Book contents
- A Qualified Hope
- Comparative Constitutional Law and Policy
- A Qualified Hope
- Copyright page
- Contents
- Notes on Contributors
- Foreword
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction
- Part I The Supreme Court of India – An Institutional Overview
- Part II The Supreme Court of India, Social and Political Mobilization
- 6 The Art of Buying Time
- 7 Court as a Symbolic Resource
- 8 PUCL v. Union of India
- Part III Welfare Rights and the Environment
- Part IV Discrimination
- Conclusion
- References
7 - Court as a Symbolic Resource
Indra Sawhney Case and the Dalit Muslim Mobilization
from Part II - The Supreme Court of India, Social and Political Mobilization
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 19 August 2019
Book contents
- A Qualified Hope
- Comparative Constitutional Law and Policy
- A Qualified Hope
- Copyright page
- Contents
- Notes on Contributors
- Foreword
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction
- Part I The Supreme Court of India – An Institutional Overview
- Part II The Supreme Court of India, Social and Political Mobilization
- 6 The Art of Buying Time
- 7 Court as a Symbolic Resource
- 8 PUCL v. Union of India
- Part III Welfare Rights and the Environment
- Part IV Discrimination
- Conclusion
- References
Summary
This chapter analyzes the impact of the Indian Supreme Court's watershed case on quotas for "backward classes," the Indra Sawhneycase. It explores the role of the decision in the mobilization of Dalit Muslims, who have been excluded from the constitutionally mandated affirmative action regime for the erstwhile Untouchable or Dalit castes ("Scheduled Castes"). It shows how the incipient mobilization came to creatively interpret the decision, in particular its interpretation of Hindu caste and a partial recognition of Muslim social stratification, as an endorsement of their claims. The appropriation and activation of the judgment allowed the mobilization to generate further political support, convince state commissions and eventually mount a constitutional challenge in the Court. This account aims to highlight the symbolic potential of the Court's decisions, often through unintended mechanisms, to reshape and extend social movement politics. It also highlights the role of political constraints, organizational infrastructure and the Indian institutional context as relevant factors in assessing judicial impact.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- A Qualified HopeThe Indian Supreme Court and Progressive Social Change, pp. 184 - 211Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2019
References
Ahmad, Imtiaz. “Introduction.” In Caste and Social Stratification among Muslims in India, edited by Ahmad, Imtiaz, xvii. South Asia Books (Manohar, 1978).Google Scholar
Akhter, Andalib. “Muslim Dalits Demand Parity with Other Dalits.” The Milli Gazette. www.milligazette.com/Archives/15102002/1510200258.htm (accessed March 20, 2015).Google Scholar
Ali, Ejaz. “Anti-Islamic Elite Muslims Opposed to Reservations for the Oppressed.” Dalit Voice, January 16, 1996.Google Scholar
Ali, Ejaz. “Jihad.” Undated manuscript.Google Scholar
Ali, Ejaz. “Mandal’s Judgements & Dalit Muslim Reservation.” Undated manuscript.Google Scholar
Ali, Ejaz. “Mandal’s Judgements & Dalit Muslim Reservation.” N.d. An Interview with Ejaz Ali. twocirclesTV, 2011. www.youtube.com/watch?v=K53Zc6Otei8 (accessed September 1, 2018).Google Scholar
Ansari, Ali Anwar. “Bihar Ke Musalmanon Ki Rajniti Ke Rang Badalne Lage.” N.d.Google Scholar
Ansari, Ali Anwar. Masawaat Ki Jung - Pasemanzar: Bihar Ke Pasmaanda Musalman. Freedom Books, 2007.Google Scholar
Ansari, Khalid Anis. “Pluralism, Civil Society and Subaltern Counterpublics.” Plur. Work. Pap. Ser. Pap. No 92011 (2011), www.hivos.nl/knowledge/content/download/65367/541333/file/PWP%20no%209%20Pluralism,%20Civil%20Society%20and%20Subaltern%20Counterpublics%20online.pdf (accessed October 1, 2013).Google Scholar
Ansari, Khalid Anis. “Rethinking the Pasmanda Movement.” Economic & Political Weekly 8–10 (2009).Google Scholar
Bhat, M. Mohsin Alam. “Conflict, Integration and Constitutional Culture: Affirmative Action and Muslims in India.” JSD Dissertation, Yale Law School, 2017.Google Scholar
Bhat, M. Mohsin Alam. “Convention on Reservation in Education, New Delhi, 29 August, 2006 – Resolution.” Muslim India 267 (September 2005): 88, 85.Google Scholar
Bhat, M. Mohsin Alam. “Muslim Caste under Indian Law: Between Uniformity, Autonomy and Equality.” Quaderni Di Diritto e Politica Ecclesiastica 20, Special Issue (2017): 165.Google Scholar
De, Rohit. “Mumtaz Bibi’s Broken Heart: The Many Lives of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act.” The Indian Economic & Social History Review 46, no. 1 (2009): 105–130.Google Scholar
Deshpande, Satish. “Dalits in the Muslim and Christian Communities: A Status Report on Current Social Scientific Knowledge.” National Commission for Minorities, Government of India, January 17, 2008. http://ncm.nic.in/pdf/report%20dalit%20%20reservation.pdf.Google Scholar
Dhavan, Rajeev. “Divide, Sub-Divide, Rule, Editorial, the Pioneer, 9 March, 1996.” Extracted in Muslim India 161 (May 1996): 227.Google Scholar
Dhavan, Rajeev. “The Supreme Court as Problem Solver: The Mandal Controversy.” In The Politics of Backwardness - Reservation Policy in India, edited by Panandiker, V. A. Pai, 262. Centre for Policy Research, 1997.Google Scholar
Epp, Charles R. The Rights Revolution: Lawyers, Activists, and Supreme Courts in Comparative Perspective. 1st edition. University of Chicago Press, 1998.Google Scholar
Eskridge, William N. “Channeling: Identity-Based Social Movements and Public Law.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review 150, no. 1 (2001): 419–525.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Falahi, Mumtaz Alam. “Table Misra Report, Include Dalit Muslims in SCs: Muslim MPs, Intellectuals.” The Milli Gazette, July 18, 2009. http://twocircles.net/2009jul18/table_misra_report_include_dalit_muslims_scs_muslim_mps_intellectuals.html#.V-_E45N95E5.Google Scholar
Galanter, Marc. “Changing Legal Conceptions of Caste.” In Law and Society in Modern India, edited by Dhavan, Rajeev, Reprint, 141. Oxford University Press, 1993.Google Scholar
Galanter, Marc. Competing Equalities: Law and the Backward Classes in India. University of California Press, 1984.Google Scholar
Galanter, Marc. “The Long Half-Life of Reservations.” In India’s Living Constitution: Ideas, Practices, Controversies, edited by Hasan, Zoya, Sridharan, E., and Sudarshan, R., 306. Anthem Press, 2005.Google Scholar
Hasan, Zoya. Politics of Inclusion: Castes, Minorities, and Affirmative Action. Oxford University Press, 2011.Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch. Hidden Apartheid: Caste Discrimination against India’s “Untouchables.” 2007. www.hrw.org/report/2007/02/12/hidden-apartheid/caste-discrimination-against-indias-untouchables (accessed August 25, 2018).Google Scholar
Hunt, Scott A., Benford, Robert D., and Snow, David A.. “Identity Fields: Framing Processes and the Social Construction of Movement Identities.” In New Social Movements: From Ideology to Identity, edited by Laraña, Enrique, Johnston, Hank, and Gusfield, Joseph R., 185–208, Temple University Press, 1994.Google Scholar
Hunt, Scott A., Benford, Robert D., and Snow, David A.. “Inclusion of Muslims in SC List Harmful- Shahabuddin’s Reply to Ejaz Ali, 16 June, 1999.” Muslim India 199 (July 1999): 318.Google Scholar
Hunt, Scott A., Benford, Robert D., and Snow, David A.. Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, Supp. (3) SCC 217 (1992).Google Scholar
Kapczynski, Amy. “The Access to Knowledge Mobilization and the New Politics of Intellectual Property.” The Yale Law Journal (2008): 804–885.Google Scholar
Lohia, Rammanohar. “Towards the Destruction of Castes and Classes.” In The Caste System, Rammanohar Lohia, 79.Google Scholar
McCann, Michael W. “How Does Law Matter for Social Movements?” In How Does Law Matter 76, edited by Garth, B.G. and Sarat, A., 88, Northwestern University Press, 1998.Google Scholar
McCann, Michael W. “M. Ejaz Ali On Muslim Reservation (excerpted from the Dalit Voice).” Extracted from Muslim India 22 (October 1999): 472.Google Scholar
McCann, Michael W. Rights at Work: Pay Equity Reform and the Politics of Legal Mobilization. University of Chicago Press, 1994.Google Scholar
Melucci, Alberto. “Getting Involved: Identity and Mobilization in Social Movements.” International Social Movement Research 1, no. 4 (1988): 329–348.Google Scholar
