Hostname: page-component-66d9dcfd78-xr9cd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-08-07T10:46:39.634Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

In Crisis or Decline? Selecting Women to Lead Provincial Parties in Government

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 February 2018

Melanee Thomas
Melanee Thomas*
Affiliation:
University of Calgary
*
Department of Political Science, University of Calgary, 2500 University Drive NW, Calgary, AB T2N 1N4, email: thomasm@ucalgary.ca
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The majority of Canada's women premiers were selected to that office while their parties held government. This is uncommon, both in the comparative literature and among premiers who are men. What explains this gendered selection pattern to Canada's provincial premiers’ offices? This paper explores the most common explanation found in the comparative literature for women's emergence as leaders of electorally competitive parties and as chief political executives: women are more likely to be selected when that party is in crisis or decline. Using the population of women provincial premiers in Canada as case studies, evidence suggests three of eight women premiers were selected to lead parties in government that were in crisis or decline; a fourth was selected to lead a small, left-leaning party as predicted by the literature. However, for half of the women premiers, evidence of their party's decline is partial or inconclusive. As a result of this exploration, more research is required to draw generalizations about the gendered opportunity structures that shape how women enter (and exit) the premier's office in Canada.

Résumé

La majorité des femmes premières ministres de provinces canadiennes ont été choisies pour occuper ce poste alors que leur parti politique était au pouvoir. Ceci est inhabituel, aussi bien dans la littérature comparée que parmi les homologues masculins. Comment s'explique le schéma sexospécifique présidant au choix de la fonction de premier ministre provincial? Cet article examine l'explication la plus courante qui ressort de la littérature comparée sur l’émergence des femmes leaders des partis compétitifs et chefs de l'exécutif politique : les femmes sont plus susceptibles d’être choisies lorsque le parti traverse une crise ou est en recul. Les données issues des études de cas portant sur la population des femmes premières ministres des provinces canadiennes suggèrent que trois femmes premières ministres sur huit ont été choisies pour diriger des partis dans des gouvernements en crise ou en déclin; une quatrième a été sélectionnée pour diriger un petit parti de gauche selon les prédictions de la littérature à l’étude. Toutefois, en ce qui concerne la moitié d'entre elles, les données attestant d'un recul du parti d'appartenance sont partielles ou peu probantes. À la suite de cet examen, une recherche plus approfondie s'impose avant de pouvoir tirer des généralisations sur les structures des possibilités sexospécifiques qui déterminent le cadre dans lequel les femmes accèdent au poste de première ministre au Canada (ou le quittent).

Information

Type
Research Article/Étude originale
Information
Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique , Volume 51 , Issue 2 , June 2018 , pp. 379 - 403
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Political Science Association (l'Association canadienne de science politique) and/et la Société québécoise de science politique 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

Footnotes

I would like to thank David Stewart, Amanda Bittner, David McGrane, Graham White, and the anonymous reviewers for comments on a previous draft of this paper. My thanks, too, to John Santos for his research assistance.

*

This article was submitted prior to the author's transition to the English-language editorial team of the Canadian Journal of Political Science. To maintain objectivity, the outgoing English-language editor maintained responsibility for the submission post transition, and the new editorial team blinded from the review process.

