Hostname: page-component-55f67697df-xlmdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-05-14T05:39:25.189Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A note on mitigating the adverse scale effects associated with daily driving restrictions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 October 2017

Arthur J. Caplan  and
Man-Keun Kim
Arthur J. Caplan*
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Economics, Utah State University, 4835 Old Main Hill, Logan, Utah 84321, USA
Man-Keun Kim
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Economics, Utah State University, 4835 Old Main Hill, Logan, Utah 84321, USA
*
*Corresponding author. Email: arthur.caplan@usu.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper investigates the role of additional regulation in mitigating the ‘adverse scale effect’ associated with daily driving restrictions, which has become a popular regulatory tool used to control episodic air pollution internationally, especially in developing countries. We find that although an annual vehicle registration tax reduces the incentive to purchase additional vehicles among households whose sole purpose for doing so is to ‘cheat’ the restriction (i.e., the ‘adverse scale effect’), it does so with an external cost. The cost occurs because households whose purpose for purchasing an additional vehicle is not to cheat the restriction are given the same disincentive with the tax. We show how simple one- and two-stage lotteries can be used to not only discriminate between cheater and non-cheater households (in particular, to avoid providing a disincentive to the latter type of household), but also to provide an even stronger disincentive to the former.

Keywords

Adverse scale effectdaily driving restrictionslotteryvehicle registration taxQ52Q53
Type
Research Article
Information
Environment and Development Economics , Volume 23 , Issue 1 , February 2018 , pp. 63 - 79
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Ajanovic, A, Haas, R and Wirl, F (2016) Reducing CO2 emissions of cars in the EU: analyzing the underlying mechanisms of standards, registration taxes, and fuel taxes. Energy Efficiency 9(4), 925–937.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barter, PA (2005) A vehicle quota integrated with road usage pricing: a mechanism to complete the phase-out of high fixed vehicle taxes in Singapore. Transport Policy 12(7), 525–536.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cantillo, V and Ortuzar, JDD (2014) Restricting the use of cars by license plate numbers: a misguided urban transport policy. DYNA 81(188), 75–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cao, J, Wang, X and Zhong, X (2014) Did driving restrictions improve air quality in Beijing? China Economic Quarterly 13(3), 1091–1126.Google Scholar
Carnovale, M and Gibson, M (2013) The effects of driving restrictions on air quality and driver behavior. Unpublished manuscript, UCSD Working Paper Series, Department of Economics, University of California, San Diego. Available at http://escholarship.org/uc/item/0v8813qm#page-1.Google Scholar
Chen, Y (2012) Transportation policy simulation and urban travel demand model. Master's thesis, Peking University, Beijing, China.Google Scholar
Chen, Y, Jin, GZ, Kumar, N and Shi, G (2013) The promise of Beijing: evaluating the impact of the 2008 Olympic games on air quality. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 66, 424–443.Google Scholar
Cropper, ML, Jiang, Y, Alberini, A and Baur, P (2013) Getting cars off the road: the cost-effectiveness of an episodic pollution control program. Environment and Resource Economics 57(1), 117–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cummings, RG and Walker, MB (2000) Measuring the effectiveness of voluntary emission reduction programmes. Applied Economics 32(13), 1719–1726.Google Scholar
Cutter, WB and Neidell, M (2009) Voluntary information programs and environmental regulation: evidence from ‘spare the air’. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 58(3), 253–265.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis, LW (2008) The effect of driving restrictions on air quality in Mexico City. Journal of Political Economy 116, 38–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
eBejing.com (2015) Circular on rotation of tail number plate of no-driving vehicles in regional rush hours on working days. Available at http://www.ebeijing.gov.cn/Government/GovernmentBulletin/t1224982.htm.Google Scholar
Eskeland, GS and Feyzioglu, T (1997) Rationing can backfire: the ‘day without a car’ in Mexico City. The World Bank Economic Review 11(3), 383–408.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feng, Y, Fullerton, D and Gan, L (2013) Vehicle choices, miles driven, and pollution policies. Journal of Regulatory Economics 44(1), 4–29.Google Scholar
