Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-vvkck Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T08:15:33.750Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Composite Coastal Cordon on Exmoor? Exploring Local Influence on First-Century a.d. Fortlet Use

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 April 2018

Matthew Symonds
Matthew Symonds*
Affiliation:
Current World Archaeology, Londonmatt@archaeology.co.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Exceptional aspects of the design and location of a pair of first-century fortlets on the Exmoor coast are explicable as a product of local influence. Previous explanations for the remote setting of these small posts and the distinctive defences securing them have focused on a signalling role, with the fortlets serving as a means to transmit messages to naval vessels patrolling the Bristol Channel. Instead, both the landscape setting and articulation with local settlement patterns imply that these installations strengthened pre-existing measures to counter coastal raiding. Parallels between this variant fortlet design and settlement morphology in the South-West peninsula suggest that the army co-opted an indigenous architectural style. The two fortlets could act as components of what was effectively a composite coastal cordon, built on collaboration between the Roman military and the local population.

Keywords

Roman militaryfortletExmoorDumnoniihybridisationcoastal controlOld BurrowMartinhoe
Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 49 , November 2018 , pp. 53 - 77
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2018. Published by The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bidwell, P.T. 1980: Roman Exeter: Fortress and Town, ExeterGoogle Scholar
Bidwell, P.T. 1999: ‘2. A summary of recent research on Hadrian's Wall’, in Bidwell, P.T. (ed.), Hadrian's Wall 1989–1999. A Summary of Recent Excavations and Research, Carlisle, 7–35Google Scholar
Bishop, M.C. 1988: ‘Cavalry equipment of the Roman army in the first century AD’, in Coulston, J.C.N. (ed.), Military Equipment and the Identity of Roman Soldiers: Proceedings of the Fourth Roman Military Equipment Conference, BAR International Series 394, Oxford, 67–195Google Scholar
Bishop, M.C., and Coulston, J.C.N. 2006: Roman Military Equipment: from the Punic Wars to the Fall of Rome, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Borlase, M. 2015: ‘Pushing back boundaries: Iron Age open settlements in Cornwall’, Current Archaeology 309, 40–2Google Scholar
Borlase, M., and Wright, M. 2014: ‘A Romano-British enclosure at East Leigh, Stratton, Cornwall’, Cornish Archaeology 53, 209–21Google Scholar
Breeze, D.J. 1974: ‘The Roman fortlet at Barburgh Mill, Dumfriesshire’, Britannia 5, 130–62Google Scholar
Breeze, D.J. 1977: ‘The garrisoning of Roman fortlets’, in Studien zu den Militargrenzen Roms II, Cologne, 1–6Google Scholar
Breeze, D.J. 2012: ‘The civitas stones and the building of Hadrian's Wall’, Transactions of the Cumberland and Westmorland Antiquarian and Archaeological Society series 3, 12, 69–80Google Scholar
Brindle, T. 2016: ‘The South-West’, in Smith, A., Allen, M., Brindle, T. and Fulford, M. (eds), The Rural Settlement of Roman Britain, Britannia Monograph 29, London, 331–58Google Scholar
Bülow-Jacobsen, A. 2012: ‘Private letters’, in Cuvigny, H. (ed.), Didymoi, Une garnison romaine dans le désert Oriental d’Égypte, vol. 2, Cairo, 234–99Google Scholar
Burnham, B.C., and Burnham, H.B. 2004: Dolaucothi-Pumsaint: Survey and Excavations at a Roman Gold-mining Complex, 1987–1999, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Burnham, B.C., and Davies, J.L. (eds) 2010: Roman Frontiers in Wales and the Marches, AberystwythGoogle Scholar
Bushe-Fox, J.P. 1932: ‘Some notes on Roman coast defences’, Journal of Roman Studies 22, 60–72Google Scholar
Chapman, E.M. 2016: ‘I. Sites explored 1. Wales’, Britannia 47, 288–91Google Scholar
