Octocorals (Alcyonacea and Pennatulacea) from Paleogene deep-water strata in western Washington State, USA

Abstract. The fossil record of octocorals from Cenozoic marine strata of western North America is quite limited, and they have not been reported previously from rocks in Washington State, USA. Two late Oligocene specimens from the upper part of the Lincoln Creek Formation in western Washington, referred to Radicipes? sp., are the first fossil record of the family Chrysogorgiidae. The family Isididae is represented by an internode and two holdfasts identified as Isidella sp. collected from the Oligocene Pysht Formation, along with specimens questionably identified as Lepidisis sp., possibly the first fossil record for this genus. Together, these are the first confirmed fossils of the Alcyonacea from north of California in western North America. The axes of sea pens from several late Eocene or early Oligocene localities in the Lincoln Creek Formation in the central part of western Washington, and the Pysht and Makah formations on the north side of the Olympic Peninsula, are the first fossil record for the Pennatulacea from western North America; all are tentatively referred to the genus ‘Graphularia’. Large axes from the Lincoln Creek Formation and Makah Formation are referred to ‘Graphularia’ (?) aff. sasai, because they are similar to the species known only from late Eocene and early Oligocene rocks in Japan.

The oldest unequivocal Cenozoic octocoral fossils from western North America and the North Pacific Basin are from rocks of latest Paleocene or earliest Eocene age in the upper part of the Santa Susana Formation in the Simi Valley, southern California, that were identified by Squires (1999) as ?Mopsea sp., aff. M. costata Milne-Edwards and Haime, 1850. This is the only previous fossil record of the family Isididae Lamouroux, 1812, from western North America. Squires and Demetrion (1992) reported two octocorals from shallow-marine Eocene (51-52 Ma) strata of the Bateque Formation in Baja California Sur, Mexico. These fossils were identified as Heliopora? sp. (Family Helioporidae Moseley, 1876) and Parisis batequensis Demetrion, 1992 (Family Parisididae Aurivillius, 1931). A small fossil questionably identified (Armentrout, 1974) as ? Callogoria [sic] sp. (=Callogorgia Gray, 1870; Family Primnoidae Milne-Edwards, 1857) from the late Oligocene uppermost part of the Lincoln Creek Formation, Canyon River, Washington, has not been formally published, and we have been unable to further evaluate the record. Nomland (1916) reported a 'gorgonian' fragment from possibly earliest Eocene rocks at Marysville Buttes, California; however, no specimen number was given, although Nomland stated that the specimen, from "locality 1853," is in the collections at the University of California (Berkeley); nobody has mentioned the specimen since. Nomland (1916) also reported a 'gorgonian' octocoral fragment from Miocene rocks of the Astoria Formation at Astoria, Oregon, although it is difficult to tell from the illustrations whether this identification is correct. Nomland (1916) did not note a specimen number or repository for the specimen, although he did state that it was from California Academy of Sciences loc. 172. In a detailed monograph of the paleontology of the Astoria Formation, Moore (1963) noted other corals from the Astoria Formation, but she made no mention of the possible octocoral fossil discussed by Nomland (1916).
Fossils of sea pens, pennatulaceans, are represented most often by the central or axial rod, which calcifies in some taxa and have been found in many parts of Europe and elsewhere (e.g., McCoy, 1877;Squires, 1958;Reich and Kutscher, 2011, and references therein), but have not been reported previously from western North America. From the North Pacific Basin, there are Cretaceous sea pen fossils from the Magellan Seamounts (Mel'nikov et al., 2006;Zakharov et al., 2007) and only two Cenozoic records of pennatulacean fossils, both from *Corresponding author.
Japan. Fossils of large pennatulacean axial rods from late Eocene or early Oligocene strata in Hokkaido were described by Yabe (1955), and an axial rod was described from Pleistocene rocks in Tokyo (Yabe and Sugiyama, 1937).
The purpose of this paper is to record fossils of octocorals from Paleogene rocks in Washington State (Fig. 1), including the first fossil record for the family Chrysogorgiidae Verrill, 1883, and first reported pennatulacean (sea pen) fossils from western North America.

Geological setting and paleoecology
Lincoln Creek Formation.-Large sea pen axes, usually in concretions, were found in rocks mapped (Pease and Hoover, 1957) as the Lincoln Creek Formation at University of Washington Burke Museum Invertebrate Paleontology (UWBM IP) loc. B9493, which is the eastern end of a roadcut, at about the level of the surface of the road, in almost structureless bioturbated tuffaceous siltstone. Bedding is indicated by lens-shaped, discontinuous accumulations of small shells, foraminifers, fish scales, and terrestrial plant detritus. A single piece of pumice ∼10 mm in diameter was found. Tubes that are lined with white quartz grains are up to 3 mm in diameter and more than 100 mm long, in some cases branching, and cut through the siltstone in no apparent preferred orientation. Mollusks in the siltstone include moderately large (up to 70 mm long) scaphopods and turrid, turritellid, naticid, and scaphandrid gastropods. Several fossil crabs were found, Pulalius vulgaris (Rathbun, 1926) being the most abundant; some were preserved in concretions, others were not. Bivalves are rare. One teleost otolith was found. The larger sea pen axis was in a concretion oriented nearly vertical with respect to bedding; smaller sea pen fragments were found in the organic accumulations in the siltstone and did not appear to have any preferred orientation. Large sea pen axes at this locality are nearly always vertically oriented and in concretions (LSG, personal observations).
A locality on Porter Creek (UWBM IP B9496) is in bioturbated tuffaceous siltstone that is exposed in the stream bed and bank. This locality has abundant, mostly vertically oriented carbonate 'pipes' similar to those described from some hydrocarbon seep deposits (e.g., Aiello, 2005), and the faunule includes gastropods, fragments of a limid bivalve and some thinshelled pectinids, scaphopods, and a few 'root tufts' of hexactinellid sponges. The crab Pulalius vulgaris is also present.
Near Malone, locality UWBM IP B9495, is a roadcut (originally along a logging railway) exposing tuffaceous siltstone. Mollusks found here include scaphopods, fasciolariid and ptychatractid gastropods, and the crab P. vulgaris.
The faunules at the Lincoln Creek Formation localities all correlate with the "Turritella-Priscofusus Zonule" of the Porter Bluffs section described by Armentrout et al. (1980), which is characterized by structureless, bioturbated fine-grained sediments with abundant gastropods and crabs, with few bivalves. The molluscan species from localities B9493, B9495, and B9496 are the same as those listed by Armentrout et al. (1980, figs. 20, 21), which are most common in their Porter Bluff section, along the highway between Porter and Malone, between their localities PB6 to PB23. Armentrout et al. (1980) interpreted this zonule to represent bathyal to upper bathyal depths, with temperate to warm-temperate water temperatures. The Porter Bluff localities PB6 to PB23 are within the 'Echinophoria' fax Zone (Prothero et al., 2001a, fig. 6), late Eocene to earliest Oligocene in age (Global chrons C13r to C12n, 30.5 to 34.5 Ma; Prothero et al., 2001a).
Two fossils preserved in nodules were found as float on gravel bars of the Canyon River, on the south side of the Olympic Peninsula where a thick section of the Lincoln Creek Formation is exposed. Both nodules have the same siltstone lithology as others found in the uppermost part of the formation locally, deposited at depths of ∼200-600 m, and possibly as deep as 760 m, based on foraminiferans (Rau, 1966). Rau (1966) also concluded that water temperature was 2-10°C. According to Prothero and Armentrout (1985), the age of the upper part of the Lincoln Creek Formation on Canyon River is late Oligocene. We cannot exclude the possibility that these fossil-bearing nodules may have come from farther upstream where older strata of the Lincoln Creek Formation are exposed, so late Oligocene is a minimum age for these fossils.   Makah Formation.-A single loose, float concretion, on the beach terrace west of the mouth of the Sekiu River (UWBM IP B9497) contained the basal portion of two sea pen axes. The strata exposed are siltstone, mudstone, and turbidite layers deposited in a marine, deep-water paleoenvironment (Snavely et al., 1980). Fossils of all kinds are rare within the almost structureless mudstone and siltstone parts of the formation. Bedding is indicated by calcareous concretions, commonly containing glendonites, and in some cases mollusks (Squires and Goedert, 1994;Goedert, 1995), whale, fish, and wood falls (e.g., Kiel and Goedert, 2006;Kiel et al., 2012), and cold-seep carbonate (Goedert and Campbell, 1995). Some glendonites in this part of the Makah Formation are in the same size range as the larger sea pen axes described herein, and sometimes mistaken for 'square bones' by fossil collectors. Some actual sea pen fossils have been referred to as square bones (e.g., some specimens from Australia: McCoy, 1877; Tate, 1877), however, glendonites are inorganic structures, and with close observation are easily differentiated from actual sea pen axes.
Pysht Formation.-Part of the Pysht Formation exposed along the coastline between the mouths of Murdock Creek westward to the mouth of East Twin River yielded 'gorgonian' holdfasts and an internode, as well as some minute sea pen axis fragments. The stratigraphically lowest strata studied herein (UWBM IP B9491) appear to be penecontemporaneously disturbed strata affected by undersea slumping or gravity flows. A large holdfast was found in these disturbed strata. Another holdfast and small internode section was found in a prominent, poorly sorted conglomerate composed of reworked concretions, molluscan shells and fragments, bone fragments (both cetacean and teleost), small shark teeth, some wood fragments (mostly bored by mollusks), and some igneous or metamorphic clasts (UWBM IP B9490). Stratigraphically above (and westward) is a sequence of mostly thin-bedded turbidite deposits with few molluscan fossils, but near the top of this section are some deposits (UWBM IP B9492) with more abundant molluscan shells, small brachiopods, wood fragments, terrestrial plant debris, a few shark teeth and fish otoliths, and small sea pen axis fragments. Stratigraphically higher are mudstones that at locality B9494 contain some concretions that apparently were exposed on the seafloor during Oligocene time, because one was found with a small 'gorgonian' holdfast and others have serpulid tubes attached to the concretion surface (JLG, personal observation).
The only extensive studies of mollusk fossils from this part of the Pysht Formation are by Durham (1944); Rau (1964) studied the foraminiferans. Magnetostratigraphic work by Prothero et al. (2001b) correlated the Pysht Formation to ca. 23.7-30.5 Ma, late early Oligocene to latest Oligocene, whereas a detailed assessment by Nesbitt et al. (2010) concluded that most of the Pysht Formation is Oligocene, but it is not possible at this time to assign a more precise age.

Materials and methods
All illustrated specimens are deposited in the NRM PAL (Swedish Museum of Natural History, Stockholm, Department of Palaeobiology); additional specimens and/or associated fossils are deposited in the UWBM (University of Washington, Burke Museum of Natural History and Culture). Bulk mudand siltstone samples (∼3 kg) from one locality in the lower part of the Pysht Formation (B9492) were dried and wetted several times to cause the rock to disaggregate for screening. Localities are described in the Appendix using section, township, and range, according to the USA Public Land Survey System; GPS coordinates are given using datum WGS84 (World Geodetic System). All macro-specimens were coated with ammonium chloride before photography, unless otherwise indicated. Small pennatulacean axes were mounted on aluminum stubs, coated with gold, and photographed with a Hitachi-4300 Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM). Occurrence.-Found as float derived from the Lincoln Creek Formation (probably the upper part), Canyon River, Grays Harbor County, Washington (precise locality details on file at NRM).
Description.-Straight axis fragments, slightly more than 1 mm diameter, and up to at least 160 mm long, circular in cross section, composed of thin, papery concentric layers, iridescent, with translucent rhizoidal base, 'roots' that appear to become spatulate distally. For example, Radicipes sakhalinensis Dautova, 2018, found living at depths exceeding 3000 m in the Sea of Okhotsk, has a very similar rootlike base (Dautova, 2018, figs. 1G-I), as does R. pleurocristatus (Stearns, 1883, fig. 1); species of other unbranched genera have disk-like calcified bases, or have an axis that is not circular in cross section (e.g., Cairns and Cordeiro, 2017). Some species of Chrysogorgia Duchassaing and Michelotti, 1864, also have rhizoidal bases (e.g., Cairns, 2001), but colonies branch and are generally of a much smaller size overall, in many cases smaller in length than the largest fossil axis fragment described herein. Unfortunately, we were unable to find any sclerites preserved, nor is there any indication of polyp arrangement.
