1 results
3 - ‘Looking for a Life’: Rohingya Refugee Migration in the Post-Imperial Age
- Edited by Barak Kalir, Malini Sur
-
- Book:
- Transnational Flows and Permissive Polities
- Published by:
- Amsterdam University Press
- Published online:
- 15 January 2021
- Print publication:
- 07 December 2012, pp 75-90
-
- Chapter
- Export citation
-
Summary
Introduction
A refugee, according to Hannah Arendt, was a person who had no right to rights. Her statement was based on her own experience during the Nazi period of being stripped of German citizenship because she was a Jew. This definition of a refugee no longer holds true. In no small measure due to the lessons learned from that experience, a refugee rights regime – flawed and inadequate though it may be – has been established both at the transnational level and, in many Western liberal states, at the national level. This has enabled and legitimised substantial refugee flows and resettlements in the second half of the twentieth century. Less well known, however, are the substantial population displacements and settlements that are illicit and outside of any formal regulatory framework, which have been sustained not by the assertion of civil rights but by the ‘paper citizenship’ of weak states (Sadiq 2008) and the conditional ‘hospitality’ of shared cultural vernaculars.
In this paper, we draw on ethnographic fieldwork and interviews with a refugee group in Malaysia – the Muslim Rohingyas from the province of Arakan in Burma – to make the following arguments. Far from there being a unified and homogenous space of global or transnational migration, represented by the contemporary Western European (and/or US) experience, it would be more appropriate to think of contemporary patterns and practices of border-crossing migration in terms of ‘imagined worlds’ (Appadurai 1990) or ‘overlapping zones’ (Balibar 2003). Bowen (2004) has recently argued for the existence of a discursively constituted ‘transnational Islamic space’. The information gleaned from our interviews with the Rohingya points to the existence of a contemporary transnational Islamic space or zone of migration governed by the practices of illiberal states and shared Muslim hospitality, and of a Muslim migrant world dwelling therein in the interstices of the illegal and the licit.
At the same time, Rohingyas are ‘persons of concern’ to the United National High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and thus clients of a transnational human rights regime. This regime, anchored in the legal norms of the Western liberal state, with its validation of refugees as a legal category, does confer some degree of state-transcending protection to extra-territorial populations that fall under its care.