Fullerton, D and West, SE (2002) Can taxes on cars and on gasoline mimic an unavailable tax on emissions? Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 43, 135–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fullerton, D and West, SE (2010) Tax and subsidy combinations for the control of car pollution. B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy 10(1), Article 8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallego, F, Montero, JP and Salas, C (2013a) The effect of transport policies on car use: a bundling model with applications. Energy Economics 40, S85–S97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallego, F, Montero, JP and Salas, C (2013b) The effect of transport policies on car use: evidence from Latin American cities. Journal of Public Economics 107, 47–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Giblin, S and McNabola, A (2009) Modelling the impacts of a carbon emission-differentiated vehicle tax system on CO2 emissions intensity from new vehicle purchases in Ireland. Energy Policy 37, 1404–1411.Google Scholar
Guo, O (2016) Want to drive in Beijing? Good luck in the license plate lottery. The New York Times. Available at https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/29/world/asia/china-beijing-traffic-pollution.html?_r=2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hennessy, H and Tol, RSJ (2011) The impact of tax reform on new car purchases in Ireland. Energy Policy 39(11), 7059–7067.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henry, GT and Gordon, CS (2003) Driving less for better air: impacts of a public information campaign. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 22(1), 45–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Innes, R (1996) Regulating automobile pollution under certainty, competition, and imperfect information. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 31, 219–239.Google Scholar
Jiang, Y (2009) Do people drive less on code red days?. Mimeo, Asian Development Bank, Manilla.Google Scholar
Kerr, GN (1995) Managing congestion: economics of price and lottery rationing. Journal of Environmental Management 45(4), 347–364.Google Scholar
Kunert, U and Kuhfeld, H (2007) The diverse structures of passenger car taxation in Europe and the EU Commissions proposal for reform. Transportation Policy 14, 306–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liu, Y and Cirillo, C (2015) Model system to evaluate impacts of vehicle purchase tax and fuel tax on household greenhouse gas emissions. Transportation Research Record 2503, 51–59.Google Scholar
Mabit, SL and Fosgerau, M (2011) Demand for alternative-fuel vehicles when registration taxes are high. Transportation Research Part D – Transport and the Environment 16(3), 225–231.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) (2016), Registration and Title Fees by State. Available at http://www.ncsl.org/research/transportation/registration-and-title-fees-by-state.aspx.Google Scholar
Osakwe, R (2010) An analysis of the driving restriction implemented in San José, Costa Rica. Policy Brief, Environment for Development (EfD). Available at http://www.efdinitiative.org/publications/analysis-driving-restriction-implemented-san-jose-costa-rica.Google Scholar
Viard, VB and Fu, S (2013) The effect of Beijing's driving restriction on pollution and economic activity. Social Science Research Network (SSRN). Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1917110.Google Scholar
Wang, L, Xu, J, Zheng, X and Qin, P (2013) Will a driving restriction policy reduce car trips?. A case study of Beijing, China, Discussion Paper Series, EfD DP 13–11, Environment for Development (EfD).Google Scholar
Wang, Y, Hao, J, McElroy, MB, Munger, JW, Ma, H, Chen, D and Nielsen, CP (2009) Ozone air quality during the 2008 Olympics: effectiveness of emission restrictions. Atmospheric Chemistriy and Physics Discussions 9, 9927–9959.Google Scholar
West, SE (2004) Distributional effects of alternative vehicle pollution control policies. Journal of Public Economics 88 (3–4), 735–757.Google Scholar
Wolff, H (2014) Keep your clunker in the suburb: low emission zones and adoption of green vehicles. The Economic Journal 124, F481–F512.Google Scholar
Zhai, K and Ying, T (2016) Beijing said to expand restrictions on vehicle use to fight smog. Bloomberg. Available at https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-08/beijing-said-to-expand-restrictions-on-vehicle-use-to-fight-smog.Google Scholar
Zhang, W, Lawell, C-YCL and Umanskaya, VI (2016) The effects of license plate-based driving restrictions on air quality: theory and empirical evidence. Unpublished manuscript, University of California at Davis. Available at http://www.des.ucdavis.edu/faculty/Lin/driving_ban_paper.pdf.Google Scholar