Mertz, Elizabeth. “A New Social Constructionism for Sociolegal Studies,” Law & Society Review 28 (1994): 1243–1265.Google Scholar
Ministry of Minority Affairs. “Muslim and Christian Leaders Meet Home Minister on Reservation for Dalit Muslims and Christians.” The Milli Gazette, January 22, 2010. www.milligazette.com/dailyupdate/2010/20100122_002_Reservation_Dalit_Muslims_Christians.htm.Google Scholar
Ministry of Minority Affairs. “Muslim Groups Back SC Status for Muslim, Christian Dalits.” Rediff. www.rediff.com/news/report/muslim-groups-back-sc-status-for-muslim-christian-dalits/20120131.htm (accessed October 1, 2016).Google Scholar
Ministry of Minority Affairs. “Muslim ‘Pariahs’ Warn of Quitting Islam.” Times of India, Patna, July 19, 1994.Google Scholar
Ministry of Minority Affairs. “Report of the National Commission for Religious and Linguistic Minorities,” May 10, 2007. www.minorityaffairs.gov.in/sites/upload_files/moma/files/pdfs/volume-1.pdf.Google Scholar
Pedriana, Nicholas. “From Protective to Equal Treatment: Legal Framing Processes and Transformation of the Women’s Movement in the 1960s.” American Journal of Sociology 111, no. 6 (2006): 1718–1761.Google Scholar
Polletta, Francesca, and Jasper, James M.. “Collective Identity and Social Movements.” Annual Review of Sociology (2001): 283–305.Google Scholar
Prime Minister’s High Level Committee. “Rao, PV for “Dalit Muslim Quota?,” The Pioneer November 12, 1999.” Extracted in Muslim India 205 (January 2000): 24.Google Scholar
Prime Minister’s High Level Committee. “Resolution of the Muslim Convention for Reservation, February 2, 2009, Delhi; National Workshop of Muslim NGOs, New Delhi, December 22–24, 2006: Brief Report & Resolutions.” Muslim India 272 (February 2007): 20.Google Scholar
Prime Minister’s High Level Committee. “Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim Community in India: A Report.” Cabinet Secretariat, Government of India, November 17, 2006. www.minorityaffairs.gov.in/sites/upload_files/moma/files/pdfs/sachar_comm.pdf.Google Scholar
Rudolph, Lloyd I., and Rudolph, Susanne Hoeber. The Modernity of Tradition: Political Development in India. University of Chicago Press, 1984.Google Scholar
Scheingold, Stuart A. The Politics of Rights: Lawyers, Public Policy, and Political Change. 2nd edition. University of Michigan Press, 2004.Google Scholar
Schneider, Elizabeth M. “The Dialectic of Rights and Politics: Perspectives from the Women’s Movement.” New York University Law Review 61 (1986): 589.Google Scholar
Sikand, Yoginder. “Dalit Muslims.” www.outlookindia.com/article/Dalit-Muslims/216144 (accessed February 23, 2015)Google Scholar
Sikand, Yoginder. Islam, Caste, and Dalit-Muslim Relations in India. Global Media Publications, 2004.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Helena. Unleashing Rights Law, Meaning, and the Animal Rights Movement. University of Michigan Press, 1996.Google Scholar
Snow, David A., and Benford, Robert D.. “Master Frames and Cycles of Protest.” Frontiers in Social Movement Theory (1992): 133–155.Google Scholar
Snow, David A., Benford, Robert D., et al. “Ideology, Frame Resonance, and Participant Mobilization.” International Social Movement Research 1, no. 1 (1988): 197–217.Google Scholar
Snow, David A., Soule, Sarah A., and Kriesi, Hanspeter, eds. The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements. 1st edition. Wiley-Blackwell, 2007.Google Scholar
Snow, David A., Soule, Sarah A., and Kriesi, Hanspeter, “Social Justice Movement: National Conference, New Delhi 7 Oct., 98 Resolution.” Extracted in Muslim India 191 (November 1998): 510.Google Scholar
Tarrow, Sidney G. Power in Movement: Social Movements and Contentious Politics. 3rd edition. Cambridge University Press, 2011.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tarrow, Sidney G. The Untouchables: Subordination, Poverty and the State in Modern India. Cambridge University Press, 1998.Google Scholar
Yadav, Yogendra. “Reconfiguration in Indian Politics: State Assembly Elections, 1993–95.” Economic and Political Weekly 31 (1996): 95.Google Scholar
Yadav, Yogendra. “What Is Living and What Is Dead in Rammanohar Lohia?” Economic & Political Weekly 45, no. 40 (2010): 93.Google Scholar
- 1
- Cited by