Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-nr4z6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-06T12:51:17.226Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

European ‘Dis-integration’ in Bosnia and Herzegovina: A Critical Reflection on Legal, Administrative and Political Obstacles Affecting the Approximation of Chapters 23 and 24 of the Acquis Communautaire

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  31 January 2013

Marco Roccia
Marco Roccia*
Affiliation:
Kent Law School, The University of Kent, Canterbury, Kent CT2 7NZ, UK. E-mail: m.roccia@kent.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Several pieces of legislation have been enacted with a view to regulating the European integration process in Bosnia and Herzegovina. A plethora of bodies are in charge for approximating the EU acquis. However, the stabilisation and association process in the field of justice related matters has not proceeded as planned due to the existence of at least four legislatures for the Justice Sector and 14 Ministries of Justice (MoJs) whose competences and tasks are not well delineated. This article focuses on the specific issues affecting the transposition of Chapters 23 (Judiciary and fundamental rights) and 24 (Justice, freedom and security) of the EU acquis. Based on the analysis of existing legislation and administrative structures and meetings with local officials and foreign donors, the author argues how, for an effective legal approximation process, a review of the current allocation of competences among State, Entities, Brčko District and canton level cannot wait. After drawing comparisons with regional best practices in the field of European integration and illustrating the complex constitutional framework of the country, the administrative and legislative obstacles characterising the approximation of domestic legislation with European standards in the field of Justice and Home affairs are explained. The author concludes by offering a set of solutions to overcome the current situation.

Type
Focus: Rights
Information
European Review , Volume 21 , Issue 1 , February 2013 , pp. 103 - 117
Copyright
Copyright © Academia Europaea 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References and Notes

1. The DEI role is defined in the Law on the Council of Ministers of BiH published on 3.12.2002 at http://www.ohr.int/decisions/statemattersdec/default.asp?content_id=28609 and in the Law on Ministers and Other Administrative Bodies of BiH (Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina, 5/03) at www.ohr.int/ohr-dept/legal/oth…/BH-LAW-ON-MINISTRIES.doc.Google Scholar
2. Competence of the DEI is regulated by article 23 Law on Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Article 18 on the Ministries and other administrative Government Bodies in BiH (infra).Google Scholar
3.Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina, No. 44/2003. According to para IV, ‘Vertical coordination shall be performed through the European integration coordinator from the entities, Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Republika Srpska and Brčko District of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The European integration coordinators from the entities and Brčko District of Bosnia and Herzegovina shall have the following duties: – Participation in drafting of strategic documents, – Organization of preparation and monitoring of timely meeting of duties and measures defined in the strategic documents, – Continuous contact to the Directorate for European Integrations in relation to all issues related to reporting and exchange of relevant information and data, –Regular gathering of information on entity institutions, Reporting of entity governments and government of Brčko District of Bosnia and Herzegovina on the accession process of Bosnia and Herzegovina to the European Union’.Google Scholar
4.Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina, No. 66/08. According to Article 2, (Establishment of Organizational Units and Jobs) ‘(1) Ministries, permanent bodies of the Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina (hereinafter: the Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina) and independent administrative bodies shall define in its rulebooks on internal organizational jobs, departments or similar mechanisms for the performance of duties as referred to in Articles 4–8 of the decision that belong to the competence of the ministry. Duties referred to in Articles 4–8 include coordination within each line ministry where they are established of European integration strategy and policy, European Union assistance instruments/programs, harmonization of legal system of Bosnia and Herzegovina with the Acquis Communautaire, in compliance with the constitutional competence in Bosnia and Herzegovina and translation of the Acquis Communautaire and cooperation with DEI’.Google Scholar
5. Chapter 23 ‘Judiciary and Fundamental Rights’ covers a number of policy areas namely independence of judiciary, anti-corruption policies; data protection; EU citizen's rights (the right to move and reside freely within the EU, to stand as candidates for the European parliament and municipal elections, diplomatic protection from a EU Embassy when they are abroad), fundamental rights as a right to live, and prohibition of torture, freedom of religion, right to education, and free speech, together with minority rights and cultural rights of citizens etc.Google Scholar
6. Chapter 24 ‘Justice, Freedom and Security’ covers border control, visas, external migration, asylum, police cooperation, fight against organised crime and against terrorism, cooperation in the field of drugs, customs cooperation and judicial cooperation in criminal and civil matters.Google Scholar
7. Adopted by the Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina, in the 82nd meeting held on 2 April 2009.Google Scholar
8. Annex 4 to the General Framework Agreement for Pease in BiH, signed on 14 December 1995.Google Scholar
9. Brčko District (BD) was established by the International Arbitration Decision of 1999, its constitutional structure is regulated by the Statute of BD. BD operates as a single self-governing administrative unit, under the sovereignty of BiH. It is separate from the two entities and has the status of an autonomous territory with its own legislation.Google Scholar
10. Article 1, paragraph 4 of the Statute of BD (adopted on 7 December 1999 at OHR website at http://www.ohr.int/ohr-offices/brcko/default.asp?content_id=5367) prescribes that the BiH Constitution, like other laws and decisions of the BiH institutions that are in force, shall be directly applicable on the whole territory of Brčko District. Further, any legislation or decisions passed by the BD authorities must be compatible with the laws and decisions of the BiH institutions.Google Scholar
11. See Article III, 4 of the BiH Constitution ‘BiH shall assume responsibility for such other matters as are agreed by Entities’.Google Scholar
12. Law on Ministries and other administrative bodies, Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina 5/03.Google Scholar
13. See Functional Review of the BIH Justice Sector p. 25.Google Scholar
14.Official Gazette of Republika Srpska, 70/02.Google Scholar
15.Official Gazette of Central Bosnia Canton, 2/97.Google Scholar
16. Adopted by the BiH Assembly on 26 January 2005.Google Scholar
17. Adopted by the Council of Ministers of BiH at its 128th session held on 7 September 2006 at http://www.mpr.gov.ba/web_dokumenti/rules_for_consultations.pdfGoogle Scholar
18. OG of BiH, 44/2003.Google Scholar
19. Otherwise, the proposed legal document shall be returned for completion; the proposing body has to act urgently and must complete it no later than 10 days after the day of return of the draft legal document.Google Scholar
20. Under Article 35 Rules of Procedures of CoM, the SL is also in charge of ensuring the publication of decisions in the Official Gazettes of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Entities and the District of Brčko.Google Scholar
21. Before 1992 the Secretariat was an independent body, which issued mandatory opinions on the conformity of a draft law with the Constitution and domestic legal order. The Secretariat functions under a new statute and powers as of 1995.Google Scholar
22. Rules of Procedures of the House of Parliament (Predstavncki Dom) and Art. 51 of Procedures of House of Peoples (Dom Naroda) at http://www.parlamentfbih.gov.ba/.Google Scholar
23. Within the Parliamentary administration a Legal Office has been set up, but its administrative capacity is too small.Google Scholar
24. Guidelines on the way of drafting and process of adoption of the technical legislation, OG BiH, 35/2006.Google Scholar
25. No such rules have been developed at a federal level. RS has some rules in this regard, which are 90% similar to these of the state level. Currently new rules are drafted and they will be mandatory for all levels of the legislative process. It is foreseen that the state level parliament must give recommendations to the entity parliaments on how to apply these rules.Google Scholar
26. OG of RS 81, 12 September 2007.Google Scholar
27. Article VI of Decision on the Procedure and Manner of Harmonisation of Legislation of RS with acquis communautaire.Google Scholar
28. Article 3 (2) of Decision on the procedure and manner of harmonisation of legislation of RS with acquis communautaire.Google Scholar
29. OG of RS 118/2008, 11/2009, 74/02.08.2010.Google Scholar
30. It also coordinates activities for strengthening the capacities of ministries for development aid; accomplishment of an Integration Strategy and legal harmonisation of RS legislation with EU regulations etc.Google Scholar
31. See Article VII, Decision on the Procedure and Manner of Harmonisation of Legislation of RS with acquis communautaire.Google Scholar
32. OG of RS, 107/2007.Google Scholar
33. Article VI, Decision on the Procedure and Manner of Harmonisation of Legislation of RS with acquis communautaire.Google Scholar
34. Article 3 (1), (2) of Regulation of FOLLH, OJ of FBiH, 49/2007.Google Scholar
35. Article 3 (3) of Regulation of FOLLH OJ of FBiH, 49/2007.Google Scholar
36. See Article 27 (1) of Rulebook for the Work of the Federal Government (integral text), OJ of FBiH, 6/2010.Google Scholar
37. The idea behind this practice is that the FOLLH is not competent to intervene in the work of the ministry as a body having legislative initiative.Google Scholar
38. Article 6 (3) of Regulation of FOLLH, OJ of FBiH, 49/2007.Google Scholar
39. Articles 80, 81 and 82 of Rulebook for the Work of the Federal Government (integral text), OJ of FBiH, 6/2010.Google Scholar
40. Article 71, ‘f’ of the Statute of BD District and Article 14 ‘h’ of the Law on BD Judicial Commission (Annex VII to the Order of the Supervisor for the Adoption of a Series of Laws and Amendments to Laws of Brčko District, dated 26 June 2007, in compliance with the Order of the Supervisor on Amendments to the Statute of Brčko District, dated 2 February 2007).Google Scholar
41. See Organisational Plan of the Office of the Mayor of BD (Rulebook on Internal Organisation of the BD Government).Google Scholar
42. This information was provided by the Secretary of the JC of BD.Google Scholar
43. Article 16, ‘f’ of Law on BD Government.Google Scholar
44. [Supremacy of federal law] ‘Federal law shall take precedence over Land law’.Google Scholar
45. The provision stresses the competence of the State for EU matters with an obligation to take into account the Länder's point of view if the act is impinging on its interests or to delegate by framework legislation to the Länder the power to issue legislation if the matter is falling under the Länder competence.Google Scholar
46. See EU Technical Assistance Contract ‘Support to the capacities in the Ministries of Justice in Bosnia and Herzegovina for strategic planning, aid co-ordination and European integration’ Terms of Reference, Activity 1.5. The contract was running from January 2010 to July 2011.Google Scholar
47. A reference to agreements as sources of legal norms is made in Article 17 Law on Rights and Duties of the Council of Ministers OG of Bosnia and Herzegovina, at http://www.ohr.int/decisions/statemattersdec/default.asp?content_id=28609 (‘In exercising its rights and duties, the Council of Ministers shall adopt decisions, conclusions and resolutions, draft and proposed laws, analyses, information materials, strategic documents, programmes, agreements, protocols and other acts (hereinafter: acts)’).Google Scholar
48. Is a MoU an administrative act or a political one? Is it subject to judicial review? How can it be enforced? How is conflict between a MoU provision and primary/secondary legislation solved?Google Scholar