Chorus, J.P. 2008: ‘Romeinse forten in de Rijndelta: over stammetjes en staanders’, in Bergmans, M., Derks, T., Doreleijers, R., van der Veer, K. and Willemsen, S. (eds), SOJA-Bundel 2007: Symposium voor Onderzoek door Jonge Archeologen, Groningen, 7–16Google Scholar
CIL 3: Hirschfeld, O. 1874: Epigraphische Nachlese zum Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum, vol. 3, ViennaGoogle Scholar
Collingwood, R.G., and Richmond, I. 1969: The Archaeology of Roman Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Cripps, L.J. 2007: ‘Re-situating the later Iron Age in Cornwall and Devon: new perspectives from the settlement record’, in Haselgrove and Moore 2007, 140–55Google Scholar
Cunliffe, B. 2001: Facing the Ocean, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Cunliffe, B. 2005: Iron Age Communities in Britain: An Account of England, Scotland and Wales from the Seventh Century BC until the Roman Conquest, AbingdonGoogle Scholar
Cuvigny, H. 2005: Ostraca de Krokodilô; la correspondence militaire et sa circulation, CairoGoogle Scholar
Cuvigny, H. 2006: ‘Le fonctionnement du réseau’, in Cuvigny, H. (ed.), La Route de Myos Hormos; l'armée romaine dans le désert Oriental d’Égypte, vol. 2, Cairo, 295–359Google Scholar
Davies, J.L. 2010: ‘Erglodd (NGR:SN 653 903; NPRN 303601)’, in Burnham and Davies 2010, 292–5Google Scholar
Davison, D. 1989: The Barracks of the Roman Army from the First to Third Centuries AD, vol. 1, BAR International Series 472, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Evans, E.M., Hopewell, D., Mason, D.J.P., Murphy, K., Roberts, O.T.P., and Silvester, R.J. 2010: ‘Shipping’, in Burnham and Davies 2010, 98–102Google Scholar
Fitzpatrick, A.P., Butterworth, C.A., and Grove, J. 1999: Prehistoric and Roman Sites in East Devon, the A30 Honiton to Exeter Improvement DBFO, 1996–9, vol. 2, SalisburyGoogle Scholar
Fox, A. 1953: ‘Hill-slope forts and related earthworks in south-west England and south Wales’, Archaeological Journal 109, 1–22Google Scholar
Fox, A. 1958: ‘South-western hill-forts’, in Frere, S.S. (ed.), Problems of the Iron Age in Southern Britain: Papers given at a C.B.A. Conference held at the Institute of Archaeology December 12 to 14, 1958, London, 35–60Google Scholar
Fox, A. 1967: ‘Martinhoe and Old Burrow’, in Studien zu den Militärgrenzen Roms. Vorträge des 6. Internationalen Limeskongress in Süddeutschland, Cologne, 15–20Google Scholar
Fox, A., and Ravenhill, W. 1959: ‘The Stoke Hill Roman signal station’, Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association 91, 71–82Google Scholar
Fox, A., and Ravenhill, W. 1965: ‘Old Burrow and Martinhoe’, Antiquity 39, 253–8Google Scholar
Fox, A., and Ravenhill, W. 1966: ‘Early Roman outposts on the north Devon coast, Old Burrow and Martinhoe’, Proceedings of the Devon Archaeological Exploration Society 24, 3–39Google Scholar
Francis, P.D., and Slater, D.S. 1990: ‘A record of vegetational and land use change from upland peat deposits on Exmoor. Part 2: Hoar Moor’, Somerset Archaeology and Natural History 134, 1–25Google Scholar
Francis, P.D., and Slater, D.S. 1992: ‘A record of vegetational and land use change from upland peat deposits on Exmoor. Part 3: Codsend Moors’, Somerset Archaeology and Natural History 136, 9–28Google Scholar
Frere, S.S., and St Joseph, J.K. 1983: Roman Britain from the Air, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Fulford, M. 2006: ‘Corvées and civitates’, in Wilson, R.J.A. (ed.), Romanitas: Essays on Roman Archaeology in Honour of Sheppard Frere, Oxford, 65–71Google Scholar
Fyfe, R.M., Brown, A.G., and Rippon, S.J. 2003: ‘Mid- to late-Holocene vegetation history of Greater Exmoor, UK: estimating the spatial extent of human-induced vegetation change’, Vegetation History and Archaeobotany 12, 215–32Google Scholar
Gardner, A. 2013: ‘Thinking about Roman imperialism: postcolonialism, globalisation, and beyond?’ Britannia 44, 1–25Google Scholar
Green, T. 2009: ‘A Bronze Age settlement at Holworthy Farm, Parracombe’, in Green, T. (ed.), Bronze Age to Bottle Seals: Glimpses of the Archaeology and History of North Devon, Barnstaple, 24–32Google Scholar
Griffith, F.M. 1984: ‘Roman military sites in Devon: some recent discoveries’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 42, 11–32Google Scholar
Griffith, F.M. 1994: ‘Changing perceptions of the context of Prehistoric Dartmoor’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 52, 85–99Google Scholar
Griffith, F.M. 1997: ‘Developments in the study of Roman military sites in south west England’, in Groenman-van Waateringe, W., van Beek, B., Willems, W. and Wynia, S. (eds), Roman Frontier Studies 1995, Oxford, 361–7Google Scholar
Griffith, F.M., and Quinnell, H. 1999: ‘Settlement c. 2500 BC to c. AD 600’, in Kain, R.J.P. and Ravenhill, W.L.D. (eds), Historical Atlas of South-West England, ExeterGoogle Scholar
Gwilt, A. 2007: ‘Silent Silures? Locating people and places in the Iron Age of south Wales’, in Haselgrove and Moore 2007, 297–328Google Scholar
Haselgrove, C.C., and Moore, T. (eds) 2007: The Later Iron Age in Britain and Beyond, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Hegarty, C., with Wilson-North, R. 2014: The Archaeology of Hill Farming on Exmoor, SwindonGoogle Scholar
Herring, P. 1994: ‘Stratton Hundred, Rapid Identification Survey’, Cornish Archaeology 33, 235–7Google Scholar
Holbrook, N. 2001: ‘Coastal trade around the south-west peninsula of Britain in the later Roman period’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 59, 149–58Google Scholar
Hunter, F. 2015: ‘The impact of Rome, c. AD 50–250’, in Farley, J. and Hunter, F. (eds), Celts: Art and Identity, London, 128–51Google Scholar
James, S. 2011: Rome and the Sword: How Warriors and Weapons Shaped Roman History, LondonGoogle Scholar
Jilek, S., and Breeze, D.J. 2007: ‘The detritus of life: the contribution of small finds to understanding smaller military installations’, in Hingley, R. and Willis, S. (eds), Roman Finds: Context and Theory, Oxford, 199–213Google Scholar
Kille, H.W. 1953: The Homeland Guide to Minehead & Exmoor: Porlock, Watchet, Dunster, with Footpath Rambles, LondonGoogle Scholar
Mackensen, M. 1987: Frühkaiserzeitliche Kleinkastelle bei Nersingen und Burlafingen an den Oberen Donau, MunichGoogle Scholar
Manning, P., and Quinnell, H. 2009: ‘Excavation and field survey at the Iron Age hillfort of Berry Ball, Crediton Hamlets’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 67, 99–132Google Scholar
Mason, D.J.P. 2003: Roman Britain and the Roman Navy, StroudGoogle Scholar
Mattingly, D.J. 2006: An Imperial Possession: Britain in the Roman Empire, 54 BC–AD 409, LondonGoogle Scholar
Maxfield, V.A. 1980: ‘The Roman military occupation of south-west England: further light and fresh problems’, in Hanson, W. and Keppie, L. (eds), Roman Frontier Studies 1979, vol. 1, BAR International series 71, Oxford, 297–309Google Scholar
Maxwell, G., and Wilson, D. 1987: ‘Air reconnaissance in Roman Britain 1977–84’, Britannia 18, 1–48Google Scholar
Nowakowski, J.A., and Quinnell, H. 2011: Trevelgue Head, Cornwall, the Importance of CK Croft Andrew's 1939 Excavations for Prehistoric and Roman Cornwall, CornwallGoogle Scholar
O'Brien, W. 2016: ‘Language shift and political context in Bronze Age Ireland: some implications of hillfort chronology’, in Koch, J.T. and Cunliffe, B. (eds), Celtic from the West 3: Atlantic Europe in the Metal Ages: Questions of Shared Language, Oxford, 219–46Google Scholar
O.Did. = Cuvigny, H. (ed.) 2012: Didymoi; une garnison romaine dans le désert Oriental d’Égypte, II les texts, vol. 2, CairoGoogle Scholar
O.Krok. = Cuvigny, 2005Google Scholar
Peters, J., and Pöllath, N. 1999: ‘Speiseabfälle mit hohem Wildanteil aus dem Kleinkastell Osterhofen-Haardorf’, Bayerische Vorgeschichtsblätter 64, 159–65Google Scholar
Poulter, A. 1995: Nicopolis ad Istrum: A Roman, Late Roman and Early Byzantine City: Excavations 1985–92, LondonGoogle Scholar
Quinnell, H. 2004: Trethurgy: Excavations at Trethurgy Round, St Austell, Community and Status in Roman and Post Roman Cornwall, CornwallGoogle Scholar
RIB: Collingwood, R.G., and Wright, R.P. 1965: The Roman Inscriptions of Britain: Volume 1 Inscriptions on Stone, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Riley, H., and Wilson-North, R. 2001: The Field Archaeology of Exmoor, SwindonGoogle Scholar
Rippon, S., Smart, C., and Pears, B. 2015: The Fields of Britannia: Continuity and Change in the Late Roman and Early Medieval Landscape, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Robertson, A. 1961: ‘Excavations at Raeburnfoot, Eskdalemuir, 1959–60’, Transactions of the Dumfries and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society, series 3, 39, 24–49Google Scholar
Salvatore, J.P. 2011: ‘The Roman military base at Pomeroy Wood’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 69, 113–23Google Scholar
Sharpe, A. 1992: ‘Treryn Dinas: cliff castles reconsidered’, Cornish Archaeology 31, 65–8Google Scholar
Sims, R., Allen, M.J., and Rainbird, P. 2014: ‘Iron Age and medieval activity and land-use at Embury Beacon fort, Hartland, Devon’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 72, 71–102Google Scholar
Suetonius, : The Lives of the Twelve Caesars, trans. Rolfe, J.C., Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge, MA/London (1914)Google Scholar
Symonds, M.F.A. 2007: ‘Built for purpose: early fortlet use in Britain and Germany’, Bulletin of the Hadrianic Society NS 2, 39–47Google Scholar
Symonds, M.F.A. 2009: ‘Fortlets and their adaptation for artificial frontiers’, in Morrillo, Á., Hanel, N. and Martín, E. (eds), Limes XX: Estudios sobre la Frontera Romana, Anejo de Gladius 13, vol. 2, Madrid, 955–63Google Scholar
Symonds, M.F.A. 2013: ‘Gateways or garrisons? Designing, building and manning the milecastles’, in Collins, R. and Symonds, M.F.A. (eds), Breaking Down Boundaries: Hadrian's Wall in the 21st Century, JRA Supplementary Series 93, Portsmouth, RI, 53–70Google Scholar
Symonds, M.F.A. 2015: ‘The curious incidence of fortlets in the Pennines’, in Breeze, D.J., Jones, R.H. and Oltean, I.A. (eds), Understanding Roman Frontiers: Papers Offered to Professor Bill Hanson on the Occasion of his Retirement, Edinburgh, 82–100Google Scholar
Symonds, M.F.A. 2017a: ‘A tale of two systems: early fortlet groups along the Danube and Bristol Channel’, in Parker, A. (ed.), Ad Vallum: Papers on the Roman Army and Frontiers, BAR International Series 631, Oxford, 35–47Google Scholar
Symonds, M.F.A. 2017b: Protecting the Roman Empire: Fortlets, Frontiers, and the Quest for Post-Conquest Security, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Tacitus, , Agricola: Tacitus, Opera minora, ed. Ogilvie, R.M. and Winterbottom, M., Oxford Classical Texts (1990)Google Scholar
Tacitus, : Annals: Books 4–6, 11–12, trans. Jackson, J., Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge MA/London (1989)Google Scholar
Tacitus, : Annals: Books 13–16, trans. Jackson, J., Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge MA/London (1989)Google Scholar
Taylor, J. 2007: An Atlas of Roman Rural Settlement in England, CBA Research Report 151, YorkGoogle Scholar
Todd, M. 1987: The South-West to AD 1000, LondonGoogle Scholar
Todd, M. 1995: ‘Charterhouse on Mendip: interim report on excavations in 1994’, Proceedings of the Somerset Archaeological and Natural History Society 138, 75–9Google Scholar
Todd, M. 1998: ‘A hillslope enclosure at Rudge, Morchard Bishop’, Devon Archaeological Society Proceedings 56, 133–52Google Scholar
Walker, J. 1989: ‘The function of Castleshaw fortlet’, in Walker, J. (ed.), Castleshaw: The Archaeology of a Roman Fortlet, Manchester, 79–108Google Scholar
Welfare, H. 2011: ‘The Roman fortlet at Longshaws, Northumberland’, Archaeologia Aeliana series 5, 40, 117–30Google Scholar
Young, A. 2012: ‘Prehistoric and Romano-British enclosures around the Camel estuary, Cornwall’, Cornish Archaeology 51, 69–124Google Scholar