Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Antidepressant efficacy of high-frequency transcranial magnetic stimulation over the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in double-blind sham-controlled designs: a meta-analysis

  • D. J. L. G. Schutter (a1)
  • Please note a correction has been issued for this article.
Abstract
Background

For more than a decade high-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) has been applied to the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) in search of an alternative treatment for depression. The aim of this study was to provide an update on its clinical efficacy by performing a meta-analysis involving double-blind sham-controlled studies.

Method

A literature search was conducted in the databases PubMed and Web of Science in the period between January 1980 and November 2007 with the search terms ‘depression’ and ‘transcranial magnetic stimulation’. Thirty double-blind sham-controlled parallel studies with 1164 patients comparing the percentage change in depression scores from baseline to endpoint of active versus sham treatment were included. A random effects meta-analysis was performed to investigate the clinical efficacy of fast-frequency rTMS over the left DLPFC in depression.

Results

The test for heterogeneity was not significant (QT=30.46, p=0.39). A significant overall weighted mean effect size, d=0.39 [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.25–0.54], for active treatment was observed (z=6.52, p<0.0001). Medication resistance and intensity of rTMS did not play a role in the effect size.

Conclusions

These findings show that high-frequency rTMS over the left DLPFC is superior to sham in the treatment of depression. The effect size is robust and comparable to at least a subset of commercially available antidepressant drug agents. Current limitations and future prospects are discussed.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Address for correspondence: D. J. L. G. Schutter, Ph.D., Experimental Psychology, Utrecht University, Heidelberglaan 2, 3584CS Utrecht, The Netherlands. (Email: d.schutter@uu.nl)
References
Hide All
Arana, AB, Borckardt, JJ, Ricci, R, Anderson, B, Li, X, Linder, KJ, Long, J, Sackeim, HA, George, MS (2008). Focal electrical stimulation as a sham control for repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: does it truly mimic the cutaneous sensation and pain of active prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation? Brain Stimulation 1, 4451.
Avery, DH, Claypoole, K, Robinson, L, Neumaier, JF, Dunner, DL, Scheele, L, Wilson, L, Roy-Byrne, P (1999). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of medication-resistant depression: preliminary data. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 187, 114117.
Avery, DH, Holtzheimer, PE 3rd, Fawaz, W, Russo, J, Neumaier, J, Dunner, DL, Haynor, DR, Claypoole, KH, Wajdik, C, Roy-Byrne, P (2006). A controlled study of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in medication-resistant major depression. Biological Psychiatry 59, 187194.
Baxter, LR Jr, Schwartz, JM, Phelps, ME, Mazziotta, JC, Guze, BH, Selin, CE (1989). Reduction of prefrontal cortex glucose metabolism common to three types of depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 46, 243250.
Berman, RM, Narasimhan, M, Sanacora, G, Miano, AP, Hoffman, RE, Hu, XS, Charney, DS, Boutros, NN (2000). A randomized clinical trial of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of major depression. Biological Psychiatry 47, 332337.
Bohning, DE (2000). Introduction and overview of TMS physics. In Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Neuropsychiatry (ed. George, M. S. and Belmaker, R. H.), pp. 344. American Psychiatric Press: Washington, DC.
Boutros, NN, Gueorguieva, R, Hoffman, RE, Oren, DA, Feingold, A, Berman, RM (2002). Lack of a therapeutic effect of a 2-week sub-threshold transcranial magnetic stimulation course for treatment-resistant depression. Psychiatry Research 113, 245254.
Burt, T, Lisanby, SH, Sackeim, HA (2002). Neuropsychiatric applications of transcranial magnetic stimulation: a meta-analysis. International Journal of Neuropsychopharmacology 5, 73103.
Chen, Y, Guo, JJ, Zhan, S, Patel, NC (2006). Treatment effects of antidepressants in patients with post-stroke depression: a meta-analysis. Annals of Pharmacotherapy 40, 21152122.
Couturier, JL (2005). Efficacy of rapid-rate repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of depression: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience 30, 8390.
Dannon, PN, Dolberg, OT, Schreiber, S, Grunhaus, L (2002). Three- and six-month outcome following courses of either ECT or rTMS in a population of severely depressed individuals: preliminary report. Biological Psychiatry 51, 687690.
Davidson, RJ, Abercrombie, H, Nitschke, JB, Putnam, K (1999). Regional brain function, emotion and disorders of emotion. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 9, 228234.
Dunlop, BW, Nemeroff, CB (2007). The role of dopamine in the pathophysiology of depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 64, 327337.
Eschweiler, GW, Wegerer, C, Schlotter, W, Spandl, C, Stevens, A, Bartels, M, Buchkremer, G (2000). Left prefrontal activation predicts therapeutic effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in major depression. Psychiatry Research 99, 161172.
Fitzgerald, PB, Benitez, J, de Castella, A, Daskalakis, ZJ, Brown, TL, Kulkarni, J (2006). A randomized, controlled trial of sequential bilateral repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for treatment-resistant depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 163, 8894.
Fitzgerald, PB, Brown, TL, Marston, NA, Daskalakis, ZJ, de Castella, A, Kulkarni, J (2003). Transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of depression: a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 10021008.
Garcia-Toro, M, Mayol, A, Arnillas, H, Capllonch, I, Ibarra, O, Crespi, M, Mico, J, Lafau, O, Lafuente, L (2001). Modest adjunctive benefit with transcranial magnetic stimulation in medication-resistant depression. Journal of Affective Disorders 64, 271275.
George, MS, Lisanby, SH, Sackeim, HA (1999). Transcranial magnetic stimulation: applications in neuropsychiatry. Archives of General Psychiatry 56, 300311.
George, MS, Nahas, Z, Lisanby, SH, Schlaepfer, T, Kozel, FA, Greenberg, BD (2003). Transcranial magnetic stimulation. Neurosurgery Clinics of North America 14, 283301.
George, MS, Nahas, Z, Molloy, M, Speer, AM, Oliver, NC, Li, XB, Arana, GW, Risch, SC, Ballenger, JC (2000). A controlled trial of daily left prefrontal cortex TMS for treating depression. Biological Psychiatry 48, 962970.
George, MS, Wassermann, EM, Kimbrell, TA, Little, JT, Williams, WE, Danielson, AL, Greenberg, BD, Hallett, M, Post, RM (1997). Mood improvement following daily left prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in patients with depression: a placebo-controlled crossover trial. American Journal of Psychiatry 154, 17521756.
Gershon, AA, Dannon, PN, Grunhaus, L (2003). Transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 160, 835845.
Grafman, J (2000). Conceptualizing functional neuroplasticity. Journal of Communication Disorders 33, 345356.
Gross, M, Nakamura, L, Pascual-Leone, A, Fregni, F (2007). Has repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) treatment for depression improved? A systematic review and meta-analysis comparing the recent vs. the earlier rTMS studies. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 116, 165173.
Haag, C, Padberg, F, Thoma, H, Zwanzger, P, Hampel, H, Moller, HJ (1997). Rapid transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in the treatment of major depression: a randomised placebo controlled study. Pharmacopsychiatry 30, 173.
Hedges, LV (1981). Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimates. Journal of Educational Statistics 6, 107128.
Hedges, LV, Olkin, I (1985). Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. Academic Press: Orlando, FL.
Heo, W, Murphy, CF, Meyers, BS (2007). Relationship between the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale and the Montgomery–Åsberg Depression Rating Scale in depressed elderly: a meta-analysis. American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 15, 899905.
Herrmann, LL, Ebmeier, KP (2006). Factors modifying the efficacy of transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of depression: a review. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 67, 18701876.
Herwig, U, Fallgatter, AJ, Höppner, J, Eschweiler, GW, Kron, M, Hajak, G, Padberg, F, Naderi-Heiden, A, Abler, B, Eichhammer, P, Grossheinrich, N, Hay, B, Kammer, T, Langguth, B, Laske, C, Plewnia, C, Richter, MM, Schulz, M, Unterecker, S, Zinke, A, Spitzer, M, Schönfeldt-Lecuona, C (2007). Antidepressant effects of augmentative transcranial magnetic stimulation: randomised multicentre trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 191, 441448.
Hoflich, G, Kaper, S, Hufnagel, A, Ruhrmann, S, Möller, HJ (1993). Application of transcranial magnetic stimulation in treatment of drug-resistant major depression: a report of two cases. Human Psychopharmacology 8, 361365.
