Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-pftt2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-19T09:41:13.529Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Politics of Loyalty: Understanding Voters’ Attitudes after Primary Elections

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 November 2020

Fulvio Venturino Open the ORCID record for Fulvio Venturino [Opens in a new window]  and
Antonella Seddone Open the ORCID record for Antonella Seddone [Opens in a new window]
Fulvio Venturino*
Affiliation:
Department of Political and Social Sciences, University of Cagliari, Cagliari, Italy
Antonella Seddone
Affiliation:
Department of Cultures, Politics and Society, University of Turin, Turin, Italy
*
*Corresponding author. Email: fventurino@unica.it
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

What happens after primary elections? Strategies of loyalty or defection in general elections have been addressed by US literature mainly by means of aggregate data. However, we lack similar studies in non-US contexts. This article investigates the strategies followed after primary elections by taking the case of the Italian Partito Democratico as an illustration. We addressed the individual drivers of loyalty or defection strategies by considering three different dimensions: (1) the outcome of the primary election, having backed a winning or losing candidate; (2) the strength of partisanship, meant as ideological congruence with the party and partisan involvement; and (3) the leader effect. We relied on four surveys (exit polls) administered during party leadership selections held in 2009, 2013, 2017 and 2019. The results suggest that all three dimensions have an influence on post-primary strategies, but what counts the most is partisan involvement.

Keywords

defectionleadershiployaltypolitical attitudesprimary elections
Type
Article
Information
Government and Opposition , Volume 57 , Issue 2 , April 2022 , pp. 233 - 252
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Government and Opposition Limited

