1 results
7 - Elias and Bourdieu
-
- By Bowen Paulle, University of Amsterdam, Bart van Heerikhuizen, University of Amsterdam, Mustafa Emirbayer, University of Wisconsin–Madison
- Edited by Simon Susen, Bryan Turner
-
- Book:
- The Legacy of Pierre Bourdieu
- Published by:
- Anthem Press
- Published online:
- 05 March 2012
- Print publication:
- 15 April 2011, pp 145-172
-
- Chapter
- Export citation
-
Summary
The deeper one penetrates the universes of Norbert Elias and Pierre Bourdieu, the clearer it becomes: the similarities between their visions of society are striking. While the two sociologists always showed great sympathy for one another, there are no indications that they were fully aware of how fundamental the subterranean intellectual affinities were. And even though many social scientists combine a high regard for some of Elias's works with great admiration for several works by Bourdieu, thereby showing an instinctive sense of the affinities between these authors, until now it seems that no one has noticed the degree to which Bourdieu and Elias are intellectual siblings. The contributions of each has been highlighted in convincing work – in the case of Elias, for example, by Goudsblom (1987), and, in the case of Bourdieu, by the likes of Wacquant (2006). Even in such careful and judicious accounts, however, important connections between the two authors have remained either hidden or implicit. Engaging in some degree of excavation, this chapter brings to light why Bourdieu and Elias can be viewed as contributors to a single theoretical approach. The most important finding here is that both relied heavily on the same triad of core concepts, and both deployed those concepts in relentlessly relational and processual fashion. Our first goal, therefore, is to uncover these deep-seated conceptual affinities.
Our second goal is to demonstrate that, when taken together, the two authors' perspectives yield a vision more far-reaching and powerful than either considered separately.