No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Seeking employment during Japan's early industrialisation: new engineering graduates and their struggles before 1900
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 March 2024
Abstract
This article examines the social background of engineers in Meiji Japan by analysing their employment-seeking activities and their role in fostering industrial development. In particular, it focuses on the graduates from the Imperial College of Engineering (ICE) in Tokyo. One of the most prestigious schools for technical education, the ICE was established by the Meiji government in 1871 and opened in 1873. In traditional Japanese society, the handicraft manufacturing sector was held in low regard. The difficulties that graduates faced while the industry was still developing serve as a stark reminder of the widespread contempt and disdain for manufacturing that existed in Japan before the new profession of engineer gained traction. By scrutinising the memoirs of these engineers, this study shows that new engineering graduates faced barriers to employment in industry due to the low social prestige of those working in manufacturing in the private sector and the conflict with traditional workers, as well as the fact that private companies could not afford to employ engineers in the early years of industrialisation.
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Royal Asiatic Society
References
1 Gerth, H. and Mills, C. W., Character and Social Structure: The Psychology of Social Institutions (New York, 1953), p. 330Google Scholar.
2 Dore, R. P., The Diploma Disease: Education, Qualification, and Development (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1976), p. 42Google Scholar. In Britain, a regular route for training engineers existed separately from universities. Therefore, the British tradition of emphasising practical experience and neglecting theory hindered the development of engineering education at universities. Educational historian Shin Hirose argues that a strong tradition of on-the-job training in Britain continued until before World War II. See Hirose, S., Igirisu gijutsusha yōsei-shi no kenkyū (Tokyo, 2012)Google Scholar.
3 Ōyodo, S., Kindai Nihon no kōgyō rikkokuka to kokumin keisei (Tokyo, 2009)Google Scholar.
4 Moore, A. S., Constructing East Asia: Technology, Ideology, and Empire in Japan's Wartime Era, 1931–1945 (Stanford, 2013)Google Scholar, specifically pp. 64–101.
5 The introduction of technical education in Japan was led by the government. The main trend was to prioritise the education of high-level engineers and delay the education of those at the intermediate level and below. One of the representative schools for intermediate technical education was Seisaku-gaku Kyōjō (Manufacturing School), which was established by the Ministry of Education in 1874 and closed within three years because it offered only simple ‘lay practice’. See M. Wada, ‘The fall of the Imperial College of Engineering: from the Imperial College of Engineering (Kōbu-dai-gakkō) to the Faculty of Engineering at Imperial University, 1886’, in Accessing Technical Education in Modern Japan, (eds.) E. Pauer and R. Mathias (Kent, 2022), pp. 161–88. Other examples include Tokyo Shokkō-gakkō (Tokyo Vocational School, later the Tokyo Institute of Technology), founded in 1881 by the Ministry of Education, and a private technical school, Kōshu-gakkō (later Kōgakuin University), established in 1887.
6 The seven courses were civil engineering, mechanical engineering, telegraphy, architecture, practical chemistry, mining, and metallurgy. These were influenced by the wide range of departments established in the Ministry of Public Works. The course of naval architecture was added in 1882. It is conceivable to consider the differences among these fields but, due to the limited number of memoirs written by graduates in each field, it was not possible to address them in this article.
7 The Imperial University (Teikoku-daigaku) was originally called the University of Tokyo and, when it merged with the ICE in 1886, it became the Imperial University. It then became Tokyo Imperial University with the establishment of the second Imperial University in Kyoto in 1897. In 1947, it was renamed the University of Tokyo.
8 Wada, M., ‘Kōbu-dai-gakkō ni okeru kagaku-ka no ichizuke’, Kagakushi kenkyū 39.2 (2012), pp. 55–78Google Scholar, at p. 71.
9 Amano, I., ‘Sangyō kakumei-ki ni okeru gijutsu-sha no ikusei-keitai to koyō-kōzō’, Kyōiku shakaigaku kenkyū 20 (1965), pp. 156–73Google Scholar; Iwauchi, R., ‘Kindai nihon ni okeru gijutsusha no keisei’, Keiei-shi-gaku 7.3 (1973), pp. 32–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar; H. Uchida, ‘Japanese technical manpower in industry, 1880–1930: a quantitative survey’, in Industrial Training and Technological Innovation, (ed.) H. F. Gosel (New York, 1991), pp. 112–35.
10 For example, Nakamura, N., Nihon tetsudō-gyō no keisei (Tokyo, 1998)Google Scholar; Tsunekawa, S., ‘Meiji Nihon ni okeru shoki denki gijutsu-sha no bunseki’, Kagakushi kenkyū 42.225 (2003), pp. 20–30Google Scholar; Tsunekawa, S., ‘Meiji-ki Nihon no doboku jigyō o sasaeta gijutsu-sha-shūdan to sono tokuchō’, Kagakushi kenkyū 44.235 (2005), pp. 177–90Google Scholar.
11 For example, M. Wada, ‘The role of the Ministry of Public Works in designing engineering education in Meiji Japan: reconsidering the foundation of the Imperial College of Engineering (Kōbu-dai-gakkō)’, in Accessing Technical Education in Modern Japan, (eds.) Pauer and Mathias, pp. 88–113.
12 For a detailed review of the reliability of the book, see Ｍ. Wada, ‘Kōbu-dai-gakkō dobokuka no jicchi kyōiku: Ishibashi Ayahiko no kaisō-roku kara’, Kagakushi kenkyū 53.269 (2014), pp. 49–66.
13 H. Morikawa, ‘Meiji-ki “Kōka-daigaku” sotsu kaisha gishi no risuto’, Keiei shirin 11.2 (1974), pp. 103–23; H. Uchida, ‘Gijutsu-sha denki mokuroku’, Keiei to rekishi 6 (1983), pp. 35–44.
14 N. Takamura, ‘Matsukata defure kara kigyō bokkō e’, in Kigyō bokkō, (ed.) N. Takamura (Kyoto, 1992), pp. 1–15.
15 M. Tanimoto, ‘“Sangyō kakumei” to “zairai-teki keizai hatten”’, in Nihon keizai-shi, (eds.) M. Sawai and M. Tanimoto (Tokyo, 2016), pp. 143–245, at p. 146.
16 Japan's industrial revolution was the process of establishing a capitalist economy that encouraged an increase in the number of companies. It should be noted that, during this period, technology transplanted from the West and traditional manufacturing were progressing in parallel. Economic historian Takafusa Nakamura shows that, even in 1909, cottage-industry production still accounted for half of all industrial production. See T. Nakamura, Nihon keizai: Sono seichō to kōzō, 3rd edn (Tokyo, 1993), p. 80. For a history of research on Japan's industrial revolution, see N. Nakamura, ‘Reconsidering the Japanese industrial revolution: local entrepreneurs in the cotton textile industry during the Meiji era’, Social Science Japan Journal 18.1 (2015), pp. 23–44.
17 T. Muramatsu, ‘Nihon no sangyō kakumei’, in Gijutsu-shi, (ed.) T. Yamazaki (Tokyo, 1961), pp. 39–68, at p. 42.
18 Hōrei zensho (Meiji 7 nen), p. 1234. If this rule could not be met due to a student dropping out, etc., the guarantor had to repay the expenses up to that point.
19 Ibid., p. 1237.
20 If they moved to the private sector, they were required to pay a penalty of 700 yen, but the Ministry of Public Works seems to have been flexible about this. For example, Minoji Arakawa, a second-year graduate from the Course of Mining at the ICE, was exempted from paying a penalty when he went to a private railway company from the Ministry of Public Works. See Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō hensan-kai (ed.), Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō, furoku (Tokyo, 1931), p. 60. Another example is the case of Tsunehisa Fujii, a fifth-year graduate from the Course of Chemistry, who was recruited by the Ministry of the Army. See T. Hayashi, ‘6 gatsu hatsuka kōbu shokikan dai-gakkō kagaku sotsugyō-seito Fujii Tsunehisa saiyō no gi ni-tsuki kaitō’, June 1883, Ref. C09121042200, at the Japan Center for Asian Historical Records. However, in many cases, no records have remained and the effectiveness of this rule is not clear.
21 H. Itō, ‘Gijutsu no mono hishoku mōshitsuke sōrō-setsu gekkyū sonohoka-tō no gi’, October 1875, Ref. A07090164800, at the Japan Center for Asian Historical Records.
22 Y. Nakanishi, Nihon kindai-ka no kiso katei, chū (Tokyo, 1983), p. 460.
23 T. Muramatsu, ‘Kindai gijutsu no ishoku to ikusei’, in Gijutsu-shi, (ed.) Yamazaki, pp. 1–38, at p. 22.
24 Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō hensan-kai (ed.), Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō (Tokyo, 1931), p. 121.
25 Ibid., pp. 104, 133.
26 Ōkura-shō (ed.), Kōbu-shō enkaku hōkoku (Tokyo, 1889), p. 806. The career paths of the graduates of the college are mentioned in Wada, ‘Kōbu-dai-gakkō ni okeru kagaku-ka no ichizuke’.
27 Wada, ‘Kōbu-dai-gakkō ni okeru kagaku-ka no ichizuke’, pp. 60–61.
28 It should be noted that the chemical industry may have been slower to develop than other industrial fields. For example, one article reports a chemical company founded in 1877 with involvement of a prominent chemist, Jōkichi Takamine (1854–1922), who was one of the first graduates from the ICE. The report notes that he would lead the chemical industry, which has lagged behind other industries. See ‘Zakki, Tokyo jinzō hiryō kaisha’, Kōgakkai-shi 77 (1888), pp. 456–57, at p. 457.
29 ‘Zakki, Kōgakkai ichigatsu no tsūjō-kai to shin-nen-enkai’, Kōgakkai-shi 110 (1891), pp. 103–6, at pp. 104–5.
30 S. Utsumi, ‘Waga-hō no Porutolando semento seizō-gyō’, Kōgyō kagaku zasshi 15.169 (1912), pp. 257–82, at p. 263.
31 Tetsudō seinen-kai honbu (ed.), Iwasaki hakushi tsuikairoku (Tokyo, 1911), pp. 15–16.
32 C. Kadono, Hei-hei bon-bon kujūnen (Tokyo, 1956), pp. 19–21.
33 Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō, furoku, p. 115.
34 Ibid., pp. 34–35. For comparison, the starting salary for a police officer was 4 yen in 1874. See Shūkan Asahi (ed.), Nedan-shi nenpyō: Meiji, Taishō, Shōwa (Tokyo, 1988), p. 91.
35 Nakamura argues that the late entry of ICE graduates into the railway industry put them at a disadvantage compared with other engineers, which ultimately encouraged them to enter the private sector. See Nakamura, Nihon tetsudō-gyō no keisei, p. 152.
36 Ibid., pp. 152–54.
37 N. Nitta (ed.), Kikuchi Kyōzō-ō den (Osaka, 1948), pp. 57–59. Studying abroad was considered a privilege that promised a high status afterwards.
38 Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō, furoku, pp. 88–89.
39 K. Yamamoto, Nihon ni okeru shokuba no gijutsu, rōdō-shi: 1854–1990 (Tokyo, 1994), p. 173.
40 What I discuss here is the relationship with foremen as it affected the employment of new graduates, not the impact of foremen and productivity. In the case of iron making, in which a large number of skilled workers were essential, foremen played an important role in securing human resources in a factory. See Y. Tōjō, ‘Shoki seitetsu-gyō to shokkō shakai’, in Kigyō bokkō, (ed.) Takamura, pp. 201–32.
41 G. Kuwada, Kuwada Gonpei, jiden (Kyoto, 1958), pp. 66–67.
42 Tōyō Bōseki kabushiki kaisha and ‘Tōyō Bōseki shichijū-nenshi’ henshū iinkai (eds.), Tōyō bōseki shichijū-nenshi (Tokyo, 1953), p. 179.
43 E. Shibusawa, S. Onuki, and Y. Takahashi, Seien kaikoroku, Jō (Tokyo, 1927), p. 432.
44 Ibid., pp. 432–33.
45 T. Kuwada, ‘Haran chōjū no gojū-nen: Mushiryoku ni shūshi sita tankō-gyō’, Sekitan jihō 2.11 (1927), pp. 1018–23, at pp. 1020–21.
46 M. Sengoku, ‘Kōgyō fushin no gen-in o ronzu’, Kōgaku-sōshi 1.5 (1882), pp. 199–205, at pp. 200–1.
47 I have discussed the ethos of samurai origin that influenced the formation of Japanese engineering in my master's thesis. See M. Wada, ‘Engineering Education and the Spirit of Samurai at the Imperial College of Engineering in Tokyo, 1871–1886’ (unpublished master's thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 2007).
48 S. Nakamura, Tanakadate Aikitsu sensei (Tokyo, 1943), p. 25. In the end, Tanakadate did not pursue political science and eventually became a professor of physics at Tokyo Imperial University.
49 S. Katsuta, Katsuta Shuichi chosakushū, 5, gakkō-ron, daigaku-ron (Tokyo, 1972), p. 295.
50 M. Yoshida, Zusetsu, gijutsu to Nihon kindaika (Tokyo, 1977), p. 188.
51 H. Dyer, Introductory Address on the Training and Works of Engineers in Their Wider Aspects (Glasgow, 1905), p. 20; and H. Dyer, Valedicory Address: To the Students of the Imperial College of Engineering (Tokyo, 1882), p. 5. After studying civil and mechanical engineering at the University of Glasgow, Henry Dyer came to Japan in 1873 when he was 24 as the first principal of the ICE. He published many works on Japan and engineering education, including Dai Nippon, the Britain of the East: A Study in National Evolution (London, 1904). Much research has been done on Dyer. For example, see N. Miyoshi, Henry Dyer: Pioneer of Engineering Education in Japan, (trans.) T. Sarada and A. Sarada (Kent, 2004). Most of Dyer's writings are available in N. Miyoshi (ed.), The Collected Writings of Henry Dyer: A Collection in Five Volumes (Kent, 2006).
52 Dore, Diploma Disease, p. 44.
53 Kyū Kōbu-dai-gakkō shiryō, p. 137.
54 S. Nakayama, Teikoku daigaku no tanjō (Tokyo, 1978), pp. 102–3.
55 Muramatsu, ‘Kindai gijutsu no ishoku to ikusei’, p. 33.
56 T. Karasawa, Gakusei no rekishi (Tokyo, 1955), p. 163.
57 S. Nishikiya, Daigaku to jinbutsu (Tokyo, 1914), p. 109.
58 Ibid., p. 8.
59 Ōkōchi, M., ‘Kōgyō kyōiku shiken’, Tōyō gakugei zasshi 31.392 (1914), pp. 210–24Google Scholar, at p. 220.