Controversial for centuries, the route across the Alps taken by Hannibal, his Carthaginian army and his famous elephants in 218 BCE formed the basis of an extended scholarly dispute between William John Law (1786–1869) and Robert Ellis (1819/20–85). Fought in the pages of books and the Journal of Classical and Sacred Philology, their exchanges lasted several years. Ellis' Treatise on Hannibal's Passage of the Alps (1853) and An Enquiry into the Ancient Routes between Italy and Gaul (1867) are also reissued in this series. Published in 1866, this two-volume work was Law's major contribution to the debate, examining the various theories and historical accounts. Modern scholarship has questioned, however, whether either man was right. Volume 2 examines the writings of Livy, comparing them to those of Polybius and determining which of the two can be deemed to be the more reliable. Law then draws his final conclusions.
Not yet reviewed
Be the first to review
Review was not posted due to profanity×
- Date Published: November 2014
- format: Paperback
- isbn: 9781108079501
- length: 328 pages
- dimensions: 216 x 140 x 19 mm
- weight: 0.42kg
- contains: 1 map
- availability: Available
Table of Contents
Part VIII. Knowledge of the Alps in Early Times:
1. Strabo on the Alps
2. The Salassian hyperbasis of Strabo
3. The Taurinian hyperbasis of Strabo
4. Polybius knew no Taurinian hyperbasis
5. The Po and the Doria of Strabo
6. The Po and the Doria of Strabo (cont.)
7. Mr Ellis on the early use of the Little Mont Cenis
8. Mr Ellis on the Little Mont Cenis
9. Mr Ellis on the Mont Cenis
Part IX. Interpretation of Livy:
2. March from the Isère
3. The march continued
4. Druentia is the Durance
5. Identity of tracks is disproved
Part X. Two Peculiar Theories:
1. Theory of M. le Comte de Fortia d'Urban
2. Of M. Replat
Part XI. Conciliation Fails:
1. We must select between the two historians
2. Livy founds his hypothesis on the words of Cincius
3. No writer prior to Livy favours his hypothesis
Part XII. Cause of Doubt:
1. Doubt has come through neglect of Polybius
2. Arnold recognised the truth
Find resources associated with this titleYour search for '' returned .
Type Name Unlocked * Format Size
This title is supported by one or more locked resources. Access to locked resources is granted exclusively by Cambridge University Press to lecturers whose faculty status has been verified. To gain access to locked resources, lecturers should sign in to or register for a Cambridge user account.
Please use locked resources responsibly and exercise your professional discretion when choosing how you share these materials with your students. Other lecturers may wish to use locked resources for assessment purposes and their usefulness is undermined when the source files (for example, solution manuals or test banks) are shared online or via social networks.
Supplementary resources are subject to copyright. Lecturers are permitted to view, print or download these resources for use in their teaching, but may not change them or use them for commercial gain.
If you are having problems accessing these resources please contact firstname.lastname@example.org.
Sorry, this resource is locked
Please register or sign in to request access. If you are having problems accessing these resources please email email@example.comRegister Sign in
You are now leaving the Cambridge University Press website. Your eBook purchase and download will be completed by our partner www.ebooks.com. Please see the permission section of the www.ebooks.com catalogue page for details of the print & copy limits on our eBooks.Continue ×
Are you sure you want to delete your account?
This cannot be undone.
Thank you for your feedback which will help us improve our service.
If you requested a response, we will make sure to get back to you shortly.×