Power, Gender and Christian Mysticism
In the western Christian tradition, the mystic was seen as having direct access to God, and therefore great authority. In this study, Dr Jantzen discusses how men of power defined and controlled who should count as a mystic, and thus who would have power: women were pointedly excluded. This makes her book of special interest to those in gender studies and medieval history. Its main argument, however, is philosophical. Because the mystical has gone through many social constructions, the modern philosophical assumption that mysticism is essentially about intense subjective experiences is misguided. This view is historically inaccurate, and perpetuates the same gendered struggle for authority which characterises the history of western christendom. This book is the first on the subject to take issues of gender seriously, and to use these as a point of entry for a deconstructive approach to Christian mysticism.
- First book to use a deconstructionist approach to Christian mysticism
- First to consider philosophical questions about mysticism in relation to question of power and gender
- Major new philosophical analysis of mysticism, challenging received philosophical ideas about the subjective nature of mystical experience
Reviews & endorsements
"...an important contribution to understanding the nature of the history of mysticism as impacted by gender and social power struggles. Highly recommended." The Reader's Review
"Both historically and philosophically, this compelling, massively documented study is a superlative contribution to medieval, religious, and feminist studies." Choice
"Jantzen's book offers a strong and convincing critique of the category of mysticism as it has ben constructed and employed by both modern theologians and philosophers of religion....In Power, Gender and Christian Mysticism, Jantzen has written an important book which should figure into all future discussions of mysticism and Politics." F.C. Bauerschmidt, Modern Theology
"This work is clear, fair, thorough, challenging, and engaging....the author serves the academic and faith communities well. The reader is constantly invited to think through the historical data and make new judgements....it deserves to be weighed seriously in any scholarly appreciation of mystical tradition and of spirituality." Barabara Paleczny, ssnd, The Canadian Catholic Review
"Jantzen's work....offers a wide-ranging discussion of the social construction of mysticism in Christianity from early exegetical spirituality, through the developments of Dionysius the Areopagite, a number of medieval case studies, to an examination of modern academic mis-readings of mystical texts. It is full of spicy critiques of other scholars, and is energized by a dauntless intention to unmask gender oppression wherever it may be lurking. ...Jantzen does an absolutely stellar job in relieving us once and for all...of the modern preoccupation with a putative "core" experience common universally to all mystics." Mark A. McIntosh, Pro Ecclesia
Product details
January 1996Paperback
9780521479264
404 pages
217 × 137 × 22 mm
0.465kg
6 b/w illus.
Available
Table of Contents
- 1. Feminists, philosophers and mystics
- 2. Mystics, martyrs and honorary males
- 3. The mystical meaning of scripture
- 4. Mystical theology and the erotic other
- 5. 'Cry out and write': mysticism and the struggle for authority
- 6. The visions of virgins: spirituality and sexual control
- 7. Heretics and witches
- 8. The language of ineffability
- 9. Conclusion: mysticism and modernity
- References
- Index.