Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-wg55d Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-18T03:57:35.086Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Immigrants in the City: New York's Irish and German Catholics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Jay P. Dolan
Assistant professor of history in the University of Notre Dame.


In the 1860s Walt Whitman described New York as a “city of spires and masts” with “the flags of all nations … duly lowered at sunset.” To this celebrator or urban life New York was a “city of the world! For all races are here; all the lands of the earth make contributions here.” The cosmopolitan character of New York was especially reflected in the city's Roman Catholic community. In the words of John Hughes, the Roman Catholic Archbishop of New York at mid-century, his “people were composed of representatives from almost all nations.” There were Italian and French Catholics, German and Irish Catholics as well as white and black American-born Catholics. And if one looked long enough, he would come across Catholic merchants from Spain and Catholic chefs from Switzerland. But within this polyglot community the two most significant ethnic groups in ante-bellum New York were the Irish and German immigrants.

Research Article
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1972

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)


1. Whitman, Walt, Leaves of Grass, ed. Kouwenhoven, John (New York: The Modern Library, 1950)Google Scholar, “Mannahatta,” p. 370 and “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry,” p. 132.

2. Ibid., “City of Ships,” p. 233.

3. Rev. Browne, Henry J., “The Archdiocese of New York a Century Ago: A Memoir of Archbishop Hughes, 1838–1858,” U. S. Catholic Historical Society Records and Studies, 39–40 (1952), 183.Google Scholar

4. The density of the city wards is given in New York State Assembly, Report of the Tenement House Committee of 1894 (Albany, 1895), p. 273Google Scholar; also the New York State Census 1865 (Albany, 1867), pp. xxivxxv.Google Scholar

5. New York State Census 1855 (Albany, 1857), p. 110Google Scholar; New York State Census 1865, p. 130 and p. xxv.

6. See Thernstrom, Stephan, “Immigrants and Wasps: Ethnic Differences in Occupational Mobility in Boston, 1890–1940,” Nineteenth Century Cities, ed. Thernstrom, Stephan and Sennett, Richard (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1969), pp. 132ff.Google Scholar, for a discussion of the immigrant character of second-generation immigrants.

7. The use of the sacramental index as a measure of relative population has been made by Francois Houtart in his work, Aspects Sociologiques du Catholicisme Américain (Paris: Les Editions Ouvrières Economie et Humanisme, 1957), pp. 227ff.Google Scholar

8. Ernst, Robert, Immigrant Life in New York City 1825–1863 (Port Washington, N.Y.: Ira J. Friedman, Inc., 1965), pp. 4142Google Scholar; Still, Bayrd, Mirror for Gotham: New York Seen by Contemporaries from Dutch Days to the Present (New York: New York University Press, 1956), pp. 161–63.Google Scholar

9. Quoted in Still, , Mirror for Gotham, p. 161.Google Scholar

10. Census of State of New York 1845 (Albany, 1846)Google Scholar, not numbered; Census of the State of New York 1865, p. 130; the Lower East Side generally includes the Seventh Ward, but this ward was not included in the description since it was predominantly Irish, while the other four wards were very German with some mixture of Irish.

11. Census of the State of New York 1865, p. 130.

12. Obendorfer, John L., C.SS.R., Portrait of a Mother: Church of Most Holy Redeemer (New York: Church of Most Holy Redeemer, n.d.), pp. 16ff.Google Scholar; Katholische Kirchenzeitung, June 10, 1858.

13. This figure was arrived at by a study of the relative sacramental index of the New York Catholic parishes, the estimated Catholic population of 350,000 in 1865 as well as other measurements of the relative German Catholic population in New York. See Dolan, Jay P., “Urban Catholicism: New York, 1815–1865,” (Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Chicago, 1970), pp. 152–55.Google Scholar

14. Archives of the Archdiocese of New York, (hereafter referred to as AANY), Diary of Rev. Richard L. Burtsell, June 22, 1865.

15. Wirth, Louis, “Urbanism as a Way of Life,” The American Journal of Sociology, 44 (07 1938), 124CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sennett, Richard, The Uses of Disorder (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1970).Google Scholar

16. The Citizens' Association of New York. Report of the Council of Hygiene and Public Health (New York: D. Appleton and Co., 1865), p. 148.Google Scholar

17. The maps used in the study were drawn up under the direction of Perris, William, Maps of the City of New York Surveyed Under Directions of Insurance Companies of Said City, Vols. 1–4 (18521853);Google Scholar see also Report of the Council of Hygiene, p. 160.

18. New York Association for Improving the Condition of the Poor, First Report of a Committee on the Sanitary Conditions of the Laboring Classes in the City of New York (New York: 1853), p. 10.Google Scholar

19. Ibid.

20. Report of the Council of Hygiene, p. 84; Rosenber, Charles E., The Cholera Years (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1962), pp. 104107.Google Scholar

21. New York State Assembly, Report of a Select Committee Appointed to Examine into the Condition of Tenant Houses in New York and Brooklyn, 1857, Vol. 3, No. 205, p. 28.Google Scholar

22. Report of the Council of Hygiene, pp. 177–79.

23. Archives of the University of Notre Dame, (hereafter referred to as AUND), Bishop John Hughes to Society for the Propagation of the Faith, Paris, June 26, 1849, f. 104; Browne, “The Archdiocese of New York a Century Ago,” p. 165.

24. Archives of Transfiguration Church, Trustees' Minutes, October 8, 1840.

25. Ibid.

26. Ibid.

27. Wuest, Joseph, C.SS.R., Annales Congregationis S.S. Redemptoris Provinciae Americae (Ilchestriae, Md.: Typis Congregationis S.S. Redemptoris, 1893), 2, p. 35.Google Scholar

28. Archives of Most Holy Redeemer Church, Chronicle of Most Holy Redeemer Church, p. 115.

29. The random sample was taken according to the principles of random sampling explained in Willis, W. Allen and Roberts, Harry V., Statistics: A New Approach (New York: The Free Press, 1956), pp. 334–39Google Scholar; the occupational categories were derived from Thernstrom, Stephan, Poverty and Progress (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1964), pp. 9094.Google Scholar

30. The trustees were listed in the minutes of the board of trustees of the parish, and their occupations were derived from the City Directory.

31. Wuest, , Annales, 2, p. 161.Google Scholar

32. AANY, Burtsell Diary, Dec. 27, 1866 and Jan. 7, 1867.

33. Freeman's Journal, July 25, 1857.

34. See, for example, Thernstrom and Sennett, eds., Nineteenth Century Cities and Thern-

35. Still, , Mirror for Gotham, p. 114.Google Scholar

36. AUND, Bishop John Dubois to Society for the Propagation of the Faith, Paris, May 9, 1836, f. 104.

37. The random sample was taken according to the principles explained in Willis and Roberts, Statistics. The Irish sample group involved fifty-three heads of families of male children baptised in the year 1850, or thirteen percent of the total of 393 families. The German sample involved fifty-three heads of families of male children baptised in 1850, or twenty percent of the total of 264 families.

38. See Wade, Richard C., “Urbanization,” The Comparative Approach to American History, ed. Woodward, C. Vann (New York: Basic Books, 1968), pp. 193–94.Google Scholar

39. Annual Report of the New York Association for Improving the Conditions of the Poor, 1867, p. 42.Google Scholar

40. Cross, Robert D., ed., The Church and the City (New York: Bobba Merrill Co., 1967), pp.xxxxiGoogle Scholar; see Houtart, , Aspects Sociologiques, pp. 49ff.Google Scholar

41. For example, Synodus Dioecesana Neo-Eboracensis Prima 1842 (Neo-Eboraci: Typis Georgii Mitchell, 1842), pp. 1112.Google Scholar

42. Houtart, François, “A Sociological Study of the Evolution of the American Catholics,” Social Kompass, 01/04, 1955, pp. 189216Google Scholar; Nuesse, C. J. and Harte, Thomas J., eds., The Sociology of the Parish (Milwaukee: Bruce Publishing Co., 1951).Google Scholar

43. Barry, Colman J., The Catholic Church and German Americans (Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press, 1953), p. 9.Google Scholar

44. Connelly, James F., The Visit of Archbishop Gaetano Bedini to the United States of America (Rome: Libreria Editrice dell' Universita Gregoriana, 1960), p. 241.Google Scholar

45. Ibid.

46. AUND, Scritture Riferite nei Congressi: America Centrale dal Canada all'istmo di Panama, Vol. 14Google Scholar, letter 226, Rev. Jeremiah Cummings to Prefect of Propaganda Fide, Nov. 24, 1847, f. 639.

47. See Gleason, Philip, The Conservative Reformers (Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1968), pp. 910.Google Scholar

48. Katholische Kirochenseitung, September 17, 1857 and September 2, 1858.

49. Ibid.

50. Ibid., September 2, 1858.

51. Ibid.

52. Dusold, Georg, C.SS.R., Goldenes Jubilaüm der Kirche zum Allerheiligsten Krlöser (New York, 1894), p. 58.Google Scholar

53. Katholische Kirchenseitung, September 7, 1857.

54. Ibid.

55. Dusold, , Goldenes Jubiläum, p. 60.Google Scholar

56. Katholische Kirchenzeitung, October 1, 1857.

57. Ibid.; Charles D. Shanly, “Germany in New York,” Atlantio Monthly, 19 (May 1867), 560.

58. Dusold, , Goldenes Jubiläum, pp. 6164.Google Scholar

59. AANY, Archbishop John Hughes to Pastor and Congregation of Most Holy Redeemer Church, August 5, 1849; Wuest, , Annales, II, 3537.Google Scholar

60. Ibid.

61. Murphy, Francis X., C.SS.R., The Centennial History of St. Alphonsus Parish (New York, 1947), pp. 15ff.Google Scholar

62. Wuest, , Annales, 5Google Scholar, part I, 163.

63. Archives of Most Holy Redeemer Church, Chronicle of Most Holy Redeemer Convent, p. 48.

64. AUND, Scritture Riferite nei Congressi: America Centrale dal Canada all'istmo di Panama, Vol. 9Google Scholar, letter 1015, Pastoral Letter of Bishop John Dubois, July 6, 1827, f. 25.

65. Metropolitan Record, June 8, 1861.

66. Freeman's Journal, March 6, 1847.

67. Wissel, Joseph, C.SS.R., The Redemptorist on the American Missions (3rd. rev. ed., privately printed, 1920), 1, pp. 230–40.Google Scholar

68. Katholische Kirchenzeitung, September 23, 1858.

69. Ibid., May 7, 1863.

70. Ibid., and many other issues of the newspaper.

71. Barry, , The Catholic Church, p. 294.Google Scholar

72. Camiani, Pier G., “Interpretazioni della Riforma Cattolica e della Controriforma,” Grande Antologia Filosofica (Milan, 1964), 6, pp. 452–53.Google Scholar

73. AANY, Burtsell Diary, November 18, 1867.

74. Ibid.

75. Roohan, James E. discusses the attitude of Catholics toward poverty in his work “American Catholics and the Social Question,” (Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Yale University, 1952).Google Scholar

76. Examples of such sermons may be found in Truth Teller, February 22, 1834, December 21, 1839, and October 1, 1842.

77. Meehan, Thomas, “Notes and Comments,” U. S. Catholio Historical Society Records and Studies, 10 (01 1917), 184–85.Google Scholar

78. AANY, Burtsell Diary, June 17, 1866.

79. William Gahan, O.S.A., Sermons for Every Sunday in the Year and for the Leading Holidays of Obligation. Rev. ed. (New York: P. J. Kenedy, 1895);Google Scholar see also Leslie, Stephen and Lee, Sidney, eds., The Dictionary of National Biography (London: Oxford University Press, 1917), 7, p. 800.Google Scholar

80. Prediche del Reverendiss. Monsig. Cornelio Musso (Vinegia: Gabriel Giolito de Ferrari, 1560);Google Scholar see also Enciclopedia Cattolica (Citta del Vaticano, 1952), 8Google Scholar, col. 1564–1565; reference to both sermon books was made in the Burtsell Diary, March 4, 1866.

81. Gahan, , Sermons, p. 254.Google Scholar

82. Stewart, Ramona, Casey (Boston: Little, Brown and Co., 1968), p. 37.Google Scholar

83. Lawrence Kehoe, ed., Complete Works of the Most Rev. John Hughes D.D. (New

84. Freeman's Journal, April 5, 1851.

85. Freeman's Journal, April 14, 1866.

86. U. S. Census, Statistics of the U. S. in 1860, Part II, p. 433.

87. Browne, “The Archdiocese of New York a Century Ago,” p. 157; the number of Masses on Sunday in each parish varied from as many as five to as few as two and the average number was three. See Metropolitan Catholic Almanac and Laity's Directory 1860 (Baltimore: John Murphy and Co., 1860), pp. 136–38.Google Scholar

88. “Religion … in New York,” Catholic World, 3 (06 1866), 386–87.Google Scholar

89. AANY, Burtsell Diary, January 14, 1867.

90. Ibid., June 22, 1865.

91. Ibid., February 22, 1865.

92. Hewit, A. S., Sermons of the Rev. Francis A. Baker, C.P.S. with a Memoir of His Life. 6th ed. (New York: The Catholic Publication House, 1865), p. 122.Google Scholar

93. Ibid., p. 125.

94. AANY, Burtsell Diary, November 24, 1867.

95. Wissel, , The Redemptorist on the American Mission, Vol. I,Google Scholar is devoted entirely to a description of parish missions; see also AUND, Scritture Riferite nei Congressi: America Centrale dal Canada all'istmo di Panama, Vol. 19Google Scholar, letter 1841, Rev. Isaac Hecker to Prefect of Propaganda Fide, June 26, 1861, f. 229–230.

96. Wissel, , The Redemptorist on the American Mission, 1, p. 58Google Scholar; 1, pp. 323–403.

97. Ibid., 1, p. 53.

98. Ibid., 1, p. 114.

99. Ibid.

100. Wuest, , Annales, 2, p. 262.Google Scholar

101. AANY, Burtsell Diary, November 24, 1867; “Religion in New York,” Catholic World, 3, pp. 381–85.Google Scholar

102. Houtart, “A Sociological Study …,” pp. 81ff., discusses the question of attendance at Sunday Mass in the U.S. and a report for the Diocese of New York in 1954 which concludes that about thirty percent of the Catholic population attended Mass on a given Sunday.

103. AUND, Scritture Riferite nei Congressi: America Centrale dal Canada all'istmo di Panama, Vol. 18Google Scholar, letter 1701, Petition of Italians to Archbishop John Hughes, August 16, 1860, f. 1522.