Skip to main content

Explaining variation in the multiplicity of private social and environmental regulation: a multi-case integration across the coffee, forestry and textile sectors

  • Marie-France Turcotte, Juliane Reinecke (a1) and Frank den Hond (a2)

Amid concerns for a regulatory void in transnational fields, the principle of private regulation has become institutionalized. Many sectors have seen the emergence of multiple and overlapping standards. When comparing the sectors, there is considerable variation in standard multiplicity. We build on three institutional perspectives that have been put forward to explain the emergence of sustainability standards – the economic, idealist and political-institutional perspectives – to analyze the phenomenon of standard multiplicity. Each perspective reflects a different kind of action logic and is simultaneously present and accessible to various parties involved. Based on a cross-sector analysis of standards multiplicity in the forestry, coffee and textile sectors, this article seeks to make two contributions. First, whereas these three perspectives have been presented as competing, we propose that they are complementary in offering partial explanations for different episodes in the dynamics underlying standards multiplicity in different sectors. Second, whereas most studies have analyzed standard setting in single sectors and thus have understood it as being an intra-sector phenomenon, our cross-sector analysis of the dynamics of standard setting suggests that it is propelled by both sector-specific contingencies and experiences as well as by the experiences from other sectors.

Corresponding author
* Département Stratégie, Responsabilité Sociale et Environnementale, École des Sciences de la Gestion, Université du Québec à Montréal, C.P. 6192, succ. Centre-Ville, Montréal (Québec) Canada H3C 4R2, e-mail:
Hide All
Aoudji Augustin K.N., Adégbidi Anselme, Agbo Valentin, Atindogbé Gilbert, Toyi Mireille S.S., Yêvidé Armand S.I., Ganglo Jean C., and Lebailly Philippe. 2012. “Functioning of Farm-Grown Timber Value Chains: Lessons from the Smallholder-Produced Teak (Tectona grandis L.f.) Poles Value Chain in Southern Benin.” Forest Policy and Economics 15: 98107.
Auld Graeme and Cashore Benjamin. 2012. “The Forest Stewardship Council.” In Business Regulation and Non-State Actors: Whose Standards? Whose development?, edited by Utting Peter, Reed Darryl and Reed Ananya, 134147. London: Routledge.
Auld Graeme, Gulbrandsen Lars H., and McDermott Constance L. 2008. “Certification Schemes and the Impacts on Forests and Forestry.” Annual Review of Environment and Resources 33: 187211.
Bartley Tim. 2007. “Institutional Emergence in an Era of Globalization: The Rise of Transnational Private Regulation of Labor and Environmental Conditions.” American Journal of Sociology 113 (2): 297351.
Bartley Tim. 2011. “Certification as a Mode of Social Regulation.” In Handbook of the Politics of Regulation, edited by Levi-Faur David, 441452. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
Bernstein Steven and Cashore Benjamin. 2007. “Can Non-State Global Governance Be Legitimate? An Analytical Framework.” Regulation and Governance 1 (4): 347371.
Brunsson Nils, Rasche Andreas, and Seidl David. 2012. “The Dynamics of Standardization: Three Perspectives on Standards in Organization Studies.” Organization Studies 33 (5/6): 613632.
Cashore Benjamin. 2002. “Legitimacy and the Privatization of Environmental Governance.” Governance-An International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions 15 (4): 503529.
Cashore Benjamin, Auld Graeme, and Newsom Deanne. 2003. “Forest Certification (Eco-labeling) Programs and their Policy-Making Authority: Explaining Divergence among North American and European Case Studies.” Journal of Forest Policy and Economics 5 (3): 225247.
Cashore Benjamin, Auld Graeme, and Newsom Deanne. 2004. “The United States’ Race to Certify Sustainable Forestry: Non-State Environmental Governance and the Competition for Policy-Making Authority.” Business and Politics 5 (3): 219259.
Cashore Benjamin, Auld Graeme, Lawson James, and Newsom Deanna. 2007a. “The Future of Non-State Authority on Canadian Staples Industries: Assessing the Emergence of Forest Certification.” Policy and Society 26 (1): 7191.
Cashore Benjamin, Auld Graeme, Bernstein Steven, and McDermott Constance. 2007b. “Can Non-State Governance ‘Ratchet Up’ Global Environmental Standards? Lessons from the Forest Sector.” Review of European Community and International Environmental Law 16 (2): 158172.
Conroy Michael E. 2007. Branded! How the “Certification Revolution” Is Transforming Global Corporations. Gabriola Island, Canada: New Society Publishers.
den Hond Frank, Frank G. de Bakker A., Neergaard Peter, and Gond Jean-Pascal. 2007. “Managing Corporate Social Responsibility in Action: Reconciling Rhetorical Harmony and Practical Dissonance.” In Managing Corporate Social Responsibility in Action: Talking, Doing and Measuring, edited by den Hond Frank, Frank G. de Bakker A. and Neergaard Peter, 205226. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing.
Dingwerth Klaus and Pattberg Philipp. 2009. “World Politics and Organizational Fields: The Case of Transnational Sustainability Governance.” European Journal of International Relations 15 (4): 707743.
Dubuisson-Quellier Sophie. 2013. “A Market Mediation Strategy: How Social Movements Seek to Change Firms’ Practices by Promoting New Principles of Product Valuation.” Organization Studies 34 (5–6): 683703.
Espinoza Omar, Buehlmann Urs, and Smith Bob. 2012. “Forest Certification and Green Building Standards: Overview and Use in the U.S. Hardwood Industry.” Journal of Cleaner Production 33: 3041.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. 2010. “Global Forest Resources Assessment 2010 – main report.” FAO Forestry Paper No. 163.
Fransen Luc W. 2010. Minding Their Own Business? Firms and Activists in the Making of Private Labour Regulation. Amsterdam, NL: Universiteit van Amsterdam.
Fransen Luc W. 2011. “Why Do Private Governance Organizations Not Converge? A Political-Institutional Analysis of Transnational Labor Standards Regulation.” Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions 24 (2): 359387.
Fransen Luc W. 2012. “Multi-Stakeholder Governance and Voluntary Programme Interactions: Legitimation Politics in the Institutional Design of Corporate Social Responsibility.” Socio-Economic Review 10 (1): 163192.
Gendron Corinne, Bisaillon Véronique, and Isabel Otero Rance Ana. 2009. “The Institutionalization of Fair Trade: More than Just a Degraded Form of Social Action.” Journal of Business Ethics 86 (1): 6379.
Gilbert Dirk U., Rasche Andreas, and Waddock Sandra. 2011. “Accountability in a Global Economy: The Emergence of International Accountability Standards.” Business Ethics Quarterly 21 (1): 2344.
Haack Patrick, Schoeneborn Dennis, and Wickert Christopher. 2012. “Talking the Talk, Moral Entrapment, Creeping Commitment? Exploring Narrative Dynamics in Corporate Responsibility Standardization.” Organization Studies 33 (5–6): 815845.
Hassel Anke. 2008. “The Evolution of a Global Labor Governance Regime.” Governance 21 (2): 231251.
Jamali Dima. 2010. “MNCs and International Accountability Standards through an Institutional Lens: Evidence of Symbolic Conformity or Decoupling.” Journal of Business Ethics 95 (4): 617640.
King Andrew A. and Lenox Michael J. 2000. “Industry Self-Regulation without Sanctions: The Chemical Industry's Responsible Care Program.” Academy of Management Journal 43 (4): 698716.
Low William and Davenport Eileen. 2005. “Postcards from the Edge: Maintaining the ‘Alternative’ Character of Fair Trade.” Sustainable Development 13 (3): 143153.
Manning Stephan, Boons Frank, von Hagen Olivier, and Reinecke Juliane. 2012. “National Contexts Matter: The Co-Evolution of Sustainability Standards in Global Value Chains.” Ecological Economics 83: 197209.
March James G. and Olsen Johan P. 1989. Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. New York: Free Press.
McCarthy John D. and Zald Mayer N. 1977. “Resource Mobilization and Social Movements: A Partial Theory.” American Journal of Sociology 82 (6): 12121241.
McCaffrey Sarah and Kurland Nancy. 2013. “Who Defines ‘Local’? Resistance to Harmonizing Standards in Ethical Markets.” Business and Politics 16 (1): 191219.
Meidinger Errol. 2006. “The Administrative Law of Global Private-Public Regulation: The Case of Forestry.” European Journal of International Law 17 (1): 4787.
