No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Kneeling in the Street: Recontextualizing Balthasar
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 January 2024
Abstract
This paper supports the burgeoning movement that looks to find affinities between Hans urs von Balthasar's theology and various liberation theologies. It does so by offering a “recontextualization” of Balthasar's thought. Specifically, it provocatively looks to recontextualize Balthasar as a theologian of the street. The argument proceeds in three stages: First, the meaning of “context,” and so the possibility of recontextualization, is discussed. While the term has become commonplace in contemporary “contextual theologies,”, the most rigorous analysis of context is found not in theology, but in literary theory. Second, the particular locale of this particular recontextualization is discussed: the street. As sign, the street is ideologically and metonymically overdetermined. Here, Derrida, Goizueta, and Maeseneer are given as examples of thinkers who think with or from the street, who are contextualized by the street. Finally, the paper turns to specific instances in Balthasar's text that demonstrate his street contextualization: namely, his criticism of Rahner's martyrless Christianity and his discussion of the saints, particularly Joan of Arc. This section rejects those claims, epitomized by Murphy, that Balthasar's name signs a totally conservative context, and so completes my project of freeing space for the aforementioned liberatory movement to continue blossoming.
Keywords
- Type
- Original Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 2017 Provincial Council of the English Province of the Order of Preachers
References
1 Ezek. 11:6.
2 Nah. 2:4.
3 Rev. 21:21.
4 Gonzalez, Michelle, “Hans urs von Balthasar and Contemporary Feminist Theology,” Theological Studies 65(3). 566‐595CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Goizueta, Roberto, Christ Our Companion (Orbis, 2009)Google Scholar.
6 de Maeseneer, Yves, “Theological Truth in a Context of Aestheticisation: Research Memoranda on Hans urs von Balthasar and Theodor Adorno,” in, Theology and the Quest for Truth (Leuven University Press, 2006)Google Scholar.
7 Ryan, Michael, Marxism and Deconstruction: A Critical Articulation (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1984). 216‐217Google Scholar.
8 de Maeseneer, Yves, “Saint Francis Versus McDonald's? Contemporary Globalization Critique and Hans urs von Balthasar's Theological Aesthetics,” Heythrop Journal XLIV. 1‐14Google Scholar.
9 Crammer, Corrine, “One sex or two? Balthasar's theology of the sexes,” in The Cambridge Companion to Hans urs von Balthasar (Cambridge University Press, 2004)Google Scholar.
10 Miller, J. Hillis, “Derrida's Politics of Autoimmunity,” For Derrida (Fordham University Press, 2009). 222‐244CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
11 In theology, this acceptance seems to manifest in two different trajectories. There is the more self‐reflexive inculturation tradition, as seen in Schreiter's Constructing Local Theologies (Orbis, 1985); and also the subtler appeal to context in the explicitly hermeneutic theologies modeled after Paul Ricoeur's philosophy, as articulated in Joy's collection, Paul Ricoeur and Narrative: Context and Contestation (University of Calgary Press, 1997).
12 Barnett, Clive, “Deconstructing Context: Exposing Derrida,” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 24 (3). 277‐293CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 ibid.
14 Thus, contra the above ideal wherein the erased are made legible, here the absence of the absent is reified.
15 Derrida, Jacques, “Aphorism Countertime,” trans. by Royle, Nicholas, in Acts of Literature (Routledge, 1992). 414‐434Google Scholar. Also: “This Strange Institution Called Literature: An Interview with Jacques Derrida,” trans. by Derek Attridge, ibid. 33‐75.
16 Acts of Literature, 64.
17 Attridge, Derek, The Singularity of Literature (Routledge, 2004), p114CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
18 Crammer, 96.
19 Goizueta, 89.
20 Olson, Joel, The Abolition of White Democracy (University of Minnesota Press, 2004)Google Scholar. Especially ch. 4: “The Failure of Multiculturalism and Color Blindness.” 95‐125.
21 See: Bill O'Reilly, “President Obama and the Race Problem,” Talking Points, (Fox News: July, 2013). Accessible: http://www.foxnews.com/transcript/2013/07/23/bill-oreilly-president-obama-and-race-problem.html. Or: Bill O'Reilly, “To Race Hustler Al Sharpton: Your Day is Done,” Talking Points, (Fox News: July, 2013). Accessible: http://nation.foxnews.com/2013/07/30/oreilly-race-hustler-al-sharpton-your-day-done.html. Both of these remarks–directed toward Obama and Sharpton, hardly exemplars of “street culture”—came in July, 20013, the month George Zimmerman was found not guilty on the charge of second degree murder for killing Trayvon Martin.
22 See: John Stossel, “You Really Shouldn't Give to These Street People,” Fox Nation (Fox News: July, 2012). Accessible: http://nation.foxnews.com/john-stossel/2012/07/05/stossel-panhandles-prove-you-really-shouldn-t-give-these-street-people.
23 Christopher Groskopf, “Headcount: One out of every 100 Americans took to the street for the Women's March, according to estimates,” Quartz (Quartz: January 2017). Accessible: https://qz.com/891978/womens-march-one-out-of-every-100-americans-took-to-the-street-according-to-estimates/.
24 Interestingly, the Merriam Webster dictionary includes entries for “street people” and “take to the street,” but not “street culture.”
25 Derrida, J. and Ferraris, M., A Taste for the Secret, trans. by Donis, G. (Cambridge, 2001). 51‐52Google Scholar.
26 Jacques Derrida, “La Difference,” in Margins of Philosophy, trans. by Alan Bass: “…and to object to this on the basis of the oldest of metaphysical oppositions (for example, by setting some generative point of view against a structural‐taxonomical point of view, or vice versa) would be, above all, not to read what here is missing from orthographical ethics.” pg. 12. The relationship between differance, which Derrida calls a spelling mistake, a sorte de grosse faute d'orthographe, and a solicitation of all “ortho,” remains a basic Derridean trait.
27 Also: Derrida's autobiographical Monolingualism of the Other; or, the prosthesis of origin: “Do you hear me! Each time I write a word, a word that I love and love to write; in the time of this word, at the instant of a single syllable, the song of this new International awakens in me. I never resist it, I am in the street at its call, even if, apparently, I have been working silently since dawn at my table.” pg. 57. (Stanford University Press, 1998).
28 Goizueta, 68.
29 Goizueta, 112.
30 Goizueta, 89.
31 ibid.
32 St. Francis vs. McDonald's, 3
33 St. Francis vs. McDonald's, 9
34 ibid.
35 St. Francis vs. McDonald's, 11
36 See: Francesca Murphy, “Is Liberalism a Heresy?” First Things (June, 2016). Accessible: https://www.firstthings.com/article/2016/06/is-liberalism-a-heresy.
37 Some examples: Endean, Philip, “Von Balthasar, Rahner, and the Commissar,” New Blackfriars 79 (293). 33‐38CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Declan Marmion, “Rahner and His Critics: Revisiting the Dialogue,” Australian eJournal of Theology 4. Williams, Rowan, Wrestling with Angels: Conversations in Modern Theology (SCM Press, 2007). 86‐106Google Scholar.
38 von Balthasar, Hans urs, The Moment of Christian Witness, trans. by Beckley, Richard (St. Ignatius Press, 1994)Google Scholar. pg.
39 von Balthasar, Hans urs, Theo‐Drama: Theological Dramatic Theory; Volume IV: The Action, trans. by Harrison, Graham (Ignatius Press, 1994). 273‐284Google Scholar.
40 ibid. 274.
41 ibid. 283.
42 I am not here interested in the accuracy of Balthasar's critique, but in the formal and strategic work it does.
43 ibid.
44 Endean, 33.
45 von Balthasar, Hans urs, “The Metaphysics of the Saints,” in The Glory of the Lord Volume V: The Realm of Metaphysics in the Modern Age (Ignatius Press, 1991). pg. 105Google Scholar.
46 von Balthasar, Hans urs, Tragedy Under Grace: Reinhold Schneider on the Experience of the West, trans. by McNeil, Brian (Ignatius Press, 1997)Google Scholar.
47 Tragedy Under Grace, 111.
48 Tragedy Under Grace, 195.
49 Tragedy Under Grace, 194.
50 Tragedy Under Grace, 188.
51 Tragedy Under Grace, 187.
52 Tragedy Under Grace, 192.
53 ibid.
54 Tragedy Under Grace, 111.
55 Fraioli, Deborah, Joan of Arc: The Early Debates (Boydell Press, 200). 126‐150Google Scholar.
56 Allmand, CT, The Hundred Years War (Cambridge University Press, 1989). 6‐28Google Scholar.