Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Cited by 26
  • Print publication year: 2013
  • Online publication date: June 2013

24 - Bubbles, Crises, and Heterogeneous Beliefs



Abstract Heterogeneous beliefs are a widely observed attribute of individuals. This chapter reviews the quickly growing literature that builds on heterogeneous beliefs to explain bubbles, crises, and endogenous risk in financial markets.

The history of financial markets has been dotted with episodes of bubbles, during which market values of assets vastly exceeded reasonable assessments of their fundamental value. Asset price bubbles can lead to severe economic consequences ranging from wasteful over-investment and frenzied trading during booms to devastating financial crises and depressed real economies during busts. Economists have emphasized many aspects of bubbles and crises. Minsky (1974) advocated the view that excessive expansion of bank credit due to optimism can fuel a speculative euphoria and slowly lead the economy to a crisis. Kindleberger (1978) stressed that irrationally optimistic expectations frequently emerge among investors in the late stages of major economic booms and lead firm managers to over-invest, overpromise, and over-leverage, which sow the seeds for an eventual collapse after they fail to deliver on their promises. Shiller (2000) highlighted a host of psychological biases people use in forming a feedback mechanism, through which initial price increases caused by certain initial precipitating factors such as new technology innovations feed back into even higher asset prices through increased investor confidence and expectations. Allen and Gale (2007) focused on agency problems of professional managers who actively seek unwarranted risk, which leads to bubbles and crises.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Abreu, Dilip and Markus K., Brunnermeier (2002). Synchronization risk and delayed arbitrage. Journal of Financial Economics 66 341–360.
Abreu, Dilip and Markus K., Brunnermeier (2003). Bubbles and crashes. Econometrica 71 173–204.
Acemoglu, Daron, Victor, Chernozhukov, and Muhamet, Yildiz (2009). Fragility of asymptotic agreement under Bayesian learning, Working paper, MIT.
Ackert, Lucy, Narat, Charupat, Bryan, Church, and Richard, Deaves (2006). Margin, short selling, and lotteries in experimental asset markets. Southern Economic Journal 73 419–36.
Adrian, Tobias and Hyun Song, Shin (2010). Liquidity and leverage. Journal of Financial Intermediation 19 418–437.
Ait-Sahalia, Yacine and Andrew, Lo (1998). Nonparametric estimation of state–price densities implicit in financial asset prices. Journal of Finance 53 499–547.
Allen, Franklin and Douglas, Gale (2000). Bubbles and crises. Economic Journal 110 236–55.
Allen, Franklin and Douglas, Gale (2007). Understanding Financial Crises. Oxford University Press, New York.
Allen, Franklin and Gary, Gorton (1993). Churning bubbles. Review of Economic Studies 60 813–36.
Alpert, M. and H., Raiffa (1982). A progress report on the training of probability assessors. In Judgement Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, Daniel, Kahneman, Paul, Slovic, and Amos, Tversky, (eds). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Anderson, Evan, Eric, Ghysels, and Jennifer, Juergens (2005). Do heterogeneous beliefs matter for asset pricing?Review of Financial Studies 18 875–924.
Aumann, Robert (1976). Agreeing to disagreeAnnals of Statistics 4 1236–1239.
Baker, Malcolm, Jeremy, Stein, and Jeffrey, Wurgler (2003). When does the market matter? Stock prices and the investment of equity-dependent firms. Quarterly Journal of Economics 118 969–1006.
Banerjee, Snehal (2011). Learning from prices and the dispersion in beliefs. Review of Financial Studies 24 3025–3068.
Barber, Brad and Terrance, Odean (2000). Trading is hazardous to your wealth: The common stock investment performance of individual investors. Journal of Finance 55 773–806.
Barber, Brad, Yi-Tsung, Lee, Yu-Jane, Liu, and Terrance, Odean (2009). Just how much do individual investors lose by trading?Review of Financial Studies 22 609–632.
Barberis, Nicholas (2011). Psychology and the financial crisis of 2007–2008. Working paper, Yale University.
Barberis, Nicholas, Andrei, Shleifer, and Robert, Vishny (1998). A model of investor sentiment. Journal of Financial Economics 49 307–343.
Barberis, Nicholas and Richard, Thaler (2003). A survey of behavioral finance. In Handbook of the Economics of Finance, Constantinides, G., Harris, M., Stulz, R. (eds). North-Holland, Amsterdam.
Basak, Suleyman (2000). A model of dynamic equilibrium asset pricing with heterogeneous beliefs and extraneous risk. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 24 63–95.
Bebchuk, Lucian and Jesse, Fried (2004). Pay Without Performance: The Unfulfilled Promise of Executive Compensation. Harvard University Press, MA.
Ben David, Itzhak, John, Graham, and Campbell, Harvey (2010). Managerial Miscalibration. NBER working paper 16215.
Benabou, Roland (2009). Groupthink: Collective delusions in organizations and markets. Working paper, Princeton University.
Blanchard, Oliver, Changyong, Rhee, and Lawrence, Summers (1993). The stock market, profit and investment. Quarterly Journal of Economics 107 115–136.
Blanchard, Olivier and Mark, Watson (1983). Bubbles, rational expectations and financial markets. National Bureau of Economic Research, NBER Working Papers 945.
Blume, Lawrence and David, Easley (1992). Evolution and market behavior. Journal of Economic Theory 58 9–40.
Blume, Lawrence and David, Easley (2006). If you're so smart, why aren't you rich? Belief selection in complete and incomplete markets. Econometrica 74 929–966.
Bolton, Patrick, Jose, Scheinkman, and Tano, Santos (2011). Outside and inside liquidity. Quarterly Journal of Economics 126 259–321.
Bolton, Patrick, Jose, Scheinkman, and Wei, Xiong (2005). Pay for short-term performance: Executive compensation in speculative markets. Journal of Corporation Law 30 721–747.
Bolton, Patrick, Jose, Scheinkman, and Wei, Xiong (2006). Executive compensation and short-termist behavior in speculative markets. Review of Economic Studies 73 577–610.
Bris, Arturo, William, Goetzmann, and Ning, Zhu (2007). Efficiency and the bear: Short sales and markets around the world. Journal of Finance 62 1029–1079.
Brunnermeier, Markus and Lasse, Pedersen (2009). Funding liquidity and market liquidity. Review of Financial Studies 22 2201–2238.
Brunnermeier, Markus, Alp, Simsek and Wei, Xiong (2012). A welfare criterion for models with distorted beliefs. Working paper, Princeton University.
Buraschi, Andrea and Alexei, Jiltsov (2006). Model uncertainty and option markets with heterogeneous beliefs. Journal of Finance 61 2841–97.
Campbell, John, Andrew, Lo, and Craig, MacKinlay (1997). The Econometrics of Financial Markets. Princeton University Press, NJ.
Cao, Dan (2011). Collateral shortages, asset price and investment volatility with heterogeneous beliefs. Working paper, Georgetown University.
Chen, Hui, Scott, Joslin, and Ngoc-Khanh, Tran (2011). Rare disasters and risk sharing with heterogeneous beliefs. Working paper, MIT.
Chen, Joseph, Harrison, Hong, and Jeremy, Stein (2002). Breadth of ownership and stock returns. Journal of Financial Economics 66 171–205.
Cheng, Ing-haw, Sahil, Raina, and Wei, Xiong (2012). Wall Street and the housing bubble: Bad incentives, bad models, or bad luck? Working paper, Princeton University.
Chinco, Alex and Chris, Mayer (2011). Noise traders, distant speculators and asset bubbles in the housing market. Working paper, Columbia University.
Constantinides, George and Darrell, Duffie (1996). Asset pricing with heterogeneous consumers. Journal of Financial Economics 104 219–240.
