Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-x24gv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-04T11:28:43.129Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

III. Cavour and Parliament

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 December 2011

D. Mack Smith
D. Mack Smith
Affiliation:
Fellow of Peterhouse, Cambridge
Get access

Extract

Constitutional history has not bulked large in risorgimento studies, because events of greater dramatic impact take precedence on this particular stage. The 1848 constitution of Piedmont has been studied, but this was a haphazard document drawn up hurriedly by inexperienced lawyers and open to either liberal or illiberal interpretation. Far more important was the formative period after 1848, during which first the Marquis Massimo d'Azeglio and then Count Camille de Cavour created traditions of parliamentary and cabinet rule. Cavour was the most successful and authoritative parliamentarian in Italian history. On his development of the constitution, however, we possess little more than the provocative but fragmentary essays of Adolfo Omodeo, largely because for nearly a century his papers have been inaccessible. The modern Italian parliament grew directly out of Cavour's theory and practice, and what he understood by liberal government is therefore highly important. There is room, at any rate, for enquiring whether he was the straightforward liberal that a dozen biographers make out.

Type
Articles
Information
Cambridge Historical Journal , Volume 13 , Issue 1 , 1957 , pp. 37 - 57
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1957

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Jan.-Feb. 1845, Zanichelli, D., Gli scritti del Conte di Cavour (Bologna, 1892), II, 355.Google Scholar

2 6 Nov. 1852, Sir James Hudson from Turin to Lord Cowley, F[oreign] O[ffice] 519/194, P[ublic] R[ecord] O[ffice].

3 29 Dec 1860, Cavour to Comtesse de Circourt, Cavour e I'Inghilterra (Cart[eggi] Cav[ouriani], Bologna, 1933), vol II, tomo II, 284–5.

4 18 Dec 1857, L'Opimone (Turin).

5 E.g 6 April 1860, Cavour against Garibaldi in parliament, Atti parlamentari

6 24 Feb 1858, Cavour to Boncompagni, C., Lettere [di Camillo Cavour] (ed. Chiala, Luigi, Turin, 1887), VI, 184Google Scholar

7 23 May 1853, Cavour in parliament.

8 la Rive, William de, Reminiscences of the life and character of Count Cavour (trans Edward Romilly, London, 1862), 107Google Scholar

9 [Carteggio] Cavour-Salmour (Bologna, 1936), 82–3; 27 Oct 1857, Cavour to de Villamarina, Marquis, Nuove lettere inedite del conte di Cavour (ed. Mayor, E., Turin, 1895), 591.Google Scholar

10 28 Jan 1856, Hudson to Cowley, F.O 519/194

11 21 Feb. 1856, Cavour to L Cibrano, Chiala, Lettere, II, 183.

12 Matter, Paul, Cavour et l'unité italienne (Paris, 1927), III, 95.Google Scholar

13 8 Jan. 1859, Cavour to Villamarina, [Il carteggio] Cavour-Nigra (Bologna, 1926), I, 289; 3 and 9 Jan. Massari, Giuseppe, Diario [1858–60 sull'azione politica di Cavour] (ed. Beltrani, G., Bologna, 1931), 146, 154.Google Scholar

14 11 March 1860, Cavour to Nigra, Cavour-Nigra, III, 167.

15 13 April 1860, ibid. 258.

16 La liberazione del Mezzogiorno (Cart. Cav. Bologna, 1952–4), III, 289; IV, 68, 76, 82, 317, 466.

17 Cavour's speeches in parliament, 11–12 March, 3–5 April 1852.

18 14 March 1857, V. Ferrero-Ponziglione, L. Corsi, A. Brofferio, T. Mamiani, General La Marmora and Cavour in parliament.

19 26 May 1854, Cavour in the Senate; 4 April 1861, G. Nicolucci in the Chamber; 3 April 1861, F. A. Mazziotti in the Chamber.

20 28 Nov. 1848, Cavour in parliament.

21 [Il conte di Cavour,] Ricordi di [Michelangelo] Castelli (ed. Chiala, Turin, 1886), 28–9.

22 1 Sept. 1858, Massari, Diario, 31; Chiala, Lettere, VI, 63, 130, 135, 145, 240; Rivista Stortca Italiana, vol 48 (1931), 16

23 22 Nov 1857, Il Piccolo Corriere d'Italia (Turin)

24 Aug 1857, Cavour to de la Rive, Chiala, Lettere, VI, 69 (a different date is given to the same letter in Chiala, II, 277); 23 Nov 1857, Cavour to Boncompagni, ibid. 87.

25 30 Dec 1857, Cavour in parliament.

26 13 Jan 1858, Rattazzi and Costa di Beauregard in parliament.

27 19 Jan. 1858, Cavour in parliament.

28 9 May 1856, Cavour to E. d'Azeglio, Cavour e I'Inghilterra, vol. 11, totno I, 12: ‘cette discussion, faite pour rehausser notre réputation parlementaire.’

29 Mme Rattazzi, Rattazzi et son temps (Paris, 1881), 1, 443.

30 8 Dec. 1858 and 22 Jan. 1860, Il Diritto (Turin).

31 Cavour-Salmour, 93–4; Massari, Diario, 102; 13 June 1861, L'Optmone; 13 June 1861, Senator E. Oldofredi to General La Marmora, Archivio La Marmora, casetta XCVI, cartella 154 (I am grateful to Conte Alberti della Marmora for letting me see his family papers); 14 June 1861, M. d'Azegho to Torelli, G., Lettere di Massimo d'Azegho a Giuseppe Torelli, ed. Paoli, Di Cesare (Milan, 1870), 130.Google Scholar

32 22 July 1857, Due de Gramont to Count Walewski, Pans, A[rchives du Ministère des Affaires] É[trangères], Corr[espondance] pol[itique]. Sard[aigne], vol. 342.

33 E.g. 9 July 1848, Cavour in parliament 30 Nov. 1862, Depretis in parliament boasted how the independent Left during 1852–8 had thought of itself not as an opposition but as a stimulus to Cavour. 1 Dec. 1862, another speech by Depretis shows that the ‘transformation’ of parties had already become a customary phrase.

34 6 Feb. 1855, Cavour in parliament.

35 24 Aug. 1849 (wrongly printed 1842), Cavour to de la Rue, Emile, [C. Cavour:] Nouvelles lettres [inédites] (ed. Bert, A., Turin, 1889), 329.Google Scholar

36 10 Oct. 1850, Cavour to Corio, G., Cavour Agricoltore (ed. Visconti, E., Florence, 1913), 282Google Scholar; 9 Feb. 1851, ibid. 292.

37 Ricci, Matteo, Azeglio e Cavour (Florence, 1882), 18–19.Google Scholar

38 Memoirs of the Minister of Justice, G. F. Galvagno, Chiala, Lettere, I, 577–8.

39 Chiala, L., Une page d'histoire du gouvernement représentatif en Piémont (Turin, 1858), 4, 187.Google Scholar

40 16 Nov. 1852, His de Butenval to Drouyn de Lhuys, A.É. Corr. pol. Sard. vol. 332.

41 20 May 1852, V. Gioberti to Massari, G., Gioberti-Massari carteggio 1838–52 (ed. Balsamo-Crivelli, , Turin, 1920), 539.Google Scholar

42 E g Cavour in parliament, 14 Aug 1849, 16 Oct 1849, 26 Nov 1810, 14 April 1851, 28 April 1851, 7 July 1851, 10 March 1853, 26 May 1854, etc

43 16 May 1856, Cavour to E d'Azegho, Cavour e I Inghilterra vol II, tonio 1, 19

44 31 March 1835, Cavour to A de la Rive, Chiala, Lettere, I, 285 7, 14 Jun 1835, Cavour to Frezet, Abate, Ruffini, Francesco, La Giouinezza di Cavour (Turin, 1937), I, 238–9Google Scholar

45 7 March 1850, Cavour in parliament, 1 Jan 1856, Cavour to E d'Azeglio, Cavour e I'lnghilterra, I, 154–5

46 26 May 1857, Cavour in parliament

47 Omodeo, Adolfo, L'opera politica del Conte di Cavour (Florence., 1940), II, 126Google Scholar

48 6 Feb 1855, Cavour in parliament

49 8 Dec. 1857, Cavour to Gramont, Chiala, Lettere, VI, 101–2.

50 19 Nov 1857, Prince de la Tour d'Auvergne to Walewski, A.É. Corr. pol. Sard. vol. 342, 6 Dec 1857, Cavour to General La Marmora, Chiala, Lettere, II, 285; 20 Jan. 1860, Cavour to Giovanni Lanza, ibid. III, 177; De Vecchi di Val Cismon, Le Carte di Giovanni Lanza (Turin, 1936), II, 157

51 1 Jan. 1858, Il Diritto(Turin).

52 6 Dec. 1857, La Tour d'Auvergne to Walewski, A É Corr pol Sard. vol. 342.

53 11 and 17 Dec. 1857, ibid.; Cavour-Salmour, 145; Massari, Diario, 436.

54 Ricordi di Castelli, 50–1.

55 23 April 1858, La Tour d'Auvergne to Walewski, A.É. Corr. pol. Sard.vol. 343.

56 1 June 1858, ibid.

57 Chiala, Lettere, VI, 204, 243.

58 18 Jan 1853, Cavour to Comte de Circourt, Cavour e I'Inghilterra, vol. II, tomo II, 245; 21 June 1857, Cavour to Comtesse de Circourt, ibid. 252.

59 27 May 1848, Cavour's article in Il Risorgimento (Turin), [Camillo Cavour:] Scritti politici (ed Gentile, Giovanni, Rome, 1930), 202–3Google Scholar

60 27 Oct 1857, Cavour to Villamarina, , Nuove lettere [inedite del Conte Camillo di Cavour] (ed. Mayor, Edmondo, Turin, 1895), 591.Google Scholar

61 21 April 1858, Cavour in parliament; 27 Jan. i860, Cavour to Marchese Montezemolo, Cavour-Nigra, III, 26; 9 April 1861, Cavour to the Senate.

62 27 Jan. 1861, Cavour to Conte Vimercati, La questione Romana (Cart. Cav., Bologna, 1929), I, 243; Jan. 1858, Cavour to W. de la Rive, Chiala, Lettere, II, 288.

63 11 Feb. 1852, L'Opinione (Turin); 4 Dec. 1853, La Gazzetta del Popolo.

64 5 Feb. 1852 and 16 April 1858, Luigi Federico Menabrea in parliament.

65 14 May 1858, Giuseppe Saracco in parliament.

66 12 April 1861, Hudson to Lord John Russell, Russell Papers, P.R.O. 30/22/68.

67 Omodeo, op. cit. I, 144.

68 18 June 1856, L'Opinione; 10 June 1860, Il Piccolo Corriere d'Italia.

69 5 March 1858, 6 July 1858, L'Indipendente (Turin). It was thought that no copy of this newspaper existed, but there is one in the Widener Library, Harvard.

70 11 March 1861, Hudson to Russell, Russell Papers, 30/22/68.

71 May 1848, Cavour's article in the Risorgimento(Turin), ed. Gentile, Scritti Politici, 165.

72 26 Nov. 1850 and 4 May 1852, Cavour in parliament.

73 24 Jan. 1848, 29 Aug. 1849, 3 Oct. 1849, ibid.

74 27 May 1848, article, ed. Gentile, Scritti politici, 205.

75 17 March 1857, Cavour in parliament.

76 14 May 1851, ibid.

77 4 and 9 July 1848, ibid.

78 14 Jan. 1852, ibid.

79 25 May 1835, Diario del Conte di Cavour(ed. Salvatorelli, L., Milan, 1941), 198.Google Scholar

80 19 Feb. 1848, article, Scritti politici, 63.

81 23 Feb. 1848, article, ibid. 71–2.

82 Ibid.; 19 Feb. 1860, Cavour to Conte Arese, Chiala, Lettere, III, 213.

83 Feb. 1861, ibid, IV, 238.

84 9 Nov. 1849, 10 Jan. 1850, Cavour in parliament.

85 13 Aug. 1849, ibid.

86 21 Nov. 1849, Lucien Murat to French Foreign Minister, Matter, op. cit. II, 134.

87 20 Feb. 1856, Cavour to Rattazzi, Cavour e I' Inghilterra, I, 193.

88 Ricordi di Castelli, 21.

89 Gattina, Petruccelli della, I moribondi [del Palazzo Carignano] (Milan, 1862), 61.Google Scholar

90 Il Conte di Cavour in parlamento: discorsi(ed. I. Artom e A. Blanc, Florence, 1868), xviii—xix; Angelo Brofferio, Storia del parlamento subalpino(Milan, 1866), 1, 146–7; Massari, Il conte di Cavour(ed. Turin, 1872), 221.

91 E.g. 16 April 1858, cit. Chiala, Lettere, II, ccliv.

92 17 Jan. 1858, Cavour to P. Magenta, Chiala, Lettere, VI, 127.

93 12 April 1861, Hudson to Russell, Russell Papers, 30/22/68.

94 Mme Rattazzi, op. cit. I, 580.

95 A. Brofferio, Fisionomie parlamentari(Turin, 1853); A. Brofferio, Il Conte di Cavour (Turin, 1861).

96 E.g. 3 March 1854, Cavour in parliament.

97 Correspondence of F. Guglianetti, Archivio di Stato, Turin, Gabinetto Ministero Intern 1848–60, cartella 40.

98 9 July 1848, Cavour in parliament.

99 22 Dec. 1849, ibid.

100 Nov.-Dec. 1849, letters of Cavour to de la Rüe, ed. Bert, Nouvelles Lettres, 357–65; Massari, Il conte di Cavour(ed. Milan, 1935), 40.

101 14 Nov. 1855, Cavour in parliament.

102 4 April 1854, ibid.; 14 Dec. 1857, Cavour to P. Vignet, Chiala, Lettere, VI, p. 105; 18 Aug. 1858, Cavour to G. Briano, ibid, VI, 270.

103 9 Sept. 1858, Cavour to A. Conte, ibid, VI, 282.

104 18 Dec. 1857, Cavour to Gay di Quarti, Jan. 1858, to A. de la Rive, ibid. 109, 118–19.

105 19 Jan. 1858, Il Diritto.

106 16 Jan. 1858, Chiala, Lettere, II, 423. Cf. the different tone of V. Ricci's circular, 20 April 1848.

107 18 Jan. 1860, Cavour to L. C. Farini, Liberazione del Mezzogiorno, v, 450; Feb. ibid., 465.

108 I. Artom's article in Nuova Antologia, 1 Nov. 1901; 5 April 1861, F. Mellana in parliament.

109 Clemente Solaro della Margarita, Discorso alia nazione(Turin, 1857), 24–35.

110 13 Jan. 1861, Cavour to C. Poerio, Chiala, Lettere, IV, 152.

111 23 April 1858, Valerio in parliament.

112 27 April 1858, ibid.; 10 June 1859, La Marmora to General Dabormida, Chiala, Lettere, III, 94, note.

113 10 June 1861, L'Opimone; 11 Nov. 1861, Il Piccolo Corriere d'Italia.

114 17 Jan 1858, Cavour to Villamarina, Chiala, Lettere, II, 292

115 D. Mack Smith, ‘Vittorio Emanuele e 1 suoi primi ministri’, Rassegna storica del risorgimenlo, April 1954, 415–18.

116 9 Feb. 1856, Hudson to Lord Clarendon, Clarendon MSS, Bodleian Library, dep. c. 55

117 Jan. 1861, cit. Chiala, Lettere, IV, 256–7; 26 Oct. 1852, M. d'Azegho to Pantaleoni, D., Massimo d'Azegho e Diomede Pantaleom, carteggio inedito (Turin, 1888), 338.Google Scholar

118 De la Rive, op. cit. 209; 6 March 1861, Farini to Castelli, Carteggio politico di Michelangelo Castelli (ed. Chiala, Turin, 1890), I, 346.

119 13 June 1861, Oldofredi to La Marmora, Archivio La Marmora, casetta XCVI, cartella 54.

120 20 May 1858, Cavour in parliament; also Artom e Blanc, Cavour in parlamento, XXII.

121 11 Oct. 1858, Cavour, cit. Massari, Diario, 67.

122 26 June 1856, Cavour to Marchese Sauli, Nuove lettere, 372; Feb. 1859, Cavour to La Farina, Chiala, Lettere, III, 22; 18 Dec. 1859, Il Piccolo Corriere d'Italia.

123 De la Rive, op. cit. 246. Omodeo notes this without comment, Opera politica, II, 140.

124 19 June 1856, L'Opinione.

125 23 Nov. 1857, Cavour to Boncompagni, Chiala, Lettere, VI, 87.

126 1 June 1858, L'Indipendente; 4 Dec. 1853, Gazzetta del Popolo.

127 28 Feb. 1858, Cavour to Villamarina, Chiala, Lettere, VI, 191.

128 Sept. 1859, Cavour to La Farina, ibid. III, 134.

129 1 April 1860, 27 May 1860, Il Piccolo Corriere d' Italia.

130 12–13 Nov. 1858, Massari, Diario, 88–9.

131 Ibid. 196, 198, 206, 290, 535.

132 4 Feb. 1859, Hudson, cit. Massari, Diario, 182; 25 Aug. 1859, Russell to Corbett, Russell Papers, 30/22/109.

133 28 March 1859, Massari, Diario, 257.

134 14 March 1859, Cavour to C. Cabella, Chiala, Lettere, III, 45; 15 May and 4 June 1859, Cavour to La Marmora, ibid. 76, 92; 13 June 1859, Cavour to Governor Vigliani, ibid. 96.

135 30 June 1861, Hudson to Russell: the King ‘rendered full justice to his many great qualities of heart and head: but he (the King) could not shut his eyes to the fact that his great statesmanship was at times most hazardous to the state. In his passion (said H.M.) he has sometimes kicked over every chair in this room. He has called me “traitor”, and worse; but I knew this was merely the effect of temper and I used to sit quietly making my own notes of the particular matter which had driven him to this extremity of heat and when he cooled I used to read them to him. After his bursts of temper he was cool and collected: I believe his reason forsook him in those moments for he seemed to have no recollection of them: and hence I often doubted whether he were a safe guide tho' I am the first to do justice to his immense courage and his great capacity for details of business. I am not at all sure (he continued) but what we might have obtained the same end with less labour and without alarming all Europe’, Russell Papers, 30/22/68.

136 16 Nov. 1848, article, ed. Gentile, Scritti politici, 288.

137 P. della Gattina, I moribondi, 58.

138 17 Feb. 1857, Duc de Gramont to Walewski, A.É. Corr pol. Sard., vol. 341.

139 13 Feb 1851, Cavour in parliament.

140 20 March 1861, Vimercati to Castelli, Carteggio di Castelli, I, 348.

141 12 April, 24 May, 1861, Hudson to Russell, Russell Papers, 30/22/68.