Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Peer review: A philosophically faulty concept which is proving disastrous for science

  • David F. Horrobin (a1)
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

P. H. Abelson (1979) Problems of science faculties (editorial). Science 204:133. [CM]

American Psychological Association (1980) Summary report of journal operations for 1979. American Psychologist 35:575. [taDPP]

J. S. Armstrong (1980b) Unintelligible management research and academic prestige. Interfaces 10:8086. [JSA]

J. J. Bartko (1966) The intraclass correlation coefficient as a measure of reliability. Psychological Reports 19:311. [GJW]

Y. Brackbill & F. Korton (1970) Journal reviewing practices: Authors' and APA members' suggestions for revision. American Psychologist 25:937–40. [taDPP]

W. J. Broad (1980a) Imbroglio at Yale. 1. Emergence of a fraud. Science 210:38–11. [DdB]

W. J. Broad (1981b) Fraud and the structure of science. Science 212:137–41. [DdB, CM]

W. J. Broad (1981c) The publishing game: Getting more for less. Science 211:1137–39. [DdB]

U. Bronfenbrenner (1977) Toward an experimental ecology of human development. American Psychologist 32:513–31. [taDPP]

D. E. Chubin (1980) Competence is not enough. Contemporary Sociology 9:204–7. [DEC, CM]

S. Cole ; J. R. Cole & G. A. Simon (1981) Chance and consensus in peer review. Science 214:881–86. [Ed., rDPP]

S. Cole ; L. Rubin & J. R. Cole (1977) Peer review and the support of science. Scientific American 237:34–11. [RTL, CM]

W. M. Cox & V. Catt (1977) Productivity ratings of graduate programs in psychology based on publication in the journals of the American Psychological Association. American Psychologist 32:793813. [taDPP]

R. Crandall (1978b) The relationship between quantity and quality of publications. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 4:379–80. [RC]

J. M. Davidson & R. J. Davidson , eds. (1980) The psychobiology of consciousness. New York: Plenum. [MJM]

W. D. Garvey & B. C. Griffith (1964) Scientific information exchange in psychology. Science 146:1655–59. [BCG]

W. D. Garvey & B. C. Griffith (1971) Scientific communication: Its role in the conduct of research and creation of knowledge. American Psychologist 26:349–62. [DdB, BCG, taDPP]

W. Garvey ; N. Lin & C. Nelson (1970) Communication in the physical and social sciences. Science 170:1166–73. [BCG]

J. C. Gibbs (1979) The meaning of ecologically oriented inquiry in contemporary psychology. American Psychologist 34:127–40. [taDPP]

W. O. Hagstrom (1974) Competition in science. American Sociological Review 39:118. [CM]

S. Harnad (1979) Creative disagreement. Sciences 19:1820. [DVC, Ed., WMH, taDPP]

R. G. Hawkins ; L. S. Ritter & I. Walter (1973) What economists think of their journals. Journal of Political Economy 81:1017–32. [JSA]

D. F. Horrobin (1974) Referees and research administrators: Barriers to scientific research? British Medical Journal 2:216–18. [CM]

J. Hall (1979) Author review of reviewers. American Psychologist 34:798. [taDPP, GJW]

C. Hendrick (1976) Editorial comment. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2:207–8. [GJW]

C. Hendrick (1977) Editorial comment. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 3:12. [taDPP]

R. J. Herrnstein (1977) Doing what comes naturally: A reply to Professor Skinner. American Psychologist 32:1013–16. [taDPP]

C. Holden (1979) Ethics and social science research. Science 206:357–340. [rDPP]

C. Holden (1980) Not what you know, but where you're from. Science 209:1097. [SP]

A. C. Leopold (1978) The act of creation: Creative processes in science. BioScience 28:436–40. [CM]

L. S. Lewis (1972) Academic freedom cases and their disposition. Change 4:8, 77. [CM]

R. B. McCall (1977) Challenges to a science of developmental psychology. Child Development 48:333–44. [taDPP]

F. J. McGuigan (1968) Experimental psychology: A methodological approach. 2d ed.Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall. [BM]

P. McReynolds (1971) Reliability of ratings of research papers. American Psychologist 26:400–101. [DP, taDPP]

C. Manwell & C. M. A. Baker (1979) The double helix: Science and myth in the act of creation. BioScience 29:742–46. [CM]

I. I. Mitroff & D. E. Chubin (1979) Peer review at NSF: A dialectical policy analysis. Social Studies of Science 9:199232. [DEC, CM]

J. R. Ravetz (1981) Avoiding fraud (correspondence). Nature 291:7. [CM]

A. Rosenblatt & S. A. Kirk (1980) Recognition of authors in blind review of manuscripts. Journal of Social Service Research 3:383–94. [tarDPP]

J. A. Rowney & T. J. Zenisek (1980) Manuscript characteristics influencing reviewers' decisions. Canadian Psychology 21:1721. [DP]

J. P. Rushton & H. L. Roediger (1978) An evaluation of 80 psychology journals based on the Science Citation Index. American Psychologist 33:520–23. [taDPP]

T. Saracevic (1975) Relevance: A review and framework for thinking on the notion in information science. Journal of the American Society for Information Science 26:321–13. [BCG]

S. Scarr & B. L. R. Weber (1978) The reliability of reviews for the American Psychologist. American Psychologist 33:935. [tarDPP, GJW, JCW]

J. J. Siegfried (1970) A first lesson in econometrics. Jottrnal of Political Economy 78:1378–79. [JSA]

M. J. White & K. G. White (1977) Citation analysis of psychology journals. American Psychologist 32:301–5. [tarDPP, MJW]

L. Wolin (1962) Responsibility for raw data. American Psychologist 17:657–58. [JSA]

W. Yoels (1974) The structure of scientific fields and the allocation of editorship on scientific journals: Some observations on the politics of knowledge. Sociological Quarterly 15:264–76. [JMB]

D. S. Zinberg (1976) Education through science: The early stages of career development in chemistry. Social Studies of Science 6:215–46. [CM]

H. Zuckerman (1970) Stratification in American science. Sociological Inquiry 40:235–57. [taDPP]

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *