Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-ndmmz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-07T05:12:44.165Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From Slaves to Citizens? Tannenbaum and the Debates on Slavery, Emancipation, and Race Relations in Latin America

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 March 2010

Alejandro de la Fuente
Alejandro de la Fuente
Affiliation:
University of Pittsburgh
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Why is Slave and Citizen, Frank Tannenbaum's influential comparative book on slavery and race relations, still referenced by modern scholars? How is it that a book that is frequently described as flawed continues to inform contemporary scholarship on race and slavery? This article seeks to answer these questions by reconstructing some of the scholarly debates sparked by Slave and Citizen. Specifically, the article discusses how some of the central premises of Tannenbaum's approach continue to inform the work of current scholars. Three of these premises are discussed in some detail: first, that “Anglo” and “Latin” America constituted two separate entities; second, that race relations in each area were fundamentally different; and third, that differences in modern race relations could only be explained by their divergent “slave systems.”

Type
Classics Revisited: Frank Tannenbaum Reconsidered
Information
International Labor and Working-Class History , Volume 77 , Issue 1 , Spring 2010 , pp. 154 - 173
Copyright
Copyright © International Labor and Working-Class History, Inc. 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. Tannenbaum, Frank, Slave and Citizen (Boston, 1992), 4, 107, 112Google Scholar.

2. For a few recent examples, see Cottrol, Robert J., “The Long Lingering Shadow: Law, Liberalism, and Cultures of Racial Hierarchy and Identity in the Americas,” Tulane Law Review 76 (2001): 40Google Scholar; Cooper, Frederick, Holt, Thomas C., and Scott, Rebecca J., Beyond Slavery: Explorations of Race, Labor, and Citizenship in Postemancipation Societies (Chapel Hill, 2000), 1–32Google Scholar; Landers, Jane, Black Society in Spanish Florida (Urbana, 1999), 1–2Google Scholar; Ingersoll, Thomas N., Mammon and Manon in Early New Orleans: The First Slave Society in the Deep South, 1718–1819 (Knoxville, 1999), xviii-xix, 120–122Google Scholar; Din, Gilbert C., Spaniards, Planters, and Slaves: The Spanish Regulation of Slavery in Louisiana, 1763–1803 (College Station, MD, 1999), xiii-xivGoogle Scholar.

3. Tannenbaum, Slave and Citizen, xv.

4. On the controversy sparked by Williams's book, see Minchinton, Walter, “Williams and Drescher: Abolition and Emancipation,” Slavery and Abolition 4 (1983): 81–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Drescher, Seymour, “The Decline Thesis of British Slavery since Econocide,” Slavery and Abolition 7 (1986), 3–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Solow, Barbara L. and Engerman, Stanley L., eds., British Capitalism and Caribbean Slavery: The Legacy of Eric Williams (New York, 1987)Google Scholar; Drescher, “Capitalism and Slavery After Fifty Years,” Slavery and Abolition 18 (1997), 12–27; Carrington, Selwyn H.H., The Sugar Industry and the Abolition of the Slave Trade, 1775–1810 (Gainesville, FL, 2002)Google Scholar.

5. Tannenbaum, Slave and Citizen, 4, 42.

6. Ibid., 63, 66.

7. Ibid., 97, 105.

8. Ibid., 95, 112.

9. On the impact of the Second World War on the politics of race in the United States, see Dudziak, Mary L., Cold War Civil Rights: Race and the Image of American Democracy (Princeton, 2000)Google Scholar; Borstelmann, Thomas, The Cold War and the Color Line: American Race Relations in the Global Arena (Cambridge, MA, 2001)Google Scholar.

10. Myrdal, Gunnar, An American Dilemma: The Negro Problem and Modern Democracy (New Brunswick, NJ, 1996), 113, 134Google Scholar.

11. Herskovits, Melville, The Myth of the Negro Past (Boston, 1990)Google Scholar; Yelvington, Kevin, “The Invention of Africa in Latin America and the Caribbean: Political Discourse and Anthropological Praxis, 1920–1940,” in Afro-Atlantic Dialogues: Anthropology in the Diaspora, ed. Yelvington, K. (Santa Fe, 2006), 53–76Google Scholar.

12. Klineberg, Otto, ed., Characteristics of the American Negro (New York, 1944)Google Scholar.

13. Pierson, Donald, Negroes in Brazil (Chicago, 1942), 156, 325Google Scholar.

14. The book was published in English as Mansions and the Shanties: The Making of Modern Brazil (New York, 1963) with an introduction by Tannenbaum.

15. DuBois, W.E.B., The Negro (New York, 1915), 98Google Scholar. See also Hellwig, David J., ed., African-American Reflections on Brazil's Racial Paradise (Philadelphia, 1992)Google Scholar.

16. Cited in Guridy, Frank A., “From Solidarity to Cross-Fertilization: Afro-Cuban/African American Interaction During the 1930s and 1940s,” Radical History 87 (2003): 24Google Scholar. See also Brock, Lisa and Fuertes, Digna Castañeda, eds., Between Race and Empire: African-Americans and Cubans Before the Cuban Revolution (Philadelphia, 1998)Google Scholar.

17. Métraux, Alfred, “An Inquiry into Race Relations in Brazil,” UNESCO Courier (1952): 6Google Scholar.

18. On the UNESCO studies, see Maio, Marcos Chor, “UNESCO and the Study of Race Relations in Brazil: Regional or National Issue?” Latin American Research Review 36 (2001): 118–136Google Scholar; Wade, Peter, Race and Ethnicity in Latin America (London, 1997), 51–57Google Scholar.

19. Bastide, Roger, “São Paulo, the Octopus Town,” UNESCO Courier (1952): 9Google Scholar.

20. Pinto, L.A. Costa, “Rio de Janeiro, Melting Pot of Peoples,” UNESCO Courier (1952): 10Google Scholar.

21. Wagley, Charles, “Attitudes in the ‘Backlands,’” UNESCO Courier (1952): 12–13Google Scholar.

22. Bastide, “São Paulo,” 9; Costa Pinto, “Rio de Janeiro,” 10; Wagley, “Attitudes,” 12; de Azevedo, Thales, “Bahia, the Negro Metropolis,” UNESCO Courier (1952): 14–15Google Scholar; Métraux, “An Inquiry,” 6.

23. Harris, Marvin, “Race and Class in Minas Velhas, a Community in the Mountain Region of Central Brazil,” in Race and Class in Rural Brazil, ed. Wagley, Charles (Paris, 1952), 47–81Google Scholar.

24. Fernandes, Florestan, The Negro in Brazilian Society (New York, 1971)Google Scholar, especially the “Preface to the U.S. Edition”; Tannenbaum, Slave and Citizen, 103.

25. Hasenbalg, Carlos, “Race and Socioeconomic Inequalities in Brazil,” in Race, Class and Power in Brazil, ed. Fontaine, Pierre-Michel (Los Angeles, 1985), 25–41Google Scholar; Hasenbalg, Discriminação e desigualdades raciaias no Brasil (Rio de Janeiro, 1979); Silva, Nelson do Valle, “Updating the Cost of Not Being White in Brazil,” in Race, Class and Power in Brazil, ed. Fontaine, Pierre-Michel (Los Angeles, 1985), 42–55Google Scholar.

26. Andrews, George Reid, Blacks and Whites in São Paulo, Brazil 1888–1988 (Madison, 1991)Google Scholar.

27. The reference to white supremacy is taken from Twine, France W., Racism in a Racial Democracy (New Brunswick, NJ, 1998), 135Google Scholar. The most accomplished scholarly articulation of this position for Brazil is Hanchard, Michael G., Orpheus and Power: The Movimento Negro of Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo, Brazil, 1945–1988 (Princeton, 1994)Google Scholar. For another important contribution see Helg, Aline, Our Rightful Share: The Afro-Cuban Struggle for Equality, 1886–1912 (Chapel Hill, NC, 1995)Google Scholar.

28. Pinto, Costa, “Rio de Janeiro”; Harry W. Hutchinson, “Shades of Colour and Meaning,” UNESCO Courier (1952): 11Google Scholar.

29. Degler, Carl, Neither Black nor White: Slavery and Race Relations in Brazil and the United States (Madison, 1971), 268Google Scholar; Skidmore, Thomas E., “Bi-racial U.S.A. vs. Multi-racial Brazil: Is the Contrast Still Valid,” Journal of Latin American Studies 25 (1993): 373–386CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Andrews, George Reid, “Racial Inequality in Brazil and the United States: A Statistical Comparison,” Journal of Social History 26 (1992), 229–263CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

30. The best-known scholarship following the Tannenbaum position was Elkins, Stanley M., Slavery: A Problem in American Institutional and Intellectual Life (Chicago, 1959)Google Scholar and Klein, Herbert, Slavery in the Americas: A Comparative Study of Virginia and Cuba (Chicago, 1967)Google Scholar.

31. Degler, Neither Black nor White, 92.

32. I analyze this debate elsewhere, “Slave Law and Claims-Making: The Tannenbaum Debate Revisited,” Law and History Review 22 (2004): 339–369, and offer here only a brief summary.

33. Harris, Marvin, Patterns of Race in the Americas (New York, 1964), 76Google Scholar; Ingersoll, Mammon and Manon, xviii.

34. For a recent survey of the contentious process of emancipation, see Andrews, George Reid, Afro-Latin America, 1800–2000 (New York, 2004), 53–84Google Scholar.

35. Fraginals, Manuel Moreno, El ingenio: complejo económico-social cubano del azúcar (Havana, 1978), 2:7–14Google Scholar.

36. Cottrol, “The Long Lingering Shadow”; Landers, Black Society in Spanish Florida.

37. Twinam, Ann, Public Lives, Private Secrets: Gender, Honor, Sexuality, and Illegitimacy in Colonial Spanish America (Stanford, 1999), 25Google Scholar; Elliott, John H., Empires of the Atlantic World: Britain and Spain in America, 1492–1830 (New Haven, 2006), 410Google Scholar.

38. Rankin, David C., “The Tannenbaum Thesis Reconsidered: Slavery and Race Relations in Antebellum Louisiana,” Southern Studies 18 (1979): 5–31Google Scholar; Ingersoll, Mammon and Manon, 211–239; Fiehrer, Thomas M., “The African Presence in Colonial Louisiana: An Essay on the Continuity of Caribbean Culture,” in Louisiana's Black Heritage, ed. Macdonald, Robert R. et al. (New Orleans, 1979), 3–31Google Scholar.

39. Din, Spaniards, Planters, and Slaves, 44.

40. Schafer, Judith K., Slavery, the Civil Law, and the Supreme Court of Louisiana (Baton Rouge, 1994), 6Google Scholar.

41. Sansone, Livio, Blackness without Ethnicity: Constructing Race in Brazil (New York, 2003), 12CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tellez, Edward E., Race in Another America: The Significance of Skin Color in Brazil (Princeton, 2004), 2Google Scholar. See also da Silva, Denise Ferreira, “Facts of Blackness: Brazil is Not (Quite) the United States … and Racial Politics in Brazil?” Social Identities 4 (1998), 201–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42. Hanchard, Orpheus and Power, 5; Twine, Racism, 4; Helg, Aline, Liberty and Equality in Caribbean Colombia, 1770–1835 (Chapel Hill, NC, 2004), 6Google Scholar.

43. For examples of this scholarship on Brazil, see Sansone, Blackness Without Ethnicity; Sheriff, Robin E., Dreaming Equality: Color, Race, and Racism in Urban Brazil (New Brunswick, NJ, 2001)Google Scholar; Segato, Rita L., “The Color-Blind Subject of Myth; Or, Where to Find Africa in the Nation,” Annual Review of Anthropology 27 (1998): 129–151CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bailey, Stanley R., “The Race Construct and Public Opinion: Understanding Brazilian Beliefs about Racial Inequality and their Determinants,” American Journal of Sociology 108 (2002): 406–439CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Fry, Peter, A Persistência da raça: Ensaios antropológicos sobre o Brasil e a África austral (Rio de Janeiro, 2005)Google Scholar. For other Latin American scenarios, see my A Nation for All: Race, Inequality and Politics in Twentieth-Century Cuba (Chapel Hill, NC, 2001); Lasso, Marixa, Myths of Harmony: Race and Republicanism during the Age of Revolution, Colombia 1795–1831 (Pittsburgh, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Chasteen, John Charles, National Rhythms, African Roots: The Deep History of Latin American Popular Dances (Albuquerque, NM, 2004)Google Scholar.

44. Degler, Neither White nor Black, 92.

45. Hoetink, H., Slavery and Race Relations in the Americas: Comparative Notes on their Nature and Nexus (New York, 1973), 40Google Scholar.

