Skip to main content

Should I Stay or Should I Go? Explaining Variation in Western Jihadists' Choice between Domestic and Foreign Fighting


This article studies variation in conflict theater choice by Western jihadists in an effort to understand their motivations. Some militants attack at home, whereas others join insurgencies abroad, but few scholars have asked why they make these different choices. Using open-source data, I estimate recruit supply for each theater, foreign fighter return rates, and returnee impact on domestic terrorist activity. The tentative data indicate that jihadists prefer foreign fighting, but a minority attacks at home after being radicalized, most often through foreign fighting or contact with a veteran. Most foreign fighters do not return for domestic operations, but those who do return are more effective operatives than nonveterans. The findings have implications for our understanding of the motivations of jihadists, for assessments of the terrorist threat posed by foreign fighters, and for counterterrorism policy.

Corresponding author
Thomas Hegghammer is Senior Research Fellow, Norwegian Defence Research Establishment (FFI), P.O. Box 25, 2027 Kjeller, Norway (
Hide All
Abou El Fadl Khaled. 2001. Rebellion and Violence in Islamic Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Aboul-Enein Youssef H., and Zuhur Sherifa. 2004. Islamic Rulings on Warfare. Strategic Studies Institute. Carlisle, PA: United States Army War College. (Accessed August 14, 2012)
Al-Amriiki Abu Mansoor. 2012. “The Story of an American Jihaadi—Part One.” (Accessed August 14, 2012.
Al-Malahim . 2010. “First and Exclusive Video Interview with Sheikh Anwar Al Awlaki.” al-Malahim Media Productions, May 23. (Accessed November 12, 2010).
Al-Tartusi Abu Basir. 2005. “bayan hawla al-tafjirat allati hasalat fi madinat lundun” [A Statement About the Bombings That Happened in London]. (Accessed April 29. 2011).
Associated Press. 2012. “Informant: NYPD Paid Me to ‘Bait’ Muslims,” October 23.
Bakke Kristin. 2011. “Acceptance and Resistance to Foreign Ideas: Transnational Insurgents’ Impact on the Chechen Separatists.” Unpublished manuscript.
Bakker Edwin. 2011. “Characteristics of Jihadi Terrorists in Europe (2001–2009).” In Jihadi Terrorism and the Radicalisation Challenge: European and American Experiences, ed. Coolsaet R.. 2nd ed. Farnham: Ashgate, 131144.
Bakker Edwin. 2006, December. Jihadi Terrorists in Europe. Clingendael Security Paper no. 2. Haag: Netherlands Institute of International Relations.
Bartlett Jamie, Birdwell Jonathan, and King Michael. 2010. The Edge of Violence. London: Demos.
Benjamin Daniel, and Simon Steven. 2002. The Age of Sacred Terror. New York: Random House.
Berger John M. 2011. “Letter from British Jihadi Describes Contacts with Anwar al-Awlaki.” (Accessed August 13, 2012).
Beutel Alejandro J. 2011, April. Data on Post-9/11 Terrorism in the United States. Washington, DC: Muslim Public Affairs Council.
Bjelopera Jerome P., and Randol Mark A.. 2010. American Jihadist Terrorism: Combating a Complex Threat. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.
Bonner Michael. 2006. Jihad in Islamic History: Doctrines and Practice. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Brachman Jarret. 2011. “‘Thou Art Responsible Only for Thyself’—the Cast.” (Accessed August 15, 2012).
Brooks Risa. 2011. “Muslim ‘Homegrown’ Terrorism in the United States: How Serious Is the Threat?International Security 36 (2): 747.
CHRGJ. 2011. Targeted and Entrapped: Manufacturing the “Homegrown Threat” in the United States. New York: New York University School of Law, Center for Human Rights and Global Justice.
Ciluffo Frank J., Ranstorp Magnus, and Cozzens Jeffrey B.. 2010. Foreign Fighters: Trends, Trajectories and Conflict Zones. Washington, DC: George Washington University Homeland Security Policy Institute.
Clarke Michael, and Soria Valentina. 2010. “Terrorism: The New Wave.” RUSI Journal 155 (4): 2431.
Coates Sam, and Page Jeremy. 2008. Pakistan ‘Linked to 75% of All UK Terror Plots,’ Warns Gordon Brown.” The Times, December 15.
Colgan Jeff, and Hegghammer Thomas. 2011. “Islamic Foreign Fighters: Concepts and Data.” Paper presented at the International Studies Association Annual Convention, Montreal.
Collins Aukai. 2002. My Jihad. Guilford, CT: Lyons Press.
Cook David. 2005. Understanding Jihad. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Cooley John K. 1973. Green March, Black September: The Story of the Palestinian Arabs. London: Frank Cass.
Crawford David. 2004. “Home Grown, New Terror Threat in EU: Extremists with Passports.” Wall Street Journal, December 27.
Cruickshank Paul. 2010. The Militant Pipeline: Between the Afghanistan-Pakistan Border Region and the West. Counterterrorism Strategy Initiative Policy Paper. Washington, DC: New America Foundation.
Dahl Erik J. 2011. “The Plots that Failed: Intelligence Lessons Learned from Unsuccessful Terrorist Attacks Against the United States.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 34 (8): 621–48.
Dalgaard-Nielsen Anja. 2010. “Violent Radicalization in Europe: What We Know and What We Do Not Know.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 33 (9): 797814.
Egerton Frazer. 2011. Jihad in the West: The Rise of Militant Salafism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Egerton Frazer, and Wilner Alexandre. 2009. “Militant Jihadism in Canada: Prosecuting the War of Ideas.” (Accessed August 14, 2012)
El Tiempo. 2011. “Con alias ‘Camilo,’ son 25 los extranjeros en las Farc” [With Camilo Are 25 Foreigners in FARC], February 11.
Farwell James P. 2010. “Jihadi Video in the ‘War of Ideas.’” Survival 52 (6): 127–50.
Felter Joseph, and Fishman Brian. 2007. Al Qa'ida's Foreign Fighters in Iraq: A First Look at the Sinjar Records. West Point, NY: Combating Terrorism Center.
Finsnes Cecilie. 2010. What Is Audio-Visual Jihadi Propaganda? An Overview of the Content of FFI's Jihadi Video Database. Kjeller: FFI.
Firestone Reuven. 1999. Jihad: The Origin of Holy War in Islam. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gartenstein-Ross Daveed, and Grossman Laura. 2009. Homegrown Terrorists in the U.S. and U.K. Washington, DC: Foundation for the Defense of Democracies.
Gerges Fawaz. 2006. The Far Enemy: Why Jihad Went Global. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Greenberg Karen, ed. 2010. Terrorist Trial Report Card: September 11, 2001—September 11–2010. New York: Center on Law and Security, New York University School of Law.
Greenberg Karen. 2011. “How Terrorist ‘Entrapment’ Ensnares Us All.” Guardian, December 12.
Guendouz Omar. 2002. Les soldats perdus de l'islam: Les réseaux francais de Ben Laden. Paris: Editions Ramsay.
Hafez Mohammed M. 2007. Suicide Bombers in Iraq. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace.
Harris Paul. 2012. “The ex-FBI Informant with a Change of Heart: ‘There Is No Real Hunt. It's Fixed.’” Guardian, March 20.
Hegghammer Thomas. 2010. Jihad in Saudi Arabia: Violence and Pan-Islamism Since 1979. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hegghammer Thomas. 2011. “The Rise of Muslim Foreign Fighters: Islam and the Globalization of Jihad.” International Security 35 (3): 5394.
Hemmingsen Ann-Sophie. 2010. “The Attractions of Jihadism: An Identity Approach to Three Danish Terrorism Cases and the Gallery of Characters Around Them.” Ph.D. diss. University of Copenhagen.
Ibrahim Yahya. 2010. “Tips for Our Brothers in the United States of America.” Inspire (2): 5557.
Jackson Sherman A. 2001. “Domestic Terrorism in the Islamic Legal Tradition.” Muslim World 91 (3–4): 283300.
Jenkins Brian. 2010. Would-Be Warriors: Incidents of Jihadist Terrorist Radicalization in the United States Since September 11, 2001. RAND Occasional Paper. Washington, DC: RAND.
Kalyvas Stathis N. 2003. “The Ontology of ‘Political Violence’: Action and Identity in Civil Wars.” Perspectives on Politics 1 (3): 475–94.
Kaplan David. 2002. “Made in the U.S.A.” U.S. News and World Report, June 2.
Karmon Ely. 2005. Coalitions Between Terrorist Organizations: Revolutionaries, Nationalists and Islamists. Leiden: Brill.
Kelsay John. 2007. Arguing the Just War in Islam. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Khadduri Majid. 1966. War and Peace in the Law of Islam. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Krueger Alan 2007. “The National Origins of Foreign Fighters in Iraq.” Paper presented at the American Economic Association Annual Meeting, Chicago.
Kühle Lene, and Lindekilde Lasse. 2010. Radicalization Among Young Muslims in Aarhus. Aarhus: Centre for Studies in Islamism and Radicalization, Aarhus University.
Kurzman Charles. 2011. Muslim-American Terrorism Since 9/11: An Accounting. Durham, NC: Triangle Center on Terrorism and Homeland Security.
Kurzman Charles, Schanzer David, and Moosa Ebrahim. 2011. “Muslim American Terrorism Since 9/11: Why So Rare?The Muslim World 101 (3): 464–83.
Lawrence Bruce. 2005. Messages to the World: The Statements of Osama bin Laden. London: Verso.
Lia Brynjar. 2007. Architect of Global Jihad: The Life of Al-Qaeda Strategist Abu Mus'ab al-Suri. London: Hurst.
Lia Brynjar. 2008. “Doctrines for Jihadi Terrorist Training.” Terrorism and Political Violence 20 (4): 518–42.
Malet David. 2009. “Foreign Fighters: Transnational Identity in Civil Conflicts.” PhD diss. George Washington University.
Malet David. 2010. “Why Foreign Fighters? Historical Perspectives and Solutions.” Orbis 54 (1): 97114.
March Andrew. 2011. “Anwar Al-’Awlaqi Against the Islamic Legal Tradition.” Yale Law School Research Paper 217.
Mendelsohn Barak. 2011. “Foreign Fighters—Recent Trends.” Orbis 55 (2): 189202.
Mintz John. 2002. “For U.S., American ‘Holy Warriors’ Hard to Track.” Washington Post, July 16.
Misri Ahmad ibn Salim. 2005. fatawa al-‘ulama’ al-kibar fi'l-irhab wa'l-tadmir: wa-dawabit al-jihad wa'l-takfir wa-mu'amalat al-kuffar [Fatwas of the Great Scholars on Terrorism and Destruction: And the Principles of Jihad, Takfir and Dealing with Infidels]. Riyadh: Dar al-Kayan.
Moghadam Assaf. 2008. The Globalization of Martyrdom: Al Qaeda, Salafi Jihad, and the Diffusion of Suicide Attacks. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Moghadam Assaf, and Fishman Brian. 2011. Fault Lines in Global Jihad: Organizational, Strategic, and Ideological Fissures. London: Routledge.
Morabia Alfred. 1993. Le Ğihad dans l'Islam médiéval: Le ‘combat sacré’ des origines au XIIeme siecle. Paris: Albin Michel.
Mueller John, and Stewart Mark G.. 2012. “The Terrorism Delusion: America's Overwrought Response to 9/11.” International Security 37 (1): 81110.
Mullins Sam. 2011. “Islamist Terrorism and Australia: An Empirical Examination of the ‘Home-Grown’ Threat.” Terrorism and Political Violence 23 (2): 254–85.
Munro Ian. 2010. “Terrorist Cell Sought Fatwa, Court Hears.” Sydney Morning Herald, September 14.
Nasiri Omar. 2006. Inside the Jihad: My Life with al-Qaeda. Cambridge, MA: Perseus.
Nelson Rick “Ozzie,” and Bodurian Ben. 2010. A Growing Terrorist Threat? Assessing ‘Homegrown’ Extremism in the United States. Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and International Studies.
Nesser Petter. 2008a. “Chronology of Jihadism in Western Europe 1994–2007: Planned, Prepared, and Executed Terrorist Attacks.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 31 (10): 924–46.
Nesser Petter. 2008b. “How Did Europe's Global Jihadis Obtain Training for Their Militant Causes?Terrorism and Political Violence 20 (2): 234–56.
Nesser Petter. 2010. “Chronology of Jihadism in Western Europe Update 2008–2010.” (Accessed October 5, 2011).
Nesser Petter. 2011a. “Ideologies of Jihad in Europe.” Terrorism and Political Violence 23 (2): 173200.
Nesser Petter. 2011b. “Jihad in Europe: Patterns in Islamist Terrorist Cell Formation and Behaviour, 1995–2010.” Ph.D. diss. University of Oslo.
Neumann Peter, and Rogers Brooke. 2007. Recruitment and Mobilisation for the Islamist Militant Movement in Europe. London: International Centre for the Study of Radicalisation and Political Violence, King's College London.
New America Foundation. 2011. “Homegrown Terrorism Cases, 2001–2011.” (Accessed October 5, 2011).
New York Daily News. 2010 “Najibullah Zazi reveals chilling details on Al Qaeda training and terrorist plot to blow up subways”. February 23.
Noonan Michael P., ed. 2010. Foreign Fighters, Sovereignty, and Counter-Terrorism: Selected Essays. Washington, DC: Foreign Policy Research Institute.
Obaid Nawaf, and Cordesman Anthony. 2005. Saudi Militants in Iraq: Assessment and Kingdom's Response. Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and International Studies.
Paz Reuven. 2005a. “Arab Volunteers Killed in Iraq: An Analysis.” PRISM Papers 3 (1).
Paz Reuven. 2005b. “Islamic legitimacy for the London Bombings.” PRISM Papers 3 (4).
Peters Rudolph. 1996. Jihad in Classical and Modern Islam. Princeton, NJ: Marcus Wiener.
Pew Research Center. 2010. “Muslim Publics Divided on Hamas and Hezbollah.”–2010.pdf. (Accessed August 14, 2012).
Reinares Fernando. 2010. “The Madrid Bombings and Global Jihadism.” Survival 52 (2): 83104.
Reuters . 2011. “Stockholm Bomber Was Trained in Iraq, Says Official,” January 7.
Sageman Marc. 2004. Understanding Terror Networks. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Sageman Marc. 2010. “Confronting al-Qaeda: Understanding the Threat in Afghanistan.” Perspectives on Terrorism 3 (4): 425.
Salem Arab, Reid Edna, and Chen Hsinchun. 2008. “Multimedia Content Coding and Analysis: Unraveling the Content of Jihadi Extremist Groups’ Videos.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 31 (7): 605–26.
Schanzer David, Kurzman Charles, and Moosa Ebrahim, 2010. Anti-Terror Lessons of Muslim-Americans. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
Schwartz David Aaron. 1991. “International Terrorism and Islamic Law.” Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 29 (3): 629–52.
Sifaoui Mohamed. 2003. Inside al-Qaeda: How I Infiltrated the World's Deadliest Terrorist Organization. London: Granta Books.
Silber Mitchell, and Bhatt Arvin. 2007. Radicalization in the West: The Homegrown Threat. New York: New York City Police Department.
Sivan Emmanuel. 1998. “The Holy War Tradition in Islam.” Orbis 42 (2): 171–94.
Sulzberger A. G., and Rashbaum William K.. 2010. “Guilty Plea Made in Plot to Bomb New York Subway”: New York Times, February 22.
Taarnby Michael. 2005. Recruitment of Islamist Terrorists in Europe: Trends and Perspectives. Copenhagen: Danish Ministry of Justice.
Tumelty Paul. 2006. “The Rise and Fall of Foreign Fighters in Chechnya.” Jamestown Terrorism Monitor 4 (2).
U.S. v Ahmed. 2010. “Indictment.” District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.
U.S. v Boyd et al. 2009. “Indictment.” District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina.
U.S. v. Mehanna and Abousamra. 2009. “Superseding Indictment.” District Court for the District of Massachusetts.
Venhaus John M. 2010. “Why Youth Join Al Qaeda.” United States Institute for Peace Special Report 236.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 78
Total number of PDF views: 777 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 2770 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 16th January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.