The largest fossil axis, NRM PAL Cn 75266, is in a nodule that broke into several pieces and exposed a longitudinal section of the axis for ∼70 mm. The axis has a slightly oblique transverse fracture that occurred before lithification of the nodule, demonstrating that the axis was originally brittle, as has been noted by Cordeiro et al. (2017) for species of Radicipes. The paleoenvironmental setting represented by the upper Lincoln Creek Formation in the Canyon River section would have been cold, deep water (up to 600 m), with a soft, muddy bottom, typical of that inhabited by Recent species of Radicipes . We cannot exclude the possibility that the Lincoln Creek Formation specimens represent an early stage, before branching, of some extremely large species of Chrysogorgia. Also, because of the fragmentary nature of the fossils, we have questioned the generic identity and it should be regarded as provisional; however, regardless of genus, these fossils are the first known for the family Chrysogorgiidae.
Remarks.-See Ott (1989Ott ( , 1995, Grasshoff and Scheer (1991), and Yang et al. (2014) for discussion and clarification of publication dates of some taxa described by Esper (1788Esper ( -1830, including how and why his plates were not necessarily published at the same time as the corresponding descriptions. Bayer (1990) provided a detailed discussion as to the validity of genus Isidella.
Isidella sp. Description.-The largest holdfast, NRM PAL Cn 75257 (Fig. 3.7), is 56.3 mm long, 35 mm wide, and up to 2 mm thick, with broadly scalloped edges, and a surface with numerous radiating grooves. The underside is not visible. Another holdfast, NRM PAL Cn 75259 (Fig. 3.3-3.5), is 38 mm high, ovoid to round in cross-section at the end of the basal stalk, 11 mm in diameter; the wider end is 42.8 × 29.5    Fig. 3.6) appears to have been a lateral branch, smooth externally with faint striations and is 11 mm long, solid, slightly flattened so that it is ovoid in cross-section with concentric rings, 3.4 × 5.2 mm diameter at its larger end, with a distinct condyle with a broad point located off center, 2.8 mm diameter at its smaller end.
Remarks.-Because Gray (1858) did not properly define his new genus Isidella, Verrill (1883) expressed doubt about its validity. Etnoyer (2008) provided a discussion of the problems with the taxonomy of Isidella, and followed Bayer (1990) who accepted the genus as valid. The fossils from the Pysht Formation offer little in the way of diagnostic characters other than the nature of the calcareous holdfasts, the calcareous internode demonstrating that branching was from a horny node, as well as the slightly flattened cross-section of the small internode that may indicate that the colony branched in one plane instead of a bush-like growth pattern. This best fits the genus Isidella. With few fossils to examine, unequivocal assignment to genus is impossible at this time because other genera of Keratoisidinae also branch from the nodes or internodes, or have internodes that are in some cases hollow and/or fluted (e.g., Bayer, 1981;Bayer and Stefani, 1987;Alderslade and McFadden, 2012;Duenas et al., 2014). Another genus within the Keratoisidinae, Acanella Gray, 1870, also branches from the nodes, and is similar to Isidella, but differs in branching pattern; whether pattern of branching is a stable character that can be used to differentiate genera within the Keratoisidinae is doubtful (e.g., Verrill, 1883;France, 2007;Duenas et al., 2014). Assignment of the fossils from the Pysht Formation to Isidella is somewhat provisional, but Isidella lives and is common in deep parts of the North Pacific Ocean, forms large individual colonies, and can form dense thickets (Etnoyer, 2008;Andrews et al., 2009;Serrato Marks et al., 2017).
Remarks.-All available specimens are only sections of relatively long and delicate internodes. The largest, ∼32 mm long and 4 mm in diameter, was originally longer, but is eroded at both ends. It has a small central canal throughout that is ∼0.5 mm across. The other two specimens are hollow; the larger specimen is 8.4 mm long and ∼2 mm in diameter, with a central canal ∼1 mm across; the smaller is ∼7 mm long and 1 mm diameter. Other than conspicuous fluting that appears to slightly twist along its length, the surface is smooth. Fossils such as these could be overlooked because of their superficial similarity to parts of some scaphopod shells, particularly those with longitudinal sculpture and a large-diameter central canal. A few scaphopod fragments were found at the same locality, however, because their sculpture does not twist along their length, and being aragonitic with a three-layer structure (Bøggild, 1930;Smith and Spencer, 2016), they are easy to differentiate from Lepidisis? sp. internodes.  (9) showing hollow interior (specimen not whitened).

