Online ordering is currently unavailable due to technical issues. We apologise for any delays responding to customers while we resolve this. For further updates please visit our website: https://www.cambridge.org/news-and-insights/technical-incident
We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 November 2020
For some years, the historiography on Francoist violence has engaged with debates developed by European scholars on the importance of citizen collaboration in authoritarian regimes. In some cases, denunciations made by ‘ordinary men’ have been quantified to establish the extent of violence in everyday life, without taking other qualitative criteria into account. This article explores the importance of urban criteria such as neighbourhood, sociability and mobility in the scope of Francoist violence, taking the military occupation of Madrid at the end of the Spanish Civil War as a case-study.
This research was carried out with the support of the project ‘La sociedad urbana en España, 1860–1983. De los ensanches a las áreas metropolitanas, cambio social y modernización’ (PGC2018-096461-B-C41). A first version of this text was discussed at ‘Séminaire d'histoire des mondes ibériques et ibéroaméricains’ (Université Toulouse – Jean Jaurès). I am thankful to François Godicheau for his comments then and to the seminar ‘Lecturas del mundo urbano’ (Universidad Complutense de Madrid) for some ‘refreshing references’ shared in the distance. I am deeply grateful to Chema Sánchez Laforet for his constant and precious help with mapping.
1 Foxá, A. de, Madrid, de corte a checa (Madrid, 1973), 78Google Scholar.
2 A. Pérez-Olivares, ‘La victoria bajo control. Ocupación, orden público y orden social en el Madrid franquista’, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, doctoral thesis, 2017, 62–98, available online at https://eprints.ucm.es/45481/1/T39392.pdf.
3 Martin, N., Haughton, T. and Purseigle, P. (eds.), Aftermath. Legacies and Memories of War in Europe, 1918–1945–1989 (Aldershot, 2014)Google Scholar.
4 Silva, D. Oviedo, ‘Denuncias y prácticas acusatorias en el Madrid bélico: los Comités de Vecinos’, in Bravo, G. Gómez (ed.), Asedio. Historia de Madrid en la guerra civil (1936–1939) (Madrid, 2017), 367–401Google Scholar; and Herrera, F. Jiménez, ‘Detrás del “Terror Rojo”. Los comités madrileños durante el verano-otoño de 1936’, in Silva, D. Oviedo and Pérez-Olivares, A. (eds.), Madrid, una ciudad en guerra (1936–1948) (Madrid, 2016), 27–72Google Scholar.
5 Anderson, P., ‘In the interests of justice? Grass-roots prosecution and collaboration in Francoist military trials, 1939–1945’, Contemporary European History, 18 (2008), 25–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bravo, G. Gómez and Marco, J., La obra del miedo. Violencia y sociedad en la España franquista (1936–1950) (Barcelona, 2011)Google Scholar.
6 Johnson, E., ‘German women and Nazi justice: their role in the process from denunciation to death’, Historical Social Research, 20 (1995), 33–69Google Scholar; Anderson, P., ‘Singling out victims: denunciation and collusion in the post-Civil War Francoist repression in Spain, 1939–1945’, European History Quarterly, 39 (2009), 7–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gellately, R., ‘Denunciation in twentieth-century Germany: aspects of self-policing in the Third Reich and the German Democratic Republic’, in Fitzpatrick, S. and Gellately, R. (eds.), Accusatory Practices. Denunciation in Modern European History, 1789–1989 (Chicago, 1997), 121–52Google Scholar.
7 Gross, J.T., Neighbors. The Destruction of the Jewish Community in Jedwabne, Poland (Princeton, 2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Andrés, C. Gil, ‘Vecinos contra vecinos. La violencia en la retaguardia riojana durante la Guerra Civil’, Historia y Política, 16 (2006), 109–30Google Scholar; Dunnage, J., ‘Surveillance and denunciation in fascist Siena, 1927–1943’, European History Quarterly, 38 (2009), 244–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
8 Graham-Dixon, F., The Allied Occupation of Germany. The Refugee Crisis, Denazification and the Path to Reconstruction (London, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Romijn, P., ‘“Liberators and patriots”. Military interim rule and the politics of transition in Netherlands, 1944–1945’, in Hoffmann, S.-L., Kott, S., Romijn, P. and Wieviorka, O. (eds.), Seeking Peace in the Wake of War. Europe, 1943–1947 (Amsterdam, 2015), 117–44Google Scholar; Tönsmeyer, T., Haslinger, P. and Laba, A., Coping with Hunger and Shortage under German Occupation in World War II (Basingstoke, 2018)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
9 Carlton, E., Occupation. The Policies and Practices of Military Conquerors (London, 1992)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hills, A., Policing Post-Conflict Cities (London, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10 I.N. Gregory and A. Geddes, Toward Spatial Humanities. Historical GIS & Spatial History (Indiana, 2014).
11 Santiáñez, N., Topographies of Fascism. Habitus, Space, and Writing in Twentieth-Century Spain (Toronto, 2013), 219–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Viejo-Rose, D., Reconstructing Spain. Cultural Heritage and Memory after Civil War (Brighton, 2011), 63–93Google Scholar; Muñoz-Rojas, O., Ashes and Granite. Destruction and Reconstruction in the Spanish Civil War and its Aftermath (Brighton, 2011), 41–70Google Scholar.
12 For the analytical relevance of mapping, see Roger, R. and Rau, S., ‘Thinking spatially: new horizons for urban history’, Urban History, 47 (2020), 372–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 Trigueros, R. Pallol, El Ensanche Norte. Chamberí, 1860–1931. Un Madrid moderno (Madrid, 2015)Google Scholar. For the quantitative importance of the district, see Crespo, V. Pinto (Dir.), Madrid: atlas histórico de la ciudad, 1850–1939 (Barcelona, 2001), 271Google Scholar.
14 Quero, C. Hernández and Trigueros, R. Pallol, ‘Suburbios rebeldes. Fragmentación y desborde social en la huelga de 1917 en Madrid’, Historia Social, 94 (2019), 47–69Google Scholar; Quero, C. Hernández and De La Cruz Salanova, L., ‘Cuando los suburbios dejaron de ser periferia. La lucha por el control de la calle en el Madrid de los años 1930’, Rubrica Contemporanea, 8 (2019), 67–86Google Scholar.
15 Edicto de la Auditoría de Guerra del Ejército de Ocupación, 30/III/1939, in ABC, 1/IV/1939.
16 Pérez-Olivares, A., ‘Objetivo Madrid: planes de ocupación y concepción del orden público durante la Guerra Civil española’, Culture & History Digital Journal, 4 (2015)Google Scholar, available online at http://cultureandhistory.revistas.csic.es/index.php/cultureandhistory/article/view/84/276.
17 Bando de Espinosa de los Monteros, 29/III/1939, in ABC, 30/III/1939.
18 G. Agamben, What Is an Apparatus? And Other Essays (Stanford, 2009).
19 D. Oviedo Silva,‘“Juro por Dios y declaro por mi honor”: verdad, impostura y estrategias autoexculpatorias en las declaraciones de la posguerra madrileña’, in Oviedo Silva and Pérez-Olivares (eds.), Madrid, 159–214. For an analysis of the questionnaires and their consequences on the micro-level scale, see Silva, D. Oviedo and Pérez-Olivares, A., ‘¿Un tiempo de silencio? Porteros, inquilinos y fomento de la denuncia en el Madrid ocupado’, Studia Historica. Historia Contemporánea, 34 (2016), 301–31Google Scholar.
20 Sampson, R.J., Great American City. Chicago and the Enduring Neighborhood Effect (Chicago, 2010)Google Scholar. Concierges were also demanded to collaborate with occupation authorities in Nazi Paris. See D. Rosbottom, When Paris Went Dark. The City of Light under German Occupation, 1940–44 (London, 2014), 168–70.
21 Oviedo Silva and Pérez-Olivares, ‘¿Un tiempo de silencio?’.
22 Pérez-Olivares, ‘La victoria’, 190–4. For further references on urban middle-class members in wartime, see J. Lawrence, ‘Material pressures on the middle classes’, in J. Winter and J.-L. Robert (eds.), Capital Cities at War. Paris, London, Berlin, 1914–1919 (Cambridge, 1997), 229–54.
23 Archivo General Militar de Ávila (AGMAV), Caja 4130, Carpeta 17, fol. 1, and Carpeta 18, fol. 3. For Paris’ case, see R. Vinen, The Unfree French. Life under the Occupation (London, 2006), 23–5. For the Jewish Quartier in Amsterdam during German occupation, see J. Presser, Ashes in the Wind. The Destruction of Dutch Jewry (Detroit, 1998), 45–57.
24 G. Eley and K. Nield, The Future of Class in History. What's Left of the Social? (Ann Arbor, 2007), 167.
25 Archivo de la Villa de Madrid (AVM), Estadística, Padrón de Chamberí, 1930, barrio de Hipódromo.
26 Archivo Histórico Nacional (AHN), FC-Causa General, 1357, 3, fols. 109 and 154.
27 For Francoism, see Oviedo Silva and Pérez-Olivares, ‘¿Un tiempo?’. For other contexts, see for instance Eley, G., ‘Hitler's silent majority? Conformity and resistance under the Third Reich (part two)’, Michigan Quarterly Review, 42 (2003), 389–425Google Scholar.
28 AHN, FC-Causa General, 1357, 4, fols. 562 and 566, and AHN, FC-Causa General, 1357, 3, fol. 146. For the important role played by information services in the rearguard, see C. Píriz, ‘Los servicios de información franquistas en la capital’, in Gómez Bravo (ed.), Asedio, 139–68. For the domestic service, see Gómez Bravo and Marco, La obra, 192.
29 AHN, FC-Causa General, 1357, 3, fol. 114.
30 AHN, FC-Causa General, 1357, 4, fols. 578 and 580.
31 V.A. Kozlov, ‘Denunciation and its functions in Soviet governance: a study of denunciations and their bureaucratic handling from Soviet Police Archives, 1944–1953’, in Fitzpatrick and Gellately (eds.), Accusatory Practices, 121–52.
32 For the figures, see AGMAV, Caja 2913, Carpeta 9. For the report, see Archivo General Histórico de la Defensa (AGHD), Sumario 13769, Legajo 4110. I follow this reference unless otherwise stated.
33 See more about this in A. Pérez-Olivares, Victoria y control en el Madrid ocupado. Los del Europa (1939–1946) (Madrid, 2018).
34 J. Lawrence, ‘Public space, political space’, in J. Winter and J.-L. Robert (eds.), Capital Cities at War. Paris, London, Berlin: 1914–1919, vol. II: A Cultural History (Cambridge, 2007), 280–312.
35 P. Gil Vico, ‘Derecho y ficción: la represión judicial militar’, in F. Espinosa Maestre (ed.), Violencia roja y azul. España, 1936–1950 (Barcelona, 2010), 251–368.
36 Fox, A., ‘Rumour, news and popular political opinion in Elizabethan and early Stuart England’, Historical Journal, 40 (1997), 597–620CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
37 Jerram, L., ‘Space, a useless category for historical analysis?’, History and Theory, 52 (2013), 400–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For further references on working-class and militancy spatial analysis, see J.L. Oyón, La quiebra de la ciudad popular: espacio urbano, inmigración y anarquismo en la Barcelona de entreguerras, 1914–1936 (Barcelona, 2008); C. Ealham, Anarchism in the City. Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Barcelona, 1898–1937 (Chico, CA, 2010).
38 J. Ruiz, Franco's Justice. Repression in Madrid after the Spanish Civil War (Oxford, 2005), 64. For prisons in post-war Madrid, see F. Hernández Holgado, ‘La prisión militante: las cárceles franquistas de mujeres de Barcelona y Madrid’, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, doctoral thesis, 2011, 162, available online at https://eprints.ucm.es/13798/.
39 For France, see R. Gildea, Marianne in Chains. In Search of the German Occupation (1940–1945) (London, 2002), 65–88; and Vinen, The Unfree French, 99–132. For the Netherlands, see G. Meershoek, ‘The Amsterdam Police and the persecution of the Jews’, in M. Berenbaum and A. Peck (eds.), The Holocaust and History. The Known, the Unknown, the Disputed and the Reexamined (Bloomington, 1998), 284–300; and M. Croes, ‘The Dutch Police Force and the persecution of the Jews in the Netherlands’, in B. De Wever, H. Van Goethem and N. Wounters (eds.), Local Government in Occupied Europe (1939–1945) (Amsterdam, 2006), 67–82.
40 ABC, 1/IV/1939; AGMAV, Caja 4130, Carpetas 17 and 18.
41 H. Lefebvre, The Production of Space (Oxford, 1991), 271–5; E. Cromier, ‘The street’, in Winter and Robert (eds.), Capital Cities, 57–104.
42 AGMAV, Caja 2552, Carpeta 45, in ABC, 4/IV/1939.
43 AVM, Actas 746, R. 860/86, Sesión extraordinaria 30 marzo 1939.
44 Boletín Oficial del Estado, n° 137, 17/V/1939.
45 Bando de 29/III/1939, in ABC, 30/III/1939.
46 Pérez-Olivares, ‘La victoria’, 251–67; Laub, T.J., After the Fall. German Policy in Occupied France, 1940–1944 (New York, 2010), 196–219Google Scholar; Romijn, P., ‘Managing the integration of the occupied Dutch territories in Hitler's empire’, in Eigner, P., Matis, H. and Resch, A. (eds.), Entrepeneurship in schwierigen Zeiten. Unternehmertuum, Karrieren und Umbrüche während der ersten Hälfte des 20. Jahrhunderts (Münster, 2013), 309–30Google Scholar.
47 de Molina, M. González and Toledo, V.M., The Social Metabolism. A Socio-Ecological Theory of Historical Change (New York, 2014), 87–106Google Scholar and 197–253. For the Francoist supply system in Madrid, see Pérez-Olivares, A., ‘Abastacer, racionar…Y pasar hambre. Franquismo y control social en la posguerra’, in Blanco, M. Ángel Del Arco (ed.), Los años del hambre. Historia y memoria de la posguerra franquista (Madrid, 2020), 173–93Google Scholar.
48 AGHD, Sumario 109268, Legajo 7062. I follow this reference unless otherwise stated.
49 Schaepdrijver, S. De, ‘Populations under occupation’, in Winter, J. (ed.), The Cambridge History of the First World War, vol. III: Civil Society (Cambridge, 2014), 242–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
50 Lewis, R., ‘Comments on urban agency: relational space and intentionality’, Urban History, 44 (2017), 137–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Garrett, B.L., Explore Everything. Place-Hacking the City (London, 2013)Google Scholar.
51 Which is defined as ‘urban spatial culture’ in Griffiths, S. and Vaughan, L., ‘Mapping spatial cultures: contributions of space syntax to research in the urban history of the nineteenth-century city’, Urban History, 47 (2020), 488–511CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
52 AGMAV, Caja 2552, Carpeta 44, and Caja 4130, Carpeta 17, fol. 4. During the Nazi occupation of Paris, the subway was also carefully monitored by German authorities. See Rosbottom, When Paris Went Dark, 182–6.
