Abstracts of World Health Organization Emergency Medical Teams Global Meeting 2022
Meeting Abstracts
Cultural Awareness in Emergency Response Teams: Assessment of Cultural Competencies Knowledge and Training
- Fadi S. Issa, Amalia Voskanyan, Alexander Hart, Christina Woodward, Robert Ciottone, Gregory R. Ciottone
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s91
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
WHO EMTs play an important role in providing assistance and health care services to countries hit by an emergency or a natural disaster. Therefore, EMTs are subjected to vastly different cultures from various countries, meaning they require training to cultural awareness, an understanding and acceptance of the languages, beliefs, cultures, and morals of those receiving care. The World Health Organization (WHO) has published minimum standards for Emergency Medical Teams (EMTs), which briefly mention that the senior EMT team member must have some knowledge of cultural awareness. However, there is no requirement for cultural awareness training for EMTs prior to responding to disasters.
Objectives:The goal of this study is to determine the presence of cultural awareness training, and if present, what are the competencies covered by the training for the WHO EMTs.
Method/Description:A survey will be distributed to Accredited WHO EMTs to capture the presence for cultural awareness training and the core competencies of the existing training.
Results/Outcomes:Data expected to be collected and analyzed by October 1, 2022.
Conclusion:Cultural awareness training is a crucial and beneficial skill for EMTs while deploying internationally. For WHO EMTs, it is essential to respond internationally in an accepted and ethical manner; cultural awareness training should be a requirement for all teams deploying to a foreign country. A cultural awareness curriculum will create more efficient EMTs that provide effective aid to countries in need.
The Taal Volcano Eruption and Landfall of Super Typhoon Odette: A Dilogy of Disasters in the Philippines, An Abstract on the Response Strategies of Dr. Jose N. Rodriguez Memorial Hospital and Sanitarium-Philippine Emergency Medical Assistance Team (DJNRMHS PEMAT) for the TAAL and DINAGAT Missions in the Years 2020 and 2021
- Gian Carla D. Cabrera, Alma P. Gamboa, Eric John D. Capito, Alfonso Victorino H. Famaran
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s92
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The country’s location makes it vulnerable to natural disasters, hence, the PEMAT’s potential was tested during local disaster response for Taal Volcano Eruption in Batangas last January 2020 and during the aftermath of Super Typhoon Odette in Dinagat Islands last December 2021, amidst COVID-19 surge.
Objectives:The primary objective of the deployment was to augment the DOH in the provision of safe, effective, and efficient quality health care services appropriate to the victims’ needs, timely, and coordinated mobilization of DJNRMHS PEMAT, and to evaluate the knowledge and skills acquired in the EMT Basic induction course in disaster response.
Method/Description:As per WHO standards, disaster responses conducted by the DJNRMHS PEMAT followed three important phases: pre-mobilization, mobilization, and post-mobilization. The methods used during these phases in Taal and Dinagat missions were the simulation of drills and application of didactics learnt from the EMT Basic Induction Course for Disaster Response conducted by the DOH in collaboration with WHO in 2019.
Results/Outcomes:The essential services rendered by DJNRMHS PEMAT, ensuring patient and responder safety despite being at the height of COVID-19 surge, were out-patient, acute emergency, trauma and basic obstetric care, basic laboratory, social welfare, public health, and pharmaceutical to 1,124 victims in the Taal Eruption and 1,089 victims of Typhoon Odette.
Conclusion:Safe and effective delivery of quality health care services by PEMAT, a team equipped with knowledge and skills acquired through mentorship, can be achieved with thorough planning, setting of mission objectives, and most importantly, having full support from the management and all stakeholders.
Development and Evaluation of E-Learning Tool for Humanitarian Public Health Training
- Awsan Bahattab, Omar Zain, Monica Linty, Ives Hubloue, Francesco Della Corte, Luca Ragazzoni
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s93
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The humanitarian health field has grown rapidly in the last decades. However, education and training programs are still limited in number, especially where it is needed most. Additionally, the cost of the training is too expensive for local humanitarian health respondents. If developed appropriately, E-Learning can potentially address these gaps.
Objectives:Develop an effective E-Learning tool for humanitarian public health training.
Method/Description:The tool was developed using an institutional-based, action research method. Rapid prototyping - a modified analysis, design, development, implementation, and evaluation (ADDIE) model - was used to identify the content and instructional design. This iterative process involved consultations and feedback from public health and disaster medicine instructors and students at different levels and training programs. Different methods were used to collect and analyze data, such as literature and courses reviews, observation, interviews, and questionnaires.
Results/Outcomes:Four scenario-based E-Simulations - targeting entry-level humanitarian health professionals - were developed and piloted based on identified needs. Formative evaluation clarified training objectives and structure. Trainees were satisfied by the simulated scenario, interactivity, questions, and timely feedback. Poor internet was identified as a potential barrier to delivering the training in the humanitarian context.
Conclusion:Clear objectives and quality content are the prerequisites for training effectiveness. Yet, instructional design is a critical element that can enhance training effectiveness. The tool’s offline mode is being adapted to improve access in poor internet connection settings. A summative evaluation will be conducted to measure the training’s effectiveness. Furthermore, successful factors in instructional design will be used to inform the development of advanced training in the field.
Fiji Emergency Medical Assistance Team’s (FEMAT) Response to Tropical Cyclone Yasa, Fiji
- Jese R. Vatukela
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s94
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Tropical Cyclone Yasa made landfall on Fiji’s main islands as a Category 5 cyclone on December 17, 2020 causing an immense impact on the health system with damages to health infrastructure amounting to 1.2 million USD.1 FEMAT was activated to assess and assist with disaster response in the greatly impacted Northern and Eastern Divisions of Fiji.
Objectives:To describe FEMAT’s response to Tropical Cyclone Yasa.
Method/Description:FEMAT’s response to TC Yasa included community assessments, provision of medical supplies and temporary tents for health facilities, and coordinating the distribution of WASH kits. FEMAT’s Health Emergency Response Team (HERT) was mobilized and provided surveillance support and medical care in Evacuation Centers (EC) treating the injured and sick. Health inspectors were deployed with FEMAT to provide food safety surveillance and management of dead animals near and in water sources.
Results/Outcomes:Four mobile FEMAT teams were deployed during the TC Yasa response for 17 days over the Christmas and New Year holidays. Teams were composed of physicians, nurses, and health inspectors, and were provided with vehicles stocked with medications, medical supplies, food, and tents. 354 different communities were visited by FEMAT HERT teams, including five islands, 170 villages, 167 settlements, four estates, and eight evacuation centers. 1,172 out-patient medical encounters were recorded. Over 110 sites were treated for potential vectors by spraying and disinfection.
Conclusion:FEMAT operationalized a small, mobile medical teams approach to respond to Category 5 tropical cyclone that impacted Fiji in December of 2020.
Tailoring and Implementing an Emergency Medical Team (EMT) Training Package for Pacific Island Countries and Areas (PICs)
- Sean T. Casey, Anthony T. Cook, Drew R. Chandler, Jan-Erik Larsen, Simon R. Cowie, Erin E. Noste
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s95
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Pacific Island Countries and Areas (PICs) represent some of the most remote and logistically challenging locations – with thousands of islands covering vast ocean territory. Since 2017, Pacific Ministries of Health have been developing EMTs, and all have worked to train team members to be deployment-ready.1
Objectives:To describe an EMT training package specifically tailored to PIC contexts, including curated content, practical exercises, and “talanoa” discussions to improve EMT readiness, with a focus on logistics in remote and austere PIC contexts.
Method/Description:WHO leveraged EMT training materials developed globally and regionally to continuously tailor an in-person EMT training package, emphasizing readiness for the deployment of light, mobile clinical teams for disaster-prone small island/large ocean countries. Emphasis was placed on practical learning exercises focusing on skills and competencies needed to manage complex Pacific deployments, and to care for populations on remote, difficult-to-reach islands with limited resources and referral options.
Results/Outcomes:The Pacific EMT training program includes a mix of didactic and practical sessions coupled with a full-scale simulation exercise; it was designed with and for Pacific EMTs. The effectiveness of the training package has been evidenced through many successful national EMT deployments in several PICs, as well as through consistently positive participant feedback.
Conclusion:Tailoring training materials to specific country contexts is essential. In the Pacific, core EMT training content with an emphasis on practical activities and simulations and “talanoa” discussions reflecting on previous deployments in remote islands has been viewed by participants as critical to preparing them for real-world deployments.
Utilizing a Medical Ship in the COVID-19 Response in Fiji
- Jese R. Vatukela, Iferemi Waqasese
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s96
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Fiji consists of 110 populated islands over an area of 2,600,000 square kilometers and is prone to disasters such as tropical cyclones.1 To increase national capacity to respond to disasters and outbreak, the Fijian government, under the commissioning of Ministry of Transport and with technical guidance from the Ministry of Health, designed a medical ship called the MV Veivueti. During Fiji’s COVID-19 surge, MV Veivueti was utilized to provide operative health services during the surge in COVID-19 patients at other health facilities.2
Objectives:To describe FEMAT’s COVID-19 response utilizing the medical ship, MV Veivueti, in Fiji’s Pacific island setting.
Method/Description:MV Veivueti has been used on multiple disaster responses, however the COVID-19 surge in mid-2021 was the first time the vessel was used during an outbreak to allow for the continuation of surgeries when other health facilities were overwhelmed with COVID-19 patients. The medical ship is staffed with a comprehensive team from Fiji’s EMT - FEMAT - including surgeons, pediatricians, obstetricians, a dentist, nurses, and other medical staff.
Results/Outcomes:From May 5 through July 6, 2021, a 12-member medical team staffed the medical ship 24-hours a day, providing primarily operative management of cases that were referred from health facilities. COVID-19 screening and IPC measures were in place and a clear patient flow was designed for patient transferred to health care facilities.
Conclusion:The use of the MV Veivueti helped ensure continuity of critical health services during the peak of the Delta VOC outbreak in the Fiji Islands.
Team Well-Being and Challenges of Deploying an EMT Halfway Around the World
- Lizzi Marmont, Ramnath Vadi, Diana Maddah
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s97
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
UK-Med, as part of our UK EMT project, deployed a team to respond to the overwhelming surge in COVID-19 cases in Papua New Guinea in late 2021. Such deployment was associated with several risks, including natural hazards; earthquakes; societal crisis; tribal fighting and civil unrest; and health risks such as extreme temperatures and poor sanitation infrastructure presented further hazards to personnel safety.
Objectives:To share lessons learned on enhancing the well-being of an EMT in a challenging context such as PNG.
Method/Description:Satisfaction survey, bilateral meetings, in addition to weekly meetings with the headquarters held throughout the deployment.
Results/Outcomes:All deployed team members felt exhausted early in the deployment, including an early lack of clarity on the deployment location which eventually ended up being Mount Hagen, a very risky area only accessible by plane. Utilizing emotional and social support, diversity acceptance within the team, and coherent coordination between team members the deployment delivered upon all agreed objectives. Local staff were integrated and a successful workplan was well-received and evaluated as making a real difference to the staff and patients, with a request for an extension of activities received from the Provincial Health Authority.
Conclusion:Considerations for staff well-being need to counter-balance the need for strict security protocols. Solid feedback mechanisms should be designed and implemented at an early stage of deployments to avoid any adverse effect on the team’s well-being. Deployment of an assessment team should strengthen coordination, ensuring required needs are being responded to and operational planning is location/context specific.
Multi-Agency Collaboration Leading to WHO EMT Classification: The Korea Disaster Relief Team
- Eun-Young Choi, Wonmi Choi, Ara Ko, Yigyeong Oh, Hyemin Kwak, Eui Yup Jung
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s98
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The Korea Disaster Relief Team (KDRT) was established in 2008 to systemize Korea’s overseas medical emergency response. Following multiple international deployments since 2008, KDRT embarked on its journey to achieve WHO Emergency Medical Team (EMT) Global Classification in 2017.
Objectives:To outline the key success factors in KDRT’s work to reach classification as a Type 1 Fixed EMT.
Method/Description:As the Korean government dispatches KDRT, a multi-agency collaboration is essential to respond to overseas disasters. To this end, KDRT leveraged a formal collaborative approach, assigning specific roles for EMT development and deployment to several national agencies: The Republic of Korea Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Health and Welfare, the Ministry of National Defense, the Korea International Cooperation Agency, Korea’s National Medical Center, and the Korea Foundation for International Healthcare. This network prepared KDRT for WHO EMT Verification and developing Standard Operation Procedures for the EMT Type 1. Based on this SOP, KDRT repeated simulations for each element to strengthening capabilities and enable deployment ensuring strong coordination with national and international partners in response.
Results/Outcomes:After initiating KDRT’s journey towards EMT classification 2017, KDRT formalized cooperation with multiple agencies, and codified these roles and responsibilities in formal/published SOPs. Finally, the KDRT was verified by WHO in June 2022.
Conclusion:This study provides a process within the operating system limited to the Republic of Korea, the country of the KDRT. However, it also can be used as a collaborative reference case in the EMT development and verification process.
A Policy Analysis of the Deployment of International EMT in the WHO African Region during the COVID-19 Pandemic
- Boniface Oyugi, Rashidatu Fouad Kamara, Larissa Tene, Lazaro Martinez, Jerry-Jonas Mbasha, Thierno Baldé
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s99
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The COVID-19 pandemic, especially in Africa, has increased the need for EMTs for surge management, clinical care, and capacity-building support for establishing national EMTs.
Objectives:To analyze the implementation of EMTs deployments in the AFRO Region during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Method/Description:This is a retrospective policy analysis done from the perspective of the EMT policy implementor using Walt and Gilson’s policy triangle1 (capturing processes, the actors, the context, and the content). Data were collected through document reviews, key informant interviews, semi-structured in-depth interviews, and focus-group discussions. Analysis was done through a priori framework analysis.
Results/Outcomes:Overall, 22 countries benefited from international EMT deployments since the onset of COVID-19, with deployment periods varying between six to 24 weeks. Development partners, governments, and local authorities supported deployments. Some deployments were hampered by inadequate knowledge of EMTs processes, bureaucratic and administrative barriers, and slow mobilization of resources. Other challenges were the lack of critical care equipment and teams facing resistance due to cultural differences. Some teams only worked in big cities rather than local regions with low capacity and high morbidities from COVID-19. Collaboration between international and national teams resulted in enhanced capacity building, optimistic volunteerism and resilience, and provision of clinical care in constraint settings to save lives.
Conclusion:The deployments were critical in saving lives in under-resourced settings despite the challenges. COVID-19 has provided an impetus to strengthen national public health response by providing training opportunities, twinning or exchange programs, building health infrastructure, and prepositioning supplies and equipment to ensure national reliance and sustainability.
Resiliency of a US Pacific Island Territory with a Type 1 EMT
- Esther L. Muna, Warren F. Villagomez, Sean T. Casey
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s100
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), a chain of 14 Pacific islands with a population of around 50,000 and a United States territory, experienced two major typhoons exceeding 150 mph/240 kmph in three years. The resiliency of the people of the CNMI is evident, and has been supplemented through support from international Emergency Medical Teams (EMTs). As a US territory, support is available from the United States federal government and international partners, but an island territory far from the US mainland, the CNMI requires strong local emergency response capacity.
Objectives:To describe:
-
How the CNMI health system conducted an environmental scan to identify and address gaps in out-patient support in disasters;
-
How the health system improved and expanded its capacity to respond to emergencies with a significant impact on the community’s health; and
-
How leveraging the integration of clinical and public health capacities contributed to the development of a multidisciplinary local Type 1 EMT in the CNMI.
Method/Description:The CNMI brought together key local agencies involved in emergency response. Because of multiple recent disaster response efforts, agencies had deep knowledge and experience, and gaps were easily identified.
Results/Outcomes:The territory’s experience with international EMTs guided the creation of a local EMT in the CNMI, engaging local agencies, physicians, nurses, and public health and preparedness staff from the territory’s health system to establish an EMT for local and potentially for regional response.
Conclusion:Building local capacity using multi-sectoral agencies and multi-disciplinary individuals improves health system resiliency in health emergency response.
-
I’M HERE: IMproving HEalth Communication in REfugee Camps
- Andrea Bartolucci, Bayes Ahmed, Ahmed Hossain
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s101
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Health care delivery in refugee camps is challenging; the setting of a refugee camp is a unique context that presents barriers and one of the main problems is the fragmentation and difficulty in communication and information sharing among HCWs deployed in a camp, especially in contexts where communication networks are not always available and accessible.
Objectives:The overall objective of this project is to facilitate health communications among health care workers in a refugee camp where the communication network is not always available or accessible.
Method/Description:A mesh network communication system will be deployed, tested, and evaluated to assess and evaluate the usage, feasibility, and reliability of the system, testing the capacity of the message to reach different parts of the camp.
Results/Outcomes:During the project’s initial phase, local health care workers (HCWs) will support the project in identifying instances when communication is challenging and will create injects/mock scenarios to use in the following phase. In the second phase, the application of the new technology is evaluated; experimental research will compare the “as is” of the system and the “to be” solution using the new technology measuring key performance indicators (KPIs) (eg, time needed to send/receive information).
Conclusion:The use of an available, affordable, and usable mobile and internet connectivity system in a context where communication networks are not always available or accessible will facilitate the communication among agencies, improve the coordination of health services, and improve the quality and timing of information sharing.
Health Care Systems on the Brink of Failure – The Impact of War on the Pattern of Emergency Health Care Visits by Ukrainian Refugees in Poland
- Krzysztof Goniewicz, Attila J. Hertelendy, Amir Khorram-Manesh
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s102
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
One of the most severe outcomes of the Ukraine war has been the systematic destruction of communities resulting in mass migration of people to Poland. Millions of affected people have arrived in Poland as war refugees requiring medical attention from a fragile health care system overburdened by the COVID-19 pandemic. This study assesses ED utilization in Polish hospitals by Ukrainian refugees.
Objectives:To assess the impact of Ukrainian refugees on ED utilization in Poland.
Method/Description:Demographic data, chief presenting complaints, diagnosis, and the level of care needed were registered. Bivariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis were performed to yield odds ratios (OR) with a 95% confidence interval.
Results/Outcomes:At the time of investigation, there were 4,000 Ukrainian refugees admitted to Polish hospitals, of which more than half were children. Results are forthcoming.
Conclusion:Although COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the insufficiency of the Polish health care system, resulting in delayed treatment for many patients, the current mass migration from Ukraine emphasizes the lack of a proper organization for crisis management in Poland. Facing an unprecedented and historic challenge, the Polish health care system, operating at the limit of its capacity, is stretched beyond capacity resulting in excess mortality, which exceeded 200,000 deaths during the pandemic. The impact was directly due to the pandemic or the delay in treating other diseases such as cardiovascular diseases and cancer. Inconsistency in medical decision making, lack of proper recommendations from the authorities, and organizational insufficiency requires a renewed focus on adaptive capacity and long-term solutions that promote systems resiliency.
Emergency Medical Teams (EMT) Education and Training – Improving Disaster Preparedness with the Portuguese Emergency Medical Team (PT EMT) E-Learning Course
- Luis Manuel Ladeira, Ivo Manuel Cardoso, Ana Margarida Correia, Fátima Rato
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s103
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
EMT’s training is considered of high importance for disaster preparedness and response. The PT EMT, joined the TEAMS 3.0 Consortium, seeking to develop a universal training program for EMTs.
Objectives:The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the PT EMT E-learning Course in preparing trainees for disaster during their EMT initial training.
Method/Description:The analyzed data were collected through the application of a final questionnaire, which aimed to assess the effectiveness of the topics covered and the self-perception of disaster preparedness. A total of 31 trainees attended the E-learning Course, but only 25 answers were collected.
Results/Outcomes:The results showed that 92% of the trainees considered as the most important themes three areas: (1) Disaster and Humanitarian Principles; (2) Safety & Self-Protection; and (3) Disaster Logistics. The overall mean score was 4.52 points (SD = 0.770) out of five for the importance of this training for the performance of their mission roles and 4.48 points (SD = 0.770) in the contribution of these contents to their individual development. After completing this E-learning module, 88% consider themselves better prepared to disaster response and to attend the practical module of the initial training program.
Conclusion:The PT EMT E-learning Course, preceding the practical TEAMS 3.0 course, proved to be effective in the preparation of trainees for the practical training, but especially, it adds a huge variety of important knowledge, solidifying their preparedness for disaster response.
The development of common training bases for EMTs, with both modules, will improve the disaster preparedness and response.
International Training on Disaster Medicine - A Peer Education Approach to Disaster Medicine
- Mahmood F. Abdulameer, Kheloud Abdelnasser
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s104
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
There is an increasing global recognition that medical education systems world-wide have a major gap in training students for medical response to disasters. The IFMSA developed the International Training on Disaster Medicine (ITDM) project to address this gap.
Objectives:To provide medical students with essential competencies in Disaster Medicine through a peer-to-peer approach.
Method/Description:Selected number of students go through a Training of Trainers course organized annually over four months, jointly with the Center for Research and Training in Disaster Medicine, Humanitarian Aid, and Global Health in Novara, Italy. Graduates then lead ITDM workshops world-wide. The workshop is based on peer-to-peer education and incorporates interactive exercises, simulating real-life scenarios. In the workshop, medical students are introduced to core concepts and skills in Disaster Medicine, public health in disaster settings, and disaster management frameworks.
Results/Outcomes:The ToT course was organized first in 2015 in Italy. It has been held seven times, graduating 120 trainers from 55 countries. While the ITDM workshop was first organized in Malta in 2016, it has been conducted a total of 22 times in 19 different countries, building the capacity of more than 250 medical students world-wide. Furthermore, more than 500 medical students have been influenced by sporadic educational activities organized by ToT graduates.
Conclusion:The ITDM project aims to fill the gap in Disaster Medicine education in medical curricula. It has offered a much-needed space for the education and training of medical students, equipping them with basic competencies in responding to disasters to prepare them to act when needed.
What Helped Support Nurses in the ED at CWM during the COVID-19 Outbreak in Fiji in 2021?
- Bronte Douglas, Mamatuki Sosefo, Singh Keshni, Di Brown, Antony Robinson
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s105
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Following a quarantine breach in April 2021, Fiji went from no cases of COVID-19 to having the highest number per capita in the world. Fiji was relatively well-prepared to respond to COVID-19 as it has strong emergency management response systems. Nevertheless, due to the rapid increase, the public health system was quickly overwhelmed. The problem was particularly acute at the main tertiary hospital in Suva.
Objectives:To describe the effects of an overwhelming COVID-19 outbreak on nurses working in the Emergency Department of Colonial War Memorial Hospital in Fiji, in 2021.
To describe the lessons learned and recommendations for the future.
Method/Description:Focus Group Discussion with two groups of nurses: (1) ED nurse and (2) nurses seconded to provide a surge workforce in the most acute phase.
Results/Outcomes:Preliminary findings show that nurses were lacking in confidence and frightened about the growing epidemic. Resources, material and human, were initially in short supply. The agency of the nurses as result of their post-graduate study and due to the collegial environment in ED resulted in increased supplies of PPE and changes to nursing practice (eg, web-based handover). Final results pending.
Conclusion:The preliminary findings of this research illustrate that even in low-resource settings, with the right support and effective nursing leadership, nurses can provide safe and effective care to patients. The research illustrates the benefits of sound, relevant education, the crucial importance of teamwork, the importance of networks, the important benefits of early deployment of the MET, and the need for effective nursing leadership.
Opportunity Cost Analysis for Emergency Medical Teams: A Tool for Policy Making Support
- Juan Carlos Negrette
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s106
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
To some planners, allocating resources for emergency response may look unnecessary if not wasteful. Low-probability events can be perceived as unlikely, and for that reason, not worth considering within the regular planning structure. This is almost a dictum when planners must operate in a low-resource setting, where competition for available resources favors an approach that focuses in addressing pressing, not eventual needs.
Objectives:Understanding this context, it is also important for planners to consider the importance of systemic resiliency, implicit in the early utilization of Emergency Medical Teams for disasters mitigation, and for that reason, as necessary instruments to reduce impact - in terms of lives lost - and cost - financial and social - of medical emergencies that result from natural and man-made disasters.
Method/Description:Conducting an adverted DALYs cost analysis of a recent disaster is an instrument that could help policy, decision makers, and planners in general gain greater visualization of the potential social and financial costs reduction associated to the implementation of EMTs and, as a corollary, acknowledge the importance of preparation for necessary systemic resilience and its impact in equity and societal well-being.
Results/Outcomes:Initial analysis shows that preparation for early responses by EMTs to mitigate disasters can result in lower costs while reducing overall mortality and morbidity and potentially favoring faster systemic recovery.
Conclusion:The approach utilized requires improvement and expanded discussion with experts and beneficiaries will most likely result in its refinement and advancement.
Establishing a National Emergency Medical Team (EMT) in the Federated States of Micronesia (FSM)
- Sean T. Casey, Moses E. Pretrick, Eliaser Johnson, Joanes Sarofalpiy, Mayson Fredrick, Momoe Takeuchi
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s107
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The Federated States of Micronesia (FSM) is a Pacific Island nation of just over 100,000 people, with 607 islands spread over an ocean territory of over 2.5 million square kilometers. The nation is regularly struck by disasters and outbreaks - most recently Typhoons Wutip and Maysak, which affected populations on hundreds of islands. To strengthen rapid response to future emergencies, the FSM Government, with support from WHO, Japan, and USAID, is now developing a national Emergency Medical Team.1
Objectives:To describe the development of FSM’s national EMT.
Method/Description:FSM’s EMT development began with a workshop facilitated by WHO in November 2019, with participants from the National Department of Health & Social Affairs (DHSA) and representatives from all four of FSM’s State Health Departments. A national EMT focal point was jointly hired by WHO and FSM’s DHSA, a Technical Working Group was established, and SOPs developed. WHO initiated procurement of a tailored Pacific EMT cache for FSM’s EMT, along with other Pacific EMTs. FSM’s EMT development has been slowed by COVID-19, but there are plans to train team members from the country’s four States to be ready for self-sufficient national deployments by early 2023.
Results/Outcomes:With support from partners, FSM is developing a self-sufficient national EMT capable of rapid response across hundreds of islands spread over a vast ocean territory.
Conclusion:FSM is strengthening readiness for future emergencies by developing a national EMT capable of rapid response to the most remote and austere post-disaster conditions, including throughout its remote outer islands.
Predicting the Demand for Medical Care in Disaster-Affected Areas using the Minimum Data Set and Machine Learning
- Yutaka Igarashi, Tatsuhiko Kubo, Yoshiki Toyokuni, Shoji Yokobori, Yuichi Koido
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s108
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
The Minimum Data Set (MDS) has allowed governments of disaster-affected countries to collect, examine, and evaluate standardized medical data from Emergency Medical Teams in real-time. However, little study has been conducted on the use of MDS data to predict health care needs.
Objectives:This research proposes an outlook on the use of machine learning and MDS data to predict the need for medical care in disaster-affected areas.
Method/Description:The characteristics of the data collected by MDS and the optimal machine learning model were discussed.
Results/Outcomes:The primary causes of disease after disasters are trauma (MDS Nos. 4–8), which frequently occurs immediately after a disaster, and infectious diseases (MDS Nos. 9–18), which can increase due to decreasing hygiene conditions. Furthermore, certain infectious diseases can spread quickly because of living in congested evacuation centers, and early detection is crucial.
Therefore, predicting the need for medical care in a disaster area is complicated and requires a combination of many machine-learning models. Data-driven methods are mostly linear approaches and cannot capture the dynamics of infectious disease transmission. Additionally, statistical models depend heavily on assumptions, making real-time infection prediction challenging. Thus, deep learning is employed to model without losing the temporal component.
Conclusion:Real-time prediction of health care needs using machine learning and MDS can be useful to policymakers by enabling them to better deploy and allocate health care resources, which is useful to patients and front-line health care providers. More detailed predictions for regions and diseases are also anticipated.
Thailand EMT Domestic Response During the COVID-19 Outbreak
- Kasemsuk Yothasamutr, Thiradet Pathomwanitka, Narumol Sawanpanyalert
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s109
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Thailand Emergency Medical Team (Thailand EMT) was verified by the WHO in 2019 as a Type 1 fixed EMT. The second wave of COVID-19 hit the country in December 2020. Samut Sakhon province was the center of the spread with many migrant workers infected. Several field hospitals were set up, one being situated in the compound of a Buddhist Temple, Wat Krok Krak. Thailand EMT was tasked in setting up and running the operation here in the initial phase.
Objectives:To describe Thailand EMT’s experience in operating a COVID-19 field hospital.
Method/Description:On December 30, 2020, 16 members of the Thailand EMT were deployed to the Wat Krok Krak Field Hospital. The team comprised of doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and emergency medical technicians who also functioned as logistic officers. Patients were admitted in groups every day. Physicians communicated with patients by using a telemedicine system to monitor patients clinically.
Results/Outcomes:From December 31, 2020 through January 6, 2021, 143 COVID-19 patients were admitted. There were 104 female and 39 male patients. Patients were between 16 and 54 years of age, with a mean of 31.5 years. All were foreigner workers from nearby countries. Three patients had to be referred to a tertiary hospital. The rest of the patients were eventually discharged.
Conclusion:Thailand EMT was able to adapt and deployed to operate a COVID-19 field hospital. Collaboration with relevant agencies and local authorities played a key role. This deployment, although within Thailand, was a good learning opportunity for the team to prepare for future operations.
Tables and Figures (optional)
Integrating Management and Operations of Rapid Response Teams and Emergency Medical Teams Globally
- Mays Shamout, Pryanka Relan, Bridget Fitzgerald, Ashley Greiner, Flavio Salio
-
- Published online by Cambridge University Press:
- 22 November 2022, p. s110
-
- Article
-
- You have access Access
- Export citation
-
Background/Introduction:
Health emergencies such as the COVID-19 pandemic strain health systems and emergency response mechanisms. Identifying critical points during the response cycle where emergency workforce and operational capacity can be improved can help break the protracted nature of responses. Global health emergency workforce, or health emergency and alert response teams such as multidisciplinary Public Health Rapid Response Teams (RRTs) and Emergency Medical Teams (EMTs), play critical roles in the response to public health emergencies.
Objectives:The project aims to explore and understand how countries manage and operationalize their RRT and EMT programs. With anecdotal evidence of countries integrating the two historically disparate groups, we propose to examine how countries are jointly or separately addressing legal frameworks and policies; management practices; reporting processes and protocols; training; as well as program operations and standards.
Method/Description:Through existing global partnerships and networks, a convenience sample of national focal points responsible for the management of their RRT and EMT program are sent an online survey followed by participating in a one-on-one interview. Quantitative and qualitative analyses will be conducted.
Results/Outcomes:Twelve countries representing all six World Health Organization regions with both RRT and EMT programs have been selected for engagement.
Conclusion:Factors contributing to or against countries integration of RRT and EMT programs will be identified. Areas of divergence or synergy of plans and standard operating procedures will be mapped. Recommendations for strengthening global health emergency alert and response teams will be generated.