References

2006 Electoral Districts Boundaries Commission. 2014. “Reports.” (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Bashevkin, Sylvia. 1993. Toeing the Lines: Women and Party Politics in English Canada. Toronto: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Bashevkin, Sylvia. 2009. Women, Power, Politics: The Hidden Story of Canada's Unfinished Democracy. Toronto: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Beckwith, Karen. 2015. “Before Prime Minister: Margaret Thatcher, Angela Merkel, and Gendered Party Leadership Contests.” Politics & Gender 11 (December): 718–45.10.1017/S1743923X15000409Google Scholar
Bodet, Marc André. 2013. “Strongholds and Battlegrounds: Measuring Party Support Stability in Canada.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 46 (3): 575–96.10.1017/S000842391300067XGoogle Scholar
Bruckmüller, Susanne and Branscombe, Nyla E.. 2010. “The Glass Cliff: When and Why Women Are Selected as Leaders in Crisis Contexts.” British Journal of Social Psychology 49: 433–451.10.1348/014466609X466594Google Scholar
CBC Digital Archives. 2014. “B.C. Elections: Bill Vander Zalm resigns.” (April 1, 2014).Google Scholar
CBC News. 2014. “Calgary MLA Len Webber quits Tory caucus to protest premier.” (April 1 2014).Google Scholar
CBC News. 2007. “Marois officially enters PQ leadership race.” www.cbc.ca/news/canada/marois-officially-enters-pq-leadership-race-1.691297 (March 29, 2014).Google Scholar
Childs, Sarah and Krook, Mona Lena. 2008. “Critical Mass Theory and Women's Political Representation.” Political Studies 56 (3): 725–36.Google Scholar
Coletto, David, Jansen, Harold J. and Young, Lisa. 2011. “Stratarchical Party Organization and Party Finance in Canada.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 44 (1): 111–36.10.1017/S0008423910001034Google Scholar
Courtney, John C. 1995. Do Conventions Matter? Choosing National Party Leaders in Canada. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.Google Scholar
Cross, William. 2004. Political Parties (Canadian Democratic Audit). Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
Cross, William, and Blais, André. 2012. Politics at the Centre: The Selection and Removal of Party Leaders in Anglo Parliamentary Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Election Almanac. 2017a. “Historic Alberta Election Polls.” http://www.electionalmanac.com/ea/alberta-election-polls/ (Jan. 10, 2017).Google Scholar
Election Almanac. 2017b. “Historic British Columbia Election Polls.” http://www.electionalmanac.com/ea/british-columbia-election-polls/ (Jan. 10, 2017).Google Scholar
Election Almanac. 2017c. “Historic Nfld. & Labrador Election Polls.” http://www.electionalmanac.com/ea/newfoundland-labrador-election-polls/ (Jan. 10, 2017).Google Scholar
Election Almanac. 2017d “Historic Ontario Election Polls.” http://www.electionalmanac.com/ea/ontario-election-polls/ (Jan. 10, 2017).Google Scholar
Elections Alberta. 2014. “Financial Disclosure, Financial Period–Annual.” http://efpublic.elections.ab.ca/efEvents.cfm?MID=FE_A (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Elections BC. 2014a. “Financial Reports and Political Contributions System.” http://contributions.electionsbc.gov.bc.ca/pcs/ (April 1, 2014).Google Scholar
Elections BC. 2014b. “Provincial General Elections—Results.” http://www.elections.bc.ca/index.php/resource-centre/reports/#ge (April 1, 2014).Google Scholar
Elections BC. 2014c. “Electoral Boundaries Commissions Reports.” http://www.elections.bc.ca/index.php/maps/electoral-boundaries-commission-reports/ (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Elections Newfoundland and Labrador. 2015. “Political Finance Reports: Income and Expenditure Statements.” http://www.elections.gov.nl.ca/elections/PoliticalFinanceReports/index.asp (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Elections Ontario. 2016. “Yearly Financial Statements.” (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Elections Prince Edward Island. 2011. “A Brief History of Electoral Reform on Prince Edward Island.” http://www.electionspei.ca/index.php?number=1055620&lang=E (Nov. 8, 2017).Google Scholar
Fox, Richard L. and Oxley, Zoe M.. 2003. “Gender Stereotyping in State Executive Elections: Candidate Selection and Success.” Journal of Politics 65 (3): 833–50.Google Scholar
Franks, C.E.S. 1987. The Parliament of Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.10.3138/9781442678262Google Scholar
Fridkin Khan, Kim. 1994. “Does Gender Make a Difference? An Experimental Examination of Sex Stereotypes and Press Patterns in Statewide Campaigns.” American Journal of Political Science 38 (1): 162–95.Google Scholar
Gidengil, Elisabeth, Nevitte, Neil, Blais, André, Everitt, Joanna and Fournier, Patrick. 2012. Dominance and Decline: Making Sense of Recent Canadian Elections. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Grénier, Éric. 2013. “B.C. post-mortem, polling methodologies, and where to go from here.” http://www.threehundredeight.com/2013/05/bc-post-mortem-polling-methodologies.html. (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Grénier, Éric. 2012a. “Quebec election: expectations vs. results.” http://www.threehundredeight.com/2012/09/quebec-election-expectations-vs-results.html. (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Grénier, Éric. 2012b. “Alberta election aftermath.” http://www.threehundredeight.com/2012/04/alberta-election-aftermath.html. (March 30, 2014).Google Scholar
Huddy, Leonie and Terkildsen, Nayda. 1993. “The Consequences of Gender Stereotypes for Women Candidates at Different Levels and Types of Office.” Political Research Quarterly 46 (3): 503–25.Google Scholar
Huddy, Leonie and Capelos, Theresa. 2002. “The Impact of Gender Stereotypes on Voters' Assessment of Women Candidates.” In Social Psychological Applications to Social Issues: Developments in Political Psychology, ed. Ottai, Victor. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.Google Scholar
Jalalzai, Farida. 2008. “Women Rule: Shattering the Executive Glass Ceiling.” Politics & Gender 4 (2): 205–31.Google Scholar
Jalalzai, Farida. 2013. Shattered, Cracked, or Firmly Intact? Women and the Executive Glass Ceiling Worldwide. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Kathlene, Lyn. 1994. “Power and Influence in State Legislative Policymaking: The Interaction of Gender and Position in Committee Hearing Debates.” The American Political Science Review 88 (3): 560–76.10.2307/2944795Google Scholar
Loewen, Peter and Bastien, Frédérick. 2010. “(In)Significant Elections? Federal By-elections in Canada, 1963–2008.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 43 (1): 87–105.10.1017/S000842390999076XGoogle Scholar
Matthews, J. Scott. 2015. “Horserace Journalism under Stress?” In Canadian Election Analysis: Communication, Strategy, and Democracy, ed. Marland, Alex and Giasson, Thierry. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
McElroy, Justin. 2017. “Grace McCarthy, influential B.C. cabinet minister for 3 decades, has died at 89.” CBC News http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/grace-mccarthy-obit-1.3987119 (September 28, 2017).Google Scholar
Mercier, Noémi. 2012. “Pauline Marois: l’étoffe d'un premier ministre?” L'actualité. Montreal 29–44. http://www.lactualite.com/actualites/politique/pauline-marois-letoffe-dun-premier-ministre/ (March 29, 2014).Google Scholar
O'Brien, Diana Z. 2015. “Rising to the Top: Gender, Political Performance, and Party Leadership in Parliamentary Democracies.” American Journal of Political Science DOI: 10.1111/ajps.12173.10.1111/ajps.12173Google Scholar
O'Brien, Diana Z., Mendez, Matthew, Peterson, Jordan Carr and Shin, Jihyun. 2015. “Letting Down the Ladder or Shutting the Door: Female Prime Ministers, Party Leaders, and Cabinet Ministers.” Politics & Gender 11 (February): 689–717.10.1017/S1743923X15000410Google Scholar
O'Neill, Brenda and Stewart, David K.. 2009. “Gender and Political Party Leadership in Canada.” Party Politics 15 (6): 737–57.Google Scholar
Paikin, Steve. 2003. The Dark Side: The Personal Price of a Political Life. Toronto: Viking Canada.Google Scholar
