Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-tj2md Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-17T18:53:52.673Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Moving Targets: The ‘Canned’ Hunting of Captive-Bred Lions in South Africa

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2018

Richard A. Schroeder
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

So-called canned hunts take place within fenced private game ranches and typically target animals bred in captivity solely for that purpose. Thousands of semidomesticated lions form the focal point of South Africa’s canned-hunting industry. Notions of animal welfare, “fair chase,” and conservation have been deployed to varying degrees to sway public opinion surrounding canned hunts in South Africa and abroad. While state regulatory efforts have largely failed to date, the Campaign Against Canned Hunting (CACH) has successfully promoted stricter controls on the importation of lion trophies in Australia, Europe, and the United States, in part by highlighting the recent death of Cecil, a charismatic lion shot by an American bowhunter in Zimbabwe.

Résumé:

Les chasses dites en « boîte » ou chasse au trophée ont lieu dans des fermes d’élevage de chasses privées clôturées, elles visent généralement les animaux sauvages élevés en captivité dans l’unique but de mourir chassé. Des milliers de lions semi domestiqués constituent le point focal de l’industrie de la chasse en « boîte » de l’Afrique du Sud. Pour influencer l’opinion publique sur les chasses en « boîte » en Afrique du Sud et à l’étranger, les notions de bien-être des animaux, de chasse équitable et de conservation ont été déployées de façons diverses. Alors que les efforts de réglementation de l’État ont largement échoué jusqu’à présent, la campagne contre la chasse en « boîte » (CACH) a favorisé avec succès des contrôles plus stricts sur l’importation de trophées de lions en Australie, en Europe et aux États-Unis, en soulignant en particulier la mort récente de Cecil, le lion charismatique tué par un chasseur américain de chasse à l’arc au Zimbabwe.

Keywords

trophy huntingSouth Africaanimal welfareconservationlions
Type
Articles
Information
African Studies Review , Volume 61 , Issue 1 , April 2018 , pp. 8 - 32
Copyright
Copyright © African Studies Association 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Arenstein, Justin. 2002. “Limpopo Province Considers Legalising Canned Lion Hunting.” African Eye News Service, June 19. allafrica.com.Google Scholar
Barkham, Patrick. 2013a. “‘Canned Hunting’: The Lions Bred for Slaughter,” The Guardian, June 3. www.theguardian.com.Google Scholar
Barkham, Patrick. 2013b. “Lions Bred to be Shot in South Africa’s ‘Canned Hunting’ Industry.” YouTube video, 10:07. June 3. www.youtube.com/watch?v=qmM6MmsFeX8.Google Scholar
Bloch, Simon. 2015. “Airlines Send SA Trophy Hunting Industry into Tailspin with Cargo Ban.” News 24, May 14. traveller24.news24.com.Google Scholar
Bothma, Jacobus du Plessis, Suich, Helen, and Spenceley, Anna. 2009. “Extensive Wildlife Production on Private Lands in South Africa.” In Evolution and Innovation in Wildlife Conservation: Parks and Game Ranches to Transfrontier Conservation Areas, edited by Suich, Helen, Child, Brian, and Spenceley, Anna, 147–62. London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
Brandt, Femke, and Spierenburg, Marja. 2014. “Game Fences in the Karoo: Reconfiguring Spatial and Social Relations.” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 32 (2): 220–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bryce, Emma. 2013. “US Gets a Taste for Lion Burgers.” The Guardian, June 7. www.theguardian.com.Google Scholar
Business Day. 2003. “Canned Hunting is Threat to Thriving Wildlife Industry.” Business Day/AllAfrica Global Media, July 18. http://www.sosrhino.org.Google Scholar
Carroll, Rory. 2004. “Ghost of Apartheid Returns to Farmlands.” The Guardian, December 23. www.theguardian.com.Google Scholar
Carruthers, Jane. 2010. “‘Wilding the Farm or Farming the Wild’? The evolution of Scientific Game Ranching in South Africa from the 1960s to the Present.” Transactions of the Royal Society of South Africa 63 (2):160–81.Google Scholar
Collard, Rosemary-Claire. 2014. “Putting Animals Back Together, Taking Commodities Apart.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 104 (1): 151–65.Google Scholar
Collard, Rosemary-Claire, and Dempsey, Jessica. 2013. “Life for Sale? The Politics of Lively Commodities.” Environment and Planning A 45: 2682–99.Google Scholar
Cook, Roger. 1997. “Making a Killing.” The Cook Report. May 6.Google Scholar
Cousins, Jenny A., Evans, James, and Sadler, Jon P.. 2009. “‘I’ve Paid to Observe Lions, Not Map Roads!’: An Emotional Journey with Conservation Volunteers in South Africa.” Geoforum 40 (6): 1069–80.Google Scholar
Cousins, Jenny A., Sadler, Jon P., and Evans, James. 2008. “Exploring the Role of Private Wildlife Ranching as a Conservation Tool in South Africa: Stakeholder Perspectives.” Ecology and Society 13 (2): 43.Google Scholar
Cousins, Jenny A., Sadler, Jon P., and Evans, James. 2010. “The Challenge of Regulating Private Wildlife Ranches for Conservation in South Africa.” Ecology and Society 15 (2): 28.Google Scholar
Crowley, Kevin. 2015. “In South Africa, Ranchers Breeding Mutant Animals to Be Hunted: Rich Marksmen Pay a Premium to Shoot ‘Frankenstein Freaks of Nature.’” Bloomberg Business, March 11.Google Scholar
Crown, Barbara. 2015. “Qatar Airways Embargoes Hunting Trophies from Cargo.” Hunting Report, June 16.Google Scholar
Donaldson, John. 2010. “Scientific Evidence on Colour Mutation/Variations.” Correspondence from the Chief Director, Applied Biodiversity Research Division, South African National Biodiversity Institute, to Nosipho Ngcaba, Director-General, Department of Environmental Affairs, September 10. www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Fitter, R. S. R., and Scott, Peter. 1978. The Penitent Butchers: 75 Years of Wildlife Conservation. New York: HarperCollins.Google Scholar
Free State Province, South Africa. 2009. SA Predator Breeders Association v. Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism, unreported case 1900/2007, 11 June 2009 (Bloemfontein).Google Scholar
Free State Province, South Africa. 2013. “Activities Regarding Listed Large Predators by Land Owners, Foreign Clients and the Exportation of Hunting Trophies.” Provincial Gazette 75, February 1. Accessed via South African Predator Association. sapredators.co.za.Google Scholar
Gajanan, Mahita. 2015. “Cecil the Lion Spurs US Lawmakers to Draft Bills to Discourage Trophy Hunting.” The Guardian, July 31. www.theguardian.com.Google Scholar
