Uncertainties about the identity of type specimens of red algae have frequently led to taxonomic and nomenclatural confusion. A procedure for extracting PCR-amplifiable DNA from formalin-fixed material and herbarium specimens was used to investigate the taxonomic status of several South African Gigartinaceae. We compared nucleotide sequences in the internal transcribed spacer 1 (ITS1) region in type specimens and other historically important collections presently referred to Gigartina bracteata, G. radula and G. stiriata. The following opinions are supported: (1) Fucus bracteatus S.G. Gmelin, Chondrodictyon capense Kützing and Iridaea clathrata Decaisne represent a single species of South African Gigartina (G. bracteata (S.G. Gmelin) Setchell & Gardner) in which the disintegration of tetrasporangial sori results in a reticulate thallus. (2) Mastocarpus polycarpus Kützing, M. incrassatus Kützing and Iridaea lapathifolia Kützing represent a single species of South African Gigartina (G. polycarpa (Kützing) Setchell & Gardner) that has often, but erroneously, been called G. radula (Esper) J. Agardh. (3) Mastocarpus verrucosus Kützing is a later heterotypic synonym of Iridaea papillosa Bory (Sarcothalia papillosa (Bory) Leister) and was based on material that probably came from southern South America rather than from South Africa, the provenance given by Kützing. (4) Fucus stiriatus Turner and Sphaerococcus burmannii C. Agardh represent a single species of South African Sarcothalia (S. stiriata (Turner) Leister).