Pickup, Mark and Johnston, Richard. 2008. “Campaign Trial Heats as Election Forecasts: Evidence from the 2004 Presidential Campaign Polls.” International Journal of Forecasting 24 (2): 272–84.Google Scholar
Pickup, Mark, J., Matthews, Scott, Jennings, Will, Ford, Robert and Fisher, Stephen. 2011. “Why did the polls overestimate Liberal Democratic Support? Sources of Polling Error in the 2010 British General Election.” Journal of Elections Public Opinion and Parties 21 (2): 179–209.10.1080/17457289.2011.563309Google Scholar
Poguntke, Thomas and Webb, Paul, eds. 2005. The Presidentialization of Politics: A Comparative Study of Modern Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/0199252017.001.0001Google Scholar
Russell, Peter H. 2008. Two Cheers for Minority Government: The Evolution of Canadian Parliamentary Democracy. Toronto: Emond Montgomery Publications.Google Scholar
Ryan, Michelle K., Haslam, Alexander and Kulich, Clara. 2010. “Politics and the Glass Cliff: Evidence That Women Are Preferentially Selected to Contest Hard-to-Win Seats.” Psychology of Women Quarterly 34 (March): 56–64.10.1111/j.1471-6402.2009.01541.xGoogle Scholar
Savoie, Donald. 1999. Governing from the Centre: The Concentration of Power in Canadian Politics. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Savoie, Donald. 2003. Breaking the Bargain: Public Servants, Ministers, and Parliament. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.10.3138/9781442657229Google Scholar
Scarrow, Susan E. 2007. “Political Finance in Comparative Perspective.” Annual Review of Political Science 10: 193–210.Google Scholar
Simeon, Richard. 2002. “Federalism and Decentralization in Canada.” Paper presented at the 2nd International Conference on Decentralization, Manila.Google Scholar
Stewart, David K. and Carty, R.K.. 1993. “Does Changing the Party Leader Provide an Electoral Boost? A Study of Canadian Provincial Parties: 1960–1992.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 26 (2): 313–30.Google Scholar
Streb, Matthew J., Burrell, Barbara, Frederick, Brian and Genovese, Michael A.. 2008. “Social Desirability Effects and Support for a Female American President.” Public Opinion Quarterly 72 (1): 76–89.10.1093/poq/nfm035Google Scholar
Studlar, Donley T. and Moncrief, Gary F.. 1997. “The Recruitment of Women Cabinet Ministers in the Canadian Provinces.” Governance 10 (1): 67–81.10.1111/0952-1895.291996029Google Scholar
Tolley, Erin. 2011. “Do Women “Do Better” in Municipal Politics? Electoral Representation across Three Levels of Government.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 44 (3): 573–94.10.1017/S0008423911000503Google Scholar
Thomas, Melanee and Bodet, Marc André. 2013. “Sacrificial Lambs, Women Candidates, and District Competitiveness in Canada.” Electoral Studies 32 (1): 153–66.Google Scholar
Thomas, Melanee, Harell, Allison, and Gosselin, Tania. “Gender, Tone, and Content of Premiers’ News Coverage: A Matched Comparison.” In Polticial Elites in Canada: Power and Influence in Instantaneous Times, ed. Marland, Alex, Lawlor, Andrea and Giasson, Thierry. Vancouver: UBC Press (forthcoming).Google Scholar
Trimble, Linda, and Arscott, Jane. 2003. Still Counting: Women in Politics across Canada. Peterborough ON: Broadview Press.Google Scholar
Trimble, Linda, Arscott, Jane and Tremblay, Manon. 2014. “A Few More Women.” In Stalled: The Representation of Women in Canadian Governments, ed Trimble, Linda, Arscott, Jane and Tremblay, Manon. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
Webb, Paul and Poguntke, Thomas. 2013. “The Presidentialisation of Politics Thesis Defended.” Parliamentary Affairs 66: 646–54.Google Scholar
White, Graham. 2005. Cabinets and First Ministers. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
White, Graham. 2013. “In the Presence of Northern Aboriginal Women? Women in Territorial Politics.” In Stalled: The Representation of Women in Canadian Governments, ed Trimble, Linda, Arscott, Jane and Tremblay, Manon. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar