Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-75dct Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-16T08:27:33.939Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

No Lessons Learned from the Holocaust? Assessing Risks of Genocide and Political Mass Murder since 1955

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 March 2003

Professor, Department of Political Science, U.S. Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21401 (


This article reports a test of a structural model of the antecedents of genocide and politicide (political mass murder). A case–control research design is used to test alternative specifications of a multivariate model that identifies preconditions of geno-/politicide. The universe of analysis consists of 126 instances of internal war and regime collapse that began between 1955 and 1997, as identified by the State Failure project. Geno-/politicides began during 35 of these episodes of state failure. The analytic question is which factors distinguish the 35 episodes that led to geno-/politicides from those that did not. The case–control method is used to estimate the effects of theoretically specified domestic and international risk factors measured one year prior to the onset of geno-/politicide. The optimal model includes six factors that jointly make it possible to distinguish with 74% accuracy between internal wars and regime collapses that do and those that do not lead to geno-/politicide. The conclusion uses the model to assess the risks of future episodes in 25 countries.This study was commissioned in 1998 by the Central Intelligence Agency's Directorate of Intelligence in response to President Clinton's policy initiative on genocide early warning and prevention. It was designed by the author and carried out using her data with other data and analytic techniques developed by the State Failure Task Force. Statistical analyses reported here were done by Michael Lustik and Alan N. Unger of Science Applications International Corporation (SAIC), McLean, Virginia. The author is senior consultant to the Task Force, which was established in 1994 in response to a request from senior U.S. policymakers to design and carry out a data-driven study of the correlates of state failure, defined to include revolutionary and ethnic wars, adverse or disruptive regime transitions, and genocides and politicides (for the latest report on Task Force research see Goldstone et al. 2002). The author acknowledges the advice of other Task Force consultants and analysts throughout the research process. The views expressed here are those of the author and do not represent the official views of the U.S. government, the U.S. intelligence community, or the Central Intelligence Agency.The author especially thanks Ted Robert Gurr for his critiquing early drafts and using the findings to construct the table that identifies high-risk countries and groups. His insistence about the importance of the study prompted me to revise the manuscript a number of times, despite my initial reluctance, given the years of work that had gone into its preparation. It was especially hard to condense this effort from its original 75 pages. The paper also benefited from a careful reading by Mark I. Lichbach of a previous report and from comments of anonymous reviewers for the American Political Science Review.

Research Article
© 2003 by the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)


Ball Patrick Paul Kubrick Spirer Herbert F. 1999 State Violence in Guatemala, 1960–1996: A Quantitative Reflection Washington, DC American Association for the Advancement of Science
Banks Arthur S. 1971 Cross-Polity Time-Series Data Cambridge, MA MIT Press
Beck Nathaniel J. Katz Jonathan N. Richard Tucker 1998 Taking Time Seriously: Time-Series-Cross Section Analysis with a Binary Dependent Variable American Journal of Political Science 42 4 1260-88Google Scholar
Breslow N. E. Day N. E. 1980 Statistical Methods in Cancer Research. Volume I: The Analysis of Case-Control Studies Lyon IARC Scientific Publications No. 32
Chalk Frank Kurt Jonassohn 1990 The History and Sociology of Genocide: Analyses and Case Studies New Haven, CT Yale University Press
Davenport Christian 1999 Human Rights and the Democratic Proposition Journal of Conflict Resolution 43 1 92 116Google Scholar
Des Forges Allison 1999 Leave None to the Tell the Story: Genocide in Rwanda New York Human Rights Watch
Esty Daniel C. Goldstone Jack A. Gurr Ted Robert Barbara Harff Marc Levy Dabelko Geoffrey D. Surko Pamela T. Unger Alan N. 1999 State Failure Task Force Report: Phase II Findings Environmental Change & Security Project Report 5 Summer 49 72Google Scholar
Fein Helen 1979 Accounting for Genocide: National Responses and Jewish Victimization during the Holocaust New York Free Press
Fein Helen 1984 Scenarios of Genocide: Models of Genocide and Critical Responses Toward the Understanding and Prevention of Genocide: Proceedings of the International Conference on the Holocaust and Genocide Israel W. Charny Boulder, CO Westview Press 3 31
Fein Helen 1993 Accounting for Genocide After 1945: Theories and Some Findings International Journal on Group Rights 1 79 106
Fein 1993 Genocide: A Sociological Perspective London and Newbury Park, CA Sage
Genocide Prevention Center. 2001 Aceh: Indonesia Report. Impending Clash May Result in Crimes against Humanity Alexandria, VA Improve the World International
Goldstone Jack A. 1991 Revolution and Rebellion in the Early Modern World Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press
Goldstone Jack A. 2002 The Case for Case Control: Substantive Issues in the Study of Rare and Calamitous Events University of California, Davis. Unpublished paper prepared for the State Failure Task Force
Goldstone Jack A. Gurr Ted Robert Barbara Harff Marc Levy Marshall Monty G. Robert Bates David Epstein Colin Kahl Mark Woodward Surko Pamela T. Unger Alan N. 2002 State Failure Task Force Report: Phase III Findings McLean, VA Science Applications International Corporation
Green D. M. Swets J. A. 1966 Signal Detection Theory and Psychophysics New York John Wiley and Sons
Gunaratna Rohan 1990 Sri Lanka: A Lost Revolution? The Inside Story of the JVP Kandy Sri Lanka Institute of Fundamental Studies
Gurr Ted Robert 1980 Handbook of Political Conflict: Theory and Research New York Free Press
Gurr Ted Robert. 1986 Persisting Patterns of Repression and Rebellion: Foundations for a General Theory of Political Coercion Persistent Patterns and Emergent Structures in a Waning Century Margaret. P. Karns New York Praeger 149-68
Gurr Ted Robert. 2000 Peoples versus States: Minorities at Risk in the New Century Washington, DC U.S. Institute of Peace Press
Gurr Ted Robert Marshall Monty G. Deepa Khosla 2001 Peace and Conflict 2001: A Global Survey of Armed Conflicts, Self-Determination Movements, and Democracy College Park, MD Center for International Development and Conflict Management
Harff Barbara 1987 The Etiology of Genocide The Age of Genocide Michael N. Dobkowski Isador Wallimann Westport, CT Greenwood Press 41 59
Harff Barbara 1992 “Recognizing Genocides and Politicides.” InGenocide Watch Helen Fein New Haven, CT Yale University Press 27 41
Harff Barbara 2001 Could Humanitarian Crises Have Been Anticipated in Burundi, Rwanda, and Zaire? A Comparative Study of Anticipatory Indicators Journeys through Conflict: Narratives and Lessons Hayward Alker Ted Robert Gurr Kumar Rupesinghe Lanham, MD Rowman & Littlefield 81 102
Harff Barbara Gurr Ted Robert 1998 Systematic Early Warning of Humanitarian Emergencies Journal of Peace Research 35 551-79
Harrell F. E. Jr Lee K. L. Califf R. M. Pryor D. B. Rosati R. A. 1984 Regression Modeling Strategies for Improved Prognostic Prediction. Statistics in Medicine 3 2 143-52Google Scholar
Heidenreich John G. 2001 How to Prevent Genocide: A Guide for Policymakers, Scholars, and the Concerned Citizen Westport, CT Praeger
Hegre Havard Tanja Ellingsen Scott Gates Gleditsch Nils Petter 2001 Toward a Democratic Civil Peace? Democracy, Political Change and Civil War, 1916–1992 American Political Science Review 95 March 33 48Google Scholar
Henderson Conway 1991 Conditions Affecting the Use of Political Repression Journal of Conflict Resolution 35 120-42
Horowitz Donald L. 1985 Ethnic Groups in Conflict Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press
Human Rights Watch. 1991. “Sri Lanka.” In World Report 1990. New York: Human Rights Watch.
Jaggers Keith Gurr Ted Robert 1995 Tracking Democracy's Third Wave with the Polity III Data Journal of Peace Research 32 November 469-82Google Scholar
Kasozi A. B. K. 1994 The Social Origins of Violence in Uganda, 1964–1985 Montreal McGill–Queen's University Press
King Gary Langche Zeng 2001 Improving Forecasts of State Failure. World Politics 53 July 623-58Google Scholar
King Gary 2001 Logistic Regression in Rare Events Data. Political Analysis 9 Spring 137-63Google Scholar
Krain Matthew 1997 State-Sponsored Mass Murder: The Onset and Severity of Genocides and Politicides Journal of Conflict Resolution 41 331-60
Kuper Leo 1977 The Pity of It All: Polarization of Racial and Ethnic Relations Minneapolis University of Minnesota Press
Kuper Leo 1981 Genocide: Its Political Use in the Twentieth Century New Haven, CT Yale University Press
Kuper Leo 1985 The Prevention of Genocide New Haven, CT Yale University Press
Le Blanc Lawrence J. 1988 The United Nations Convention and Political Groups: Should the United States Propose an Amendment? Yale Journal of International Law 13 268-94
Lemkin Raphael 1944 Axis Rule in Occupied Europe Washington, DC Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Lichbach Mark I. 1987 Deterrence or Escalation? The Puzzle of Aggregate Studies of Repression and Dissent Journal of Conflict Resolution 31 266-97
Lichbach Mark I. 1998 Contending Theories of Contentious Politics and the Structure-Action Problem of Social Order Annual Review of Political Science 1 401-24
Licklider Roy 1995 The Consequences of Negotiated Settlements in Civil Wars, 1945–1993 American Political Science Review 89 681-90
Lopez George A. 1986 National Security Ideology as an Impetus to State Violence and State Terror Government Violence and Repression: An Agenda for Research George A. Lopez Michael Stohl Westport, CT Greenwood Press 73 95
Makiya Kanan 1992 The Anfal: Uncovering an Iraqi Campaign to Exterminate the Kurds Harper's Magazine 284 No. 1704 May 53 61Google Scholar
Mattas David 1992 Remembering the Holocaust Genocide Watch Helen Fein New Haven, CT Yale University Press
Melson Robert 1992 Revolution and Genocide Chicago University of Chicago Press
Minority Rights Group. 1984. Uganda and Sudan—North and South. Report No. 66. London: Minority Rights Group
Munck Gerardo L. Jay Verkuilen 2002 Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy: Evaluating Alternative Indices Comparative Political Studies 35 5 34
Powers Samantha 2002 A Problem from Hell: American and the Age of Genocide New York Basic Books
Prunier Gerard 1995 The Rwanda Crisis: History of a Genocide New York Columbia University Press
Quigley T. 1999 Guatemala: Never Again Report of the Guatemalan Roman Catholic Church's Inter-Diocesan Recuperation of the Historical Memory Project (REMHI) Maryknoll, NY Orbis Books
Rabushka Alvin Shepsle Kenneth A. 1972 Politics in Plural Societies: A Theory of Democratic Instability Columbus, OH Merrill
Riemer Neil 2000 Protection Against Genocide: Mission Impossible? Westport, CT Praeger
Rummel Rudolph J. 1995 Democracy, Power, Genocide, and Mass Murder Journal of Conflict Resolution 39 3 26
Sambanis Nicholas 2001 Do Ethnic and Nonethnic Civil Wars Have the Same Causes? A Theoretical and Empirical Inquiry (Part I) Journal of Conflict Resolution 45 3 259-82Google Scholar
Schlesselman J. J. 1982 Case-Control Studies: Design, Conduct, Analysis New York Oxford University Press
Schmeidl Suzanne 1997 Exploring the Causes of Forced Migration: A Pooled Analysis, 1971–1990. Social Science Quarterly 78 284 308
Tilly Charles 1978 From Mobilization to Revolution Reading, MA Addison–Wesley
Totten Samuel Steven Jacobs 2002 Pioneers of Genocide Studies: Confronting Mass Death in the Century of Genocide Westport, CT Greenwood Press
Walker Scott Poe Steven C. 2002 Does Cultural Diversity Affect Countries' Respect for Human Rights? Human Rights Quarterly 24 237-63