Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-5nwft Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-31T06:47:15.163Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Labor1 History and Public History in Australia: Allies or Uneasy Bedfellows?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 October 2009

Lucy Taksa
Affiliation:
University of New South Wales

Abstract

This paper reflects on the ways in which public labor history and more populist forms of public history have intersected and/or diverged in Australia since the 1970s. By comparing various labor heritage programs and public history interpretation strategies at four redeveloped industrial heritage sites, it examines how both approaches have conceived and represented workers' history and the relationship between past and present, industrialization and deindustrialization. Drawing on the concepts of “nostalgia” and “nostophobia,” the paper suggests that in Australia, labor history/heritage and public history are fundamentally at odds as a result of different political and economic imperatives and the recognition given to workers' collective traditions.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © International Labor and Working-Class History, Inc. 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

2. Stanton, Cathy, The Lowell Experiment: Public History in a Postindustrial City (Amherst and Boston, 2006), 45Google Scholar.

3. Samuel, Raphael, Theatres of Memory: Volume 1, Past and Present in Contemporary Culture (London, 1996), 179Google Scholar.

4. Healy, Chris, “Working for the Living Museum of the West,” in Packaging the Past? Public Histories, ed. Rickard, John and Spearritt, Peter (Melbourne, 1991), 158Google Scholar.

5. Stanton, Lowell Experiment, 26.

6. Heron, Craig, “The Labour Historian and Public History,” Labour/Le Travail 45 (2000): 187CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7. Ibid., 190. See, for examples, Stephen, Ann and Reeves, Andrew, Badges of Labour, Banners of Pride (Sydney, 1984)Google Scholar; Irving, Terry and Taksa, Lucy, Places, Protests and Memorabilia: The Labour Heritage Register of New South Wales (Sydney, 2002)Google Scholar; Radio Projects Westrail Workshops, Murdoch University Radio Web, http://www.radio.murdoch.edu.au/westrail.html, accessed July 28, 2008; Taksa, Lucy and Summer Hill Media, Steam Power: A History of the Eveleigh Railway Workshops, Video (Sydney, 2001)Google Scholar; Taksa, Lucy, “Preserving the Eveleigh Railway Workshops in Cyberspace,” Transnews, Official Journal of the Australian Services Union, NSW and ACT Services Branch (Transport Division) (1999): 1013Google Scholar; Taksa, Lucy, “Using the Information Superhighway to Interpret the Heritage of the Eveleigh Railway Workshops,” Rail and Road, The Magazine of the NSW Branch of the Rail, Tram and Bus Union 91 (1999): 1316Google Scholar.

8. Heron, “The Labour Historian,” 182.

9. Layman, Lenore, “Labour History in the Making: The Australian Scene in the 1980s and Directions for the 1990s”, in Culture and the Labour Movement, ed. Martin, John E. and Taylor, Kerry (Palmerston North, 1991), 3536, 45Google Scholar.

10. Page, Max, “Radical Public History in the City,” Radical History Review 79 (2001): 115Google Scholar.

11. Stanton, The Lowell Experiment, 24, 26.

12. Summerby-Murray, Robert, “Interpreting Deindustrialised Landscapes of Atlantic Canada: Memory and Industrial Heritage in Sackville, New Brunswick,” The Canadian Geographer/Le Géographe Canadian 46 (2002): 4950Google Scholar.

13. Samuel, Theatres of Memory, 192–197.

14. Micha F. Lindemans, “Janus,” http://www.pantheon.org/articles/j/janus.html, accessed August 25, 2006.

15. Edwards, J.A., and Llurdes-i-Coit, J.C., “Mines and Quarries,” Annals of Tourism Research 23 (1996): 342343CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

16. Leckie, Jacqueline, “The Long, Slow Haul: Issues in 20th Century Pacific Labour History”, in Pacific Islands History: Journeys and Transformations, ed. Lal, B. (Canberra, 1992), 149–66Google Scholar.

17. Price, Richard, “The Labour Process and Labour History,” Social History 8 (1983): 5775CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Zeitlan, Jonothan, “From Labour History to the History of Industrial Relations,” Economic History Review 40 (1987): 159–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar; “A Round Table: Labour, Historical Pessimism and Hegemony,” The Journal of American History 75 (1988): 115–161; Price, Richard, “What's in a Name? Workplace History and Rank and Filism,” International Review of Social History 34 (1989): 6277CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cronin, James E., “The Rank and File and the Social History of the Working Class,” International Review of Social History 34 (1989): 7888CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18. Eade, Susan, “Social History in Britain in 1976—A Survey,” Labour History 31 (1976): 3842CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Merritt, John, “Labour History,” in New History: Studying Australia Today, ed. Osborne, Graeme and Mandle, William Frederick (Sydney, 1982), 113118Google Scholar; Patmore, Greg, Australian Labour History (Melbourne, 1991), 816Google Scholar.

19. Irving, Terry, “Introduction: Labour History, Crisis and the Public Sphere,” in Challenges to Labour History, ed. Irving, Terry (Sydney, 1994), 913Google Scholar; Curthoys, Ann, “Labour History and Cultural Studies,” Labour History 67 (1994): 1215CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

20. Markey, Raymond, “Labour History and Industrial Relations in Australia,” in Contemporary Industrial Relations in Australia and New Zealand: Literature Surveys, Proceedings of the Biennial Conference of the Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand, ed. Hince, Kevin and Williams, Alan (Wellington, 1987), 169198Google Scholar; Patmore, Greg, History and Industrial Relations (Sydney, 1990)Google Scholar.

21. Gollan, R.A., “Labour History,” Bulletin of the Australian Society for the Study of Labour History (ASSLH) 1 (1962): 34Google Scholar.

22. Roberts, Alan, “The Development of Australian Oral History, 1798–1984,” Oral History Association of Australia Journal 7 (1985): 11Google Scholar; Waters, Edgar, “Industrial Folk Song,” Labour History 7 (1964): 59CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23. Pascoe, Rob, The Manufacture of Australian History (Melbourne, 1979), 4850Google Scholar.

24. Ward, Russel, “The Australian Legend Re-Visited,” Historical Studies 18 (1978): 180CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25. Waters, “Industrial Folk Song,” 118; Merritt, “Labour History,” 124.

26. See generally Bulletin, ASSLH, 1962–1964.

27. Patmore, Australian Labour History, 8–12; Merritt, “Labour History,” 122–38.

28. Braverman, Harry, Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century (New York & London, 1974)Google Scholar; Patmore, Greg, “Systematic Management and Bureaucracy: The NSW Railways Prior to 1932,” Labour and Industry 1 (1988): 306321CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Taksa, Lucy, “Scientific Management: Technique or Cultural Ideology?Journal of Industrial Relations 34 (1992): 365395CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29. Lowenstein, Wendy and Loh, Morag, The Immigrants (Melbourne, 1977)Google Scholar; McGrath, Ann, Born in the Cattle: Aborigines in Cattle Country (Sydney, 1987)Google Scholar.

30. McCalman, Janet, Struggletown, Public and Private Life in Richmond 1900–1965 (Melbourne, 1984)Google Scholar; Lowenstein, Wendy, Weevils in the Flour: An Oral Record of the 1930s Depression in Australia (Melbourne, 1983)Google Scholar; Lowenstein, Wendy and Hills, Tom, Under the Hook, Melbourne Waterside Workers Remember Working Lives and Class War: 1900–1980 (Melbourne, 1982)Google Scholar; Adam-Smith, Patsy, The Shearers (Melbourne, 1982)Google Scholar.

31. Burgmann, Verity and Lee, Jenny, Staining the Wattle: A People's History of Australia (Melbourne, 1988)Google Scholar.

32. Kirby, Sandy, Artists and Unions: A Critical Tradition, Report On the Art & Working Life Program (Sydney, 1992), 12Google Scholar.

33. Ibid., 10–11; Bower, Ros, “The Arts at the Workplace,” Caper: Community Arts Board, Australia Council 5 (1980): 1Google Scholar; Mills, Debra, “All Those in Favour,” in Industrial Issues and Cultural Tools: Papers and Proceedings of the 2nd National Art and Working Life Conference, 1990 (Redfern, 1991), 5Google Scholar; Reeves, Andrew, A Tapestry of Australia: The Sydney Wharfies Mural (Sydney Port, 1992), 910Google Scholar.

34. Reeves, A Tapestry, 6–8, 12.

35. Kirby, Artists and Unions, 12.

36. Bower, “The Arts,” 2.

37. Anon, ., “Art and Working Life Program,” Arts Facts (Sydney, 1989)Google Scholar.

38. Cassidy, Stephen, “Art and Working Life In Australia,” Report: Australia Council (Sydney, 1984)Google Scholar.

39. Ibid., 7–17; The Workers' Cultural Action Committee of Newcastle, “Working Class, Working Culture,” Caper 19 (1984): 2–29.

40. John K. Lesses, “Strengthening Links with the Broader Community,” in Industrial Issues and Cultural Tools, 10–12; James Robertson, “Engaging the Broader Community in Labour Day Celebrations as Part of an Advocacy Strategy for the Trade Union Movement,” in Industrial Issues and Cultural Tools, 12–13; Tom Barton, “Community Development as the Basis for a Trade Union Arts Program—and its Implications for Recruitment,” in Industrial Issues and Cultural Tools, 14–16.

41. Barton, “Community Development,” 15–16.

42. Taksa, Lucy, “The Industrial History of South Sydney,” Pictures for Cities Exhibition Catalogue (Sydney, 1984), 1421Google Scholar; Layman, Lenore and Goddard, Julian, Organise! Labour: A Visual Record (Perth, 1988)Google Scholar; Zubrycki, Tom, History of the Australian Trade Union Movement, Video (Sydney, 1988)Google Scholar funded by Film Australia, the Australian Bicentennial Authority, and the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU); Stephen and Reeves, Badges of Labour.

43. Taksa, Lucy, “The Promotion of Working Class Culture: Arts and Working Life in the NSW Railways,” The Hummer 17 (1987): 26Google Scholar.

44. Cassidy, Art and Working Life, 20.

45. Hearn, Mark, Working Lives: A History of the Australian Railways Union, NSW Branch (Sydney, 1990), 14Google Scholar.

46. Irving, Terry, “Editorial: How to Save the Butlin Archives,” Labour History 73 (1997): vviiGoogle Scholar.

47. High, Steven, Corporate Wasteland: The Landscape and Memory of Deindustrialization (Cornell, 2007)Google Scholar; High, Steven, “Deindustrialization in Canada,” Urban History Review/Revue d'histoire urbaine 35 (2007), 213Google Scholar; Newsletter of the Westrail Workshops [Midland] History Project: 1.2 (2000); Oliver, Bobbie and Bertola, Patrick, The History of the Westrail Midland Railway Workshops (Crawley, 2006)Google Scholar; Taksa, Lucy, “Machines and Ghosts: Politics, Industrial Heritage and the History of Working Life at the New South Wales Eveleigh Railway Workshops,” Labour History, 85 (2003): 6588CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

48. Irving, “Introduction: Labour History,” 3, 9–13.

49. Layman, “Labour History,” 36.

50. Rickard and Spearritt, Packaging the Past.

51. Graeme Davison, “Paradigms of Public History,” in Rickard and Spearritt, Packaging the Past, 8.

52. Ibid., 9–10.

53. Barblan, Marc-A. and Riva, Mauro, “The Industrial Heritage Centre: an Original Venture in Geneva,” Museum 36 (1984): 65Google Scholar; Peter Spearritt, “Money, Taste and Industrial Heritage,” in Packaging the Past, ed. Rickard and Spearritt, 34–5.

54. Colley, Sarah, Uncovering Australia: Archaeology, Indigenous People and the Public (North Sydney, 2002), 17, 24–25, 58Google Scholar; Spearritt, “Money, Taste,” 35, 37; Davison, “Paradigms,” 8; Nankervis, Max, “Some Recent Directions in the Conservation of the Built Environment,” Journal of Australian Studies 30 (1991): 52Google Scholar.

55. Stuart, Ian, “Stranger in a Strange Land: Historical Archaeology and History in Post Contact Australia,” Public History Review 1 (1992): 140Google Scholar; Cutcliffe, Stephen H. and Lubar, Steven, “The Challenge of Industrial History Museums,” The Public Historian 22 (2000): 16CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

56. Barblan and Riva, “The Industrial Heritage Centre,” 65; Wallace, Terry, “Working of the Train Gang: Alienation, Liminality and Communitas in the UK Preserved Railway Sector,” International Journal of Heritage Studies 12 (2006): 220CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57. Frisch, Michael, A Shared Authority: Essays on the Craft and Meaning of Oral and Public History (Albany, 1990), 188Google Scholar; Summerby-Murray, “Interpreting Deindustrialised Landscapes,” 50. Also see: Frisch, Michael, “De-, Re-, and Post-Industrialization: Industrial Heritage as Contested Memorial Terrain,” Journal of Folklore Research 35 (1998): 241–49Google Scholar.

58. Lowenthal, David, The Past is a Foreign Country (Cambridge, 1990), 10Google Scholar.

59. Ibid., 4.

60. Ibid., 11.

61. Ibid., 8.

62. Hopkins, Anthony G., “Introduction: Globalization—An Agenda for Historians,” in Globalization in World History, ed. Hopkins, Anthony G. (London, 2002), 2, 68Google Scholar.

63. Holmes, David, “Virtual globalization—an introduction,” in Virtual Globalization: Virtual Spaces/Tourist Spaces, ed. Holmes, David (London, 2001), 1Google Scholar; Martin, Cindy, “Gasworks Sparks Village for 5,000,” The Sun-Herald November 12, 2000:70Google Scholar; Radford, Anthony, “New Recipe for Old Arnott's site,” The Inner Western Suburbs Courier, 116 (2000):1Google Scholar; Creagh, Sunanda, “Battle Stations for Eveleigh,” Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) August 2–3, 2008, 11Google Scholar.

64. Lowenthal, The Past, 399. See, for example: “Lithgow Shows its Metal,” The Daily Telegraph, April 26, 2001, 13; Elliott, Lyla, “‘Derailed’: The Closure of the Midland Workshops,” in The Workshops: A History of the Midland Government Railway Workshops, ed. Bertola, Patrick and Oliver, Bobbie (Crawley, 2006), 235258Google Scholar.

65. Wallace, Mike, Mickey Mouse History and Other Essays on American Memory (Philadelphia, 1996), 2526Google Scholar.

66. Layman, “Labour History,” 45.

67. Evans, Kathryn, “Nostalgia, Sepia and Design: Producing the Past in the Australian Women's Weekly,” Public History Review 2 (1993): 6869Google Scholar.

68. Davison, Graeme, The Use and Abuse of Australian History (Sydney, 2000), 116Google Scholar.

69. Davis, Fred, Yearning for Yesterday: The Sociology of Nostalgia (New York, 1979)Google Scholar; Gabriel, Yiannis, “Organizational Nostalgia—Reflections on ‘The Golden Age,’” in Emotion in Organizations, ed. Fineman, Stephen (London, 1993), 121Google Scholar; Strangleman, Tim, Work Identity at the End of the Line? Privatisation and Culture Change in the UK Rail Industry (Basingstoke, 2004), 108Google Scholar.

70. Strangleman, Tim, “The Nostalgia of Organisations and the Organisation of Nostalgia: Past and Present in the Contemporary Railway Industry,” Sociology 33 (1999): 729–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tim E. Strangleman, “Railing Against the Past? History, Heritage and Work in the UK Railway Industry,” Manchester International Centre for Labour Studies, Working Paper 23 (1998), 6–10.

71. Strangleman, Work Identity, 109.

72. Strangleman, “Railing Against the Past?” 11; Strangleman, “The Nostalgia of Organisations,” 728.

73. Strangleman, Work Identity, 110.

74. Summerby-Murray, “Interpreting Deindustrialised Landscapes,” 49–50.

75. The Register of the National Estate, “Eveleigh Railway Workshops,” registered April 26, 1988, http://www.ahc.gov.au/register, accessed February 23, 2006.

76. Register of the National Estate Database, Database Number 015903, File Number 1/2/033/0014; NSW State Heritage Inventory.

77. Don Godden & Associates, A Heritage Study of Eveleigh Railway Workshops (Sydney, 1986); Godden Mackay Pty Ltd, White Bay to Blackwattle Bay, Central to Eveleigh Heritage Study (Sydney, 1990); Schwager Brooks and Partners, Eveleigh Precinct Conservation Policy (Sydney, 1993); Wendy Thorpe, Heritage Assessment: Archaeological Resources, in Australian Technology Park Master Plan Site Eveleigh (Sydney, 1994); Heritage Group State Projects Division of NSW Department of Public Works and Services (NSW DW & S), Eveleigh Railway Yards Locomotive Workshops Conservation Management Plan, (Sydney, 1995); Godden Mackay, Eveleigh Workshops Management Plan for Moveable Items and Social History (Sydney, 1996); Paul Rappaport, Chief Mechanical Engineer's Building: 327 Wilson Street, Chippendale, Eveleigh Locomotive Workshops Conservation Management Plan (Sydney, 1997); Heritage Group, NSW DW & S, Eveleigh Carriage Workshops: Conservation Analysis, (Sydney, 1999); Simpson Dawbin, Large Erecting Shop Conservation Management Plan (Sydney, 2003).

78. The University of Sydney, the University of NSW, and the University of Technology, Sydney.

79. Brennan, Walter, “On the Track of New Technology: Redfern Railway Shed Hosts Info Superhighway,” Sunday Telegraph, June 30, 1996: 50Google Scholar; NSW Department of Planning, Building Better Cities: A Newsletter for Eveleigh, 2 (1993), 3 (1994), 5 (1995); Farrelly, E.M., “Home for Technology Confounds Pessimists,” SMH, August 6, 1996: 16Google Scholar.

80. Peter Emmett and Gary Warner, Eveleigh Locomotive Workshop Interpretation Design Concept and Plan (Sydney, 1998); Paul Davies, Eveleigh Carriage Works Interpretation Plan (Sydney, 2000).

81. NSW DW & S, Conservation Management Plan; Lucy Taksa, Social History, Oral Transcripts, Photographic Collection, in Godden Mackay, Management Plan for Moveable Items, Vol.s II, IV, V.

82. Sunanda Creagh, “Anvil chorus sparks an overwrought row,” SMH, August 8, 2008: 7; http://www.redwatch.org.au/RWA/statesignificant/atp/blacksmith/080822min/?searchterm=wrought, accessed 20 December 2008.

84. Jamal, Nadia, “Railyards Brought Back to Life under Eveleigh Facelift,” SMH, April 24, 2001Google Scholar; Hallett, Bryce, “Railyard Becomes Arts Central as Theatre Companies Roll In,” SMH, March 21, 2002Google Scholar; O'Rourke, C., “Rail Workshop to Become Platform for Inner City Hub,” SMH, July 26–27, 2003Google Scholar; Bryce Hallett; Jopson, D. and Ryle, G., “Bold Vision for Technology Park Blurred in a Haze of Debt,” and “Goodbye to History—Heritage Laws Won't Apply Here,” SMH, November 29, 2004Google Scholar.

85. Taksa, Lucy, “Pumping the Life-Blood into Politics and Place: Labour Culture and the Eveleigh Railway Workshops,” Labour History 79 (2000): 1134CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Taksa, Lucy, “The Material Culture of an Industrial Artifact: Interpreting Control, Defiance and Everyday Resistance at the New South Wales Eveleigh Railway Workshops,” Historical Archaeology 34 (2005): 827CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86. Redfern Waterloo Authority Update Newsletter, (2005): 4; http://www.redfernwaterloo.nsw.gov.au/other/newsletters/september05_newsletter.pdf, accessed March 15, 2007.

89. Young, Linda, “Launceston Railway Workshops: Tasmania's Engineering Heritage,” in Industrial Heritage Special Issue, Locality 10 (1999): 10, 14Google Scholar; Bicentennial Oral History Project, Queen Victoria Museum and Art Gallery (Launceston, 1988).

91. Ann Blake, “Shakespeare Notes from a Small Island,” http://home.vicnet.net.au/~bard/S'peare%20Notes%20Small%20Island.htm, accessed March 16, 2007.

92. http://www.qvmag.tas.gov.au, accessed March 16, 2007.

93. Samuel, Theatres of Memory, 303; Summerby-Murray, “Interpreting Deindustrialised Landscapes,” 50.

94. Shire of Swan, Westrail and the WA Department of Planning and Urban Development, Midland Railway Workshops Site Conservation Policy (Perth, 1994).

95. Perth Branch ASSLH, “Westrail Midland Workshops Labour History Project Visitors' Day Sunday 21 March 1999,” Pamphlet (Perth, n.d); Byrne, Neil, “Westrail Workshops (Midland) History Project,” Labour History Newsletter 1 (1999): 67Google Scholar; Echo, 14 (1999).

96. Correspondence, Janis Bailey (Secretary Perth Branch ASSLH) to Lucy Taksa, November 3, 1999; Byrne, Neil, “Westrail Workshops (Midland) History Project”, Labour History Newsletter, 1 (1999): 1213Google Scholar; Midland Redevelopment Authority (MRA), The Midlander, Summer 2001.

97. MRA, The Midlander, Winter 2001.

98. Westrail Workshops [Midland] History Project, Vol. 1, No. 1, March 2001: 1–2; MRA, The Midlander, Summer 2002; West Australian Government Media Statement, “Wall of names to honour workshops workers,” October 18, 2002; West Australian Government Media Statement, “Artworks interpret the stories from the historic Midland Railway Workshop site,” December 11, 2002.

99. http://www.midlandworkshops.org.au/, accessed March 26, 2007.

100. Ric McCracken, correspondence with Lucy Taksa, March 26, 2007.

101. http://www.midlandworkshops.org.au/, accessed March 24, 2007.

102. The Queensland Heritage Trails Network contributed $AUS15 million to the museum development. Greg Hallam, The North Ipswich Railway Workshops: Brisbane History Group Visit, November 21, 1999, Unpublished Paper, 1–3; “The Workshops Rail Museum Queensland, Ipswich,” http://www.heritagetrails.qld.gov.au/attractions/ipswich2.html, accessed December 18, 2003.

103. The Queensland Museum—The Workshops Rail Museum: http://www.qmuseum.qld.gov.au/campuses/theworkshops.asp, accessed August 5, 2003.

105. ‘ALL ABOARD FOR BIG LOUD FUN! The Workshops Museum Ipswich – QLD: http://wwwgeriantics.com.au/editorials/238_rail_museum.html, accessed August 5, 2003.

109. Murphy, Dennis J., The Big Strikes, Queensland 1889–1965 (St. Lucia, 1983)Google Scholar; Cribb, Margaret, “State in Emergency: The Queensland Railway Strike of 1948,” Labour History 24 (1973): 225248CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

110. Samuel, Theatres of Memory, 306; Wallace, Mickey Mouse History, 88–114; Wallace, “Working of the Train Gang,” 220; Prentice, Richard R., Witt, Stephen F., Hamer, Claire, “Tourism as Experience: The Case of Heritage Parks,” Annals of Tourism Research 25 (1998): 124CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

111. Lowenthal, David, Possessed by the Past: The Heritage Crusade and the Spoils of History (New York, 1996), 12Google Scholar; Samuel, Theatres of Memory, 266, 306; Summerby-Murray, “Interpreting Deindustrialised Landscapes,” 58; Wallace, Mickey Mouse History, 26, 89.

112. Wallace, Mickey Mouse History, x.

113. Lowenthal, The Past, 240.

114. Frisch, A Shared Authority, 188.

115. Frisch, “De-, Re-, and Post-Industrialization,” 248.

116. Summerby-Murray, “Interpreting Deindustrialised Landscapes,” 50.