Meyer John W. 2010. “World Society, Institutional Theories, and the Actor”. Annual Review of Sociology 36 (1): 120.
Micheletti Michele. 2003. Political Virtue and Shopping: Individuals, Shopping and Collective Action. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Mueller Martin, Gomes dos Santos Virginia, and Seuring Stefan. 2009. “The Contribution of Environmental and Social Standards Towards Ensuring Legitimacy in Supply Chain Governance.” Journal of Business Ethics 89 (4): 509523.
Mutersbaugh Tad. 2005. “Fighting Standards with Standards: Harmonization, Rents, and Social Accountability in Certified Agrofood Networks.” Environment and Planning A 37 (11): 20332051.
Olson Mancur. 2000 [1965]. The Logic of Collective Action. Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
O'Rourke Dara. 2004. Community-Driven Regulation: Balancing Development and the Environment in Vietnam. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Overdevest Christine. 2010. “Comparing Forest Certification Schemes: The Case of Ratcheting Standards in the Forest Sector.” Socio-Economic Review 8 (1): 4776.
Petkova Iva. 2006. “Shifting Regimes of Governance in the Coffee Market: From Secular Crisis to a New Equilibrium?Review of International Political Economy 13 (2): 313339.
Prakash Aseem and Potoski Matthew. 2007. “Collective Action through Voluntary Environmental Programs: A Club Theory Perspective.” Policy Studies Journal 35 (4): 773792.
Rasche Andreas and Kell Georg. eds. 2010. The United Nations Global Compact: Achievements, Trends and Challenges. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Reinecke Juliane, Manning Stephan, and Hagen Olivier Von. 2012. “The Emergence of a Standards Markets: Multiplicity of Sustainability Standards in the Global Coffee Industry.” Organization Studies 33 (5/6): 791814.
Sasser Erika N., Prakash Aseem, Cashore Benjamin, and Auld Graeme. 2006. “Direct Targeting as an NGO Political Strategy: Examining Private Authority Regimes in the Forestry Sector.” Business and Politics 8 (3): 132.
Schepers Donald H. 2010. “Challenges to Legitimacy at the Forest Stewardship Council.” Journal of Business Ethics 92: 279290.
Scherer Andreas Georg and Palazzo Guido. 2007. “Toward a Political Conception of Corporate Responsibility: Business and Society seen from a Habermasian Perspective.” Academy of Management Review 32 (4): 10691120.
Schurman Rachel. 2004. “Fighting ‘Frankenfoods’: Industry Opportunity Structures and the Efficacy of the Anti-Biotech Movement in Western Europe.” Social Problems 51 (2): 243268.
Shamir Ronen. 2008. “The Age of Responsibilization: On Market-Embedded Morality.” Economy and Society 37 (1): 119.
Sharp Paul F. 1949. “The Tree Farm Movement: Its Origin and Development.” Agricultural History 23: 4145.
Sikavica Katarina and Pozner Jo-Ellen. 2013. “Paradise Sold: Resource Partitioning and the Organic Movement in the US Farming Industry.” Organization Studies 34 (5–6): 623651.
Tamm Hallström, Kristina and Magnus Boström. 2010. Transnational Multi-Stakeholder Standardization. Organizing Fragile Non-State Authority. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Turcotte Marie-France, de Bellefeuille Stéphane, and den Hond Frank. 2007. “Gildan Inc.: Influencing Corporate Governance in the Textile Sector.” Journal of Corporate Citizenship 27: 2336.
Tysiachniouk Maria. 2013. “Fostering Transparency in the Transnational Supply Chain: From Russian Forest Producers to Consumers in Europe and the USA.” Forest Policy and Economics 31 (June): 311.
Utting Peter. 2001. Regulating Business via Multi-Stakeholders Initiatives: A Preliminary Assessment. Geneva, Switzerland: UNRISD.
Vogel David. 2008. “Private Global Business Regulation.” Annual Review of Political Science 11 (1): 261282.
Whelan Glen, Frank G. de Bakker A., den Hond Frank, and Muthuri Judy. 2013. “Situated Interests: Managing Conflict In and Around Multi-stakeholder Initiatives.” Working Paper. Nottingham: University of Nottingham ICCSR.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Business and Politics
  • ISSN: -
  • EISSN: 1469-3569
  • URL: /core/journals/business-and-politics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 10 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 146 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 20th January 2017 - 20th February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.