Crossref Citations
This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by Crossref.
Burgess, Glenn
2009.
British Political Thought, 1500–1660.
p.
246.
Article contents
Gerrard Winstanley's Experimental Knowledge of God (The Perception of the Spirit and the Acting of Reason)
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 March 2011
Extract
This essay is an attempt to find out what Winstanley meant by certain terms, using close textual analysis. Extensive work has already been done in locating Winstanley in political, theological and, as far as possible, intellectual terms. This will receive only cursory treatment here. A scholarly tradition can be traced from Bernstein, through Petergorsky and Margaret James to Christopher Hill, which places Winstanley at the beginning of the development of materialist socialism although, it is suggested, his ideas proved to be a false start and went underground for a century or more. This view derives from his later works, especially The Law of Freedom, with its practical design of tilling the land communally, and sees his mysticism either as a cloak for revolutionary aims or as an undeveloped stage in his thought which he later left behind and which is thus of secondary importance. Work has been done, sometimes by the same scholars, to map out the tenets of his religious beliefs in the context of contemporary radical Puritanism, considering whether he was, for instance, a mortalist, a universalist or a millenarian, and how far he was any of these. For such doctrinal identification one can look to W. S. Hudson, the co-operative study of L. Mulligan, J. K. Graham and J. Richards and to Christopher Hill, for all of these have compared and contrasted his beliefs with those of Seekers, Ranters, Fifth Monarchists and Quakers. Hill himself, however, has pointed out the difficulties of placing Winstanley in a particular group because of the fluidity of the borders between one sect and another; sects sharing certain beliefs while differing in others and changing character internally with changing political circumstances.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1988
References
1 Bernstein, E., Cromwell and Communism, London 1961Google Scholar; Petergorsky, D. W., Left-wing Democracy in the English Civil War, London 1940Google Scholar; James, W., Social Problems and Policy during the Puritan Revolution; Hill, C. (ed.), The Law of Freedom and Other Writings, Harmondsworth 1973Google Scholar.
2 Hudson, W. S., ‘The economic and social thought of Gerrard Winstanley’, Journal of Modem History xvii (1946), 1–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Mulligan, L., Graham, J. K. and Richards, J., ‘Win-stanley: a case for the man as he said he was’, this Journal xxviii (1977), 57–75Google Scholar ; Hill, C., ‘The religion of Gerrard Winstanley’, Past and Present, Supp. v (1978)Google Scholar.
3 Hayes, T. W., Winstanley the Digger, Harvard 1978.Google Scholar
4 For biographical details see The Works of Gerrard Winstanley (hereinafter cited as Works), ed. Sabine, G. H., New York 1941Google Scholar , introduction.
6 For Truth Lifting up its Head, see ibid. 97-146.
7 Ibid. 147-245.
8 Ibid. 249-66.
9 Ibid. 443-97.
10 Ibid. 499-602.
11 A lot of work has been done to discover whether Winstanley returned to practising a trade and died a Quaker, which would show that his ‘materialist’ phase was a temporary one and that he became a pacifist, see Vann, R. T., ‘The later life of Gerrard Winstanley’, Journal of the History of Ideas xxvi (1965), 133–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Alsop, James, ‘Gerrard Winstanley's later life’, Past and Present Ixxvii (1979), 73–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
12 Truth, 100.
13 Ibid. 101.
14 Ibid. 104.
15 Ibid. 104-5.
16 Ibid. 105.
17 The Breaking of The Day of God, abstracted in Works, 87-90, esp. at p. 88.
18 Truth, 124.
19 The New Law of Righteousness, in Works, 147-245, esp. at p. 242.
20 See the remarks of General Ireton reproduced in Puritanism and Liberty, being the Army Debates (1647-9) from the Clarke Manuscripts with Supplementary Documents in Puritanism, ed. Woodhouse, A. S. P., London 1950, 21Google Scholar.
21 Quoted in ibid. 106.
22 Nuttall, G. F., The Holy Spirit in Puritan Faith and Experience, London 1947, 38.Google Scholar
23 Puritanism and Liberty, 59-60.
24 Mystery of God, 81-2.
25 Breaking of The Day, 89.
26 A Watchword to the City of London, 315-39 esp. at pp. 328-9.
27 The Saints Paradise, in Works, 93-4.
28 In Works, 459.
28 Paradice, abstract in Works, 93.
30 Ibid.
31 , Nuttall, Holy Spirit, 115.Google Scholar
32 Col. Rainborough, quoted in , Woodhouse, Puritanism and Liberty, 55.Google Scholar
33 Capt. J. Clarke quoted in ibid. 38.
34 , Hill, ‘Religion’, 37–9.Google Scholar
35 Hill, C., ‘Reason and reasonableness’, in Hill, C. (ed.), Change and Continuity in Seventeenth-century England, London 1974.Google Scholar
36 Truth, 109.
37 The True Levellers Standard Advanced (1649), in Works, 247–66 esp. at p. 251.Google Scholar
38 Truth, 105.
39 Ibid. 108.
40 Paradice, 96.
41 Fire in The Bush, in Works, 462; cf. Clarkson, Lawrence, ‘A single eye all light, no darkness’, in Cohn, Norman, The Pursuit of the Millennium, London 1957, 113.Google Scholar
42 Fire, 456.
43 Ibid. 458.
44 Ibid. 494.
45 Ibid. 481.
46 Ibid. 489.
47 Ibid. 485.
48 Ibid. 495.
49 Hill, C., The World Turned Upside Down: radical ideas during the English Revolution, Harmondsworth 1982, 140.Google Scholar
50 New Law, 224-5.
51 Ibid. 216, 217.
62 The Law of Freedom, in Works, 501-602 esp. at p. 565.
53 New Law, 229.
54 Ibid. 162-3 (mY emphasis).
55 True Levellers, 256.
56 New Law, 169.
57 , Hayes, Winstanley the Digger, 15.Google Scholar
58 , Hill, World Turned Upside Down, 150.Google Scholar
59 New Law, 231.
60 , Hill, op. cit. 142.Google Scholar
61 Law of Freedom, 565.
62 See also Rupp, G., Patterns of Reformation, London 1969Google Scholar , part iii, ch. xxi (Thomas Miintzer, Hans Huth and the ‘Gospel of All Creatures’).
63 New Law, 231.
64 Ibid. 165.
65 Ibid. 231.
65 Ibid. 226.
67 Ibid. 229.
68 Fire, 453.
69 New Law, 155. A New-Years Gift for the Parliament and Armie, in Words, 353-96 esp. at p. 376.
70 , Hill, World Turned Upside Down, 131.Google Scholar
71 , Hudson, ‘Economic and social thought’, 8, 21.Google Scholar
72 ‘The peace they experienced in their hearts was the final justification of the digging’, ibid. 11.
73 Truth, 134.
74 Mew Law, 243-4.
76 Ibid. 155.
76 Ibid. 185.
77 Ibid. 195.
78 New-Years Gift, 369.
- 1
- Cited by