Journal of Paleontology 96(3):539-551
These internodes with a smooth surface, fluted longitudinally, being hollow and showing no indication of any branching, best fit the diagnostic characters for species of Lepidisis. Only 11 or 12 species of Lepidisis are known, none as fossils, so the specimens from the Pysht Formation, if correctly identified, are the first fossil record for the genus. Species of Keratoisis Wright, 1869, also have hollow internodes, but colonies tend to be more robust and with branches. However, as already noted, whether colonies branch or not is no longer regarded as a reliable character for differentiating genera within the Keratoisidinae. Octocorallia indet. Remarks.-This small holdfast is ∼10 mm across, the 'stem' was central, with the surface displaying faint radiating grooves. It is attached to the outer surface of a small nodule that is ∼70 mm long × 50 mm wide, containing a small glendonite. Light-colored, roughly circular places on the nodule may indicate other areas where holdfasts were once located. Similar small fossil holdfasts have been described from Eocene and Oligocene strata in the southeastern United States (e.g., Giammona and Stanton, 1980;Kocurko, 1988Kocurko, , 1993Kocurko and Kocurko, 1992, and references therein), some even attached to mudstone nodules, but most of these appear smooth and do not seem to have the faint grooves possessed by the Pysht Formation specimen. Similar small fossil holdfasts were reported from Paleocene deposits in Denmark (Nielsen, 1917) and Eocene rocks on Seymour Island, Antarctica (Stolarski, 1996).

Order Pennatulacea Verrill, 1866
Remarks.-Pennatulacea, originally as a suborder, is most often attributed to Verrill in 1865, but the publication date of Volume 4 of the Proceedings, and the associated Communications of the Essex Institute (for 1864-1865) is clearly given on the cover as 1866. The title page of Verrill's (1866) article states "communicated February 29, 1865," but apparently the actual year of publication should be cited as 1866 (see Williams, 1999, for additional comments and references).
Description.-The large specimens from the Lincoln Creek Formation are, in most cases, preserved in life position, vertical with respect to bedding, are brown to black in color, incomplete, but as preserved they can exceed 300 mm in length and are up to 8 mm in diameter. They are generally circular in cross-section, with very slight depressions visible on two sides toward the upper ends. The lower, basal parts appear to end in a blunt point, as shown in the Makah Formation specimens (Fig. 5.1). The lower ends display a roughened surface due to imprints of chimney cells. The surface of the upper parts of the rods are smoother, but still have a distinct grain almost resembling a smooth piece of wood. In cross-section, annular rings are distinctly visible along with radial fibrous structure. Smaller fragments were found in the sediments surrounding the larger rods at locality B9493; these are described under 'Graphularia' spp. because we are uncertain as to whether these represent the same species as the larger specimens.
Materials.-NRM PAL Cn 75260, two axial rods in one concretion from UWBM IP loc. B9497; NRM PAL Cn 75262-75264 (all parts of one individual), and 75265, large axial rods in nodules and siltstone from UWBM IP loc. B9493.
Remarks.-'Graphularia' (?) sasai was described based on fragments of large pennatulacean axes collected from the late Eocene to early Oligocene Tyaro Formation (Onbetu = Ombetsu Group) in Japan. These strata are today called the Charo Formation and are of early Oligocene age (e.g., Kurita, 2004). According to Yabe (1955, p. 291), the 'G.' (?) sasai specimens were preserved in sections of somewhat cylindrical concretions and apparently in life position, vertical with respect to bedding. Their large size (sections broken at each end, but up to 250 mm long and 11 mm diameter), geochronological age, and preservation mode closely match those of the largest specimens from the Lincoln Creek Formation. The cross-sections and surface texture of the specimens from Japan described by Yabe (1955) are similar to those of the Lincoln Creek Formation specimens, at least in part. The specimens from Japan (Yabe, 1955, fig. 1) and Washington (Fig. 5.2, 5.3) are circular in cross-section and appear relatively smooth. Yabe (1955, p. 288-289) described the surface of the specimens from Japan as having "very fine longitudinal corrugations," but his illustration (Yabe, 1955, fig. 2) does not have a scale, and the caption only indicated "greatly enlarged." The fossil from the Makah Formation ( Fig. 5.1) shows a roughened surface similar in appearance to the enlarged illustration of 'G.' (?) sasai, but we are unable to make direct comparisons at this time. Because the fossils from Japan and Washington are incomplete, we cannot exclude the possibility that they all represent different parts of the axis from the same or a closely related species. Living pennatulacean species are known to be widely distributed even across oceanic basins (e.g., Williams, 2011) so it would not be surprising to find the same species inhabiting both sides of the North Pacific Ocean during Paleogene time. 'Graphularia' (?) sasai was also listed by Sato (1972, table 1), citing Shimokawara (1963) as the source of the record, from the late Eocene Poronai Formation on Hokkaido, but these specimens were not described, and it is not clear whether these were the same specimens described by Yabe (J. Nemoto, IGPS, personal communication, 2021). Large pennatulacean axes have been described from Cenozoic strata of Australia and New Zealand. One species, 'Graphularia' senescens Tate, 1877, originally considered to be a belemnite, is synonymous with 'Graphularia' robinae McCoy, 1877, from southern Australia, and apparently abundant, according to McCoy (1877), in some sections of the late Oligocene Jan Juc Marl near Waurn Ponds near Geelong, and a place called 'Bird Rock Bluff.' Both species were from the same Waurn Ponds locality, with 'G.' senescens being published in February 1877, and 'G.' robinae in September 1877; we consider them to be the same species. Although 'G.' senescens is similar in size (length more than 300 mm, diameter up to 12 mm; McCoy, 1877) to 'G.' (?) sasai from Japan and 'G.' (?) aff. sasai from Washington State, 'G.' senescens becomes distinctly quadrangular in the assumed upper portions, described as "square bones" by quarrymen (McCoy, 1877;Tate, 1877). No mention was made as to whether the Australian specimens were preserved in life position. From several different localities in late Eocene to early Miocene strata in New Zealand, large pennatulacean axes named 'Graphularia' longissima Squires, 1958, were described as circular in cross-section in the lower (= basal) portion, being subquadrangular in the upper part, and up to at least 300 mm long and 13 mm in diameter. The pattern of pits on the more basal part of 'G.' longissima (Squires, 1958, pl. 2, fig. 15) is similar to 'G.' (?) aff. sasai from the Journal of Paleontology 96(3):539-551 Makah Formation (Fig. 5.1, 5.3); no mention was made as to whether 'G.' longissima was preserved in life position.
Larger sea pen axes, such as 'G.' (?) sasai from Japan and 'G.' (?) aff. sasai from Washington, have good potential for preservation in life position, at least for the basal part of the axis. Some sea pens have axial rods up to 2 m long, with up to one-fourth of that length embedded in the sediment already (e.g., Greathead et al., 2007). In some species, the basal portion of the axis is also more heavily calcified as well (de Moura Neves et al., 2018), which would presumably also enhance their preservation potential. We suspect that these fossil axes may be relatively common in Cenozoic strata in western Washington, but have been overlooked and assumed to be burrows, plant stems, or inorganic structures (i.e., glendonites). Over a period of 30 years, ∼30 specimens of 'G.' (?) aff. sasai have been collected from locality B9493; most were discarded because they were assumed to be burrows and others lost to personal collections, with all but one oriented vertically with respect to bedding (LSG, personal observation).
'Graphularia' spp. Figure 5.4-5.8 Occurrence. Remarks.-Associated with large specimens identified as 'G.' (?) aff. sasai at locality B9493 were fragments of small sea pen axes up to 2.5 mm in diameter, and >5 mm long, chalky and white in color. These have no distinguishing characters, other than being circular in cross-section and composed of layers of radial calcite. Small fragments were also found in the lower part of the Lincoln Creek Formation on Porter Creek (loc. B9496), and near Malone, Washington (loc. B9495). Because these are all from the same part of the Lincoln Creek Formation and all are circular in cross-section, it is possible that they are fragments of juvenile 'G.' (?) aff. sasai, but we cannot be certain at this time.
On the north side of the Olympic Peninsula, locality B9492, in the Pysht Formation in Clallam County west of Murdock Creek, produced 24 specimens, all small fragments <10 mm long and <2 mm in diameter. These differ from the Lincoln Creek Formation specimens in that while some are circular in cross-section, others are slightly flattened or distinctly quadrate. A few of the smaller quadrate fragments have a central groove on each flat side. Even though fossils of sea urchin spines of similar size to the sea pen axis fragments are found together at this locality, it is easy to differentiate them; urchin spines are composed of minutely porous stereom, whereas the sea pen axes are solid, composed of annular layers of calcite, which in cross section appears similar to rings of a tree along with radial calcite. One specimen (NRM PAL Cn 75281, from locality B9490) is a rod, circular in cross-section, 17.5 mm long (missing ∼2 mm near one end) and 1.8 mm in diameter, preserved in coarse matrix with a small shark tooth and bivalve fragments. Fossils of small sea pen axes such as these from elsewhere in the world are placed in various species within the genus 'Graphularia' (e.g., Branco, 1885;Nielsen, 1917;Yabe and Sugiyama, 1937;Shapiro and Ramsdell, 1965;Bałuk and Pisera, 1984;Mel'nikov et al., 2006;Reich and Kutscher, 2011). The Pysht Formation specimens are not complete enough to assign to species, but they do indicate that there is some previously unrecognized pennatulacean diversity preserved within these strata.

Discussion
Alcyonacea.-The specimens of Isidella sp. and Lepidisis? sp. of the Isididae, and Radicipes? sp. of the Chrysogorgiidae reported here are the first confirmed fossils of the Alcyonacea from north of California in western North America. Estimated divergence times among Cnidaria using a time-calibrated molecular phylogeny (Park et al., 2012) indicate that the Isididae diverged from other Alcyonacea at the base of the Jurassic, with error margins ranging from the Carboniferous to the early Cretaceous. Fossil calibration points for the Park et al. (2012) time tree were the splits between three pairs of genera of scleractinian corals, based on data from Veron et al. (1996), and did not include any fossil Octocorallia. In the time-calibrated molecular tree of the Anthozoa, Quattrini et al. (2020) and McFadden et al. (2021) pushed the split of the calcaxonian families Isididae and Chrysogorgiidae even further back in time, to the early Triassic. The fossil calibration points for these trees included an early Miocene record of Keratoisis internodes from New Zealand (Hayward, 1977). These estimated early origins of Isididae and Chrysogorgiidae are at odds with the fossil record, with the first holdfasts and corallia assignable to the Isididae appearing in the Late Cretaceous (Voigt, 1958;Małecki, 1982;Žítt and Nekvasilová, 1993;Schlagintweit and Gawlick, 2009;Borszcz et al., 2013;Löser, 2015), and the Oligocene record of Chrysogorgiidae reported here.
Pennatulacea.-Frond-like fossils as old as the Ediacaran had been attributed to the Pennatulacea (Glaessner and Wade, 1966;Jenkins, 1985;Waggoner and Collins, 2004), although more recent re-analyses of their morphologies questioned these interpretations Brasier, 2007, 2008 (Voigt, 1958;Antcliffe and Brasier, 2008;Reich and Kutscher, 2011). This is notably younger than the molecular age estimates. The fossils to calibrate the dates in the phylogeny of Quattrini et al. (2020) did not include any Pennatulacea; the only calibration point among the entire Octocorallia was an early Miocene record (Hayward, 1977) of the isidid Keratoisis from New Zealand.
Another time-calibrated molecular phylogeny, with focus on Pennatulacea and using the early to middle Eocene record of Virgularia presbytes Bayer, 1955, from the Pointe-a-Pierre Formation in Trinidad as a calibration point, indicates an Early Cretaceous origin of the Pennatulacea (García-Cárdenas et al., 2020). However, the Eocene record of V. presbytes has been shown to be a trace fossil instead of an octocoral (Häntzschel, 1958). Despite this invalid calibration point, the suggested Early Cretaceous origin of the Pennatulacea is in much better agreement with the fossil record than the early Paleozoic origin indicated by Quattrini et al. (2020) and McFadden et al. (2021) and is consistent with an origin of pennatulacean high-Mg calcite axes within a time of calcite seas (Balthasar and Cusack, 2015).
Although fossil pennatulacean axes are relatively common in Europe, the only Cenozoic fossils previously reported from the North Pacific basin are from Japan (Yabe and Sugiyama, 1937;Yabe, 1955). The late Eocene to Oligocene specimens of 'Graphularia' (?) aff. sasai and 'Graphularia' spp. from Washington State are the first fossil records from the eastern North Pacific and extend the geographic range of 'Graphularia' considerably.