Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Political-Legal Order and the Curious Double Character of China’s Courts

  • Ling LI (a1)
Abstract

This article provides an analytical account of how politics and law in China are organically integrated in the institutional architecture of courts as designed by the Chinese Communist Party (“the Party”). This design allows the Party to retain its supreme authority in the interpretation, application, and enforcement of the law through its institutional control over courts. At the same time, the Party can, under this design, also afford to grant an autonomous sphere where courts can perform their adjudicative functions with minimal interference from the Party, as long as the Party is assured of full authority to determine the scope of the “autonomous-zone,” to impose rules on it, and to revoke it when necessary. Consequently, courts assume a double character: a pliant political agent on the one hand and a legal institution of its own agency on the other.

Copyright
Footnotes
Hide All
*

Correspondence to Ling Li, Department of East Asian Studies/Sinology, University of Vienna, Spitalgasse 2, Hof 2, Tür 2.3, Vienna, 1090, Austria. E-mail address: liling6234@gmail.com. The author has written extensively on Chinese politics and law, especially issues related to corruption and anti-corruption. Her most recent publication can be found at https://univie.academia.edu/LingLi.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Anonymous (1998) “Zhu Rongji zai basheng(qu) daji zousi he pianhui gongzuo zuotanhui shang qiangdiao zhichu jianding buyi di yanli daji zousi fanzui [Firmly Strike against Smuggling: Zhu Rongji Said at the Eight-Provinces (Districts) Symposium on Striking against the Crimes of Smuggling and Obtaining Foreign Currency by Fraud],” People’s Daily, 26 October.
Anonymous (2011) “zuigaoyuan: zhongda shipin anquan an yifa congzhong panchu [Supreme People’s Court: Aggregating Sentences Shall Be Applied to Serious Food Safety Cases],” Xin Jing Bao Newspaper Network, 28 May.
Anonymous (2015) “renmen weishenme huainian qiao shi [Why Do People Commemorate Qiao Shi],” Xinhua News Network, 15 June.
Anonymous (2017) “Zhongguo Weishenme Buneng Shixing Xifang Sifa Duli [Why Western Judicial Independence Cannot Be Adopted in China],” https://www.chinacourt.org/article/detail/2017/01/id/2512847.shtml (accessed 10 November 2018).
Brødsgaard, Kjeld Erik (2002) “Institutional Reform and the Bianzhi System in China.” China Quarterly 170.
Chen, Baocheng (2012) “Qiao Shi’s Talk at the National Political-Legal Work Colloquium on Jan. 19, 1989—Exerpts from Qiao Shi’s Book Talking about Democracy and Rule by Law,” http://china.caixin.com/2012–06–21/100403122.html (accessed 10 November 2018).
Cui, Min (2012) “Bashi Niandai ‘Yanda’ De Huigu Yu Fansi [A Review and Reflection on the ‘Strike-Hard’ Campaigns in the 1980s].” yanhuang chunqiu [China through the Ages], no. 5 (2012).
Fu, Yulin, & Peerenboom, Randall (2010) “A New Analytic Framework for Understanding and Promoting Judicial Independence in China,” in R. Peerenboom, ed., Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion, New York: Cambridge University Press, 95133.
He, Xin (2007) “Why Did They Not Take the Disputes? Law, Power, Politics in the Decision-Making of Chinese Courts.” 3 International Journal of Law in Context 203225.
Hou, Meng (2013) “ ‘Dang Yu Zhengfa’ Guanxi De Zhangkai—Yi Zhengfa Weiyuanhui Wei Yanjiu Zhongxin [An Explanation of the Relationship between the Party and the Courts—from the Perspective of the Political-Legal Committee].” 2 faxue jia 115.
Jin, Chongji (1998) 周恩来传 [A Biography of Zhou Enlai, Vol. 1–4], Beijing: Central Party Literature Press.
Kavass, Igor I., & Christian, Gary I. (1979) “1977 Soviet Constitution: A Historical Comparison.” 12 Vandebilt Journal of Transnational Law 533662.
Lewis, Margaret K. (2010) “Controlling Abuse to Maintain Control: The Exclusionary Rule in China.” 43 New York University Journal of International Law & Politics 629.
Li, Ji (2017) “The Power Logic of Justice in China.” 65 The American Journal of Comparative Law 95144.
Li, Ling (2010) “Corruption in China’s Courts,” in R. Peerenboom, ed., Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion, New York: Cambridge University Press, 196220.
Li, Ling (2012) “The ‘Production’ of Corruption in China’s Courts—the Politics of Judicial Decision-Making and Its Consequences in a One-Party State.” 37 Law & Social Inquiry 848877.
Li, Ling (2015) “‘Rule of Law’ in a Party-State—a Conceptual Interpretive Framework of the Constitutional Reality of China.” 2 Asian Journal of Law and Society 93113.
Li, Zhen (2016) “Mao Zedong zhuchi zhiding zhonghua renmin gongheguo di yibu xianfa [Mao Zedong Taking the Lead to Draft the 1st Constitution of the P.R.C.],” Xiang Chao, 5 September.
Lim, Benjamin Kang (2014) “Special Report—The Power Struggle Behind China’s Corruption Crackdown,” Reuters, 23 May.
Liu, Fuzhi (2010F) Memoire of Liu Fuzhi, Beijing: Central Wenxian Publishing House.
Liu, Quan’e (2012) “Shanganning Bianqu Sifa Gaige Yu ‘Zhengfa Chuantong’ De Xingcheng [Judicial Reform in Shanganning Border-Region and the Establishment of the ‘Political-Legal Tradition’].” Jilin University.
Liu, Wei (2010W) “Ershi Ge Zhongyang Jigou Zhixing Liandong Jizhi Pojie Fayuan Zhixing Nan [Twenty Central Institutions Take Joint Actions to Solve the Obstacles in Enforcing Court Judgments].” minzhu yu fazhi shibao [Democracy and Rule by Law Times], 26 July.
Liu, Zhong (2013) “The Shaping of the Thought of Party Governing Politics and Law in Organization History (1949–1958).” 2 Fa Xuejia [The Jurists] 1632.
Long, Zongzhi (1997) “Should Prosecutors Stand Up—a Reflection on the Rituals of the Trial.” Fa Xue, no. 3.
Ma, Haiyan (2013) “Dang Shipin Anquan Pai Zai Jingji Fazhan Shouwei [When Food Safety Is Put at the Top of Economic Development Agenda],” http://finance.sina.com.cn/zl/money/20131216/105717646164.shtml (accessed 10 November 2018).
Mao, Zedong (1992) “Dui Zhongyang Jueding Chengli Caijing, Zhengfa, Waishi, Kexue, Wenjiao Ge Xiaozu De Tongzhigao De Piyu He Xiugai [Mao Zedong’s Remarks and Edits of the Central Party’s Drafted Notice on the Establishment of the Financial, Political-Legal, Foreign Affairs, Science, and Culture and Education Small Groups],” in Mao Zedong’s Manuscripts since the Establishment of the P.R.C., Vol. 7, Beijing: Central Archive Publishing House, 268–9.
Miller, Alice (2008) “The CCP Central Committee’s Leading Small Groups.26 China Leadership Monitor 121.
Minzner, Carl (2011) “China’s Turn against Law.” 59 American Journal of Comparative Law 935984.
Ng, Kwai Hang, & He, Xin (2017) Embedded Courts: Judicial Decision-Making in China, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Party Congress Database (1958) “Summary of the 5th Plenary Session of the 8th Central Party Committee,” Online Archive, http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64162/64168/64560/65348/4442051.html (accessed 10 November 2018).
Peng, Zhen (1992a) Lun Xin Zhongguo De Zhengfa Gongzuo [On the Political-Legal Work in New China], Beijing: Renmin Publishing House.
Peng, Zhen (1992b) “Summarized Scripts of the Speech at the First Meeting of the Central Political-Legal Committee,” in Z. Peng, ed., Lun Xinzhongguo De Zhengfa Gongzuo [On the Political-Legal Work of New China] , Beijing: Central Wenxian Publishing House, 216217.
Qian, Haoping (2012) “How Does the ‘Leading Small-Group’ Lead?” Nanfang Renwu Weekly, 5 September.
Qian, Haoping (2014) “Zhengfawei Zhuanxing Zhe Yinian [The Year of Transition for Party Political-Legal Committees],” nanfang zhoumo [Southern Weekend], 17 January.
Qin, Xudong (2014) “Zhongyang Sifa Tizhi Gaige Lingdao Xiaozu Jiexi [An Illustration of the Central Judicial Institutional Reform Leading Small-Group],” Caixin Network, 19 January.
Shao, Zonghai (2005) “Defining the Institutional Role of the Central Party Small Leading Groups.” 48 Mainland Research 124.
Special Report, (2014) “How Do ‘Small-Groups’ Goven a Big Country?1154 dianji jinri, Online archive, from Sohu News Portal. http://news.sohu.com/s2013/dianji-1154/ (accessed 22 February 2019).
Xinhua News (2012) “Zhou Yongkang: Full Implementation of All Judical Institutional Reform Measures,” Xinhua News, 20 January.
Yang, Xiancheng (2013) “ Zalan Gongjianfa He Qingli Jieji Duiwu [Destroying Publis Security Organs, Courts and Procuratorates and Purging Classes].” 2 yanhuang chunqiu [China through the Ages] 5558.
Ye, Zhusheng (2014) “Zhengfawei Xietiaohui Jizhi Mianlin Gaige [Political-Legal Committee Coordinating Meeting Mechanism Faces Change],” Nan Feng Chuang, 9 May.
Yu, Hao (2013) “ Sifa Jieshi ‘Shoushen’ Chenggong [Successful ‘Shrink’ of Judicial Interpretations].” 9 China’s People’s Congress Journal 3235.
Zhang, Taisu (2012) “The Pragmatic Court: Reinterpreting the Superme People’s Court of China.” 25 Columbia Journal of Asian Law 161.
Zhong, Jinyan (2012) “ Zhengfawei Lishi Yu Yanbian De Zai Sikao [A Revisit to the History and Vicissitude of the Political-Legal Committee].” 12 yanhuang chunqiu [China through the Ages] 5056.
Zhou, Yongkun (2012) “ Zhengfawei De Lishi Yu Yanbian [The History and Vicissitude of the Political-Legal Committee].” 9 yanhuang chunqiu [China through the Ages] 714.
Zhu, Suli (2010) “The Party and the Courts,” in R. Peerenboom, ed., Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion, New York: Cambridge University Press, 5268.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Asian Journal of Law and Society
  • ISSN: 2052-9015
  • EISSN: 2052-9023
  • URL: /core/journals/asian-journal-of-law-and-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed