We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 20 November 2018
Giotto's fresco cycles of the lives of St. John the Baptist and St. John the Evangelist in the Peruzzi Chapel in Santa Croce, Florence, have not enjoyed as much scholarly attention as the vast fresco cycle in the Arena Chapel. Scholars have analyzed the space depicted in the frescoes, the striking monumentality of the figures, and the depiction of architecture oblique to the picture plane; thematic content, however, has received less attention than form and space. In this essay, I will propose some religious and secular iconographic and thematic unities: themes of rebirth, resurrection, and communitas, which correlate with fourteenth-century Florentine attitudes toward wealth, historiography, and a belief in the spiritual role of the earthly city. The themes of the frescoes articulate the social and political structures of early fourteenth-century civic life, as Giotto transformed traditional subjects into images of contemporary significance in these frescoes.
This paper was previously read at the Northwest Pacific Renaissance Conference, affiliate of the Renaissance Society of America, in Tacoma, Washington, in March, 1980. Co-winner of the 1986 Nelson Prize.
1 Ueberwasser, Walter, Giotto: Frescoes, trans. Hottinger-Mackie, Mary D. (New York, 1950) 18 Google Scholar. Battisti, Eugenio, Giotto (New York, 1960) 123 Google Scholar, mentions the monumentality of these figures in connection with a didactic function of their attitudes and gestures “to underscore the moods and states of mind of heroes portrayed.” Other secondary sources are: Gnudi, Cesare, Giotto, trans, by Boothroyd, R. H. (London, 1960 212-18Google Scholar; Gosebruch, Martin, Giotto und die Entwicklung des neuzeitlichen Kunstbewusstseins (Cologne, 1962) 143-50Google Scholar; Rintelen, Friedrich, Ciotto und die Giotto-Apokryphen (Munich- Leipzig, 1912) 126ffGoogle Scholar; Cole, Bruce, Giotto and Florentine Painting, 1280-1375 (New York, 1976) 108-14Google Scholar; Bologna, Ferdinando, Novitasu Giotto, Giotto al tempo della cappella Peruzzi (Turin, 1969) 51–56 Google Scholar; Procacci, Ugo, “Relazione sui lavori eseguiti agli affreschi de Giotto nelle capelle Bardi e Peruzzi in S. Croce,” Rivista d'Arte, 19 (1937): 377-89Google Scholar; Basil De Selincourt, Giotto (London, 1905) 196; Bellosi, Luciano, Giotto (New York, 1981) 65 Google Scholar.
2 Gy-Wilde, Julia, “Giotto-Studien,” Wiener Jahrbuch fur Kunstgeschichte, 7 (1930):45–94 Google Scholar, esp. 75-78. John White uses the word “congealed” to describe pre-Peruzzi figural groups, agreeing with Gy-Wilde that figures possess more space and individuality in the Peruzzi frescoes; White, , The Birth and Rebirth of Pictorial Space (London, 1957) 76 Google Scholar.
3 See Gosebruch 143-47.
4 Stubblebine, James, Assisi and the Rise of Vernacular Art (New York, 1985) 88–98 Google Scholar. Other studies cited here on the date of the frescoes are: Gardner, Julian, “The Decoration of the Baroncelli Chapel in Santa Croce,” Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte, 34 (1971): 89–113 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; also Gardner, , “The Early Decoration of Santa Croce in Florence,” Burlington Magazine, 113 (July 1971): 391-92Google Scholar; Borsook, Eve, “Giottonelle Cappelle Bardi e Peruzzi,” in Giotto egotteschi in Santa Croce (Florence, 1966) 30–38 Google Scholar; Gilbert, Creighton, “L'ordine cronologico degli affreschi Bardi e Peruzzi,” Bolletino a“Arte, 43 (October 1968): 192-97Google Scholar; White, John, Pictorial Space 72–77 Google Scholar. For an examination of Sta. Croce, see Walter, and Paatz, Elisabeth, Die Kirchen von Florenz, 1 (Frankfurt-am-Main, 1955): 497–569 Google Scholar.
5 Gnudi, Cesare, L'artegotica in Francia e in Italia (Turin, 1982)Google Scholar, illus. 58 and 59. See also Schmidt, Gerhard, “Giotto und die Gotische Skulpturei,” Romische Historische Mitteilungen, 21 (1979): 127-44Google Scholar. See Telpaz, Anne Markham, “Some Antique Motifs in Trecento Art,” Art Bulletin, 46 (1964): 372-76CrossRefGoogle Scholar, for comparisons of the Arena frescoes with antique sarcophagi.
6 Riess, Jonathon B. “French Influences on the Early Development of Civic Art in Italy,” in Machaut's World: Science and Art in the Fourteenth Century, ed. Pelner Cosman, M. and Chandler, B. (New York, 1978) 285–309.Google Scholar
7 Ibid. 294-306.
8 Bologna, , Novità su Giotto 51–56.Google Scholar
9 For further discussion of the Florentine versions of their roman legacy in the fourteenth century, see Rubinstein, Nicolai, “The Beginnings of Political Thought in Florence: A Study in Mediaeval Historiography,” Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 5 (1942): 198–227 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lamer, John, Culture and Society in Italy, 1290-1420 (New York, 1971) 112ffGoogle Scholar. See also Davidsohn, , Forschungen zur Ceschichte von Florenz (Berlin, 1896-1908), 4.1: 31–38 Google Scholar, for a discussion of the growing interest in history and civic myths.
10 Larner 73, 112. See also Wieruszowski, Helene, “Art and the Commune in the Time of Dante,” Speculum, 19 (1944): 14–33 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Davidsohn, 2.2:125.
11 Tintori, Leonetto and Borsook, Eve, Giotto: The Peruzzi Chapel (New York, 1965) 8–10.Google Scholar
12 Weinstein, Donald, “The Myth of Florence,” in Rubinstein, N., ed., Florentine Studies, Politics and Society in Renaissance Florence (Evanston, 1968) 15–44 Google Scholar. See also Green, Louis, Chronicle into History: An Essay on the Interpretation of History in Florentine Fourteenth-Century Chronicles (Cambridge, 1972)Google Scholar. Green says Villani's Chronicles may have been written in the 1330s or as late as the 1340s. See Villani, Croniche, 1.1 (Trieste, 1857): 7.
13 In his will of 1292, Donato Peruzzi designated funds for a family chapel. See Tintori and Borsook for a history of the commission.
14 Tintori, and Borsook, , Giotto 8.Google Scholar
15 Vasari, Giorgio, Vite, ed. Milanesi, Gaetano, 1 (Florence, 1878): 373-74.Google Scholar
16 Becker, Marvin, Florence in Transition, 2 Google Scholar: The Decline of the Commune (Baltimore, 1967): III. References to family member portraits are made by Rintelen 132, and by Tintori and Borsook 23. The portraits are in contemporary dress. The Strozzi also had portraits of themselves painted at Sta. Maria Novella.
17 Hyde, J. K., Society and Politics in Medieval Italy, the Evolution of the Civil Life, 1000- 1350 (London, 1973), pp. 172-73Google Scholar. See also Hyde, , “Some Uses of Literacy in Venice and Florence in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries,” Proceedings of the Royal Historical Society, ser. 5, 29 (1979), 112-28.Google Scholar
18 Larner, , Culture and Society, p. 110 Google Scholar . In the 1330s, the Peruzzi had 100,000 fl. compared with the Medici wealth in 1458 of 30,000 fl.
19 Ibid.,p. 112.
20 Ibid. 65-66. Davidsohn 4: 126 describes the struggle for supervision of the Baptistry; at 458 Davidsohn mentions that the supervision of the Duomo's construction was entrusted to the Arte del Lana.
21 Larner, , Culture and Society 56 Google Scholar, 61. See also Wieruszowski 16.
22 Hyde, , Society and Politics in Medieval Italy 155 Google Scholar. Also see Edgcombe Staley, J., The Guilds of Florence (New York, 1967)Google Scholar.
23 One prominent example of this fusion in art was the depiction of Siena's Maestà, “the Virgin in Majesty, patron saint of the city. In Simone Martini's Maestà which decorates a wall in the Palazzo Pubblico, there are several symbols of the city. In the same building is a painting of the civic allegory, the Lorenzetti Allegory of Good and Bad Government with its central image of Peace. These allegories were a new genre fostered by civic patronage, which also encouraged stylistic naturalism and secularized iconographies of religious subjects. See Rubinstein, Nicolai, “Political Ideas in Sienese Art: The Frescoes by Ambrogio Lorenzetti and Taddeo de Bartolo in the Palazzo Pubblico“, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 21 (1958): 179–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
24 White, John, Pictorial Space 76 Google Scholar. See also Gnudi, , Giotto 202 Google Scholar.
25 Giotto's realism is mentioned in connection with his supposed self-portrait and portrait of Dante by Davidsohn 4.3: 220, and Wieruzowski 20n.3.
26 Garrison, Edward B., Italian Romanesque Panel Painting (New York, 1976)Google Scholar reproduces a pair of Lucchese tabernacle shutters, c. 1290-1300, with six scenes from the Life of the Baptist (122) including Birth, Naming, Angel Appearing to Zacharias, and 3 other scenes. He ascribes the shutters to Deodato di Orlando; they are now in Berlin. Garrison also includes an altarpiece with scenes from the life of the Baptist (143) with 12 scenes, now in Siena, and an altarpiece from Venice, c. 1325, six scenes of the Baptist's days (224), now in Paris.
27 The Golden Legend of Jacobus de Voragine, trans. Ryan, Granger and Ripperger, Helmut (New York, 1941) 322.Google Scholar
28 Larner, , Italy in the Age of Dante and Petrarch, 1216-1380 (London and New York, 1980) 62 Google Scholar. Tin tori and Borsook 8 mention the Peruzzi clan living in the neighborhood of Sta. Croce.
29 Sapori, Armando, The Italian Merchants in the Middle Ages, trans. Kennen, Patricia Ann (New York, 1970) 21–30 Google Scholar. For a discussion of the nature ofconsorterie and Florentine kinship patterns, see Kent, F. W., Household and Lineage in Renaissance Florence (Princeton, 1977) 8–11 Google Scholar. For a survey of changes in family life from the eleventh through the fourteenth century, see Herlihy, David, “Family Solidarity in Medieval Italian History,” in Economy, Society, and Government in Medieval Italy, ed. Herlihy, D., Lopez, R. S., and Slessarev, V. (Kent, Ohio, 1969) 173-84Google Scholar. Herlihy argues that the family acquired a new solidarity in the course of the fourteenth century in providing new cultural support and moral bonds (180-81).
30 “La Poverta,” Giotto's canzone, was first published by Rumohr in 1827, and appears in Gabrielli, Margherita, Giotto e I'origine del realismo (Rome, 1960) 91–110.Google Scholar
31 Rough, Robert H., “Enrico Scrovegni, The Cavalieri Gaudenti, and the Arena Chapel in Padua,” Art Bulletin, 62 (1980): 24–35.Google Scholar
32 Baron, Hans, “Franciscan Poverty and Civic Wealth as Factors in the Rise of Humanistic Thought,” Speculum 13 (1938): 1–37 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Becker, Marvin B., “Florentine Politics and the Diffusion of Heresy in the Trecento: A Socioeconomic Inquiry,” Speculum 34 (1959): 60–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
33 Tintori and Borsook 43n90.
34 White, John, “Giotto's Use of Architecture in ‘The Expulsion of Joachim,’ at Padua,” Burlington Magazine 115 (1973): 439-47.Google Scholar
35 Larner, , Dante and Petrarch 113 Google Scholar. The division of Florentine society into minuto, grassi and aristocrats (magnati) was articulated by Sapori, in La crisi delle compagnie mercantile dei Bardi e dei Peruzzi (Florence, 1926) 118-20, and has been followed by subsequent scholars such as Becker, Brucker and Baron. The ebb and flow of power among the classes in Florence is carefully described in Becker, Marvin, “Some Aspects of Oligarchical, Dictatorial, and Popular Signoriein Florence 1282-1382,” Comparative Studies in Society and History, 2 (1959-60): 440-51.Google Scholar
36 Tintori and Borsook 43; Previtali, , Giotto el la sua bottega (Milan, 1967) 11.Google Scholar
37 Fanelli, , Firenze, architettura e citta (Florence, 1973) 86–92 Google Scholar. See the review of Fanelli's book by Friedman, David, Journal of Society of Architectural Historians, 35 (May 1976): 141-42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
38 Fanelli 130.
39 Waley, Daniel, The Italian City-Republics (New York, 1969) 35 Google Scholar, describes the remarkable population growth during which Florence had 50,000 inhabitants at the beginning and twice that at the end of the thirteenth century. The walls of 1172 enclosed 197 acres, while walls begun in 1284 and finished fifty years later enclosed 1,556 acres.
40 Ibid. 152. See also Schevill, Ferdinand, Medieval and Renaissance Florence 1 (New York, 1963): 241 Google Scholar. Villani also praises the community spirit of the merchant-banking families who contributed to this greatness in Croniche, 11.94: 419-20.
41 For a discussion of this convention, see Krinsky, Carol Herselle, “Representations of the Temple of Jerusalem before 1500,” Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 33 (1970): 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
42 Denny, Don, “Some Symbols in the Arena Chapel Frescoes,” Art Bulletin, 55 (1973): 205-12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
43 Bongiorno, Laurence Mack, “The Theme of the Old and the New Law in the Arena Chapel,” Art Bulletin, 50 (1968): 11–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
44 Denny 209.
45 Bongiorno 11-13.
46 Denny 212.
47 See Freyham, R., “The Evolution of the Caritas Figure in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries”, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 11 (1948): 68–86 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Previtali also mentions the substitution of Invidia for Avarice in the Arena frescoes (73). Selma Pfeiffenberger notes these changes, too; she points out that invidia also connoted usury but was a more generalized vice, in “The Iconology of Giotto's Virtues and Vices at Padua,” Ph.D. dissertation, Bryn Mawr College, 1967, p. 45. Reference is to Purgatorio, XIII.37, and IV.49-57.
48 Alpatoff, Michael, “The Parallelism of Giotto's Paduan Frescoes,,” Art Bulletin, 29 (1947): 149-54CrossRefGoogle Scholar examines Giotto's complex, symbolic reading and arrangement of narratives.
49 Ueberwasser 18.
50 Tintori and Borsook 23 describes the Kress altarpiece.
51 I have used the following sources on the history of the Franciscans during the late thirteenth and early fourteenth centuries: Ludivico Bregio, P., L'osservanza francescana in Italia nel secolo XIV (Rome, 1963)Google Scholar; Bloomfield, Morton W., “Joachim of Flora,” Traditio, 13 (1957): 249–311 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Coulton, G. G., From St. Francis to Dante: Translationsfrom the Chronicle of the Franciscan Salimbene (1221-1228) (New York, 1968)Google Scholar; Douie, Decima, The Nature and the Effect of the Heresy of the Fraticelli (Manchester, 1932)Google Scholar; Lambert, M. D., “The Franciscan Crisis under John XXII,” Franciscan Studies, 32 (1972): 123-43Google Scholar; Piana, George La, “Joachim of Flora: A Critical Study,” Speculum, 7 (1932): 257-82CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Moorman, John, A History of the Franciscan Order (Oxford, 1968)Google Scholar; Pertwee, Carter, “Peter John Olivi: Historical and Doctrinal Study,” Franciscan Studies, 20 (1960): 215-60Google Scholar; Reeves, Marjorie, “The Abbot Joachim's Disciples and the Cistercian Order,” Sophia, 9 (1951): 355-71Google Scholar; Scudder, Vida D., The Franciscan Adventure (London and Toronto, 1931)Google Scholar; Tocco, Felice, La quistione delta poverta nel secolo XIV (Naples, 1910)Google Scholar; Lambert, M. D., Franciscan Poverty (London, 1961)Google Scholar; Blume, Dieter, Wandmalerei als Ordenspropaganda (Worms, 1983).Google Scholar
52 Tintori and Borsook 23; Gy-Wilde 63.
53 Douie 24 and 38. See Dante Paradiso, XII: 140-41 on Joachim, towards whom Dante was favorably disposed. Also at XII: 124-25 is a reference to Ubertino da Casale, a prominent Spiritual. Alpatoff 153 believes that Giotto, like Dante, was in touch with progressive thinkers such as the Averroists and the Joachimites.
54 Douie 216.
55 Becker 48. Velluti's chronicle is excerpted in Brucker, Gene, The Society of Florence: A Documentary Study (New York, 1971) 106–110.Google Scholar
56 Schevill 1: 187.
57 Larner, , Dante and Petrarch 100–112.Google Scholar
58 See Davis, Charles, “Remigio de'Girolami and Dante,” Studi Danteschi, 86 (1959): 105-36Google Scholar; Davis, , “An Early Florentine Political Theorist: Fra Remigio de’ Girolami,” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 104 (1960): 662-76Google Scholar; and Dante: De Monarchia, ed. E. Moore, intro. W. H. V. Reade (Oxford, 1916) xi-xiii.
59 Sapora 43-45, 49. Rhodes, W. E., “The Italian Bankers in England and their Loans to Edward I and Edward III,” in James Tait and Thomas F. Tout, Historical Essays by Members of Owens College, Manchester (London, 1902) 137-68.Google Scholar
60 Larner, , Culture and Society 63.Google Scholar
61 Rubinstein, Nicolai, “Marsilius of Padua and Italian Political Thought of his Time,” in Hale, J. R., et al., Europe in the Late Middle Ages (Evanston, 1965) 44–75 Google Scholar. See also Gewirth, Alan, Marsilius of Padua, The Defender of Peace (New York-London, 1964)Google Scholar.
62 Rubinstein, , Marsilius 45.Google Scholar
63 Ibid. 55.
64 Hyde, “Some Uses of Literacy” 109-28.
65 See Jones, P.J., “Florentine Families and Florentine Diaries in the Fourteenth Century,” Papers of the British School at Rome, 24 (1956): 183–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
66 Jones, P. J., “Communes and Despots: The City-State in Late Medieval Italy,” Proceedings of the Royal Historical Society, ser. 5, 15 (1965): 71–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
67 Nolan, Barbara, in The Gothic Visionary Perspective (Princeton, 1977)Google Scholar, cites twelfthcentury exegetical writers on St. John's Revelation who radically depart from medieval views. Through a system of concordances these writers reinterpret the Apocalypse historically from Adam to their own period. These writers and others, such as Abbot Suger, extended anagogic interpretations and thereby created parallels between historicearthly life and eternal-spiritual life, “to discover the realities of the heavenly Jerusalem in the images of the earthly Jerusalem” (36). Nolan cites many writers, including Dante, and art works which expand this new anagogic interpretation in the thirteenth century.
68 Davis, Charles T., “II Buon Tempo Antico,” in Florentine Studies: Politics and Society in Renaissance Florence, ed. Rubinstein, Nicolai (Evanston, 1968) 45–69 Google Scholar. See also Aquilecchia, G., “Dante and the Florentine Chroniclers,” Bulletin of the John Rylands Library, 48 (1965-66): 48–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