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aarts, K, Blais, A and Schmitt, H (eds) (2011) Political Leaders and Democratic Elections. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Abramowitz, AI (1989) Viability, Electability, and Candidate Choice in a Presidential Primary Election: A Test of Competing Models. Journal of Politics 51(4), 977–992.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkeson, LR (1993) Moving Toward Unity: Attitudes in the Nomination and General Election Stages of a Presidential Campaign. American Politics Quarterly 21(3), 272–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkeson, LR (1998) Divisive Primaries and General Election Outcomes: Another Look at Presidential Campaigns. American Journal of Political Science 42(1), 256–271.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkeson, LR (1999) Sure, I Voted for the Winner! Overreport of the Primary Vote for the Party Nominee in the National Election Studies. Political Behavior 21(3), 197–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barnea, S and Rahat, G (2007) Reforming Candidate Selection Methods: A Three-Level Approach. Party Politics 13(3), 375–394.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bernardi, L, Sandri, G and Seddone, A (2017) Challenges of Political Participation and Intra-Party Democracy: Bittersweet Symphony from Party Membership and Primary Elections in Italy. Acta Politica 52(2), 218–240.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bernstein, RA (1977) Divisive Primaries do Hurt: U.S. Senate Races, 1956–1972. American Political Science Review 71(2), 540–545.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bordignon, F (2014) Matteo Renzi: A ‘Leftist Berlusconi’ for the Italian Democratic Party? South European Society and Politics 19(1), 1–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brady, DW, Han, H and Pope, JC (2007) Primary Elections and Candidate Ideology: Out of Step with the Primary Electorate? Legislative Studies Quarterly 32(1), 79–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buell, EH Jr (1986) Divisive Primaries and Participation in Fall Presidential Campaigns: A Study of 1984 New Hampshire Primary Activists. American Politics Quarterly 14(4), 376–390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Canes-Wrone, B, Brady, DW and Cogan, JF (2002) Out of Step, Out of Office: Electoral Accountability and House Members’ Voting. American Political Science Review 96(1), 127–140.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carey, JM and Polga-Hecimovich, J (2006) Primary Elections and Candidate Strength in Latin America. Journal of Politics 68(3), 530–543.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Close, C and Kelbel, C (2019) Whose Primaries? Grassroots’ Views on Candidate Selection Procedures. Acta Politica 54(2), 268–294.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Close, C, Kelbel, C and Van Haute, E (2017) What Citizens Want in Terms of Intra-Party Democracy: Popular Attitudes Towards Alternative Candidate Selection Procedures. Political Studies 65(3), 646–664.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lobo M, Costa and Curtice, J (eds) (2014) Personality Politics? The Role of Leader Evaluations in Democratic Elections. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cross, WP and Blais, A (2012) Who Selects the Party Leader? Party Politics 18(2), 127–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cross, WP and Katz, RS (eds) (2013) The Challenges of Intra-Party Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cross, WP and Pilet, JB (eds) (2015) The Politics of Party Leadership: A Cross-National Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cross, W and Pruysers, S (2019) Sore Losers? The Costs of Intra-Party Democracy. Party Politics 25(4), 483–494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cross, WP, Kenig, O, Pruysers, S et al. (2016) The Promise and Challenge of Party Primary Elections: A Comparative Perspective. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.Google Scholar
De Luca, M and Venturino, F (2017) The Effects of Primaries on Electoral Performance: France and Italy in Comparative Perspective. French Politics 15(1), 43–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Djupe, PA and Peterson, DAM (2002) The Impact of Negative Campaigning: Evidence from the 1998 Senatorial Primaries. Political Research Quarterly 55(4), 845–860.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, J and Ivaldi, G (2018) The Presidential Primaries and Polarization of Mainstream Party Politics. In Evans J and Ivaldi G, The 2017 French Presidential Elections. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 45–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fasano, LM and Natale, P (2017) L'ultimo partito. 10 anni di Partito Democratico. Turin: Giappichelli.Google Scholar
Garzia, D (2011) The Personalization of Politics in Western Democracies. Leadership Quarterly 22(4), 697–709.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garzia, D (2013) The Rise of Party/Leader Identification in Western Europe. Political Research Quarterly 66(3), 533–544.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garzia, D and Venturino, F (2018) I leader di partito nelle elezioni 2018. In ITANES (ed.), Vox populi. Il voto ad alta voce del 2018. Bologna: il Mulino, pp. 211–223.Google Scholar
Geer, JG (1988) Assessing the Representativeness of Electorates in Presidential Primaries. American Journal of Political Science 32(4), 929–945.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hacker, A (1965) Does a ‘Divisive’ Primary Harm a Candidate's Election Chances? American Political Science Review 59(1), 105–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hazan, RY and Rahat, G (2010) Democracy Within Parties: Candidate Selection Methods and Their Political Consequences. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henderson, M, Hillygus, DS and Tompson, T (2010) Sour Grapes or Rational Voting? Voter Decision Making Among Thwarted Primary Voters in 2008. Public Opinion Quarterly 74(3), 499–529.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herrnson, PS and Gimpel, JG (1995) District Conditions and Primary Divisiveness in Congressional Elections. Political Research Quarterly 48(1), 117–134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirano, S, Snyder, JM Jr, Ansolabehere, SD et al. (2010) Primary Elections and Partisan Polarization in the U.S. Congress. Quarterly Journal of Political Science 5(2), 169–191.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hogan, RE (2003) The Effects of Primary Divisiveness on General Election Outcomes in State Legislative Elections. American Politics Research 31(1), 27–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson, DB and Gibson, JR (1974) The Divisive Primary Revisited: Party Activists in Iowa. American Political Science Review 68(1), 67–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ignazi, P (2020) The Four Knights of Intra-Party Democracy: A Rescue for Party Delegitimation. Party Politics 26(1), 9–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Indridason, IH and Kristinsson, GH (2013) Primary Consequences: The Effects of Candidate Selection Through Party Primaries in Iceland. Party Politics 21(4), 565–576.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Karvonen, L (2010) The Personalisation of Politics: A Study of Parliamentary Democracies. Colchester: ECPR Press.Google Scholar
