Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-x5gtn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-02T18:54:22.463Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘A Dubious Twilight’: Reflections on Dreams in Patristic Literature

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Patricia Cox Miller
Patricia Cox Miller
Affiliation:
associate professor of religion inSyracuse University, Syracuse, New York.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

As Wendy O'Flaherty has argued persuasively in her recent book, Dreams, Illusion, and Other Realities, it is possible to falsify the hypothesis that one is dreaming—by waking up; but it is not possible to verify that one is awake by falling asleep. The thought that one cannot verify the fact that one is awake but only only falsify the fact that one is asleep (by waking up) delivers something of a jolt to Western “common sense,” which typically takes for granted the distinctness of such categories as “real” and “unreal,”“conscious” and “unconscious,”“dream” and “waking life.” Yet, as O'Flaherty points out, we know that we cannot see ourselves seeing an illusion, just as we cannot verify the “reality” of ourselves in the moment when we are engaged in testing our reality.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 55 , Issue 2 , June 1986 , pp. 153 - 164
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. O'Flaherty, Wendy Doniger, Dreams, Illusion and Other Realities (Chicago, 1984), pp. 198–199Google Scholar and passim.

2. Plato, Theaetetus 158d, in Plato: The Collected Dialogues, ed. Hamilton, Edith and Cairns, Huntington (Princeton, 1961), p. 863.Google Scholar

3. Moore, Marianne, “Poetry,” in A College Book of Modern Verse, ed. Robinson, James K. and Rideout, Walter B. (New York, 1958), p. 325.Google Scholar

4. For Natalius, see Eusebius, , Ecclesiastical History 5.28;Google Scholar for Perpetua, see Passio Perpetuae et Felicitatis 4, in The Acts of the Christian Martyrs, trans. Musurillo, Herbert (Oxford, 1972), pp. 111–112.Google Scholar

5. Athanasius, , Contra Gentes 31.38–44,Google Scholar in Athanasius Contra Gentes and De Incarnatione, ed. and trans. Thomson, Robert W. (Oxford, 1971), p. 87.Google Scholar

6. Athanasius, , Contra Gentes 33.25Google Scholar Thomson, p. 90).

7. Plato, , Symposium 175c (Hamilton and Cairns, p. 530).Google Scholar

8. Berry, Wendell, “A Meeting,” in A Part (San Francisco, 1980), p. 18.Google Scholar

9. See Ovid: Metamorphoses, trans. Humphries, Rolfe (Bloomington, 1955), pp. 272–282Google Scholar(Meta. 11.400–750).

10. See Ovid, , Meta. 11.596:Google Scholar “Nebulae caligine mixtae exhalantur humo dubiaequae crepuscula lucis” (Clouds of vapor breathe forth from the earth, and dusky twilight shadows).

11. For a discussion of the authenticity of Perpetua's journal, which is incorporated into the text of the martyrdom, see Dodds, E.R., Pagan and Christian in an Age of Anxiety (New York, 1970), pp. 48–53;Google Scholar for an interesting psychological and historical discussion of Perpetua's dreams, see Lefkowitz, Mary R., “The Motivations for St. Perpetua's Martyrdom,” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 44 (1976): 417–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12. Passio Perpetuae 4 (Musurillo, pp. 111–113).Google Scholar

13. The literature from antiquity is extensive; see the discussions by Dodds, E. R., Pagan and Christian in an Age of Anxiety, pp. 37–53,Google Scholar and Brown, Peter, The Making of Late Antiquity (Cambridge, Mass., 1978), pp. 40–45, 54–55, 66–67.Google Scholar

14. Tertullian, , De Anima 47.2,Google Scholar in Quinli Septimi Florentis Tertuliani: De Anima, ed. Waszink, J. H. (Amsterdam, 1947), p. 65Google Scholar(my translation).

15. For a survey of dream material in biblical, classical, and late antique literature, see Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, ed. Friedrich, Gerhard, trans. Bromiley, Geoffrey W., 10 vols. (Grand Rapids, 1964–1976), vol. 5,Google Scholar s.v. “önar,” by Albrecht Oepke, pp. 220–238.

16. Tertullian, , De Anima 43.7 (Waszink, p. 59).Google Scholar

17. Tertullian, , De Anima 43.10 (Waszink, p. 60).Google Scholar

18. Ibid.

19. Tertullian, , De Anima 42.3 (Waszink, p. 58).Google Scholar

20. Passio Perpetua 4 (Musurillo, p. 113).Google Scholar

21. Artemidorus, , The Interpretation of Dreams: Oneirocritica, 1.1–5, trans. White, Robert J. (Park Ridge, N.J., 1975), pp. 14–20.Google Scholar

22. Steiner, George, “The Historicity of Dreams (two questions to Freud),” Salmagundi 61 (1983): 13.Google Scholar

23. Ibid.

24. See Musurillo, , Acts of the Christian Martyrs, pp. 111–113.Google Scholar

25. See Frend, W. H. C., Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church (Garden City, N.Y., 1967), p. 269,Google Scholar for the suggestion that martyrs' dreams reflected the teachings to catechumens in Carthage.