Holtzheimer, PE, Russo, J, Avery, DH (2002). A meta-analysis of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of depression. Psychopharmacological Bulletin 35, 149169.
Holtzheimer, PE, Russo, J, Claypoole, KH, Roy-Byrne, P, Avery, DH (2004). Shorter duration of depressive episode may predict response to repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation. Depression and Anxiety 19, 2430.
Höppner, J, Schulz, M, Irmisch, G, Mau, R, Schlafke, D, Richter, J (2003). Antidepressant efficacy of two different rTMS procedures: high frequency over left versus low frequency over right prefrontal cortex compared with sham stimulation. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience 253, 103109.
Huang, YZ, Edwards, MJ, Rounis, E, Bhatia, KP, Rothwell, JC (2005). Theta burst stimulation of the human motor cortex. Neuron 45, 201206.
Joffe, R, Sokolov, S, Streiner, D (1996). Antidepressant treatment of depression: a meta- analysis. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 41, 613616.
Joo, EY, Han, SJ, Chung, SH, Cho, JW, Seo, DW, Hong, SB (2007). Antiepileptic effects of low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation by different stimulation durations and locations. Clinical Neurophysiology 118, 702708.
Jorge, RE, Robinson, RG, Tateno, A, Narushima, K, Acion, L, Moser, D, Arndt, S, Chemerinski, E (2004). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation as treatment of poststroke depression: a preliminary study. Biological Psychiatry 55, 398405.
Kauffmann, CD, Cheema, MA, Miller, BE (2004). Slow right prefrontal transcranial magnetic stimulation as a treatment for medication-resistant depression: a double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Depression and Anxiety 19, 5962.
Keller, J, Nitschke, JB, Bhargava, T, Deldin, PJ, Gergen, JA, Miller, GA, Heller, W (2000). Neuropsychological differentiation of depression and anxiety. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 109, 310.
Kimbrell, TA, Little, JT, Dunn, RT, Frye, MA, Greenberg, BD, Wassermann, EM, Repella, JD, Danielson, AL, Willis, MW, Benson, BE, Speer, AM, Osuch, E, George, MS, Post, RM (1999). Frequency dependence of antidepressant response to left prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) as a function of baseline cerebral glucose metabolism. Biological Psychiatry 46, 16031613.
Klein, E, Kreinin, I, Chistyakov, A, Koren, D, Mecz, L, Marmur, S, Ben-Shachar, D, Feinsod, M (1999). Therapeutic efficacy of right prefrontal slow repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in major depression: a double-blind controlled study. Archives of General Psychiatry 56, 315320.
Koerselman, F, Laman, DM, van Duijn, H, van Duijn, MA, Willems, MA (2004). A 3-month, follow-up, randomized, placebo-controlled study of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in depression. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 65, 13231328.
Lisanby, SH, Gutman, D, Luber, B, Schroeder, C, Sackeim, HA (2001). Sham TMS: intracerebral measurement of the induced electrical field and the induction of motor-evoked potentials. Biological Psychiatry 49, 460463.
Loo, C, Mitchell, P, Sachdev, P, McDarmont, B, Parker, G, Gandevia, S (1999). Double-blind controlled investigation of transcranial magnetic stimulation for the treatment of resistant major depression. American Journal of Psychiatry 156, 946948.
Loo, CK, Mitchell, PB (2005). A review of the efficacy of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) treatment for depression, and current and future strategies to optimize efficacy. Journal of Affective Disorders 88, 255267.
Loo, CK, Mitchell, PB, Croker, VM, Malhi, GS, Wen, W, Gandevia, SC, Sachdev, PS (2003). Double-blind controlled investigation of bilateral prefrontal transcranial magnetic stimulation for the treatment of resistant major depression. Psychological Medicine 33, 3340.
Loo, CK, Mitchell, PB, McFarquhar, TF, Malhi, GS, Sachdev, PR (2007). A sham-controlled trial of the efficacy and safety of twice-daily rTMS in major depression. Psychological Medicine 37, 341349.
Lyness, JM, Bruce, ML, Koenig, HG, Parmelee, PA, Schulz, R, Lawton, MP, Reynolds, C 3rd (1996). Depression and medical illness in late life: report of a symposium. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 44, 198203.
Manes, F, Jorge, R, Morcuende, M, Yamada, T, Paradiso, S, Robinson, RG (2001). A controlled study of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation as a treatment of depression in the elderly. International Psychogeriatrics 13, 225231.
Martin, JL, Barbanoj, MJ, Schlaepfer, TE, Clos, S, Perez, V, Kulisevsky, J, Gironell, A (2002). Transcranial magnetic stimulation for treating depression. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Issue 2, Art. no.: CD003493.
Martin, JL, Barbanoj, MJ, Schlaepfer, TE, Thompson, E, Perez, V, Kulisevsky, J (2003). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for the treatment of depression. Systematic review and meta-analysis. British Journal of Psychiatry 182, 480491.
McNamara, B, Ray, JL, Arthurs, OJ, Boniface, S (2001). Transcranial magnetic stimulation for depression and other psychiatric disorders. Psychological Medicine 31, 11411146.
Miniussi, C, Bonato, C, Bignotti, S, Gazzoli, A, Gennarelli, M, Pasqualetti, P, Tura, GB, Ventriglia, M, Rossini, PM (2005). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) at high and low frequency: an efficacious therapy for major drug-resistant depression? Clinical Neurophysiology 116, 10621071.
Mogg, A, Pluck, G, Eranti, SV, Landau, S, Purvis, R, Brown, RG, Curtis, V, Howard, R, Philpot, M, McLoughlin, DM (2008). A randomized controlled trial with 4-month follow-up of adjunctive repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the left prefrontal cortex for depression. Psychological Medicine 38, 323333.
Moncrieff, J, Wessely, S, Hardy, R (1998). Meta-analysis of trials comparing antidepressants with active placebos. British Journal of Psychiatry 172, 227231.
Moncrieff, J, Wessely, S, Hardy, R (2004). Active placebos versus antidepressants for depression. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Issue 1, Art. no.: CD003012.
Mosimann, UP, Schmitt, W, Greenberg, BD, Kosel, M, Müri, RM, Berkhoff, M, Hess, CW, Fisch, HU, Schlaepfer, TE (2004). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: a putative add-on treatment for major depression in elderly patients. Psychiatry Research 126, 123133.
Nahas, Z, Kozel, FA, Li, X, Anderson, B, George, MS (2003). Left prefrontal transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) treatment of depression in bipolar affective disorder: a pilot study of acute safety and efficacy. Bipolar Disorders 5, 4047.
Nahas, Z, Li, X, Kozel, FA, Mirzki, D, Memon, M, Miller, K, Yamanaka, K, Anderson, B, Chae, JH, Bohning, DE, Mintzer, J, George, MS (2004). Safety and benefits of distance-adjusted prefrontal transcranial magnetic stimulation in depressed patients 55–75 years of age: a pilot study. Depression and Anxiety 19, 249256.
O'Reardon, JP, Solvason, HB, Janicak, PG, Sampson, S, Isenberg, KE, Nahas, Z, McDonald, WM, Avery, D, Fitzgerald, PB, Loo, C, Demitrack, MA, George, MS, Sackeim, HA (2007). Efficacy and safety of transcranial magnetic stimulation in the acute treatment of major depression: a multi-site randomized controlled trial. Biological Psychiatry 62, 12081216.
Padberg, F, Moller, HJ (2003). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: does it have potential in the treatment of depression? CNS Drugs 17, 383403.
Padberg, F, Zwanzger, P, Keck, ME, Kathmann, N, Mikhaiel, P, Ella, R, Rupprecht, P, Thoma, H, Hampel, H, Toschi, N, Moller, HJ (2002). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in major depression: relation between efficacy and stimulation intensity. Neuropsychopharmacology 27, 638645.
Padberg, F, Zwanzger, P, Thoma, H, Kathmann, N, Haag, C, Greenberg, BD, Hampel, H, Moller, HJ (1999). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in pharmacotherapy-refractory major depression: comparative study of fast, slow and sham rTMS. Psychiatry Research 88, 163171.
Post, A, Muller, MB, Engelmann, M, Keck, ME (1999). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in rats: evidence for a neuroprotective effect in vitro and in vivo. European Journal of Neuroscience 11, 32473254.
Poulet, E, Brunelin, J, Boeuve, C, Lerond, J, d'Amato, T, Dalery, J, Saoud, M (2004). Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation does not potentiate antidepressant treatment. European Psychiatry 19, 382383.
Prudic, J, Haskett, RF, Mulsant, B, Malone, KM, Pettinati, HM, Stephens, S, Greenberg, R, Rifas, SL, Sackeim, HA (1996). Resistance to antidepressant medications and short-term clinical response to ECT. American Journal of Psychiatry 153, 985992.
Radziwon-Zaleska, M, Matsumoto, H, Skalski, M, Wilkowska, J, Januszko, P, Matoszko, D, Dziklinska, A, Gmaj, B, Szelenberger, W (2006). Therapeutic tricyclic antidepressant drug monitoring in younger and older depressive patients. Pharmacological Reports 58, 501506.
Robinson, RG, Szetela, B (1981). Mood change following left hemispheric brain injury. Annals of Neurology 9, 447453.
Rosenberg, MS, Adams, DC, Gurevitch, J (2000). MetaWin. Statistical Software for Meta-Analysis. Version 2.0. Sinauer Associates: Sunderland, MA.
Rosenthal, R (1979). The ‘file drawer problem’ and tolerance for null effects. Psychological Bulletin 86, 638641.
Rosenthal, R, DiMatteo, MR (2001). Meta-analysis: recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Annual Review of Psychology 52, 5982.
Rossini, D, Lucca, A, Zanardi, R, Magri, L, Smeraldi, E (2005). Transcranial magnetic stimulation in treatment-resistant depressed patients: a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Psychiatry Research 137, 110.
Roth, Y, Amir, A, Levkovitz, Y, Zangen, A (2007). Three-dimensional distribution of the electric field induced in the brain by transcranial magnetic stimulation using figure-8 and deep H-coils. Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology 24, 3138.
Rumi, DO, Gattaz, WF, Rigonatti, SP, Rosa, MA, Fregni, F, Rosa, MO, Mansur, C, Myczkowski, ML, Moreno, RA, Marcolin, MA (2005). Transcranial magnetic stimulation accelerates the antidepressant effect of amitriptyline in severe depression: a double-blind placebo-controlled study. Biological Psychiatry 57, 162166.
Sackeim, HA (1994). Continuation therapy following ECT: directions for future research. Psychopharmacological Bulletin 30, 501521.
Schutter, DJLG, van Honk, J (2005 a). The cerebellum on the rise in human emotion. Cerebellum 4, 9094.
Schutter, DJLG, van Honk, J (2005 b). A framework for targeting alternative brain regions by repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in the treatment of depression. Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience 30, 9197.
Schutter, DJLG, van Honk, J (2006). An electrophysiological link between the cerebellum, cognition and emotion: frontal theta EEG activity to single pulse cerebellar TMS. Neuroimage 33, 12271231.
Schutter, DJLG, van Honk, J, d'Alfonso, AAL, Peper, JS, Panksepp, J (2003). High frequency rTMS over the medial cerebellum induces a shift in the prefrontal electroencephalography gamma spectrum: a pilot study in humans. Neuroscience Letters 336, 7376.
Szuba, MP, O'Reardon, JP, Rai, AS, Snyder-Kastenberg, J, Amsterdam, JD, Gettes, DR, Wassermann, E, Evans, DL (2001). Acute mood and thyroid stimulating hormone effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation in major depression. Biological Psychiatry 50, 2227.
Teneback, CC, Nahas, Z, Speer, AM, Molloy, M, Stallings, LE, Spicer, KM, Risch, SC, George, MS (1999). Changes in prefrontal cortex and paralimbic activity in depression following two weeks of daily left prefrontal TMS. Journal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience 11, 426435.
van Honk, J, Schutter, DJLG, Putman, P, de Haan, EHF, d'Alfonso, AAL (2003). Reductions in phenomenological, physiological and attentional indices of depressive mood after 2 Hz rTMS over the right parietal cortex in healthy human subjects. Psychiatry Research 120, 95101.
Wassermann, EM (1998). Risk and safety of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: report and suggested guidelines from the International Workshop on the Safety of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation, June 5–7. 1996. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 108, 116.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed