and Mercury resort to misogynistic gnōmai to manipulate the heroes' fears.Worse, the misogyny strikes at the nobility and resolve of the heroines.Athena's assertion contradicts what we know of Penelope's constancy and makes for a cruel and ironic intertext for the tragedy of Dido, whose devotion to her dead husband fades only through divine intervention (Aen.1.719-22).It is thus surprising that the misdirection and misogyny of the two speeches have not been considered side-by-side, especially in view of the many other parallels in the stories of the two queens. 27oth are famed for their devotion to the memories of their husbands and for refusing to remarry. 28Both spurn proud suitors despite great pressure and danger.Penelope's suitors dissipate Odysseus' wealth and plot to kill Telemachus (Od.4.663-702).Dido's refusal of marriage leaves her and her fledgling city vulnerable (Aen.4.35-41, 4.534-6). 29And both heroines are renowned for cunning.Penelope's stratagem of weaving Laertes' shroud puts off her suitors for years, and the disguised Odysseus finds himself admiring how Penelope extracts gifts from the suitors by means of her guile (Od.18.290-303).Dido manages to flee Tyre with the treasure of the greedy Pygmalion, and her byrsa-trick secures land enough for a city (1.360-8). 30he most dramatic of Virgil's direct allusions to Penelope is Dido's declaration to Anna that rather than violate her pudor she would wish for the earth to swallow her or for Jupiter to strike her down with a lightning bolt (Aen.4.24-9), echoing Penelope's wish to die by Artemis' arrows and meet Odysseus below the earth rather than marry a lesser husband (Od.20.80-2; see also 18.201-5). 31Anna's advice to Dido to 'interweave reasons for delay' (Aen.4.51 causasque innecte morandi) alludes to Penelope, with an ironic reversal: Penelope weaves Laertes' shroud to delay remarriage, while Anna's proposal is intended to bring marriage about. 32enelope wins κλέος by using δόλος to avoid remarriage. 33Recounting to the Ithacans how she put off the suitors for three years with the ruse of Laertes' shroud, Antinous acknowledges that she has fashioned μέγα κλέος for herself (Od.2.125).Reporting Penelope's triumph to Agamemnon in Odyssey 24, Amphinomus attributes the slaughter of the suitors to Penelope's δόλος (24.126-8): ἡ δ' οὔτ ἠρνεῖτο στυγερὸν γάμον οὔτ' ἐτελεύτα, ἡμῖν φραζομένη θάνατον καὶ κῆρα μέλαιναν, ἀλλὰ δόλον τόνδ' ἄλλον ἐνὶ φρεσὶ μερμήριξε.
The last two lines together are reproduced in Mercury's warning that Dido is 'turning over in her breast deceptions and horrid crime' (4.563): illa dolos dirumque nefas in pectore uersat. 34Upon hearing the news from Amphinomus, Agamemnon praises Penelope for her mindful devotion to Odysseus, proclaiming that her κλέος will never perish (24.194-8).
Penelope succeeds in resisting remarriage, while Dido fails to abide by her oath. 35In her confrontation of Aeneas Dido bitterly reminds him of the loss of her fama prior, which had been her sole pathway to the stars (4.321-3): te propter eundem | exstinctus pudor et, qua sola sidera adibam, | fama prior.Odysseus praises Penelope's κλέος with the same image (19.108): ἦ γάρ σευ κλέος οὐρανὸν εὐρὺν ἱκάνει. 36Virgil thus creates both harmonies and dissonances with his allusions to Homer's Penelope. 37Knauer catalogues several such 'Umkehrungen' in Virgil's use of Homer, including the relevant instance mentioned above of Odysseus eagerly leaving Calypso while Aeneas departs 30   49. Hardie (n.9), 360 notes 'When it comes to feminine fama, Dido is the anti-Penelope', but citing Kopff he concedes that 'there are ways in which she models the role of Penelope more positively'.
Carthage with great reluctance, a contrast unfavourable to the Trojan. 38Thus both Penelope and Odysseus hover in the background of Aeneid 1 and 4, exemplifying the heroic standards that Dido and Aeneas fail to live up to.
Often overlooked in the discussions of Virgil's allusions to Penelope, however, is the pre-Virgilian tradition about Dido in which Aeneas does not appear and she successfully uses δόλος to evade remarriage. 39The account of the earliest witness, Timaeus (c.350-260 B.C.E.; OCD 4 ), is summarized within a later anonymous collection of anecdotes about outstanding women, the Tractatus de mulieribus. 40After Theiosso (= Dido) founds her city, the king of the Libyans wants to marry her.She refuses, but her citizens insist.Feigning that she will perform a ritual for release from oaths, she builds and lights a massive pyre near her palace and throws herself from her chamber onto the fire.In the more elaborate narrative of the Augustan historian Pompeius Trogus-which is preserved in Justin's epitome (18.4-6)-when the Carthaginians compel Dido to marry Iarbas, she obtains a delay-one thinks of Anna's causas innecte morandi-of three months to build a pyre on a far edge of the city on the pretence of appeasing the manes of Acharbas (= Sychaeus).Rather than throw herself onto the flames, she climbs the pyre and kills herself with a sword.The tradition's power is evident in post-Virgilian times, when Dido persists as a heroine of marital fidelity, including for Christian authors such as Tertullian and Jerome, whose citations of her legend are likely inspired by her appearance in collections of exempla of virtuous women. 41he pre-Virgilian Dido remains visible in Virgil's poem. 42Quint sees Dido's lament for her fama prior and Jupiter's observation that Dido and Aeneas are oblitos famae melioris amantis (4.221) as ironic allusions to her pre-Virgilian reputation, and notes that when Dido speaks her own epitaph (4.653-8) she recounts the achievements of her traditional self. 43In light of the fama Virgil has taken from Dido, Mercury's uarium et mutabile is crueller and more painful to read than Athena's affront to Penelope's κλέος.
A facility for δόλος is therefore common to the κλέος of Penelope and the fama of Dido.But it has a double edge.Repeatedly telling the story of Agamemnon's homecoming, Homer makes Clytemnestra's δόλος in the service of her seducer Aegisthus a cautionary tale for Odysseus and Telemachus. 44The most memorable version is Agamemnon's chilling account to Odysseus of Clytemnestra's role (11.404-34) in Aegisthus' treachery.When recalling how she pitilessly killed Cassandra (11.422), he calls her δολόμητις, an epithet otherwise applied only to Aegisthus. 45Odysseus deplores Clytemnestra's δόλος (11.439).Agamemnon assures Odysseus that Penelope will not devise such a plot against him (11.444-6).Suddenly mindful of his own disaster, however, Agamemnon warns Odysseus to put in secretly at Ithaca, since after Clytemnestra there can be no trusting women (11.456): ἐπεὶ οὐκέτι πιστὰ γυναιξίν.Such misogyny is not commonplace in Homer. 46It is not surprising that this line has been proposed as the Homeric model for Mercury's uarium et mutabile semper femina. 47The misogynistic warnings of Athena and Agamemnon, both concerning Penelope, express the same fear of women's capacity for secretly reversing their feelings and crafting deceptions.Virgil could well have had both warnings in mind when composing his scene.But Athena's admonition to Telemachus, issued in the depth of night by a deity for the purpose of instilling panic in the hero and a haste to depart, accounts for what Agamemnon's warning cannot-namely, why Virgil puts a misogynistic warning into the mouth of Mercury as he appears to Aeneas in a pre-dawn dream urging him to flee from Carthage.
By the time Odyssey 15 opens, Telemachus has already heard Nestor tell of Clytemnestra's seduction by Aegisthus (3.253-75).Nestor pointedly says that Clytemnestra at first resisted the advances, 'for she had a noble mind' (φρεσὶ γὰρ κέχρητ' ἀγαθῆ ͅ σι), anticipating and undermining Agamemnon's similar words to Odysseus about Penelope at 11.445.It is just after narrating Orestes' revenge (3.303-10) that Nestor warns Telemachus not to wander for long away from Ithaca (3.313-16), the lines that Athena will repeat to Telemachus.Menelaus too recounts Agamemnon's demise (4.512-47).Athena's warning to Telemachus that his mother might take property with her and forget about him and his father when she remarries is not so horrifying as these recollections of Clytemnestra's treachery, but the latter provide a background against which a more mundane deception by Penelope might seem plausible. 48n Homer's use of the story of Agamemnon's murder Olson writes: 'The Mycenean tales' most basic and repeated function in the epic, in fact, is to create suspense and irony through a series of deceptive hints and foreshadowings, false leads and suggestive dead ends.' 49 Bednarowski similarly highlights the role of stories of dolus in Aeneid 2 and 3 'in keeping alive interest in Aeneas's and Dido's affair and in shaping audience expectations going into Book 4', and, quoting Olson's observation, astutely compares Homer's use of the betrayal of Agamemnon to build tension around Penelope, but without extending this insight to the function of Mercury's second speech in Aeneid 4. 50 Virgil's use of Phaedra as a model for Dido at the opening of Aeneid 4 raises similar dire possibilities in the reader's mind, as do allusions to a mistress of deception greater than Clytemnestra, Medea, including a nod to Euripides in Mercury's warning that Aeneas must flee before dawn. 51Just as Athena exploits what Telemachus knows about his mother's cunning and what he has heard in the cautionary tale of Clytemnestra, so too does Mercury capitalize also upon Aeneas' knowledge of Dido's capacity for plotting (Aen.1.360-8) and his experience of her rage and despair (Aen.4.305-30, 4.362-92).For the reader sympathetic to Dido's plight, however, who has just seen Dido turn her anger against herself as she resigns herself to death, the god's falsehoods and misogyny, like Athena's, carry the sting of injustice.Unlike Penelope, Dido cannot overcome the charge implied by Mercury's warning.She will never have the chance.

HASTY DEPARTURES
In their haste to leave, both Telemachus and Aeneas feel compelled to run roughshod over the proprieties of ξενία and hospitium.Saying nothing of Athena's appearance, Telemachus immediately awakens Peisistratus with a kick from his heel and bids him bring the horses and prepare the chariot for departure (15.44-7), forgetting Athena's instruction (15.14) to wake Menelaus. 52Peisistratus objects that it is dark and reminds Telemachus to wait for Menelaus to bring gifts and bid them farewell (15.49-55).After Mercury's first appearance Aeneas is quite mutabilis.Despite the winter seas, ardet abire fuga dulcisque relinquere terras (4.281). 53Conscious that his departure will be a delicate matter, he has his men prepare in secret, that he may await the right opportunity to inform Dido (4.288-94).Undeceived, she confronts him angrily (4.296-306). 54elemachus' leave-taking has two stages.Menelaus graciously accedes to his request to depart, with words that could apply to Calypso but also to the lovesick Dido (15.68-71): Τηλέμαχ', οὔ τί σ' ἐγώ γε πολὺν χρόνον ἐνθάδ' ἐρύξω ἱέμενον νόστοιο· νεμεσσῶμαι δὲ καὶ ἄλλῳ ἀνδρὶ ξεινοδόκῳ, ὅς κ' ἔξοχα μὲν φιλέῃσιν, ἔξοχα δ' ἐχθαίρῃσιν· ἀμείνω δ' αἴσιμα πάντα. 55ut as Telemachus and Peisistratus later approach Pylos, Telemachus asks to be dropped off at his ship rather than continue to the city, lest Nestor's hospitality delay him (15.199-201).Peisistratus here confronts on behalf of his friend the same problem that Aeneas faces when weighing how to approach Dido about his departure (Aen.4.283-94).Virgil's line signalling Aeneas' conclusion (4.287 haec alternanti potior sententia uisa est), unique in his corpus, is his closest rendition of Homer's formula for the end of Peisistratus' deliberation at Od. 15.204: ὧδε δέ οἱ φρονέοντι δοάσσατο κέρδιον εἶναι.Although Homer employs this formula several times elsewhere, this is the only passage where it is used of pondering the proprieties of bidding farewell. 56Peisistratus agrees that Nestor would keep Telemachus in Pylos and bids him to make haste before Nestor finds out about his leaving, sure he will come down himself and will be angry (Od.15.209-14).
Here, as friends part, we should ponder why Virgil alighted upon Odyssey 15 as he devised Aeneas' exit from the stage of Carthage.Telemachus and his short trip abroad do not make for an obvious model.He is taking his first steps beyond Ithaca, searching for his father, with no love affair on the horizon.Aeneas, a seasoned warrior and a widower with a son, has wandered for years, burying his father before arriving in Dido's realm.He should know better than to shirk his duty.It is thus no surprise that Mercury's rebuke is so much harsher than Athena's prompting of Telemachus.But the vulnerability of fatherlessness and the prospect of kingdoms squandered link Aeneas and Telemachus.Bringing these themes to the fore are the queens at the centre of both stories, both famous for fidelity to their husbands and for skills at deception.Exploiting the tension created by Penelope's predicament and Clytemnestra's treachery, Athena issues a gnōmē about woman's changeableness to instil panic in Telemachus, heightening the suspense at the end of his journey.But Penelope will triumph all the same.Virgil adapts Homer's stinging device to a devastating end.Driving Aeneas to headlong flight, Mercury's words also signal that the gods too have abandoned the queen.
We can be sure that Peisistratus will placate Nestor on behalf of his young friend.But when Dido catches sight of Aeneas' fleet under sail, astonished that she has given everything to an ungrateful and callous aduena, her curse foretells centuries of enmity and decades of cruel war between two great cities (Aen.4.584-629).

KEVIN MUSE University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
kmuse@uwm.edu

To extricate his hero from this Antonian fate, Virgil evokes the
On the conjoined themes of res and fama in Roman comedy and satire, see also R.D. Brown, Lucretius on Love and Sex (Leiden, 1987), 254-5 on Lucr.4.1123-4.On comic potential in encounters between humans and gods elsewhere in the Aeneid, see T. Fuhrer, 'Wenn Götter und Menschen sich begegnen: Komische Szenen in Vergils Aeneis?', in S. Freund and M. Vielberg (edd.),Vergilund das antike Epos: Festschrift Hans Jürgen Tschiedel (Stuttgart, 2008), 221-36.Virgil's ancient commentators did not hesitate to cite parallels from comedies: see R.B. Lloyd, 'Plautus and Terence in Vergil: a Servian perspective', in R.M. Wilhelm and H. Jones (edd.),TheTwo Worlds of the Poet: New Perspectives on Vergil (Detroit, 1992), 244-53 (at 250 praising Saylor's findings).comedy of the spendthrift son.Mercury's intervention as obiurgator is humorous but not funny.Dissonance blares as a divine comedy envelops Aeneas to shield him from what he has done.Dido will be abandoned to tragedy.2.ATHENA'S APPEARANCE TO TELEMACHUS AND MERCURY'S SECOND SPEECH TO AENEAS Athena's next lines to Telemachus provide the model for Mercury's misogynistic warning in his second appearance to Aeneas.Having reminded Telemachus that the suitors are squandering his patrimony, Athena raises the spectre that Penelope herself could precipitate disaster by remarrying and taking some of his property (Od.15.14-23):WhenTelemachus asks Menelaus for permission to leave, he pleads the vulnerability of his possessions, omitting the suitors' plot (Od.15.86-91).Virgil has thus divided Athena's warning into two.Athena sounds the alarm that Telemachus is out of place and warns him of the danger to his patrimony.Mercury in his first speech does the same, scolding Aeneas for neglecting his regnum and res and condemning his inaction as he wastes time on land when he should be at sea.Athena then warns Telemachus of the threat to his patrimony posed by Penelope owing to the changeable nature of a woman's heart and of the suitors' plot to ambush him.Mercury's second speech likewise warns of a surprise attack and the fickleness of la vituperatio entre 44 et 30 a. C. n. (Brussels, 2016), 273-80.See also Pease (n. 2), 23-8; W. Suerbaum, Vergils Aeneis: Epos zwischen Geschichte und Gegenwart (Stuttgart, 1999), 233-6; S. Bertman, 'Cleopatra and Antony as models for Dido and Aeneas', EMC 44 N.S. 19 (2000), 395-8; L. Weeda, Vergil's Political Commentary in the Eclogues, Georgics and Aeneid (Berlin, 2015), 115-19.