Goodrich, Andre. 2015. Biltong Hunting as a Performance of Belonging in Post-apartheid South Africa. London: Lexington.Google Scholar
Hall, Jenny. 2010. “Building the Ethical Dimension of the Environmental Right: The Contribution of the South African Predator Breeders Association v the Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism.” South African Journal of Environmental Law and Policy 17 (1): 1–22.Google Scholar
Hargreaves, Richard. 2010. “Countering the Moral and Ethical Argument for Canned Hunting of Captive Bred Lions in South Africa.” Journal of the WildCat Conservation Legal Aid Society 3 (Summer 2010).Google Scholar
House Committee on Natural Resources. 2016. “Missing the Mark: African Trophy Hunting Fails to Show Consistent Conservation Benefits.” A Report by the Democratic Staff of the House Committee on Natural Resources, June 13.Google Scholar
Hunter, Luke. 2015. “Walking with Lions: The Myth of Conservation.” Panthera, September 30. http://www.panthera.org.Google Scholar
Hunting Report. 2016. “Conservation Force and Partners Sue New Jersey to Enjoin ‘Big Four’ Hunting Trophy Ban.” Email Extra Bulletin, July 12.Google Scholar
Josefsson, Jenny. 2014. “Safe-Guarding the Colonial Present: Game Farms on the Frontier in KwaZulu-Natal’s ‘Battlefields Route.’” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 32 (2): 258–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kamuti, Tariro. 2014. “The Fractured State in the Governance of Private Game Farming: The Case of KwaZulu-Natal Province, South Africa.” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 32 (2): 190–206.Google Scholar
Kauffman, Vanessa. 2014. “Service Proposes Endangered Species Act Protection for the African Lion.” US Fish & Wildlife Service News Release, October 27. http://www.fws.gov.Google Scholar
Larimer, Sarah. 2015. “While Airlines Ban Hunting Trophy Shipments, UPS Says it Won’t Bow to Controversy.” Washington Post, August 4. http://www.washingtonpost.com.Google Scholar
Levy-Abegnoli, Julie. 2015. “EU Set to Ban Lion Hunting Trophy Imports.” Parliament Magazine, February 6. www.theparliamentmagazine.eu.Google Scholar
Lindsey, Peter, Alexander, Robert, Balme, Guy, Midlane, Neil, and Craig, Joseph. 2012. “Possible Relationships between the South African Captive-Bred Lion Hunting Industry and the Hunting Conservation of Lions Elsewhere in Africa.” South African Journal of Wildlife Research 42 (1): 11–22.Google Scholar
Lindsey, Peter, Balme, Guy, Funston, Paul, Henschel, Philipp, and Hunter, Luke. 2016. “Life after Cecil: Channelling Global Outrage into Funding for Conservation in Africa.” Conservation Letters 9 (4): 296–301.Google Scholar
Lindsey, Peter, Roulet, Pierre, and Romañach, Stephanie. 2007. “Economic and Conservation Significance of the Trophy Hunting Industry in Sub-Saharan Africa.” Biological Conservation 134 (4): 455–69.Google Scholar
McGreal, Chris. 2001. “Lions Face New Threat: They’re Rich, American and They’ve Got Guns.” The Guardian, April 27. http://www.theguardian.com.Google Scholar
Mercer, Chris. 2014. “An Interview with Chris Mercer, Director of the Campaign Against Canned Hunting (CACH) and the Global March for Lions.” Video produced by Trevor and Susan Barrett, February 24, 2014. youtube/kxtTWYNm98I.Google Scholar
Milman, Oliver. 2015. “Australia Bans Hunting ‘Trophies’ from Lions Entering or Leaving the Country.” The Guardian, March 13. www.theguardian.com.Google Scholar
Mkhize, Nomalanga. 2014. “Game Farm Conversions and the Land Question: Unpacking Present Contradictions and Historical Continuities in Farm Dwellers’ Tenure Insecurity in Cradock.” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 32 (2): 207–19.Google Scholar
Neumann, Roderick. 1995. “Dukes, Earls and Ersatz Edens: Aristocratic Nature Preservationists in Colonial Africa.” Environment and Planning D, Society and Space 14 (1): 79–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
News 24. 2015. “SAA Cargo Stops Transporting Hunting Trophies Following ‘CAA Fine.’” traveller24.news24.com.Google Scholar
Pak-Harvey, Amelia. 2013. “Melissa Bachman’s African Lion Hunt Draws Anger.” Christian Science Monitor, November 21. http://www.csmonitor.com.Google Scholar
Parker, Faranaaz. 2012. “SA Breeders Embrace Growing Asian Demand for Lion Bones.” Mail and Guardian, July 5. http://mg.co.za.Google Scholar
Patterson, Gareth. 1998. Dying to Be Free: The Canned Lion Scandal and the Case for Ending Trophy Hunting in Africa. New York: Viking Penguin.Google Scholar