46. I learned about these studies through Verena Stolcke's excellent overview, “The Slavery Period and Its Influence on Household Structure and the Family in Jamaica, Cuba, and Brazil,” in Family Systems and Cultural Change, ed. Elza Berquó and Peter Xenos (Oxford, 1992), 125–143; Gutman, Herbert, The Black Family in Slavery and Freedom, 1750–1925 (New York, 1976)Google Scholar; Higman, B.W., “The Slave Family and Household in the British West Indies, 1780–1834,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 6 (1975): 261–287CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47. da Costa, Emilia Viotti, “Commentary,” Luso-Brazilian Review (1992), 147Google Scholar.

48. Cell, John W., The Highest State of White Supremacy: The Origins of Segregation in South Africa and the American South (Cambridge, 1982), xiiCrossRefGoogle Scholar; Marx, Anthony W., Making Race and Nation: A Comparison of South Africa, the United States, and Brazil (New York, 1998), 8–9Google Scholar.

49. Marrero, Leví, Cuba: Economía y sociedad (Madrid, 1992), 15: 232–34Google Scholar; Scott, Rebecca J., Slave Emancipation in Cuba: The Transition to Free Labor, 1860–1899 (Princeton, 1985), 39–41Google Scholar; Schmidt-Nowara, Christopher, Empire and Antislavery: Spain, Cuba, and Puerto Rico, 1833–1874 (Pittsburgh, 1999), 102–108, 129–135Google Scholar; Bonilla, Raúl Cepero, Azúcar y abolición (Barcelona, 1976), 68–85Google Scholar; Corwin, Arthur, Spain and the Abolition of Slavery in Cuba, 1817–1886 (Austin, 1967), 189–214Google Scholar.

50. Ferrer, Ada, Insurgent Cuba: Race, Nation and Revolution, 1868–1898 (Chapel Hill, NC, 1999), 15–42Google Scholar; Scott, Slave Emancipation, 45–62; Ibarra, Jorge, Ideología mambisa (Havana, 1967), 42–58Google Scholar.

51. Marrero, Cuba, 15: 306–11; Scott, Slave Emancipation, 45–62; Ferrer, Insurgent Cuba, 27–28.

52. Pérez, Louis A., Cuba Between Empires, 1878–1902 (Pittsburgh, 1983), 310Google Scholar.

53. Scott, Slave Emancipation, 63–83, 127–171; Cowling, Camillia, “Negotiating Freedom: Women of Colour, Gender and the Transition from Slavery to Free Labour in Cuba, 1870–1886,” Slavery and Abolition 26 (2005): 377–391CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

54. Corwin, Spain, 255–272; Scott, Slave Emancipation, 73–74.

55. Helg, Our Rightful Share, 36–38; Ferrer, Insurgent Cuba, 128–137.

56. Carreras, Julio, Historia del estado y el derecho en Cuba (Havana, 1981), 191Google Scholar.

57. There is a growing scholarship on the postwar political reforms, the Partido Liberal Autonomista, and the Autonomist regime in the island. Most of this scholarship has been produced by Spanish scholars such as Luis Miguel Mora, García, “Tras la revolución, las reformas: el Partido Liberal Cubano y los proyectos reformistas tras la Paz del Zanjón,” in Cuba, la perla de las Antillas, ed. Orovio, Consuelo Naranjo and Mallo, Tomas (Aranjuez, 1994), 197–212Google Scholar; Mora, García, “La fuerza de la palabra: el autonomismo en Cuba en el último tercio del siglo XIX,” Revista de Indias 61 (2001), 715–748Google Scholar; Vega, Mariano E. de and Fernández, José Cayuela, “Elite hispano-cubana, autonomismo y desastre del '98,” Colonial Latin American Review 9 (2000), 81–112Google Scholar; Montaud, Inés Roldán de, La Restauración en Cuba y el fracaso del proyecto reformista (Madrid, 2000)Google Scholar.

58. Ferrer, Insurgent Cuba, 199–200; de la Fuente, A Nation for All, 56–60; Pérez, Cuba Between Empires, 303–314.

59. Scott, Rebecca J., Degrees of Freedom: Louisiana and Cuba After Slavery (Cambridge, MA, 2005), 264Google Scholar.