Coval, Joshua and Erik, Stafford (2007). Asset fire sales (and purchases) in equity markets. Journal of Financial Economics 86, 479–512.
Croitoru, Benjamin and Lei, Lu (2009). Asset pricing in a monetary economy with heterogeneous belief. Working paper, McGill University.
Danielsson, Jon, Jean-Pierre, Zigrand, and Hyun Song, Shin (2010). Balance sheet capacity and endogenous risk. Working paper, London School of Economics and Princeton University.
Daniel, Kent, David, Hirshleifer, and A., Subrahmanyam (1998). Investor psychology and security market under- and over-reactions. Journal of Finance 53 1839–1885.
David, Alexander (2008). Heterogeneous beliefs, speculation, and the equity premium. Journal of Finance 63 41–83.
D'Avolio, Gene (2002). The market for borrowing stock. Journal of Financial Economics 66 271–306.
Diether, Karl, Christopher, Malloy, and Anna, Scherbina (2002). Differences of opinion and the cross section of stock returns. Journal of Finance 57 2113–2141.
De Long, Brad, Andrei, Shleifer, Lawrence, Summers, and Robert, Waldman (1990). Noise trader risk in financial market. Journal of Political Economy 98 703–738.
De Long, Brad, Andrei, Shleifer, Lawrence, Summers, and Robert, Waldman (1991). The survival of noise traders in financial markets. Journal of Business 64 1–19.
Detemple, Jerome and Shashidhar, Murthy (1994). Intertemporal asset pricing with heterogeneous beliefs. Journal of Economic Theory 62 294–320.
Dieckmann, Stephan (2011). Rare event risk and heterogeneous beliefs: The case of incomplete markets. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 46 459–488.
Duffie, Darrel (2010). Asset price dynamics with slow-moving capital, (American Finance Association Presidential Address). Journal of Finance 65 1237–1267.
Duffie, Darrell, Nicolae, Garleanu, and Lasse Heje, Pedersen (2002). Securities lending, shorting, and pricing. Journal of Financial Economics 66 307–339.
Duffie, Darrel, Nicolae, Garleanu, and Lasse Heje, Pedersen (2005). Over-the-counter markets. Econometrica 73 1815–1847.
Dufwenberg, Martin, Tobias, Lindqvist, and Evan, Moore (2005). Bubbles and experience: An experiment on speculation. American Economic Review 95 1731–1737.
Dumas, Bernard, Alexander, Kurshev, and Raman, Uppal (2009). Equilibrium portfolio strategies in the presence of sentiment risk and excess volatility. Journal of Finance 64 579–629.
Dumas, Bernard, Karen, Lewis, and Emilio, Osambela (2011). Differences of opinion and international equity markets. Working paper, Wharton School.
Fostel, Ana and John, Geanakoplos (2008). Leverage cycles and the anxious economy. American Economic Review 98 1211–1244.
Friedman, Milton (1953). Essays in Positive Economics. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
Froot, Kenneth and Paul, O'Connell (1999). The pricing of US catastrophe reinsurance. In The Financing of Catastrophe Risk, Kenneth, Froot (ed). University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
Galbraith, John Kenneth (1997). The Great Crash 1929. Houghton Mifflin Company, New York.
Gallmeyer, Michael and Burton, Hollifield (2008). An examination of heterogeneous beliefs with a short-sale constraint in a dynamic economy. Review of Finance 12 323–364.
Garber, Peter (2000). Famous First Bubbles: The Fundamentals of Early Manias. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Garleanu, Nicolae and Lasse, Pedersen (2011). Margin-based asset pricing and deviations from the law of one price. Review of Financial Studies 24 1980–2022.
Geanakoplos, John (2003), Liquidity, default, and crashes: Endogenous contracts in general equilibrium, In Advances in Economics and Econometrics Theory and Applications, Eighth World Conference, Vol 2. Econometric Society Monographs, pp. 170–205.
Geanakoplos, John (2010). The leverage cycle. NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2009. 24 1–65.
Geczy, Christopher, David, Musto, and Adam, Reed (2002). Stocks are special too: an analysis of the equity lending market. Journal of Financial Economics 66 241–269.
Gervais, Simon, and Terrance, Odean (2001). Learning to be overconfident. Review of Financial Studies 14 1–27.
Gilchrist, Simon, Charles, Himmelberg, and Gur, Huberman (2005). Do stock price bubbles influence corporate investment?Journal of Monetary Economics 52 805–827.
Grinblatt, Mark and Matti, Keloharju (2000). The investment behavior and performance of various investor types: a study of Finland's unique data set. Journal of Finance 55 43–67.
Griffin, D. and A., Tversky (1992). The weighing of evidence and the determinants of overconfidence. Cognitive Psychology 24 411–435.
Gromb, Denis and Dimitri, Vayanos (2002). Equilibrium and welfare in markets with financially constrained arbitrageurs. Journal of Financial Economics 66 361–407.
Gromb, Denis and Dimitri, Vayanos (2010). Limits of arbitrage: The state of the theory. Annual Review of Financial Economics 2 251–275.
Grossman, Sanford and Joseph, Stiglitz (1980). On the impossibility of informationally efficient markets. American Economic Review 70 393–408.
Harris, Milton and Artur, Raviv (1993). Differences of opinion make a horse race. Review of Financial Studies 6 473–506
Harrison, Michael, and David M., Kreps (1978). Speculative investor behavior in a stock-market with heterogeneous expectations. Quarterly Journal of Economics 92 323–336.
Haruvy, Ernan and Charles, Noussair (2006). The effect of short selling on bubbles and crashes in experimental spot asset markets. Journal of Finance 61 1119–1157.
Haruvy, Ernan, Yaron, Lahav, and Charles, Noussair (2007). Traders' expectations in asset markets: experimental evidence. American Economic Review 97 1901–1920.
Haughwout, Andrew, Donghoon, Lee, Joseph, Tracy, and Wilbert, van der Klaauw (2011). Real estate investors, the leverage cycle and the housing market crisis. Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Staff Reports, no. 514, September 2011. Available at
He, Zhiguo and Arvind, Krishnamurthy (2009). Intermediary asset pricing. Working paper, University of Chicago and Northwestern University.
He, Zhiguo and Wei, Xiong (2010). Delegated asset management and investment mandates. Working paper, University of Chicago and Princeton University.
He, Zhiguo and Wei, Xiong (2012). Debt financing in asset markets. American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 102 88–94.
Hirota, Shinichi, and Shyam, Sunder (2007). Price bubbles sans dividend anchors: Evidence from laboratory stock markets. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 31 1875–1909.
Hirshleifer, David (2001). Investor psychology and asset pricing. Journal of Finance 56 1533–1597.
Hong, Harrison and Jeffrey, Kubik (2003). Analyzing the analysts: Career concerns and biased earnings forecasts. Journal of Finance 58 313–351.
Hong, Harrison, Jose, Scheinkman, and Wei, Xiong (2006). Asset float and speculative bubbles. Journal of Finance 61 1073–1117.
Hong, Harrison and Jeremy, Stein (2003). Differences of opinion, short-sales constraints, and market crashes. Review of Financial Studies 16 487–525.
Hong, Harrison and Jeremy, Stein (2007). Disagreement and the stock market. Journal of Economic Perspectives 21 109–128.
Hong, Harrison and David, Sraer (2011). Quiet bubbles. Working paper, Princeton University.
Hussam, Reshmaan, David, Porter, and Vernon, Smith (2008). Thar she blows: Can bubbles be rekindled with experienced subjects?American Economic Review 98 924–937.
Jarrow, Robert (1980). Heterogeneous expectations, restrictions on short-sales, and equilibrium asset prices. Journal of Finance 35 1105–1113.
Jouini, Elyes and Clotilde, Napp (2007). Consensus consumer and intertemporal asset pricing with heterogeneous beliefs. Review of Economic Studies 74 1149–1174.
Kandel, Eugene and Neil, Pearson (1995). Differential interpretation of public signals and trade in speculative markets. Journal of Political Economy 103 831–872.
Kindleberger, Charles (1978). Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Kiyotaki, Nobu and John, Moore (1997). Credit cycles. Journal of Political Economy 105 211–248.
Kondor, Peter (2009). Risk in dynamic arbitrage: The price effects of convergence trading. Journal of Finance 64 631–655.
Kogan, Leonid, Stephen, Ross, Jiang, Wang, and Mark, Westerfield (2006). The price impact and survival of irrational traders. Journal of Finance 61 195–229.
Kogan, Leonid, Stephen, Ross, Jiang, Wang, and Mark, Westerfield (2011). Market selection. Working paper, MIT.
Krishnamurthy, Arvind (2009). Amplification mechanisms in liquidity crises. American Economic Journals – Macroeconomics 2 1–33.
Kurz, Mordecai (1994). On the structure and diversity of rational beliefs. Economic Theory 4 877–900.
Kurz, Mordecai (1996). Rational beliefs and endogenous uncertainty, Economic Theory 8 383–397.
Kyle, Albert (1985). Continuous auctions and insider trading, Econometrica 53 1315–1335.
Kyle, Albert and Albert, Wang (1997). Speculation duopoly with agreement to disagree: Can overconfidence survive the market test?Journal of Finance 52 2073–90.
Kyle, Albert and Wei, Xiong (2001). Contagion as a wealth effect. Journal of Finance 56 1401–1440.
Lamont, Own and Richard, Thaler (2003). Can the market add and subtract? Mispricing in tech stock carve-outs. Journal of Political Economy 111 227–268.
Lei, Vivian, Charles, Noussair, and Charles, Plott (2001). Non-speculative bubbles in experimental asset markets: Lack of common knowledge of rationality vs. actual irrationality, Econometrica 69 830–859.
Lin, H. and M., McNichols (1998). Underwriting relationships, analysts' earnings forecasts and investment recommendations. Journal of Accounting and Economics 25 101–127.
Mackay, Charles (1841). Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of CrowdsOffice of the National Illustrated Library, London.
Malmendier, Ulrike and D., Shantikumar (2007). Are investors naive about incentives?Journal of Financial Economics 85 457–489.
Mankiw, Gregory, Ricardo, Reis, and Justin, Wolfers (2004). Disagreement about inflation expectations, NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2003 18 209–248.
Mei, Jianping, Jose, Scheinkman, and Wei, Xiong (2009). Speculative trading and stock prices: Evidence from Chinese A–B share premia. Annals of Economics and Finance 10 225–255.
Mian, Atif and Amir, Sufi (2009). The consequences of mortgage credit expansion: Evidence from the US mortgage default crisis. Quarterly Journal of Economics 124 1449–1496.
Milgrom, Paul and Nancy, Stokey (1982). Information, trade and common knowledge. Journal of Economic Theory 26 17–27.
Miller, Edward (1977). Risk, uncertainty and divergence of opinion. Journal of Finance 32 1151–1168.
Minsky, Hyman (1974). The modeling of financial instability: An introduction. In Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Pittsburgh Conference, Modeling and Simulation 5 267–272.
Mitchell, Mark, Lasse Heje, Pedersen and Todd, Pulvino (2007). Slow moving capital. American Economic Review 97 215–220.
Morck, Randall, Andrei, Shleifer and Robert, Vishny (1990). The stock market and investment: Is the market a sideshow?Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2 157–215.
Morris, Stephen (1995). The common prior assumption in economic theory, Economics and Philosophy 11 227–253.
Morris, Stephen (1996). Speculative investor behavior and learning. Quarterly Journal of Economics 111 1111–1133.
Odean, Terrance (1998). Volume, volatility, price, and profit when all traders are above average. Journal of Finance 53 1887–1934.
Odean, Terrance (1999). Do investors trade too much?American Economic Review 89 1279–1298.
Ofek, Eli and Matthew, Richardson (2003). DotCom Mania: The rise and fall of Internet stock prices. Journal of Finance 58 1113–1137.
Panageas, Stavros (2006). The neoclassical q theory of investment in speculative markets. Working paper, University of Chicago.
Pastor, Lubos, and Pietro, Veronesi (2006). Was there a NASDAQ bubble in the late 1990s?Journal of Financial Economics 81 61–100.
Pastor, Lubos, and Pietro, Veronesi (2009). Learning in financial markets. Annual Review of Financial Economics 1 361–381.
Polk, Christopher and Paola, Sapienza (2009). The stock market and corporate investment: A test of catering theory. Review of Financial Studies 22 187–217.
Porter, David, and Vernon, Smith (1995). Futures contracting and dividend uncertainty in experimental asset markets. Journal of Business 68 509–541.
Rajan, Raghuram (2010). Fault Lines. Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ.
Reinhart, Carmen and Kenneth, Rogoff (2009). This Time Is Different. Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ.
Rosenberg, Joshua and Robert, Engle (2002). Empirical pricing kernels. Journal of Financial Economics 64 341–372.
Rothschild, Michael (1974). A two-armed bandit theory of market pricing. Journal of Economic Theory 9 185–202.
Sandroni, Alvaro (2000). Do markets favor agents able to make accurate predictions?Econometrica 68 1303–1342.
Savage, L. J. (1954). The Foundation of Statistics. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Scheinkman, Jose A., and Wei, Xiong (2003). Overconfidence and speculative bubbles. Journal of Political Economy 111 1183–1219.
Sebenius, James and John, Geanakoplos (1983). Don't bet on it: Contingent agreements with asymmetric information. Journal of the American Statistical Association 78 424–426.
Shefrin, Hersh (2008). A Behavioral Approach to Asset Pricing. Academic Press.
Shen, Ji, Hongjun, Yan, and Jinfan, Zhang (2011). Collateral-motivated financial innovation. Working paper, Yale University.
Shiller, Robert (1998). Macro Markets. Oxford University Press, New York.
Shiller, Robert (2000). Irrational Exuberance. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Shleifer, Andrei and Robert, Vishny (1997). Limits of arbitrage. Journal of Finance 52 35–55.
Sims, Christopher (2008). Inflation expectations, uncertainty, and monetary policy. Working paper, Princeton University.
Simsek, Alp (2010). Belief disagreements and collateral constraints. Working paper, Harvard University.
Simsek, Alp (2011). Speculation and risk sharing with new financial assets. Working paper, Harvard University.
Smith, Vernon L., Gerry L., Suchanek, and Arlington W., Williams (1988). Bubbles, crashes, and endogenous expectations in experimental spot asset markets, Econometrica 56 1119–1151.
Stein, Jeremy (1996). Rational capital budgeting in an irrational world. Journal of Business 69 429–455.
Welch, Ivo (2000). Views of financial economists on the equity premium and on professional controversies. Journal of Business 73 501–537.
White, Eugene (1990). The stock market boom and crash of 1929 revisited. Journal of Economic Perspectives 4 67–83.
Xiong, Wei (2001). Convergence trading with wealth effects: An amplification mechanism in financial markets. Journal of Financial Economics 62 247–292.
Xiong, Wei and Hongjun, Yan (2010). Heterogeneous expectations and bond markets. Review of Financial Studies 23 1433–1466.
Xiong, Wei and Jialin, Yu (2011). The Chinese warrants bubble. American Economic Review 101 2723–2753.
Yan, Hongjun (2008). Natural selection in financial markets: Does it work?Management Science 54 1935–1950.
Yu, Jialin (2011). Disagreement and return predictability of stock portfolios. Journal of Financial Economics 99 162–183.
Zapatero, Fernando (1998). Effects of financial innovations on market volatility when beliefs are heterogeneous. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 22 597–626.