Katz, RS and Mair, P (eds) (1994) How Parties Organize: Change and Adaptation in Party Organizations in Western Democracies. London: Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kenig, O (2009) Democratization of Party Leadership Selection: Do Wider Selectorates Produce More Competitive Contests? Electoral Studies 28(2), 240–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kenney, PJ and Rice, TW (1987) The Relationship Between Divisive Primaries and General Election Outcomes. American Journal of Political Science 31(1), 31–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
King, A (ed.) (2002) Leaders' Personalities and the Outcomes of Democratic Elections. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lazarus, J (2005) Unintended Consequences: Anticipation of General Election Outcomes and Primary Election Divisiveness. Legislative Studies Quarterly 30(3), 435–461.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lazarus, J (2018) Divisive Primaries: When Do They Hurt in the General Election? In Boatright, RG (ed.), Routledge Handbook of Primary Elections. London: Routledge, pp. 175–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levy, MR (1983) The Methodology and Performance of Election Day Polls. Public Opinion Quarterly 47(1), 54–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mény, Y (2017) A Tale of Party Primaries and Outsider Candidates: The 2017 French Presidential Election. French Politics 15(3), 265–278.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miller, PM, Jewell, ME and Sigelman, L (1988) Divisive Primaries and Party Activists: Kentucky, 1979 and 1983. Journal of Politics 50(2), 459–470.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mughan, A (2009) Partisan Dealignment, Party Attachments and Leader Effects. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties 19(4), 413–431.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Norrander, B (1996) Presidential Nomination Politics in the Post-Reform Era. Political Research Quarterly 49(4), 875–915.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pasquino, G and Valbruzzi, M (2016) Primary Elections between Fortuna and Virtù. Contemporary Italian Politics 8(1), 3–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pasquino, G and Valbruzzi, M (2017) The Italian Democratic Party, its Nature and its Secretary. Revista Española de Ciencia Política 44, 275–299.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pasquino, G and Venturino, F (2010) Il Partito Democratico di Bersani: persone, profilo e prospettive. Bologna: Bononia University Press.Google Scholar
Pasquino, G and Venturino, F (2014) Il Partito Democratico secondo Matteo. Bologna: Bononia University Press.Google Scholar
Peterson, DAM and Djupe, PA (2005) When Primary Campaigns go Negative: The Determinants of Campaign Negativity. Political Research Quarterly 58(1), 45–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Piereson, JE and Smith, TB (1975) Primary Divisiveness and General Election Success: A Re-Examination. Journal of Politics 37(2), 555–562.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Poguntke, T and Webb, PD (eds) (2007) The Presidentialization of Politics: A Comparative Study of Modern Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Polk, J and Kölln, AK (2018) Electoral Infidelity: Why Party Members Cast Defecting Votes. European Journal of Political Research 57(2), 539–560.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rahat, G and Kenig, O (2018) From Party Politics to Personalized Politics? Party Change and Political Personalization in Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rombi, S and Serricchio, F (2019) L'elezione di Zingaretti: la rivincita del partito?. Novi Ligure: Edizioni Epoké.Google Scholar
Sanches, ER, Lisi, M, Razzuoli, I et al. (2018) Intra-Party Democracy from Members’ Viewpoint: The Case of Left-Wing Parties in Portugal. Acta Politica 53(3), 391–408.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sandri, G and Seddone, A (eds) (2015) The Primary Game. Primary Elections in the Italian Democratic Party. Novi Ligure: Edizioni Epoké.Google Scholar
Sandri, G, Seddone, A and Venturino, F (eds) (2015) Party Primaries in Comparative Perspective. Farnham: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Scarrow, SE, Webb, PD and Poguntke, T (eds) (2017) Organizing Political Parties: Representation, Participation, and Power. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Southwell, PL (1986) The Politics of Disgruntlement: Non Voting and Defection Among Supporters of Nomination Losers. Political Behavior 8(1), 81–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Southwell, PL (1994) Prenomination Preferences and General Election Voting Behavior. Social Science Journal 31(1), 69–77.Google Scholar
Southwell, PL (2010) The Effect of Nomination Divisiveness on the 2008 Presidential Election. PS: Political Science & Politics 43(2), 255–258.Google Scholar
Stewart, DK (2018) Primaries and the Personalization of Party Leadership. In Cross, WP, Katz, RS and Pruysers, S (eds), The Personalization of Democratic Politics and the Challenge for Political Parties. London: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 79–101.Google Scholar
van Haute, E and Gauja, A (eds) (2015) Party Members and Activists. London and New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Venturino, F (2015) Promoting Internal Democracy: An Analysis of the Statute of the Partito Democratico. In Sandri, G and Seddone, A (eds), The Primary Game: The Case of the Italian Democratic Party. Novi Ligure: Edizioni Epoké, pp. 35–50.Google Scholar
Ware, A (1979) Divisive Primaries: The Important Questions. British Journal of Political Science 9(3), 381–384.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wattenberg, MP (1991) The Rise of Candidate-Centered Politics: Presidential Elections of the 1980s. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Webb, PD, Poguntke, T and Kolodny, R (2012) The Presidentialization of Party Leadership? Evaluating Party Leadership and Party Government in the Democratic World. In Helms, L (ed.), Comparative Political Leadership. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 77–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wichowsky, A and Niebler, SE (2010) Narrow Victories and Hard Games: Revisiting the Primary Divisiveness Hypothesis. American Politics Research 38(6), 1052–1071.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Venturino and Seddone supplementary material

Venturino and Seddone supplementary material

Download Venturino and Seddone supplementary material(File)
File 43.5 KB