26. See especially the Martyrdom of Marian and James and the Martyrdom of Montanus and Lucius, in Musurillo, , Acts of the Christian Martyrs, pp. 197–238.Google Scholar The five “visions” (horaseis) that come to the author of the Shepherd of Hermas “when he gets sleepy,”“while sitting on his bed,” and so on are elaborate dreams that provoke a profound metamorphosis in the psyche of the author, whose understanding of himself and of the divine world is considerably deepened as he moves through one dream after another.

27. See the discussions of Aristides in Brown, , Making of Late Antiquity, pp. 41–44,Google Scholar and Dodds, Pagan and Christian in an Age of Anxiety, pp. 39–45.

28. For detailed discussions of dream therapy in the cult of Asclepius, see Kee, Howard C., “Self-Definition in the Asclepius Cult,” in Jewish and Christian Self-Definition, vol. 3,Google ScholarSelf-Definition in the Greco-Roman World, ed. Meyer, Ben F. and Sanders, E. P. (Philadelphia, 1982), pp. 118–136;Google ScholarBehr, Charles Allison, Aelius Aristides and the Sacred Tales (Amsterdam, 1968), pp. 23–40Google Scholar and passim; Kerenyi, Carl, Asklepios: Archtypal Image of the Physician's Existence (Princeton, 1959);Google Scholar and Meier, C. A., Ancient Incubation and Modern Psychotherapy (Evanston, 1967).Google Scholar

29. Aelius, Aristides, The Sacred Tales 2.46,Google Scholar in Behr, , Aelius Aristides, p. 232.Google Scholar

30. See the discussion by André-Jean, Festugière, Personal Religion Among the Greeks (Berkeley, 1960), pp. 91–95.Google Scholar

31. Aristides, Aelius, The Sacred Tales 2.53Google Scholar (Behr, p. 234).

32. See Peter Brown's discussion of Aristides's illnesses as a barometer of the social tensions of his time: “Aristides' behavior, therefore, poses a problem: did the rising within him of a threatening sense of superiority backed by considerable energy and aggression unconsciously help bring on the illnesses and the murderous cures that tied his energy down to a battle with his body, so that Aristides' overweening ambition was safely locked away in a world of grandiose dreams and visions?”; Making of Late Antiquity, p. 43.

33. Hippolytus, , Commentary on Daniel 3.6,Google Scholar in Hippolyte: Commentaire sur Daniel, trans. Lefèvre, Maurice, Source chrétiennes 14 (Paris, 1947). p. 137.Google Scholar

34. Homer, , Odyssey 4.790–837,Google Scholar trans. Fitzgerald, Robert (Garden City, N. Y., 1963), pp. 76–78.Google Scholar

35. Augustine, , The City of God 18.18, in Augustine: Concerning the City of God Against the Pagans, trans. Bettenson, Henry (Baltimore, 1972), pp. 782–783.Google Scholar

36. Ibid.

37. Ibid., pp. 783–784.

38. Trimorphic Protennoia, (Nag Hammadi Library [NHL] 13.35), trans. Turner, John D., in The Nag Hammadi Library in English, dir. Robinson, James M. (New York, 1978), p. 462.Google Scholar

39. Ibid., NHL 13.41 (Robinson, p. 465).

40. Origen, , Homilies on Genesis 11–13,Google Scholar in Origen, : Homilies on Genesis and Exodus, trans. Heine, Ronald E., Fathers of the Church 71 (Washington, D.C., 1981), pp. 168–195.Google Scholar

41. Origen, , Hom, on Gen. 12.5(Heine, p. 182).Google Scholar

42. Ibid., 11.3 (Heine, p. 173).

43. Ibid., 13.3 (Heine, pp. 189–195).

44. Ibid., 12.5 (Heine, p. 183).

45. Ibid., 13.3 (Heine, pp. 189, 191).

46. Origen, On Susanna, in PG II. 44A, trans. Brown, , Making of Late Antiquity, p. 71;Google ScholarAgainst Celsus 1.66, in Origène: Contre Celse, trans. Borret, Marcel, Sources chrétienne 132, 4 vols. (Paris, 1967–1969), 1:263.Google Scholar

47. Origen, , Against Celsus 1.48Google Scholar (Borret, , p. 202).Google Scholar

48. Ibid.

49. Brown, , Making of Late Antiquity, pp. 69–71.Google Scholar

50. Origen, , Commentary on John 2.31,Google Scholar quoted and discussed by Smith, Jonathan Z., “The Prayer of Joseph,” in his Map is not Territory: Studies in the History of Religions (Leiden, 1978), pp. 27–28.Google ScholarPubMed

51. The Gospel of Truth, NHL 1.3Google Scholar, trans. MacRae, George W. (Robinson, , pp. 37–49).Google Scholar

52. Ibid., NHL 1.3.28 (Robinson, p. 42).

53. Ibid., NHL 1.3.29 (Robinson, p. 43).

54. Ibid., NHL 1.3.28 (Robinson, pp. 42–43).

55. Clement, of Alexandria, , The Pedagogue 2.9,Google Scholar in Clément d'Alexandrie: Le Pedagogue, trans. Mondésert, Claude, Sources chrétiennes 108 (Paris, 1965), pp. 155–163,Google Scholar for Clement's discussion of dreams.