Potgeiter, Pieter. 2013. “Inclusion of Panthera Leo in the Definition of ‘Listed Large Predator.’” (Section 1 of Draft Threatened or Protected Species Regulations). Correspondence from President of South African Predator Association to Ms. Magdel Boshoff, Director-General of the Department of Environmental Affairs.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2012. “Professional Hunters’ Association of South Africa Speaks Out on the Tarnishing of Its Industry by Unscrupulous Operators.” Press release, June 20. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2013a. Position Paper on Lion Hunting, December 5. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2013b. “Shooting or Hunting: Call It What You Like—PHASA Has a Duty to Be Involved.” Press release, December 24. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2014a. “Recognize Hunting as a Conservation Tool, Urges PHASA.” Press release, March 3. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2014b. “Revenue from Hunting Tourists Breaks R1 Billion Mark.” Press release, December 9. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2015a. “Airlines Ban on Transporting Hunting Trophies,”June 18. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Professional Hunters Association of South Africa (PHASA). 2015b. “PHASA Hopeful for a Reversal of SAA’s Cargo Ban,” June 1. http://www.phasa.co.za.Google Scholar
Republic of South Africa. 2004. “National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act, 2004.” Government Gazette 467. ship.mrc.ac.za/biodiversity.pdf.Google Scholar
Republic of South Africa. 2005a. “Draft National Norms and Standards for the Sustainable Use of Large Predators in South Africa Issued in Terms of Section 9(1) of the National Environmental Management Biodiversity Act, 2004.” Government Gazette 475, January 28. www.wag.co.za.Google Scholar
Republic of South Africa. 2005b. Panel of Experts on Professional and Recreational Hunting in South Africa: Report to the Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism, October 25. www.huntingreport.com.Google Scholar
Ruddin, Muzaffa. 2015. “Trophy Hunting in Africa: You Kill It, You Carry It.” The Economist. May 15. www.economist.com.Google Scholar
Schroeder, Richard. 2012. Africa after Apartheid: South Africa, Race and Nation in Tanzania. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Smith, Neil. 1992. “Contours of a Spatialized Politics: Homeless Vehicles and the Production of Geographical Scale.” Social Text 33: 54–81.Google Scholar
Snijders, Dhoya. 2012. “Wild Property and Its Boundaries—On Wildlife Policy and Rural Consequences in South Africa.” Journal of Peasant Studies 39 (2): 503–20.Google Scholar
Solon, Olivia. 2013. “Avaaz Counters Accusations of Clicktivism and Takes on the Lion Bone Trade.” Wired, June 17. www.wired.co.uk/.Google Scholar
South African Predator Association (SAPA). 2013. “Policy Document: Norms and Standards for Hunting Ranch Lions (Captive Bred Lions) in South Africa,” November 13. www.sapredators.co.za.Google Scholar
Spierenburg, Marja, and Brooks, Shirley. 2014. “Private Game Farming and its Social Consequences in Post-apartheid South Africa: Contestations over Wildlife, Property and Agrarian Futures.” Journal of Contemporary African Studies 32 (2): 151–72.Google Scholar
Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa. 2010. SA Predator Breeders Association v. Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism (72/10) [2010] ZASCA 151, November 29.Google Scholar
Trendler, Karen. n.d. “The Illegal Pet Trade and the Wildlife Industry: A South African Perspective.” Wildcare Africa Trust\IFAW. Unpublished manuscript. www.fauna.org.au.Google Scholar
Trivedi, Bijal P. 2002. “To Boost Gene Pool, Lions Artificially Inseminated.” National Geographic Today, June 12. http://news.nationalgeographic.com.Google Scholar
Tsui, Bonnie. 2006. “Trophies in a Barrel: Examining ‘Canned Hunting.’” New York Times, April 9.Google Scholar
Tully, Paul. 2014. “Global March for Lions – 15th March 2014.” YouTube video, 5:20. April 10. www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOgBP9uKzqA.Google Scholar
Ward, Clarissa. 2014. “Lion Whisperer.” 60 Minutes, November 30. www.cbsnews.com.Google Scholar
Williams, Evan. 2013. “Canned Hunting.” Special Broadcasting Service, Australia. Dateline, November 26. http://www.sbs.com.au.Google Scholar
Young, Bruce, and Chevallier, Nick. 2015. “Blood Lions: Bred for the Bullet.” Documentary film. Regulus Vision.Google Scholar