Aristotle in the Arabic World - Lettinck P.: Aristotle's Physics and its Reception in the Arabic World, With an Edition of the Unpublished Parts of Ibn Bâjja's Commentary on the Physics. (Aristoteles Semitico–Latinus, 7.) Pp. ix+793 (88 pages of Arabic text). Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1994. Cased, Gld 300/$171.50.
1 On Ibn Sînâ's theory of mayl, see his Tabî'iyyât [Physics] 4.12, 313–19, Ilâhiyyât [Metaphysics] 9.2, 381–93, and Fi s–samâ' [De Caelo] 1, 3; see also ZimmermanF. W., ‘Philoponus’ impetus theory in the Arabic tradition' in SorabjiR., ed., Philoponus and the Rejection of Aristotelian Science (London, 1987), pp. 121–129. On the difference between Philoponuš and Ibn Sînâ's versions of the theory, see HasnawiA., ‘Aspects de la synthèse avicennienne’, in SinaceurM. A., ed., Penser avec Aristote (Paris, 1991), 233–235; and on Ibn Sîinâ's legacy to Buridan and Descartes, see MennS., ‘Descartes and some predecessors on the divine conservation of motion’, Synthese83 (1990), 223–226.
2 The copy–editing is also sloppy. Even for a book so large, there are a lot of mistakes: too many in the English text to mention, and several in the Arabic transliterations. Two instances where errors in transliterating the Arabic affect the sense are page 262, line 10: ‘ġayr mudrik’ (‘not perceiving’) should read as ‘ġayr mudrak’ (‘imperceptible’); and 598, 24: ‘al–âlim assaġîr’ (‘the young scholar’!) should read as ‘al–âlam as–saġîr’ (‘the microcosm’).
Recommend this journal
Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.